6 ms·
I surprised there was no mention in the blog post or the comments so far about the homework factor. It isn't just personal side projects that people are workin
by slg 10y ago
I surprised there was no mention in the blog post or the comments so far about the homework factor. It isn't just personal side projects that people are working on over the weekend. I am betting the relative percentage of CS students on the site is also much higher on the weekend. Tags like assembly, pointers, algorithm, recursion, class, and math are all rather vague. Those topics are all discussed at length in CS classes, but if you are working on a real world project in those fields, odds are you will tag it with a more specific technology you are using rather than the abstract theory behind it.
EDIT: On second look, Python, C, and C++ are also the go to languages for CS classes (along with Java but that is also a big enterprise language unlike the other three.) Almost this whole list seems to be schoolwork related.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> On second look, Python, C, and C++ are also the go to languages for CS classes And so is Haskell. But I doubt Unity 3D is schoolwork related.
- beefsack 10y agoI used Haskell for a significant portion of my CS education, it's possible you aren't far from the mark.
- zzzzzzzza 10y agoI went to ut austin and after a long time using haskell for intro classes the administrators succumbed to temptation (and possibly pressure from dell/ibm for wage slaves) maybe ~10 years ago and started using java. It was kind of horrible because the professor for (at least one of the) intro classes reproduced cons, car and cdr from lisp and had us construct a bunch of data structures out of this monstrous java lisp hybrid. point being probably only top tier cs depts use haskell.
- rifung 10y agoI don't think it has anything to do with the "tier" as I believe UT Austin used Haskell because of Dijkstra: http://chrisdone.com/posts/dijkstra-haskell-java http://chrisdone.com/posts/dijkstra-haskell-java MIT has also switched to Python from Scheme
- wyager 10y agoIt was around when Dijkstra died that UT switched away from Haskell to Java. And yes, from what I've heard from several faculty members around in that period, a lot of it was from external pressure from large regional employers (some of which you have mentioned).
- sulam 10y agoHonestly, would you rather hire an intern that has to learn Java from scratch, or one that actually had a class in it? I'm a fan of Haskell, but I think it being the intro CS class language is an educational fail.
- inimino 10y agoUniversities are not supposed to be trade schools though, right?
- flukus 10y agoAround here they always advertise themselves with slogans like "an education for the real world". I think they became trade schools but still haven't realized it.
- noir_lord 10y agoIn the absence of proper trade schools they end up adapting (or been forced into) offering something that looks a lot like a trade school. I've maintained for years (since I was at college in the 2000's (UK meaning of college not US)) that programming education should be two tier, the theoretical tier at university and the practical tier using the traditional trade school model. Taking another domain there is a lot of difference between the person doing the load bearing calculations on the bricks and structures and the person laying the actual bricks. I've always fallen more into the latter camp naturally, I like to build things and I learn the applicable theory as and when I need to and you can get a long way with experience and a little theory when you can leverage the underpinning work of other people. It's interesting to note that in the UK the apprentice/master model sorta exists already if you squint in the difference between junior/senior developer when done 'correctly' anyway though at the moment due to developer demand the meaning of 'senior' has degraded down to a couple of years commercial experience apparently.
- yttrium 10y agoNo way - I used unity for two classes in college, one elective and one non elective. I know of at least 2 more available as well.
- jeron 10y agojust curious, what classes were they? I believe my university uses Unity for the VR classes
- yttrium 10y agoThe first was part one of a graphics sequence. That class goes on for at least one more, although I stopped after the first one because it wasn't really my cup of tea. The second was one of the project courses required to finish the degree - it was also part of a two part series.
- Kiro 10y agoWhat are you saying "no way" to? Of course there are classes using Unity but I am very certain the bulk of these questions are not school related. Just look at any of the big Indie Game groups on Facebook.
- hutzlibu 10y agoYes, the only time I had to mess with Haskell was, when I had to ...
- jackmott 10y agoI expect a lot of C/C++ are from weekend game/graphics hobbyists.
- metaprinter 10y agoI robotC for weekend Lego NXT / EV3 classes.
- zik 10y agoPersonally I write compilers in C++ on the weekend.
- 72deluxe 10y agoPerhaps people are writing C++ successfully instead of asking questions about it or looking for answers regarding it. I know I'm writing C++ every weekend (and day, night, morning, afternoon.....)
- rifung 10y agoWhat proportion of people asking questions do you think are students vs professionals/other nonstudents? Seeing as most people are only students for 4 years of their life, I would be surprised at how much students contribute to this change. I also can't think of a reason as to why students would be asking more questions on weekends vs weekdays. Especially for the big difference in Haskell, I just can't imagine its largely caused by students since most students will probably only get to use it for one or two courses.
- kybishop 10y agoStudents are much more likely to ask lots of questions. Far more difficult projects are often due on a Monday or Tuesday to give students the weekend to finish up, the exact kind of projects likely to elicit questions at the last minute.
- rifung 10y agoDo you have any data to back that up? At least when I was a student, I would be pretty unlikely to ask on Stack Overflow because I'd probably need answers quickly and not want to wait for a response, but I don't expect everyone to be like me. I also don't even feel like my assignments were typically due on Monday or Tuesday. I remember often students would ask their teachers to make their assignments due Friday instead of Monday.
- morgante 10y ago> At least when I was a student, I would be pretty unlikely to ask on Stack Overflow because I'd probably need answers quickly and not want to wait for a response, but I don't expect everyone to be like me. Many classes have assignments over a week or two. It absolutely makes sense to ask SO for questions. If anything, there was less urgency to my homework questions than there is to my current professional ones. > I also don't even feel like my assignments were typically due on Monday or Tuesday. While I had my fair share of assignments on Monday, that doesn't need to be true to explain this. Even if you assume that students work equally throughout the week on homework, they'd represent a larger percentage of developers during the weekend (when professionals are much less likely to be working).
- morgante 10y agoYup, seeing the top 10 list made me immediately think of homework assignments. In the real world, programmers don't take their questions with "recursion" or "pointers" very often. Nor is Assembly a common language for side projects. This definitely seems like a case of students simply being relatively overrepresented on weekends.
- KirinDave 10y agoASM (not necessarily x86), C and C++ are very well represented in side projects and hobbies because of the DIY device community, though.
- thinkmassive 10y agoCertainly, because it's what a lot of us learned in academia. Everyone's right!
- frozenport 10y agoThe argument is that you would see a more specific tag like MIPS.
- zrm 10y agoSuppose you have 10000 posts tagged with #MIPS #assembly, 8000 tagged with #x86 #assembly and 6000 tagged with #arm #assembly. Then you have 10000 tagged with #MIPS and 24000 tagged with #assembly.
- js8 10y agoFunny, when I saw the top 10, Edward Kmett came to my mind. He is likely the most prolific Haskell hacker, but he also recently started a side project writing some graphics shaders for VR in C (when he was younger, he was in the demoscene community). So yeah, some people are weird that way..
- jackmott 10y agoI think focusing one one high level language like Haskell/OCaml/F# and one low level language like C is the truth path to enlightenment.
- hyperpallium 10y agoI would have expected HW to be only a small proportion, but I'd also expect think terms like "pointers, algorithm, recursion" to be much more common for HW. If Hw, would correlate annually with semesters (noting that SO is internationally popular, and different countries have different schedules).
- solidr53 10y agoYou're right, github data would be much more accurate for weekend projects.
- jammycakes 10y agoThis. Also, I'd have thought that with weekend projects you're more likely to find things out by experimentation and reading the documentation than by asking questions. With work or classroom projects, you have to work with a fixed spec, a prescribed technology, all sorts of Best Practices, and deadlines. Weekend projects give you much more freedom in all four respects. So yes, GitHub would be much more accurate.
- mirekrusin 10y agoExactly and plausible Haskell weekend shift explanation may be that it's just difficult language and/or not many people are using it in real projects (during work week).