11 ms·
Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of Temporary Work
- DiThi 10y agoWhy aren't politicians making easier to hire people part time? It would benefit not only the unemployed but also the employed that wants to trade part of their salary with more free time.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoNot all capabilities are positive-value for the owner - being able to sell your kidneys means that people will have an incentive to extort you into giving up a kidney. Also, letting people make the best decision for them isn't the same thing as the best rule for everyone to follow. Tragedy of the Commons is the best example for this - if everyone makes their best choice for how many fish to catch, the lake gets emptied. I really ought to turn the above two points into a detailed blog post aimed at libertarians. (Libertarians make good points, too - generally they have better policies than the ones they critique. These processes are some of the biggest things that libertarians categorically ignore, though.)
- yummyfajitas 10y agoIn theory this is true. Is there major kidney related extortion in Iran, where kidney sales are legal? What similar extortion do you see in other similar markets? Is there any reason to believe this is not a random, unsubstantiated fear?
- ThrustVectoring 10y ago>What similar extortion do you see in other similar markets? Perhaps a better example is the secret ballot.
- michaelmrose 10y agoWhere it's legal to sell kidneys I imagine people are presured by poverty to make medically unsound choices surely this is bad enough?
- DiThi 10y agoYou may have misunderstood the idea I wanted to explain. Look at my answers in this sub thread.
- mordae 10y agoHow exactly would it benefit the unemployed? They lose all the benefits the moment they start working!
- DiThi 10y agoIt may shock you, but rules and welfare were invented by humans, for specific goals. If the goals are not fulfilled any more, it may be time to change the rules. That phenomenon is called "welfare cliff", and it should be addressed if politicians wants to make part time jobs easier for both employers and employees.
- pkaye 10y agoMost of those in this article are looking for the stability of full time employment. They don't want to juggle a bunch of part time jobs.
- adenomatous 10y agoThere is such a thing as working a single 1/2 or 2/3 job in a permanent position. It's not a bad way to live. More people ought to try.
- DiThi 10y agoI want one stable, non temporary, part time job, even though I would be earning less. Many people want too.
- pkaye 10y agoAre you speaking as someone in the EU because there are plenty of part time jobs in the US but usually they don't come with any benefits.
- DiThi 10y agoYes, I'm from the EU. Does part time jobs in the US disqualifies you from unemployment benefits?
- pkaye 10y agoThe US qualifications may vary slightly form state to state but in California is is based on minimum income on a quarter basis over the past year. This threshold is pretty low but the benefits are minimal also. You can continue to work part time but the earnings are subtracted from the unemployment benefits so rarely a net gain. The real problem with part time jobs is that they usually don't include health insurance benefits. It is cheaper for an employer to give one full time worker health insurance benefits instead of giving two part time workers health insurance benefits. I think if the US had free national health insurance it would really change the landscape of part time jobs as more people would be open to it.
- rkrzr 10y agoIt's not hard to hire people part time. But that is also not the point that this article is making. The problem is that a whole generation of people in Europe is currently facing unemployment/underemployment and temporary job contracts which prevents them from making plans for the future like starting a family etc.
- DiThi 10y ago> It's not hard to hire people part time. It is hard. There are incentives for employers to only hire full time (more people = more administrative work and less favorable numbers when computing taxes, etc). There are incentives for unemployed people to seek full time jobs and not part time jobs: You lose unemployment benefits when you do any type of job. The so called welfare cliff.
- candiodari 10y agoIn at least one western European country part-time has the reputation of being about 2h less work than full-time, but 60% of the pay. Partly because they always demand you come in 4 days out of 5, sometimes all 5, and so traffic time is the same. Knowing that a LOT of people spend 1h+ each way, this means a part-time job effectively shortens your workday (time away from home) from 10h to 8h. So you can extrapolate from that exactly how employers use part-time.
- DiThi 10y agoI'll rephrase: politicians should consider making easier for both employers and employees to just work less hours with exactly the same hourly wage.
- andmarios 10y agoIn Greece, with our austerity measures, part-time employment came as a requisite from our creditors, because it would turn our economy more competitive. What really happened in an economy with 23% unemployment? Now anyone can hire you legally for as little as 100 euro per month and, since there are a million people out there looking for a job, can demand from you to work 12 hours per day for 5 or 6 days a week. Slavery does give a competitive edge to a business.
- DiThi 10y ago> can demand from you to work 12 hours per day for 5 or 6 days a week How is that "part time"?
- brandon272 10y agoSeems like we go back to the concept of basic income, which Elon Musk recently "doubled down" on: http://finance.yahoo.com/news/elon-musk-doubles-down-universal-175300665.html http://finance.yahoo.com/news/elon-musk-doubles-down-univers...
- DamnYuppie 10y agoI think before we take that step we should explore an improvement in labor laws that make it less undesirable to enter into full time employment agreements.
- brandon272 10y agoYes, but it's still a race to the bottom. To make it "less undesirable" for an employer to hire a full time employee simply means reduced compensation, benefits and protections for said employees. "We won't hire you on a full time basis because we need the flexibility to lay you off whenever we want and we want to pay you less and offer you fewer benefits." Do we really need to make employment as unpleasant and stressful as it can possibly become before we accept the fact that some kind of basic safety net is needed?
- jimmywanger 10y ago> Do we really need to make employment as unpleasant and stressful That's a large oversimplification. Employment is stressful because the business world is stressful. By entering into a contract with an employer, the employer is not only giving you a salary, but some sort of assurance that you'll be buffered from the market because the employer has larger cash reserves to ride out market fluctuations. Nobody can stop you from freelancing, which gives you ultimate freedom, but also doesn't insulate you from market conditions. By making it more difficult to fire you, the employer has to reduce compensation, benefits, and protections because the overall value proposition has shifted, since the employer now is far less flexible in dealing with market situations.
- 10y ago
- Shivetya 10y agoodd there was no attempt to present solutions or show if any of the countries were trying to find any. Basic Income won't solve this mess unless you are willing to give up a lot to get it. As in it won't be free, some benefits will go by the wayside as BI will need to cover all your needs. I figure education will hit the block first, get a job while on BI to prove you can hold one then you can get schooling or more advanced trade skill training. the problems with BI are many. politicians and such would have a difficult time establishing how much is enough because even those who wholly exist on a BI system would demand access or the ability to obtain certain items and goods. the danger is establishing by government edict a permanent underclass, appeased just enough to keep them from challenging the system. likely to be better to incentivize hiring people by providing discounts/paybacks/guarantees to employers to get the people in place
- zigzigzag 10y agoIn France at least, attempts to liberalise labor laws tend to cause riots. I don't know about Spain or Italy but they have famously sclerotic labor markets that never seem to get reformed. It's just not a priority of the voters. Not sure what's going on with more liberalised countries like the Netherlands, but consider the massive influxes of people from continental Europe to the UK, which has relatively relaxed labor laws, and that may have something to do with it. Also, note that most of the people the article covers don't have any skills worth talking about. They studied art history, social analysis, hotel management and things like that. Such people would find it hard to find a committed employer even in better times. The first example is a doctor, but she suffers from a double whammy of regulation: not only labor laws but also licensing that makes it hard for her to even relocate to a better run country.
- sokoloff 10y agoHere's the key line in the article: > Under European labor laws, permanent workers are usually more difficult to lay off and require more costly benefit packages, making temporary contracts appealing for all manner of industries, from low-wage warehouse workers to professional white-collar jobs. Make it extremely costly for an employer to exit a permanent contract and employers are less willing to enter those contracts. Shouldn't be terribly surprising.
- tostitos1979 10y agoI've met quite a few grad student interns from Europe. Was very surprised when they told me. Quite an unintended consequence of a well-meaning policy.
- literallycancer 10y agoIn some places it's actually illegal to intentionally skirt the labor laws by using temporary contractors for jobs that are not of temporary nature (seasonal agriculture workers ok, cashiers not ok), but yeah, it's not enforced that much.
- ptaipale 10y agoAnd trying to enforce it won't really help. It'll just drive away even those temp jobs, if the employers cannot find legal ways to go around requirements. The fundamental problem is that employment law tries to treat the employer as a nasty exploiter, not as a provider of something good to those to whom it pays salary. The law often starts from confrontation and zero-sum game, not from having shared goals and interests.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThe biggest reason for this is that some employers are nasty exploiters. I'd like to make-believe that everyone treats each other well, but it just isn't so. The laws aren't designed to accuse everyone, but to protect future workers from suffering a similar fate. So you wind up getting laws designed so that employers need to be fair when firing, allowing folks time off after pregnancy (including men), allowing folks to stay home when they are sick, and making sure folks can try to correct their ways before getting fired. And contrary to your belief, enforcement of laws seems to happen here (norway). Temp agencies seem to be much more used than they were in the US.. and weirdly less predatory to the worker. It still sucks only having a temp job, but that's how a lot of folks get started working here.
- elevensies 10y agoGiven the levels of unemployment in the EU over the last 10 years, and the current million+ a year immigration rate, this is going to get worse before it gets better. A lot worse.
- pasquinelli 10y agoWhy would new people coming in drive unemployment up?
- maverick_iceman 10y agoUm, supply and demand? Fixed number of jobs, more applicants. So unemployment goes up almost tautologically.
- argigg 10y agoWhy would the number of jobs be fixed? Do all countries have the same number of jobs, regardless of population?
- pasquinelli 10y agomore people, more demand for goods and services, more jobs.
- swingbridge 10y agoMostly a result of regulations that make it difficult for companies to get rid of people (either because they're not good or the company needs to shed staff). I've seen this sort of thing backfire a lot in Europe where well intended regulation causes far more harm (both to individuals and the economy of the country) than good. Was in a meeting not too long back where major investments were being discussed and the places to invest where on the table (with jobs at stake). Long story short some regulatory monkey was saying "this ref prevents this, you'd have to do that" and such for a location in Europe at which point the execs in the room basically just said "fine, we just won't invest there... if they want to have silly practices we'll just put the jobs elsewhere." And they did. I'm no Republican but the concept of regulations killing jobs and hurting the people they intended to help is a very real thing.
- dikdik 10y agoThe same argument can be made about taxes. Based on your reasoning, it's a race to the bottom for all countries in order to attract businesses. Are we supposed to have no regulation and no taxation on businesses because otherwise some other state/country can offer them a better deal? Or do we need to have stronger regulation across country borders/policy that prohibits these loopholes. Maybe we should tax a US company more if they choose to produce products in another country to get around regulations that we have in the US.
- linkregister 10y agoI don't think the parent poster suggested there be no regulation or taxes. Clearly there are more to countries than tax rates and regulations. However, the parent poster relates an anecdote where one country with less restrictive regulation is chosen over another, all other things being equal. So to answer your question, if a country has a superior market or the right labor pool, then it will succeed despite higher tax rates or restrictive regulations, to a point. Despite a zero corporate tax rate and few regulations, Somalia still hasn't posed a threat to Europe and the U.S. as a corporate headquarters. The "race to the bottom" is bounded by other factors besides tax rates and regulation. Rule of law, enforceability of contracts, access to a skilled labor pool, access to markets, etc. are more important. Interestingly enough, these factors are a correlated to sufficient government revenue and regulation to uphold contracts and satisfy labor.
- morsch 10y agoThe article calls dismisses one or two year contract jobs as temporary work. All jobs are temporary in at-will environment! Meanwhile, according to the article (which quotes a report based on numbers 5 years old, so who knows how things are now), 50% of new jobs in the EU are still permanent. And 20% of the temp contracts turn into permanent positions. Not that permanent is actually permanent, employers in the EU fire permanent employees all the time (either for cause, or because there is no viable business alternative; permanent positions also come with a 3-6 month "at-will" probationary period).
- zigzigzag 10y agoNo, it's not the same. Laws that are different for "temporary workers" normally require those workers to genuinely be temporary. That means you get laid off when your time is up regardless of whether you are doing a good job or whether the company wants to keep you: unless you are spectacular, your contract ends and it's someone elses turn. In an environment with very liberal labor laws, there is no government enforced "time up". If you're doing good work and the company still needs you, then you still have a job. And as you point out, "permanent" jobs aren't permanent anyway. I can't really see good reasons to have such tight labor laws.
- todd8 10y agoYears ago, I was told by an executive at a company that I did some consulting for that it cost them the equivalent of seven years of an employee's annual salary to fire someone if the employee was working in their French subsidiary. I suspected that there was some hyperbole in that claim, but perhaps a HN reader knows just how costly it is to fire an employee in France, for example.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patmcguire 10y agoSome of this is due to regulations, some of this is the fact that they can now get away with it. The market can be efficient in more than one way. I will say that the concepts of year contracts are totally alien to me as an American. But I think Europe still works on the old-school postwar model, where you're horribly underpaid at the start of your career and the company makes a bunch of money off of that, but over time you make more and more until it morphs until a well paid sinecure. So they're just stuck at that horrible entry phase forever and never move to the good part.
- vertex-four 10y agoHold on a second. People are essentially suggesting "strip the regulations, let companies fire people at will". How precisely are short-term contracts worse than at-will employment where you can be fired at a moment's notice? You need to constantly have one eye on the job market either way, or risk losing your income security. At least short-term contracts don't create an information asymmetry - you need to find a new job at the end of the contract, not whenever your boss decides, for reasons unknown to you, that they don't need you any more. If workers want security in employment, they're going to have to create it themselves - through worker-owned companies.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoThere are several advantages to the employer to have temp contract workers rather than full time employees (even at will). You don't have to pay them benefits like health insurance, workers' comp, 401k etc. Also if they get fired they are much less likely to bring a discrimination lawsuit.
- vertex-four 10y agoThis is the EU, not the US.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoIn the US a lot of people are understanding why less coercive labor laws ultimately end up benefitting the employees. That's why so many states have gone right to work recently. Edit: I would also like to add that I don't support mandating unions to represent all employees. Just like an employee should be under no obligation to join/pay dues to a union, a union should have no obligation to represent all employees. It should be a voluntary association.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoVery similar situation persists in India where the section VIIB of the Industrial Disputes Act says that a company needs government permission to lay off people if they have 100 or more employees. As a result a lot of companies never go beyond 99, giving up growth and employment prospects for a large part of the population. Moreover, this creates a vast class of underemployed people outside the protection of those laws, euphemistically called the "informal sector".