18 ms·
Falling Home Prices Could Be a Good Thing
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoCould be? For anyone outside the boomer generation falling housing prices would be a godsend. Millennials are starting to get priced out of entire cities, and it's generally the ones with the most jobs available. It's starting to look like "millennial" will become an insult meaning someone with no job and no money, hilarious given that it applies to an entire generation.
- zkms 10y agoI strongly concur -- as a millennial who has been without adequate housing a few times, falling housing prices and rising housing supply (the latter tends to be a necessary condition for the former) is extremely good.
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoI'm in the upper middle class wage quartile and my rent is so high that losing my job would ruin me completely. High rent(for a reasonable one-bedroom) combined with my student loan payments means it takes about $3700 a month just to pay bills and live. I'm not in Cali or NYC either.
- patrickthebold 10y agoI think you mean it's good for anyone who's not a homeowner.
- chatterbeak 10y agoI'm an actual homeowner (no mortgage!) in 94087, and I'd love it if house prices fell. Bubbles aren't good for anyone, in the long run.
- caconym_ 10y agoNo kidding. I'm not an economist so my opinion on this isn't necessarily worth a lot but it seems pretty clear that it's more important for young people to be able to live financially stable lives near good job markets than it is for real estate to perform as a lucrative investment for those who are already well-off enough to own it. The former is clearly necessary for the future health of our society and economy; the latter seems easily replaceable: just invest in something else. Since we can't all live in the single most desirable place, it's always going to be a market in some sense, but I really believe that we could (and should) do a much better job making housing affordable than we do now.
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoThe biggest problem in most of these cities is current residents preventing new housing from being built. Most of these residents own property of their own and directly benefit from the higher prices that result. Most of these residents are also old. It's literally the boomer generation fucking over everyone trying to move in for their own benefit.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThe solution here is to build new communities. Find a place with no residents but within commute radius, and build up. And ignore all the environmental bullcrap that existing home owners will try to astroturf. People won't hurt environment by gathering in one place that they did by spreading up.
- dajohnson89 10y agoThe amount of capital required for that seems enormous. But a good idea.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThat's the sort of capital banks will happily lend to you.
- autokad 10y agoi'm not a boomer and that wouldn't be good for me. it wouldnt be a godsend to cities either, with plummeting revenues (schools would be especially hit hard). home prices fell not long ago, and that was bad for nearly everyone. home prices and jobs kind of come together, not always but mostly. its sort of like wishing no one would eat at your favorite restaurant so you wouldn't have to wait in line, only to see it go out of business. millennials will have to do better than wishing people ahead of them get dragged down so they can jump ahead.
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoThis is only a problem for foolish states/cities that raise money mostly from property taxes. Besides, the main problem is current residents not allowing additional housing to be built. The additional income from new properties would more than offset the revenue drop from property values. It's not about millennials "jumping ahead" either. This generation came of age during the worst recession since the great depression. They are on track to be the poorest generation in American history. The combination of funding cuts to state universities and rising housing costs in places with jobs available gives millennials less choice and more debt than any generation alive in the US. This is a generation that is the best educated but poorest in our nation's history, coming right after one of the richest and prolific generations. The implications are clear. The previous generation maintaining the status quo. They voted for the funding cuts and NIMBYism that resulted in the lack of housing and student loan debt of the current generation.
- monkmartinez 10y agoI disagree. One, property taxes didn't go down materially in my jurisdiction despite housing prices dropping precipitously. Two, schools have already been hit hard with horrible admin teams and the rise of open-enrollment. Three, jobs don't have as much of an affect on home prices as they once did. That is, investors|flippers|NAR shysters| and the government control far more of the housing market prices than we give credit for. I am not a boomer, but they have been in charge for a while and have really messed things up.
- autokad 10y ago
- hsitz 10y agoThe idea that you need to buy a house, or that buying a house is always a wise financial move if you have the means to do it, is misguided. The question of whether it's a financially smarter decision to own a house vs rent (and invest the savings) is not easily answered, which alternative ends up better over the long term is different in different scenarios. One thing that is true in most conditions, though, is that in comparing alternatives where a young person buys more house than they need (which used to be quite common) against renting a modest and reasonable "young adult" apartment, renting is likely to come out ahead.
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoIt's not fully about buying or renting either. Pricing effects both equally
- hsitz 10y agoThe question of whether buying or renting is better financially depends on lots of different things. The price to rent ratio is one of those things. I'm not sure what you mean by "pricing affects both equally", but it certainly is not true that the price to rent ratio in a location is fixed over time or that it is the same in different locations or cities at the same time. In areas with high price to rent ratios it is often better to rent. In areas with low price to rent ratios it is often better to buy. A basic definition can be found here: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price-to-rent-ratio.asp?lgl=no-infinite http://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price-to-rent-ratio.asp?...
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIt depends. Outside NYC/SanFran, rents are usually what you'd pay for a mortgage plus some nominal upcharge. I took a gig in Houston in 2011, knew it was a bubble going in, and rented. I probably paid $200 more per month to rent vs. buy. Apres la deluge in 2016, I was in great shape; it cost me roughly $12k as insurance against having to sell into a down market.
- RestlessMind 10y agoToday's first time homebuyer is typically 35 yr old[1]. Assuming people older than 35 too have (typically) purchased homes by now, you are looking at boomers + genX + genY, invested in the real estate market. In other words, falling home prices would devastate a broad portion of the society and would wreck the economy. [1] http://www.zillow.com/agent-resources/download/todays-first-time-home-buyer/ http://www.zillow.com/agent-resources/download/todays-first-...
- throwawaydbfif 10y agoAnother way to look at it is that home buying in the millennial generation is at a historical low. They are the biggest generation besides boomers so the effect of this is somewhat magnified. "Devastating" the housing market to make it possible for younger Americans to buy homes again will only decrease wealth inequality since the ones who own homes are generally wealthy. It's not like the houses will suddenly go away if housing prices drop. They are hard assets, nothing is destroyed by the lowering of housing values besides speculative worth. Sure some people would lose a lot of money but it would largely hurt the wealthy and help income equality along with leveling the gap a bit between those generations and poorest one in our history
- RestlessMind 10y ago> ... will only decrease wealth inequality since the ones who own homes are generally wealthy. I beg to differ. Wealthy will be fine because they have diversified assets. The ones truly hurt would be people in their 30's, who have just started putting down roots (first home, family etc) and would have invested a chunk of their savings in the downpayment. So wealth inequality might reduce a bit between top 20% and bottom 20%. But it will increase between 1% and the rest. > ...nothing is destroyed by the lowering of housing values besides speculative worth. Household balance sheets for middle-class, whose main asset is their homes, are destroyed. Now suddenly you are left with, say, a mortgage of 400K vs a house worth only 250K. > ... help income equality along with leveling the gap a bit ... Nope - the boomers would still fare better since their mortgages should have been paid off by now (generally), and they have a decent rich safety net. Ones screwed are genX and genY as I explained above.
- pdkl95 10y agoWhile lower house prices would be great for "millennials", the real problem is the gap in income[1] that started a ~25 years ago. Housing prices wouldn't be nearly as bad if incomes were at their proper level relative to productivity. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ef/Productivity_and_Real_Median_Family_Income_Growth_in_the_United_States.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ef/Producti...
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoDean Baker places this at around 1980, so more than 25 years. There was the one span of time ( late '90s ) where it was suspended, and wages grew. He has a new book, "Rigged" and flogs the book on BookTv ( my "books for the post literate" source... )
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoPolicy has been explicitly designed to suppress wages. The Humphrey-Hawkins bill of 1979 is considered in Fed moves, but a vague notion of "price stability" gets first pick.
- Retric 10y agoThe average home price in 1950 was ~8,450$ or $84,151 today. Suggesting even 200k as a reasonable median seems excessive. PS: Medain income was $4,237 in 1950 which works out to $42,195 today. So, it's not like the average american is all that much better off.
- ebbv 10y agoLand was a lot more plentiful in 1950, especially near urban centers. The population has also increased drastically. Inflation alone is not enough to do a reasonable extrapolation of what houses should cost today.
- Retric 10y agoThe US still has a lot of farm land in every state in the continental US under 5k per half acre. While it's true the population has flocked to a tiny fraction of city's that's more an issue poor planning than any fundamental issue. https://www.usda.gov/nass/PUBS/TODAYRPT/land0815.pdf https://www.usda.gov/nass/PUBS/TODAYRPT/land0815.pdf
- WillPostForFood 10y agoHouses are also bigger now, safer due to many construction regulations, more energy efficient (at least per sq/ft), all of which also add to the cost.
- Retric 10y agoBigger is largely a result of poor incentives. Insulation is really cheap with the median running less than 1% of new home sale prices. US home prices in the US have an interesting history with several incentices to make homes more affordable resulting in higher home prices. 120 years ago most non farm houses where bought with cash, resulting in cheap and affordable housing being the norm. PS: Like with cars the trend is for people with above average incomes buying new homes which means the used market tends to have older upsale housing instead of affordable new housing.
- techsupporter 10y agoAt the risk of sounding brusque, don't just read the headline of this article and then comment because the headline doesn't mean what it reads like on the surface. It's not "house prices are falling and this could be awesome." Instead, the article's thesis is: > So instead of looking at homes as investments, what if we regarded them like a TV or a car or any other consumer good? People might expect home prices to go down instead of up. Homebuilders would probably spend more time talking about technology and design than financing options. Politicians might start talking about their plans to lower home prices further, as they often do with fuel prices. The article is going over a paper[0] that asks what would happen to house prices if houses were treated as disposable consumer goods instead of a means of storing wealth. It also points out, correctly in my opinion, that such a shift would be monumental (if only because everyone would have to do it at the same time). 0 - http://realestate.wharton.upenn.edu/research/papers/full/802.pdf http://realestate.wharton.upenn.edu/research/papers/full/802...
- twblalock 10y agoIncidentally, this is what has happened in Japan, but with one big difference. In Japan, people expect houses to be worthless after a decade, and they rebuild their houses frequently. This is partly because the poor quality of houses built in the first decades after WWII has created a bias against older homes that is probably no longer justified. Many buyers tear down homes and replace them -- this happens everywhere, but it is more common in Japan. People who have owned their home for a few decades will have it torn down and rebuilt every 20-30 years, and they will continue to live in the new one without any intention of selling the land. On the other hand, while homes are worthless after a decade, land is extremely expensive. This leads to 40-year mortgages or to people building homes on land they lease for decades, and having them torn down when the lease ends. I don't expect that kind of situation to develop in the US, nor do I want it to, but it's always good to learn about other approaches to home ownership, because it demonstrates that considering a home as an investment is not natural or inevitable.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBut the problem is, if you've just spent 40 years paying a mortgage (which I assure you is probably a non-insignificant amount of your lifetime income in aggregate), you would expect to be able to recoup at least some of that expense, no? In the US, your primary residence is usually your largest asset, and by its very nature, it becomes an investment that you want to protect. The depreciating nature of real estate in Japan is okay because they're a nation of savers. They have other investments to draw upon in retirement. This is not true in the US, and your home is essentially a forced retirement vehicle (unless you're just stripping out the equity all of the time, in which case you're screwed). TL;DR It'd be fine if we pushed down real estate asset prices if people saved more and needed less income in retirement.
- pager86 10y agoHouses can basically last an arbitrarily long amount of time and still remain functional. With most things, like a car, there is some nebulous end of life where its value is effectively $0, and the value of that thing will steadily decrease over time until it reaches that point. Because houses hold their value, people can sell houses when they don't need them, which makes it an investment. Of course value of housing and land change over time - the fact that there's a market ensures that - and of course people want to sell something for more than they bought it for if they are planning on selling. Housing as an investment is so intrinsic to its nature I don't see how to avoid it.
- chadcmulligan 10y agoI'm not sure if that's true - houses depreciate the same as cars. What does appreciate is the house on its location, often old houses go for land value, sometimes less if they haven't been maintained because you have to factor demolition costs in.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoI mostly agree with you, but want to note that there are exceptions to land appreciating. You can look at neighborhoods in cities like Detroit or Buffalo where the house and land have depreciated to almost nothing.
- maxsilver 10y ago> Houses can basically last an arbitrarily long amount of time and still remain functional. With most things, like a car, there is some nebulous end of life where its value is effectively $0, and the value of that thing will steadily decrease over time until it reaches that point. That's equally true of housing as well. Come on up to Michigan, I can walk you though entire neighborhoods filled with homes that are all functionally obsolete and valueless. Homes actually get worse -- a home can have negative value. If an empty lot costs $60k, it's not uncommon for a house on an equivalent lot to be only worth $50k, because it's assumed you'll have to spend $10k to properly demolish and dispose of the existing home before the lot becomes usable. In this scenario, the homes value is effectively negative $10k. Homes don't hold their value, land and zoning does. And with prices as crazy high as they are today, the actual home cost is almost an afterthought. I suspect if land and zoning actually became affordable, more people would opt to toss and rebuild their old homes with new modern ones, similar to Tokyo residential development.
- branchless 10y agoLand is expensive because the banks will advance huge amounts against your future income. They have no constraint on this as when they advance credit they do so by creating it. When wages go up, mortgage lending goes up (and by a multiple). The banks hoover up all productivity gains. NYTimes might want house prices to go down but they have to take on the banks if they mean it. Incredible that anyone could disagree with this, really, but downvote away.
- mcguire 10y agoIt seems difficult to argue with the idea that the reason housing in SF is more expensive that that in Detroit is because there is more money chasing it.
- branchless 10y agoApparently many think it's because people in SF have forgotten how to build. They are constructing inefficiently using expensive materials. Credit sets the price. Banks issue as much credit as they can, leaving workers with enough to eat / heat / clothe themselves and no more. I cannot understand how anyone can think otherwise. This is how we create money. Where is all the money going in SF with all the highly paid devs? A big wedge to the landlords. Because all productivity gains flow into land because that is what the banks use to create new debt.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> Where is all the money going in SF with all the highly paid devs? A big wedge to the landlords. Because all productivity gains flow into land because that is what the banks use to create new debt. But you don't have to live in SF. You live there because that's where employers who will pay high wages are. Therefore, you decide to live there instead of working remotely or living somewhere with a lower cost of living. Landlords are not the problem (although, they are a symptom). Tech employers who demand you live in SF are the problem. And as long as employees continue to flock there despite the real estate cost, employers will continue to push the externality of housing costs onto them. When non-tech workers complain its too expensive to live in SF, everyone says "market forces". When tech workers complain its too expensive, its a housing crisis.
- sologoub 10y ago> By the paper’s calculations, a home in the San Francisco area should cost around $281,000. This makes very little sense to me - San Francisco is surrounded by water on three sides and borders other towns/cities on the 4th, so how does one account for the demand of new housing once the existing housing is built? In other words, let's say we increase density sufficiently, so that we flood the market with new homes (apartments for SF) and drive the price down to 281k. As time passes and population increases, with a fixed land supply, you'll need to build denser. But you have people already living in the homes you'll need to tear down. How do you force enough of them to move so that you always maintain enough housing stock to keep prices low? It has been done with marginal success in non-market economies. For example, in USSR, when new apartment buildings were to be built where older ones currently stood, government simply ordered people to relocate to "improved" new apartments, usually located in undesirable areas of the city. This is hardly fair. A US version of that could use eminent domain powers, but I somehow doubt the people of the city would support that. Another question is whether people will want to live in that level of density. Eventually, you'll have price stratification based on height and access to sunlight. In NYC, you already see sunlight or lack of it as a significant pricing factor. Street noise is another factor. That said, it doesn't mean there isn't some sort of sane middle ground. SF could use more development, just like the westside of LA, but it won't result in $281k price point.
- rtpg 10y ago"The people of the city" It depends on what proportion of the city owns their home. If most people are renters, of course they want the price of housing to go down! If there's one good rallying cry against capitalism as an effective means of societal advance, it's rent seeking and the conflicts it causes. I bring it up every time this topic comes up, but NYC is not the only way to make a "big city". Tokyo is nice, high density, but there are trees all over the place. All for 1/5th the rent of SF. A well designed big city is not one that just has taller buildings. It has better service distribution, so there are, overall, less cars. There aren't just a grid of avenues (that's too convenient for cars!), but many roads that are smaller. Building development is not allowed to block out sunlight from other buildings. Street noise is handled by making only a couple large avenues, with most streets being extremely small and low-traffic. Yes, it makes traffic worse for some people. Don't have as many people driving all over.
- mcguire 10y agoIt is somewhat difficult to take seriously a paper that includes a statement like "Vacant land sales are rarely observed in the United States,..." I haven't gone through the economic model described in the paper, but it appears to be a traditional, static, linear thing that has a few issues. If you want to live somewhere with fewer regulations, there are plenty of opportunities. Just avoid these things: http://kotv.images.worldnow.com/images/6723723_G.jpg http://kotv.images.worldnow.com/images/6723723_G.jpg And probably: http://www.precisebuildings.com/images/uploads/build/400/dsc_0017__large.jpg http://www.precisebuildings.com/images/uploads/build/400/dsc... And keep in mind these may be your neighbors: http://worldonline.media.clients.ellingtoncms.com/img/croppedphotos/2016/04/01/trash_house310_2-lead_t240.jpg?9b075e176a263354460210e5f64f6db9d4623575 http://worldonline.media.clients.ellingtoncms.com/img/croppe...
- lazyasciiart 10y agoWhat are the first two pictures?
- rhizome 10y agoFirst one looks like a suburban chicken coop and the second a factory farm.
- mcguire 10y agoThe first is a pen for raising fighting chickens. The roosters are in cages; you need to keep them separated or they will (obviously) fight. Not all fighting chickens are raised for cockfights, but in largely-unregulated areas of the US, many are. The fights are illegal and rather unsavory, and tend to attract characters who are rather unsavory themselves. Not the kind of thing you want for neighbors. The second is a building for raising commercial chickens. In my experience, they smell worse than cattle feedlots but better than hog packing plants. The third is an oddity: many people seem to store their wealth in the form of junk in their yards. Not sure how that's supposed to work, actually. You'll occasionally hear of someone in a metropolitan area being forced to clean up, or having the city do it for them. This is not the case in the regulation-free rural areas.
- 0xC0DECAFE2020 10y agoI'm in the process of researching alternatives to conventional housing. It's a fascinating area to research. The alternatives, particularly with regard to new building systems and modes of living, are available at reasonable cost. The road blocks in the way are breaking with tradition/mindset and filling the gap with regard to rent seeking revenues both public and private, but mostly public in the form of property taxes. I see us being on the cusp of a change in attitudes and the way we value housing.
- monkmartinez 10y agoThis is cool, and I really hope it goes somewhere. I own a home, but think the whole thing is stupid.
- S4M 10y agoI had a colleague at a previous job who was living in a boat. He once told me tnat the costs to rent a place in the harbour, to maintain the boat and the utilities were about 400 euros/month, which is about the rent he'd pay for a small studio in Barcelona. The rents arec cheaper there but maybe in New York or San Francisco one can save lots of money like that.
- kogepathic 10y ago> I had a colleague at a previous job who was living in a boat. Sounds like fun! Do you know what kind of boat (e.g. motor boat, sail boat, yacht) and how much he paid for the boat? Looking at sail boats, they're surprisingly expensive for a reasonably sized one (e.g. seafaring).
- pfarnsworth 10y agoThe real solution is to entice global companies like Google and Facebook to start building employment centers in areas like the Midwest. Having so many rich engineers competing for the same houses is what is causing prices to skyrocket. There's no excuse for contemporary companies to keep pouring more and more money into the Bay Area, when they could easily work remote. Divert the demand to other geographic locations, and then you'll see the supply loosen and prices soften.
- twblalock 10y ago> The real solution is to entice global companies like Google and Facebook to start building employment centers in areas like the Midwest. Why should they do that when the best engineers want to live in the Bay Area? The talent can come to them.
- brutus1213 10y agoI know many engineers at those companies. After a baby or two, everyone starts complaining about crazy home prices.
- twblalock 10y agoEveryone complains, but few actually leave, and there are many more willing to move to the Bay Area to replace those who do leave. The major tech companies aren't stupid. If they could benefit significantly by opening offices in the midwest or anywhere else they don't currently have offices, they would have done it by now.
- brutus1213 10y ago"aren't stupid" .. agreed to some extent. But I don't buy the no talent outside the bay area theory. Wonder if something else is afoot. I'll give you an anecdote .. Google has an engineering office in Waterloo and Amazon has one in Toronto. Both have quite a few former expats who wanted to be closer to their Canadian families. There is demand.
- RestlessMind 10y agoI read the article and it just glosses over the political difficulties, which will be extremely hard to overcome. Basically, when the most engaged citizenry also happens to be homeowners, legislating any measure that reduces home values will be akin to political suicide. Even while it acknowledges the hypothetical nature of its arguments, the article doesn't consider negative factors - like the massive number of middle class middle-aged homeowners, whose mortgages will be underwater in case home prices were to drop. Is there going to be bailout of all of them? If not, we are looking at a repeat of 2008. If yes, who foots the bill? Maybe, this idea would have been interesting at the beginning before homeownership was entrenched with the personal wealth. Now? Not so sure.
- Atheros 10y agoPrices don't need to actually drop in dollar terms. They can drop slowly in real terms. That would be sufficient. No 2008-event necessary.
- RestlessMind 10y agoYou mean, rate of inflation being higher than rate of house price increases? Sounds good in theory, but how do you pull it off in practice in a somewhat free market like US?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Mikeb85 10y agoFalling home prices is absolutely a good thing. When home prices are too high, it prices out regular consumers, only professional investors and landlords can afford them, they take economic rent, it's a drag on the economy and cost of living, and hurts the working class. It's pretty easy to see in places like Vancouver, and while it's not as bad in many other places, it's still insidious.
- anonu 10y agoIn the US, homes are the best way for the middle class to create wealth because the government essentially subsidizes this transfer. The entire financial system and tax code are designed to support this. There is no other country in the world where you can just get a loan that leverages you up 10:1 . This is where the cycle begins. Home prices have to go up now, otherwise these loans go underwater and we get another financial crises like the one we saw in 2008. Then, the tax code effectively gives you free money to do this trade. If you don't take advantage of it, you're probably missing out. Finally, this is why we always like a bit of inflation. Inflation devalues that loan and pushes the price of your house up. Falling home prices would be a disaster for America ... we've already seen this scenario less than 10 years ago...
- dilemma 10y ago>The entire financial system and tax code are designed to support this. There is no other country in the world where you can just get a loan that leverages you up 10:1. It's actually the same in most or all western countries.
- jstanley 10y ago> There is no other country in the world where you can just get a loan that leverages you up 10:1. That's a big claim, and possibly I've misunderstood it. I live in England and I had no trouble at all getting a mortgage with a 10% deposit.
- pzone 10y agoThe entire point of the article is that this way of thinking is outdated. Yes, we have long considered homes as primary investments and as the best way to grow wealth, and yes, we have had falling home prices bite us in the ass before. But these things are not set in stone, and a world where houses are just one of many goods we own and consume would work out just fine too, and perhaps it would work even better. We can change the tax code, and home prices don't have to drop suddenly like they did in 2008 and put people underwater. They could simply plateau.
- namlem 10y ago
- dalbasal 10y agoI wonder how much of the "shrinking middle class" is attributable to rising house prices in the desirable areas that these people live.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe number of desirable places with good wages has declined. We're struggling with this. Dean Baker has at least the start of a theory. His BookTv is here, soon ( it was on air yesterday, so they haven't posted it yet ): https://www.c-span.org/video/?421857-2/dean-baker-discusses-rigged https://www.c-span.org/video/?421857-2/dean-baker-discusses-...
- kqr2 10y agoHis books are freely available online. His latest book is Rigged: How Globalization and the Rules of the Modern Economy Were Structured to Make the Rich Richer http://deanbaker.net/books/rigged.htm http://deanbaker.net/books/rigged.htm