8 ms·
FCC spectrum auction bidding ends at $19.6B
- NateyJay 10y agoDoes auctioning channels off to the highest bidder result in the best use of the spectrum?
- tptacek 10y agohttp://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/09/coase-and-spectrum-auctions.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/09/coa... Spectrum auctions are one of the more famous results of economics theory, and the first thing that people think of when they think of Ronald Coase (who won a Nobel and is up there in the pantheon of 20th century economists).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- baddox 10y agoDepends what "best" means and what you think about markets and regulations.
- upofadown 10y agoNot really. It tends to lead to a situation where in a particular area you can only use the spectrum that is owned by a service you subscribe to. So if you are on Big Bobs Phonz when it is busy (or you would just like more bandwidth) you can't pay to use Medium Sally's Wavz spectrum without a separate subscription. In rural areas things can get fairly weird, where every major company has to provide coverage (and redundant equipment) to ensure any sort of continuity of service. So the problems are non-optimal spectrum utilization and pointlessly redundant cell sites. You could extend the idea of municipal owned last mile broadband to wireless as it is more or less the same problem. But then there would be no point in having spectrum auctions. Governments have gotten used to the money they get for awarding spectrum monopolies so I don't see the municipal wireless idea going anywhere anytime soon.
- revelation 10y agoAn extra $20B in income for the Government that the carriers will then spend the better part of the next 10 years recouping through their usual business practices like maintaining quasi-monopolies, ridiculous usage limits, massive over-subscription, anti-net-neutrality practices like "most favored streaming service" and other regressive, growth-inhibiting moves. There is this "pure capitalist" ring to allocating spectrum through auction but the practical effects have been devastating. It's trading $20B in income now for stifling the growth that dumb, unrestricted, fast mobile pipes would offer to the remainder of the economy.
- tptacek 10y agoThat's what the regulators told Coase when he proposed auctions. The problem with this argument is that it presumes spectrum would be allocated productively (or "fairly") in the absence of an auction. But that historically wasn't the case, and isn't the case with any number of other scarce resources doled out by governments. Even among good-faith claimants, there is competition, obstinacy, incompetence, and waste; those things are fundamental to all of enterprise. That's true of auction winners as well, of course, but at least we're (a) getting revenue for the resource, and (b) forcing people to put their money where their mouth is: you don't write a 9-10-figure check without having at least some earthly clue of how you'll put the thing you bought to use.
- revelation 10y agoYet we've put a bunch of 2.4 GHz spectrum out there with essentially "here you go, please channel hop, use up to those dBm" and it certainly has been a vastly, vastly more productive use than any single one of those carrier spectrum auctions. And why did that happen? They probably figured it was worthless to auction given the attenuation. So if something nets minus dollars in your auction scheme but trillions of economic value, hey, I think we're still waiting for some data to come in on this thesis.
- zanny 10y agoThis is the reality of light frequencies. We restrict all of them, and have only a whitelist of actually usable open spectrum that everyone crowds in. What we really need is just a blacklist of low frequencies for emergency coding and military use, while the rest are open. Intentional interference would still be illegal as it is now, because that is a disjoint law independent of whether spectrum is private or public.
- DannyBee 10y agoSo, basically, this was a complete and total bust: In June, the FCC said sellers had initially sought $86.4 billion for 126 megahertz of television airwaves taken from broadcasters to be sold for wireless use. Many analysts had expected broadcasters to earn substantially more in the auction, with some forecasting in 2016 $30 billion in proceeds. This is the spectrum that would have been used for the "tv whitespace" wireless (except now you could do it amazingly better with clear spectrum) I guess the analysts don't realize that a lot of these guys don't need tons more spectrum, they just want to prevent others from using it. Don't worry though, our FCC chief is on it: "FCC Chairman Ajit Pai said the closing of bidding is a "major milestone," adding the spectrum will boost wireless service." No idea how, since even with the fcc rules around use, they'll do pretty much nothing. Hey, you know what also would have boosted it? Having the people who actually gave a crap, and were trying to make wireless available to everyone by using this, do it. Or worse, we'll see wonderful devices that only work with specific carriers. To be fair though, congress literally forced them to auction it after massive lobbying from telcos and isps. I'm sure though, that those same congressman will not remember to ask why the hell the auction did so badly if they needed the spectrum so much. This spectrum all would have been better off in the hands of people trying to actually boost our economy, and it would have been worth a lot more in 20b to help free people from the iron grip of broadband non-competition.
- tptacek 10y agoI believe you in this specific case, but how do you devise a rule for this that works in the general case, or a rule that determines when we should switch to the "let Google or companies it blesses" special case from that general case?
- mjw1007 10y agoIt would be more interesting if the article had reported the median analyst forecast. Given that it doesn't go as far as to say "most analysts had expected substantially more", it seems plausible that this the result is in fact in line with expectations.
- DannyBee 10y ago
- jimrandomh 10y agoWas any of this allocated to unlicensed/consumer usage? There's a serious shortage of uncrowded public spectrum in cities, and a few good channels for 802.11something would do a lot more good than giving the same spectrum to a cell phone carrier.
- abpavel 10y agoThat's why carriers wanted this spectrum - so noone else can use it and pose a risk to status quo "Want wireless? Go to established carriers."
- prostoalex 10y agoIn the 2.4 GHz spectrum the frequencies immediately above WiFi are owned by a Bay Area satellite company GlobalStar. The current plan is to monetize that via a nationwide (planet-wide) satellite network https://www.wirelessweek.com/news/2016/11/sprint-board-globalstars-amended-24-ghz-proposal https://www.wirelessweek.com/news/2016/11/sprint-board-globa...
- superkuh 10y agoAnd the 5 GHz ISM (wifi) band is being infiltrated by LTE-U from telcos. This is despite the fact that it causes loss of 80%+ of channel capacity when sharing with wifi. The telcos are doing everything they can to wipe out public wireless connectivity.
- joecool1029 10y agoMost of 5GHZ was already fairly worthless thanks to the po-po and the weathermen using it. That DFS 'feature'. If the telcos want to use high channel deploys on 5GHZ for LTE-U microcells, I say why not. It's not like it propagates very far and it gives an easy way to assist with capacity at stadiums, train stations, and conference halls.
- superkuh 10y ago
- NelsonMinar 10y agoThis is the auction to consolidate television broadcasts, to free up some UHF space for other uses. Here's some background beyond what the article says. If anyone has a summary / picture of exactly what frequencies become available and what their bandwidth is, I'd love to see it. The FCC's page for the auction. Includes a nifty dashboard view of the bidding. https://www.fcc.gov/about-fcc/fcc-initiatives/incentive-auctions https://www.fcc.gov/about-fcc/fcc-initiatives/incentive-auct... The Wikipedia article has some of the history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_reallocation#Broadcast_incentive_auction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum_reallocation#Broadcas...
- drmpeg 10y agohttp://www.tvtechnology.com/Portals/0/TVT_20141119-1515.jpg http://www.tvtechnology.com/Portals/0/TVT_20141119-1515.jpg
- revelation 10y agoIt seems impossible to find what spectrum they have actually sold here, just meaningless bandwidth numbers (I'm happy to sell you 1 GHz of spectrum any time, I'll tell you the carrier). Apparently it is UHF channel 30-51, or 566-692 MHz.
- upofadown 10y agoActually, UHF TV channels 38-51 (614-698). Channel 37 is the radio astronomy hole which now gets to be part of the guard band between TV and wireless. So in one sense the outcome is fairly optimal in that there is less spectrum wasted on the guard band.
- amelius 10y agoWhat happens to signals that are technically within the spectrum, but are being transmitted in a "directed-beam" between two locations?
- boznz 10y agoits like speeding.. it's fine so long as nobodies watching. If your low power and nobodies inbetween or in the overspill region then keep calm and carry on, if not reconsider getting licensed modems
- ericabiz 10y agoIs there any plan for the FCC to address Wifi issues with spectrum auctions like this? Right now, Wifi is becoming practically unusable in large apartment complexes or open spaces like conference centers due to the large number of devices competing for spectrum. I'd be interested to hear if there are any FCC plans or open standards that could resolve this.
- tedunangst 10y agoHigh frequency wifi like 60ghz that doesn't go through walls.
- throwaway2048 10y agoif only my apartment didnt have walls.
- davidf18 10y agoIt is good news that the auction raised less than expected. It shouldn't be auctioned at all. The cell phone providers simply pass on the costs of spectrum to customers. The government should want to make cell phone use as low-cost as possible to encourage its use.
- zackmorris 10y agoI'm a little unclear about this. Is this a lease or a sale? As spectrum is part of the commons, then amortized over forever the price should be, well, infinite.
- joecool1029 10y agoIt's a sale.