13 ms·
> The scourge of ticket bots and the immorality of the shady ticket scalpers using them is conventional wisdom I very much disagree. If I am willing to pay th
by jstanley 10y ago
> The scourge of ticket bots and the immorality of the shady ticket scalpers using them is conventional wisdom
I very much disagree.
If I am willing to pay the asking price for tickets, I should be able to buy them. If you're offering them so cheaply that I will happily buy all of the tickets then you're offering them too cheap and you can't really complain if I buy them.
If it weren't for ticket-scalpers, die-hard fans who are willing to pay extra to secure a place would have no option. Thanks to ticket-scalpers, it is possible for die-hard fans to ensure they can get one even if the tickets are "sold out" by just offering more money.
This is a classic case of an inefficient market being made more efficient.
Without ticket scalping: the original seller sells all the tickets. Some fans get to watch the gig, and others don't, and the availability of tickets bears no relation to how much you're willing to pay to get hold of one, only to how quickly you decide to book one.
With ticket scalping: the original seller sells all their tickets more quickly. The fans who want to see the gig the most get to see it, with less chance of tickets being made unavailable by people who don't want to see it as badly (i.e. don't want to pay as much money), and the ticket scalper makes a profit. Everyone's a winner.
- knz 10y agoThere is a middle ground of letting legitimate buyers purchase tickets and then selling them on the secondary market if they are unable to attend. Automated bots/teams of people buying many tickets purely for the sake of profit doesn't benefit anyone other than the scalpers.
- rubber_duck 10y ago>Automated bots/teams of people buying many tickets purely for the sake of profit doesn't benefit anyone other than the scalpers. He just told you - it benefits people who want to pay more but would otherwise have to rely on luck to buy the tickets - this is the entire reason the system works.
- rhino369 10y agoThe people running the show could just sell the tickets using an auction mechanism. It doesn't make sense to let a middle man take a huge cut. Well it probably does make sense for PR reasons. Nobody wants to be the band/team/event gouging their fans.
- rubber_duck 10y ago>Well it probably does make sense for PR reasons. Nobody wants to be the band/team/event gouging their fans. Yes and this is why they exist :)
- knz 10y ago> There is a middle ground of letting legitimate buyers purchase tickets and then selling them on the secondary market if they are unable to attend. And nothing stops those people from buying a ticket from someone who is no longer able to attend on StubHub. Bands aren't putting on a show so that their wealthiest fans can attend.
- rubber_duck 10y ago>And nothing stops those people from buying a ticket from someone who is no longer able to attend on StubHub. And the difference between that and scalping to the buyer is ? If you can't bid on the price you're still relying on luck to get it which sucks if you want to pay more. So your argument was that only scalpers benefit - people who can now secure tickets at a markup also benefited.
- knz 10y agoThe difference is that hundreds if not thousands of fans for a large event are not automatically pushed to the more expensive secondary market for no reason other than profit making by a few people.
- SippinLean 10y agoIt makes it nearly impossible for anything that isn't a machine to acquire retail tickets. When 496/500 GA tickets go to a bot, the scarcity and price are artificially inflated.
- tomtoise 10y ago> Everyone's a winner. Except perhaps those die-hard fans who do not have the extra money available to see what may be a once-in-a-lifetime show. Perhaps a more correct ending would be "Everyone who has enough disposable income is a winner."
- OJFord 10y agoIf they're too cheap, then it would be everyone with enough disposable time to sit in queue and grab them before they sell out.
- tomtoise 10y agoThis is another reason scalpers are bad. Botting the process gives an edge in both speed and tenacity over legitimate fans sitting in the queue. Ticket allotment limits are only affecting legitimate users, as those scalpers who use bots can get around this with multiple sessions.
- mikeash 10y agoTime is distributed a lot more equitably than money, so people tend to find this sort of thing to be more fair.
- Chris2048 10y ago> Time is distributed a lot more equitably than money How so?
- mikeash 10y agoIf you compare the ratio between the 90th percentile and 10th percentile of "wealth," when it comes to time then that ratio is around 1.5-1.7 for Americans (the 10th percentile male lives about 55 years, female 62 years; the 90th percentile is 93/96). If you look at income, the ratio between 90th and 10th percentile is over 10. If you look at net worth, the ratio is actually negative, because the 10th percentile has less than zero net worth. If you expand it out to the 100th percentile then the difference is even more stark. The 100th percentile income is many orders of magnitude higher than the 10th percentile, while the 100th percentile time is less than 3x higher than the 10th percentile.
- number6 10y agoBrought to you by Ayan Rand
- jkoebler 10y agoI was saying that artists and ticketmaster and politicians are happy to sell the narrative that "ticket bots and scalpers are the problem and we can't do anything about it" when that is very much not the case. Lots of fans buy this, because they don't know any better. As a journalist, the writing I've seen about the ticket industry the last year has been so, so bad and so simplistic and so infuriating, so I decided to do this piece to fight a lot of these misconceptions
- jstanley 10y agoI'm glad you wrote it! I was in quite a heated debate about this a few weeks ago, where everyone else in the room disagreed with me. Hopefully public opinion will start to reflect market reality in time :)
- Retric 10y agoBecause bands make less money they produce fewer shows which is another net loss. Further, it's not die hard fans that use scalped tickets it's people with disposable money. If anything fewer die hard fans get tickets because a fan will showup at 12:00 to buy tickets but they don't build a bot to get them in the next 0.1 seconds.
- NLips 10y agoThis is incorrect. There's a false equivalence between the fans who want to see the gig the most and the fans who are willing to spend the most. The current system means that people with lots of money who aren't super interested will out compete raging fans on low incomes. I'm not suggesting that basing it on first come, first served is ideal, but I think it's probably fairer. If an event organiser/ticketer wants to use dynamic pricing, that's up to them. Sometimes they don't want to be cause they'd rather build or reward loyalty. Maybe they want to make sure that low income households have a decent chance of getting tickets. The system above is advocating for efficient markets over everything else.
- jstanley 10y ago> There's a false equivalence between the fans who want to see the gig the most and the fans who are willing to spend the most. This is how scarce resources are allocated. There is no fairer way to decide who wants something the most than to ask who is willing to give up the most to acquire it. > If an event organiser/ticketer wants to use dynamic pricing, that's up to them. Absolutely. And if a third party wants to buy tickets at the offered price, that's up to them.
- tomtoise 10y ago> There is no fairer way to decide who wants something the most than to ask who is willing to give up the most to acquire it. What is 'the most' for one may be pocket change for another.
- mturmon 10y ago"...There is no fairer way to decide..." Now, this seems unimaginative. Surely, especially given all the feedback and critique on this thread, you can come up with other factors besides price that should influence fairness in this transaction? We may decide that introducing other factors (like band loyalty or degree of enthusiasm for the show) is difficult, impractical, or threatens entrenched interests, but that's another issue. We can't let enthusiasm for the allocation properties of markets ("it's Pareto optimal!") bleed over into value judgements about the outcome ("...so we all agree it's most fair!").
- rawTruthHurts 10y agoI completely agree. Only those with money should have the right to enjoy life. Or education. Or health services. Or their favourite bands, if that's the case.
- mrob 10y agoWithout education you accomplish much less than you otherwise would in life. Modern society is not sustainable without widespread education. Without health services your risk of death or disability increases. But if you can't see your favorite band live you substitute some other form of entertainment.
- simonsarris 10y agoYou reasoning is a pretty good example of why the median person should be very wary of anyone saying that free markets and their "efficiency" are a good thing, or will result in good outcomes for them. They will result in good outcomes for the richest, sure. We can agree to that. You are conflating die-hard fans with die-hard wealthy fans which is a little silly. Not all fans have the same marginal value of pocket change. One median-income fan may be easily be more die-hard than another more blasé millionaire fan, yet he is also a die-hard fan of feeding his children. Just because he is unwilling to sacrifice his children to go to the concert does not mean he is less of a fan. The millionaire is not really a die-hard fan, but can easily pay, so he does. So no, the fan who wants to see the gig the most does not get to see it. That's only true if everyone has the same amount of disposable income. They don't. For the median person, "the free market" just means "the person with the most money gets to make all of the decisions." So much so that a person who cares much less can affect an outcome he hardly cares about, because he also does not care about the money involved, because he has so much of it relative to the median person. "I mean, it's one banana, Michael. What could it cost? $10?"
- snarf21 10y agoIsn't this easily solved with a fan club that any member gets up to 2 tickets that are non transferable (physical printed tickets only via mail)? The benefit of being in the club is to getting access to these. Rich has a lot less to do it and then there are a lot less for the bots anyway. People are lazy and will always choose the easiest option. If the only way to get good seats and cheap tickets is a fan club (e.g.) and you make that simple, people will change their behavior. If you can only get good seats on StubHub, that's where you'll go.
- jkoebler 10y agoScalpers join fan clubs and have people on the inside who can do name changes for them
- Pigo 10y agoHowever justifiable it might be, this ticket gouging is the reason I haven't seen a concert in almost a decade. Maybe I'm a cheap bastard because I refuse to pay hundreds for the few decent artists I've seen on tour, but it's not that I don't have the money. The first NIN concert I went to, I only had to steer clear of certain mosh-pits. The last one I had to put up with a sea of "brighter than the stage" phones upheld to block my view. I don't particularly care if everyone knows I was there, and I can watch incredible videos from home while drinking Rhinegeist. I do think Kid Rock's approach to sales (tickets and beer) is awesome, and I grew to respect him for thinking outside the box. It's just a shame that I'm not a fan by any means.
- knodi123 10y ago> If I am willing to pay the asking price for tickets, I should be able to buy them. If you're offering them so cheaply that I will happily buy all of the tickets then you're offering them too cheap and you can't really complain if I buy them. And if I'm an artist who wants to ensure that fans without a lot of money can see me? Should I be allowed to offer a concert where tickets cost 20% of market value, or should "the market" step in and say "no. I'm the one in charge, and I say that once you reach a certain level of fame, only rich people are allowed to see you live. sorry, but you've outgrown your original fanbase." That feels like kind of a sick attitude. The solution here is either the invisible hand of the market, OR tight controls exercised at the artist's discretion.
- ikeboy 10y ago>And if I'm an artist who wants to ensure that fans without a lot of money can see me? Either run background checks on fans and only allow people without a lot of money to take those seats, or throw large enough events such that there's enough supply to meet the demand at your preferred price.
- knodi123 10y agoThis really feels like treating the invisible hand like a religion. At all costs, price controls must be avoided! The will of the merchant is irrelevant! The only thing that matters is maximizing profit- any other solution would commit the heresy of denying power to wealth! Seriously - either background checks, or rent out yankee stadium? No solutions in between?
- ikeboy 10y agoWhat will of the merchant here is being thwarted? The question was how to fulfil the merchant's desires, and I gave several possible answers. As long as there's more demand than supply, some mechanism will allocate the scarce supply to the buyers who want it most in the sense of being willing to pay the most for it. Any other system cannot be pareto-optimal.
- gpvos 10y ago> Without ticket scalping: [...] Some fans get to watch the gig, and others don't, and the availability of tickets bears no relation to how much you're willing to pay to get hold of one, only to how quickly you decide to book one. How quickly one decides to book a ticket seems like a better way to define a die-hard fan than how much money one has available for a ticket.
- halflings 10y agoSorry for the iffy analogy, but the first thing that comes to mind is hedge funds speculating over food [1], and the real-world impact that has on poor people that clearly have no say in the game. Scalpers are making a ton of money by creating an artificial shortage of tickets, not because there were already people willing to pay such a high price. If fresh water would cost $100 tomorrow, I'm sure people will still be willing to pay for it (because they really want it, and that's the only price they can get it for). Doesn't mean that it's fair in any way. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2010/jul/19/speculators-commodities-food-price-rises https://www.theguardian.com/business/2010/jul/19/speculators...
- darpa_escapee 10y ago> If it weren't for ticket-scalpers, die-hard fans who are willing to pay extra to secure a place would have no option. VIP tickets sold by the venue exist to solve the problem of "some fans might pay more than others to see the same show" and fans get extra value with their ticket purchase in the form of a VIP experience. Tickets sold by scalpers don't have the added value beyond the value created by their artificial scarcity.
- candiodari 10y agoIn my experience VIP tickets sell out faster than normal ones. I'm not saying I understand it, but there you go.
- onion2k 10y agoWith ticket scalping: the original seller sells all their tickets more quickly. The fans who want to see the gig the most get to see it, with less chance of tickets being made unavailable by people who don't want to see it as badly (i.e. don't want to pay as much money), and the ticket scalper makes a profit. Everyone's a winner. Here's hoping a cabal of billionaires don't start applying this logic to things like food or houses.
- mattnewton 10y agoTicket scalping hurts artist exposure by finding an equilibrium point on price alone, where many artists may really want to maximize audience size and not earnings from tickets. Concerts are like promotional events for their brand and many people buy albums, swag, post on social media about the event, and that's all beneficial to the artist. Ticket scalping removes the ability of the artist to maximize attendance (and potentially limits the groups in attendance to ones outside the bands core marketing demographics) I think it is more complicated than treating tickets as widgets to be sold.
- ikeboy 10y agoMaximize audience size by renting a large enough place to meet demand at the price you want to sell at.
- mattnewton 10y agoThat's a better solution imo, but that assumes a perfectly flexible supply of venue space that often isn't there in practice. When it is, I also imagine the price is free to scale exponentially with venue size. Also, say there simply aren't enough teenagers to make it reach an equilibrium point on price alone. This method still ignores the fact that the artist might want to optimize for something other than ticket revenue. A sold out venue of trendy twenty-something's is can be worth much more than a handful of rich die hard fans willing to pay tenfold. Finally, it requires a really good handle on what that expected audience is going to be, not just what they can pay, which is hard to do.
- ikeboy 10y ago>Also, say there simply aren't enough teenagers to make it reach an equilibrium point on price alone. If there are scalpers, that means there are more people who want to come than seats available. If the price is, say, $50, then there's a certain number of people who would buy at $50. If that number of seats is made available, then the scalper incentive disappears. >A sold out venue of trendy twenty-something's is can be worth much more than a handful of rich die hard fans willing to pay tenfold I mean, if you want younger people, just make age restrictions. But you can have both by just getting a larger venue. >Finally, it requires a really good handle on what that expected audience is going to be, not just what they can pay, which is hard to do. Well that's where scalpers make the market more efficient, by having a lot of experience knowing what the expected audience will be.
- wnevets 10y agoI'm hoping this post is satire.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dvdcxn 10y ago>Everyone's a winner Except the people who badly want to see a band but unfortunately do not work for a trendy startup and therefore cannot afford the tickets in their increasingly gentrified city.
- vacri 10y ago> If it weren't for ticket-scalpers, die-hard fans who are willing to pay extra to secure a place would have no option. This is fantasy free-market nonsense. Fan clubs routinely get a round of ticket sales before it's opened up to the general public. It's quite common for an event to have tickets sold in batches to different groups, and for there to be pre-event events as well. If you're willing to pay extra, join a fan club. It's also faulty reasoning - if other die-hard fans have already bought the tickets from scalpers, you can't just offer more money to the scalper and get one of their tickets. You can, however, buy directly off that other fan, but you can do that already anyway.