12 ms·
Millennials want to live in cities. Specifically, millennials want to live near city centers, where they can commute to work by foot, bike, train, bus, or Segw
by bitwize 10y ago
Millennials want to live in cities.
Specifically, millennials want to live near city centers, where they can commute to work by foot, bike, train, bus, or Segway. Basic laws of supply and demand dictate that the value of property, and the rents, must go up, since as society urbanizes there are an increasing number of people vying for a fixed amount of real estate.
Part of the American dream of owning a home was predicated on the fact that land would be developed outside the major cities, and homeowners would use newly affordable automobiles to get to their workplace and anywhere else they might want to go. Which led to drab, soulless, lifesucking suburbs and an obsession with gas-guzzling, air-polluting, global-temperature-raising motor vehicles. Ewwwwwwwwwww. How bourgeois, how planet-unconscious, how typically American.
So while millennials may not particularly dislike owning homes, they have made lifestyle choices that tend to make home ownership more difficult. Unfortunately, those are the constraints of modern capitalism. Personally, I think we need to rethink our whole economic system. It'd be great if someone came up with an alternative economic system in which one can have one's cake and eat it too, but until that happens we're stuck with the situation we're in.
Meanwhile, houses in the boonies are cheap. If you can remote-work your way into a boonie lifestyle, you can own a home on a rather modest income indeed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nugget 10y agoOne solution is to revitalize second- and third-tier urban centers. Places like Nashville (already hot), Tampa, Detroit, and Indianapolis. Perhaps even Lincoln, Nebraska, and Birmingham, Alabama. Not everyone can live in Manhattan itself but the density, services, and lifestyle millennials want can be recreated elsewhere where land costs are practically zero. An art scene, a food scene, some condo loft conversions and trendy commercial space; it's a sort of county-level cultural CRISPR process. Smart entrepreneurs are already hard at work on this but it's an effort in which I think Government could provide massively effective incentives to accelerate the outcome.
- riprowan 10y agoYou've hit the nail on the head. The trick is to discover and curate small city life so that one can live in a small city without feeling like one went back in time. Then you get to have your cake and eat it too.
- pc86 10y agoWe live in a very small city (metro pop 500-600k so maybe 1/4 the size of Nashville and 1/2 the size of Birmingham), and when my wife and I were dating we lived in an apartment downtown. It was great! Only two things made us move. 1. We wanted a big dog, and that's a non-starter for 90% of apartments. 2. Property taxes were 3-4x what they were just a mile or two outside of the city center.
- woah 10y agoThe scarcity of housing in cities is artificial. Most cities have a class of elderly landowners who enjoy their unobstructed views and high property values and have the time to sit in planning meetings all day and will fight tooth and nail against any new construction, using both liberal (gentrification) and conservative (crime and crowding) arguments.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThe development obstruction is real. If you don't believe me then join Nextdoor for a neighborhood that's in the bay. You will find a group of highly dedicated and organized individuals who's sole purpose in life is to prevent any new high capacity zoning or construction.
- nmerouze 10y agoI've lived in Paris where it is the same, or even worse because there are historic buildings everywhere. Now I live in Japan where it is the polar opposite. I live in a very dense area of Osaka in a building built in 2013 for the same price than my way smaller and very old place in Paris. If only Europe and North America could be like that...
- yourapostasy 10y agoInteresting, any insight to why the Japanese body politic expresses a stronger preference for new and denser construction? I've heard anecdotally that Japanese culture specifically (and Asian culture more loosely) tends to shun "used" housing far more than the US market, but haven't been able to find any reference to support that hearsay.
- donw 10y agoThat is broadly true -- used houses have negative value here in Japan, as you need to first tear the thing down so that you can build whatever it is that you want. In Japan, things shake. A lot. Earthquake damage adds up pretty quickly, and is stupidly expensive to engineer against, so most houses are built with an expected lifespan of probably somewhere around 50 years. They're certainly safe, but there is a strong expectation that a family will live there until the kids move out and the parents retire. Highrises are economically preferable for a number of reasons. Japan has both an excellent rail transit network and sane zoning laws. So you end up with a cluster of highrises around a train station, where the bottom 1-3 levels are devoted to shopping, recreation, and everything else that you would see in a typical shopping mall. Life revolves around the rail network, at least in Tokyo. You don't as much go from the Ikebukuro Ward to the Shinjuku Ward as you go from Home to Ikebukuro Station to Shinjuku Station to Where It Is You Want To Go. I don't see this ever happening in the US, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Personally, I would much prefer a larger number of slightly smaller cities, with companies either going fully-remote, or establishing a federated group of (drastically cheaper) offices in multiple cities. You end up with a lot more local flavor, but without the SF or NYC rents.
- yourapostasy 10y agoAs long as we're using capitalism to explain what is happening, then by all means let's use more capitalism in the US housing market. 1. Remove all government sponsorship of mortgages, gradually spool off all existing GSE mortgages into private markets. Possible exception: owner-occupied homes, limit one per 2. Remove all implicit government backing of insurers and re-insurers of anything having to do with mortgages. 3. Remove mortgage interest deduction. 4. Valuations reported to IRS, property insurers, permitting offices and bank loans link back to publicly-available property tax records. 5. Property developers, not taxpayers, pay for initial costs to extend infrastructure, foot the bill for floating the bonds to maintain the extensions, and residents moving in must pay into the bond fund over time, gradually paying off the initial buyers of the bond; bonds are reissued as old bonds mature. 6. Bill back costs of developing (up to inner core density, with adjustments to purchase fast public transport into inner core) further out from urban core back to inner core residents as increased property taxes spread over 7 years, if inner core residents vote down densification, and rebate some of the collected funds to developers of outer core. 7. Standardize all government building codes to a single set, specifying function/intent/goal and not form, thereby allowing offshore for example factory-built modules to access a contiguous national market, or alternative construction techniques without lengthy permitting. These and other measures that open up competition for real estate development would be wildly politically unpopular in most areas and constituencies of the US. The US real estate market is superficially capitalist for a number of very interconnected reasons, and I've observed similar dynamics in other nations I've enquired about property within. Property is an extremely special-case asset, with privileged market protections/distortions few other asset categories enjoy.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoWhile the rest are generally sound, Number 6 abandons the market and capitalism in favor of government intervention again, which is unfortunate and invites the system to be abused and gamed by the usual set of cronies. I'm against it. Number 1 should avoid use of the proposed exception for the same reason that mortgage interest shouldn't be deductible: it's a subsidy that distorts the market and is unfair to the good people who are still renting (who are, broadly speaking, probably not as well off in general, so it's a regressive subsidy where we pay the rich). You should add a #8 to remove all government subsidies of flood insurance and similar vehicles, especially along rivers and coasts, as they're basically paying people money to build homes (often luxury or vacation homes) in dangerous places.
- goseeastarwar 10y ago"Millennials want to live in cities." Says who? The article doesn't: "Overall, more than 80 percent of millennials already live in suburbs and exurbs, and they are, if anything, moving away from the dense, expensive cities" Some of it is due to cost, as it has always been, but there are hundreds of other lifestyle factors at work. Backyards are neat too, as it turns out. So are excellent public schools. So is your child riding their bike to the park. Nearly all of my friends and I lived in the city after college, got married, had kids, and moved to the burbs...just like our parents did.
- yardie 10y agoI think you protest too much. I've lived in both the cities and suburbs. I prefer the cities. As a family with an solo child the suburbs was mentally draining for our boy. What's the use of the backyard if you're playing by yourself. The park was too far away for him to walk and he had a good chance of being the only kid there, because of backyards. And finally, everyone was so damn insular. In the year we lived there we only knew a few neighbors. I'm in a low tax state which means the schools are chronically underfunded. Our school in the suburbs relied on parent fundraising to cover a lot of extracurricular stuff. Our city school relies on the density of the student body and the density of property taxes to fund extracurricular programs. It seems like everyday he's sent home with something he wants to sign up for. We sold he car, bought bikes, and ride everywhere including the park. We gave the suburbs a shot, it didn't work, so we left. My brother, on the other hand loves it. Big house for him and his spouse, the kids, and their dirt bikes.
- pc86 10y agoSchools are funded largely by property taxes, so the tax climate of your state has little to no bearing on how much money your school has, and certainly no bearing on how well they spend what they have.
- bretthoerner 10y agoIf only that were always true: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_Hood_plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_Hood_plan In Austin we paid $406 million in state recapture in 2016. That's one third of AISD's budget for the year. That money doesn't come back to us, to be clear. I wouldn't be surprised if something similar were in place in other states. In addition, I believe the state has plenty of laws that control what each county can do tax-wise, I'm too lazy to find them all right now. My point is that the state matters a lot. (Note: I'm not saying that I'm against any of this, necessarily.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wattt 10y ago> by Segway What planet are you living on where this is true? Do you work for Segway's marketing department or something?
- simonh 10y agoI think the post makes more sense if you replace 'Millennial' with 'Exaggerated caricature of a Hipster'.
- bitwize 10y agoCome now. Everybody knows the fixie is the hipster ride of choice.
- beaconstudios 10y agoare unicycles out now?
- amelius 10y agoPerhaps he meant those hoverboards that don't actually hover.
- sqldba 10y agoPeople live in suburbs and use automobiles though - and the price of houses in suburbs is still too expensive to buy (unless you're talking > 1-2 hour of travel time per day). Boonies aside (that's not the suburbs, that's literally in the middle of nowhere, and in a work environment where more and more managers don't allow remote-work), I don't think your argument holds water.
- vonmoltke 10y agoWhat suburbs are you talking about? I know people who have chosen to live way the hell out and give themselves a nasty commute, but price was rarely the driver. As for travel time, unless you are really lucky I don't think it is possible to consistently have less than 1 hour of travel time per day unless you move house every time you change jobs. Even in NYC moving just a few blocks can add or subtract 15 minutes to your commute.
- pc86 10y agoI live in a suburb where you can see the downtown buildings from our front porch. I could walk if I wanted to. Our mortgage is roughly 25% more expensive than our rent was when living downtown, including the property taxes. I think a lot of people on HN would do well to remember that any time you're discussing real estate, places like NYC and San Francisco are very much the exception, not the rule.
- facepalm 10y agoHow is that a constraint of modern capitalism? Because capitalism wouldn't build ugly, cheap skyscrapers in the town center? Even if you build government housing in town centers and give it to people for cheap, you haven't really changed the dynamics. You only subsidize a lucky set of people (the ones who get to live near the town center). How will they be chosen? Adherence to the party line?
- ouid 10y agoImagine, for a second, that there is no tax benefit to home ownership. In such a world, there is basically no reason to own a home. The cost of renting a home is about the same as the interest on a mortgage. The money that would go towards "principle" instead goes into your bank account. The interest that you pay on a mortgage is tax deductible, which is essentially a subsidy exclusively available to people who make more than the amount of money required to own a home where they live. This subsidy for decentralized living is equivalent to a tax on the vastly more efficient centralized plan. It's not intrinsic to our economic system.
- cosmie 10y agoThe cost of renting a home is about the same as the interest on a mortgage _when you purchase_. If you purchased around my house two years ago, your mortgage would be less than $800. But current rates have it at about $1,300. As a rental, you can start renting that at $1,300/month even though you bought in when market rate was $800. Plus, there's a huge number of tax benefits to investment property ownership, far more than for owner-occupied [1]. If you're going to remove the tax advantages of owner-occupied, you should also reduce the benefits of investment properties. But then you'll likely see rent rates hike as a result and the bar will tip in favor of ownership again. [1] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/top-ten-tax-deductions-landlords-29497.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/top-ten-tax-deduction...
- refurb 10y agoThe cost of renting a home is about the same as the interest on a mortgage _when you purchase_. It depends on the market. Price to rent ratios can vary a ton.[1] The link is from 2016, but the extremes are: San Francisco 48x (housing price is 48x monthly rent) Detroit 6.5x The neutral rent to price ratio is ~15. If it's higher than that, it's better to rent. If it's lower, it's better to buy. [1]https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-cities https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-ci...
- ouid 10y agoYes, I would also remove investment property tax benefits, were I emperor, but it would not cause rental rates to rise. That's not how the rental rate is decided. The rental rate is based on vacancy and income, ie supply and demand. If rental is harder to make money on, the only effect will be to drive down the cost of the property as the actual number of houses is fixed.
- Consultant32452 10y agoRental prices are being held artificially high by large private equity firms. They're going bankrupt because no one can afford them. Obama bailed them out on his way out the door which will keep rent artificially high for years to come. http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2017/01/the-obama-administration-bails-out-private-equity-landlords-at-the-expense-of-the-middle-class-government-guarantees-for-rental-securitization.html http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2017/01/the-obama-administrat...
- wcummings 10y ago>If you can remote-work Lots of people can't. Most people don't work in tech, and probably can't. Telling service workers to live in the boonies and commute an hour and a half by car to their minimum wage job is stupid and tone deaf, obviously there are better solutions. >use newly affordable automobiles to get to their workplace Many metro areas are so congested automobiles are no longer the convenient affordable choice they used to be. For some mass transit is less about being planet-conscious and more about not wanting to sit in traffic for half the day and spend $300/mo on parking. Property is hardly an optimal free market and there's lots of things we can do to improve the situation other than making fun of "Millennials". Most people I know would happily pay less to live outside of the city so long as they were still well-connected to the city center by the transit network. Expanding and improving commuter rail access and building denser more appealing suburbs will be big wins imo.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThey can work in Kansas City instead of Manhattan or SF. I'd say the majority of folks never consider moving out of the big population centers (by definition, actually). And its a really good idea, not just because of housing and density issues, but other quality of life measures.
- wcummings 10y agoCities are expensive for everyone. Not everyone has the luxury of being able to frictionlessly relocate. There's a reason lots of people live where they do. Telling people to "just move" is not a real solution.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoTelling people its hopeless is actually not a solution at all. And those people 'just moved' to NYC after all.
- wcummings 10y agoCity projects take decades to take shape. It's not hopeless, it just takes time and political will. There are people advocating for greater zoning capacity, streamlined permitting processes and investment in mass transit, among other things. >And those people 'just moved' to NYC after all. When the rich get priced out of downtown, they don't move to KC. They move to cheaper areas outside of downtown and drive up prices for lower-income people living there. When four young professionals pile into an old single family home because there aren't enough apartments, that drives up prices for families who have one or two sources of income, not four. This affects everyone who lives in a city, not just wealthy transplants. Yuppies are not the ones being displaced. The solution is a steady increased supply of market-rate housing.
- wobbleblob 10y agoYou all have so much space, but how you choose to use it is a bit disappointing. There is no shared space. No bike lanes, ok, I understand that, but in most places in town, there aren't even side walks. No town squares, no city parks, just endless rows of little castles, accessible only by car. Crossing the street on foot is illegal. Even to go running or cycling, I'd have to drive somewhere first. There are enough things to like, but this aspect is something I'll never get used to.
- cmiles74 10y agoA lot of these problems are part of this long standing idea that everyone would be traveling by car, which leads to the creation of the cheapest and least thoughtful roads possible. These ideas seem to be gradually fading, even in the small town where I live there's a big project up to add bicycle lanes and improve sidewalks.[0] [0]: http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/02/easthampton_to_compete_for_fed.html http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/02/easthampton_t...
- wobbleblob 10y agoA friend mentioned they successfully petitioned against a sidewalk on their side of the road, they don't want people walking by their property. These are cultural differences that Hollywood doesn't prepare you for.
- amyjess 10y agoMillennial here. This doesn't describe me or most of my friends. Sure, I know a couple of people who have moved to the city, but most of us have chosen to stay in the suburbs. Most of the people I went to college with and still keep in contact with either a) rent or own a house in the suburbs or b) live in a suburban apartment complex (i.e. sprawling fields of 2-story buildings). I personally split the difference and rent a townhouse in the suburbs. I have one friend who lives in one of those suburban mixed-use developments that's becoming popular now, but that's only because he's legally blind and can't drive. He's told me multiple times that if his retinas worked right, he'd own a car and drive everywhere. I love the suburbs, I love sprawl, and the same goes for most of my friends. I also hate noise and hate crowds. We don't want to live somewhere that has a "soul": we just want a place that's safe to live and have lots of space. My friends who have kids also want a place that has good schools. We're pretty bourgeois and proud of it. We're not hipsters, and in fact we're more likely to make fun of hipsters than anything.
- bretthoerner 10y agoThe opposite describes me and most of my friends. ;) I suppose it makes sense that suburban people meet suburban friends and urban people meet urban friends. That said, I don't think people in urban areas would say they love crowds or noise (and I really don't think I encounter much of either in central Austin). I'm curious what you do with all of the space. The idea of loving sprawl is odd to me. I grew up in the burbs and hate the idea of raising my kid in a place where so much of your time is spent in a car. The idea of getting a car to go anywhere or do anything crushes my soul. I think if I moved out of the city I'd mostly miss being able to walk/bike (or bus) to so many things.
- amyjess 10y ago> I suppose it makes sense that suburban people meet suburban friends and urban people meet urban friends. That's true. And it also helps that I work in the suburbs (at both my current job and my last job): all my coworkers live in the burbs too, even the ones who are the same age as me (32) or younger. Of course, I live in the Dallas area, where 90% of the tech industry is in the northern suburbs, and so are all the ethnic enclaves. You want to work in the tech industry? If you live in the city, you'll have to commute to the suburbs, so living in the burbs means you have a shorter commute. You want authentic {insert Asian ethnicity here} food? You have to go to the suburbs for it. > I'm curious what you do with all of the space. The idea of loving sprawl is odd to me. I have a lot of stuff. Also, I just like to have room to breathe; I'm slightly claustrophobic. And I just really like the look and feel of the way the northern suburbs of Dallas are laid out. I don't know if I can put it into words; it's just aesthetically pleasing to me. I've recently been toying around with the idea of moving out of state (because a. political reasons, and b. after my cat died last week, I kinda want to disappear and start over where I don't know anyone), and for aesthetic reasons the only other parts of the country that appeals to me are parts of SoCal, specifically Torrance and Orange County. They're the only places that have the same kind of aesthetics I like about the Dallas burbs. > I grew up in the burbs and hate the idea of raising my kid in a place where so much of your time is spent in a car. The idea of getting a car to go anywhere or do anything crushes my soul. I think if I moved out of the city I'd mostly miss being able to walk/bike (or bus) to so many things. I'm actually childfree, so I have no intention of raising a kid, but if I did, I'd like to raise my kid in an environment like the one I grew up in. I had a front yard and a back yard to play in, trees to climb, a large neighborhood to walk and ride my bike around. I still have fond memories walking or riding my bike down the winding alleyways and residential streets of Far North Dallas. I feel sorry for my friends' kids who are growing up in apartments (suburban apartments, yes, but still apartments). Apartment complexes just aren't conducive to that kind of atmosphere. There was no crime, no homeless people shouting things at me on the street. I went to highly-rated public schools... my family didn't have to worry about burning $$$$ on a private school just to get me a good education. Oh, and speaking of homeless people shouting things at me on the street... that regularly happened to me when I worked downtown from 2012 to 2014. I constantly had homeless people demanding I give them money or cigarettes, and they'd call me a liar when I told them I don't carry cash or that I quit smoking. I wouldn't want to subject a kid to that. During that time, I fervently wished I had a car so I could just roll up the windows and not have to deal with them. I'll always equate "not taking a car to go somewhere or do something" with "being subject to street harassment". Oh yeah, and when I worked downtown, I was too early in my transition for me to really get catcalls; if I worked there now, I'd probably be catcalled to hell and back. No thank you. I'd rather have the safety and the security of a car when I go places. Also, your name sounds really, really familiar. I think we may have gone to high school together. Did you go to HS in Richardson, TX in the early 00s? (no, you won't recognize my name... I changed my whole name -- first, middle, and last -- a few years ago)
- pouetpouet 10y agodamned if you do, damned if you don't. Want/have to move into ig cities for work->you want to live bourgeois style city center. want to stay in the boonies for cheap housing/nature/lifestyle-> you think you are entitled to a job here, jos aren't coming to you, you have to move to big job centers...
- VLM 10y agoGaslighting. You're poor, but that's OK because you never wanted money anyway and its far more important to do other things than to have money and the accompanying lifestyle. Now pay no attention to who has siphoned the money you would have had out of the system so you can't have it, isn't it more important that you hug trees? Cities have soul, I mean, spirits, I mean lots of places to buy spirits, I mean bars, and alcohol consumption is the only important cultural activity in life, why being drunk is the definition of being cultured.. Other than that, there's nothing to do in the city other than cultural activities that tend to be too expensive (if you had money you'd be living in the burbs and commuting to the activity like all the participants) and nobody on a percentage basis attends those cultural activities. Probably 100000 people say how great it is that we have a theater for off broadway musicals for every person who buys an actual over priced ticket. There are no bars in the burbs (LOL). In fact there is nothing to do in the burbs. Yup people should definitely be encouraged to stay away and stop crowding my burb.
- Arizhel 10y ago>Meanwhile, houses in the boonies are cheap. If you can remote-work your way into a boonie lifestyle, you can own a home on a rather modest income indeed. You can, but then you're stuck with all the downsides of living in the boonies: you're far away from any cultural activities, shopping, good grocery stores (i.e. not Walmart), and all the people around you are probably culturally very different and even downright distasteful, unless you happen to like extremely religious and conservative people asking you about your personal relationship with Jesus or what kind of guns you like. And this isn't all "boonies" either; some of them are pretty pricey. I live about 75 minutes from DC in a pretty rural area currently, and houses here are not that cheap. However, if I moved near some family members (about an hour SW of Richmond VA) houses there are much cheaper. And the benefits are somewhat similar: either way it's roughly an hour to get to some decent shopping, though DC's stuff is much better than RVA's, but RVA does have some cultural attractions plus some higher-end shops, just not as much as DC. But being surrounded by people you have no interest in meeting kinda sucks; at least when you're right in a city it's easier to find groups or people you get along well with who aren't too far away. Anyway, this all assumes remote work. For the Millenials, this might not be that helpful. Most jobs still require you to be on-site, and that's not going to be doable if you live in the boonies and don't want a long commute. And that's just computer work; very little non-computer work can be done remotely. What we really need is real estate development laws which push for the construction of more affordable housing, though that would probably mean more high-rise condos, rather than single-family houses. Instead, developers always target the high end of the market, building "luxury condos" and the like. There's a limited amount of real estate anywhere, so the obvious solution is to build up, not out. Finally, another thing about those "cheap" houses in the boonies. I live in one of those currently, and the heating bills are atrocious. New, nice houses out here are expensive; the cheap ones are older and horribly inefficient. They're not building a lot of new houses in the boonies, so it's mainly older stuff. The new houses in the boonies are giant mansions built by rich people as getaways. Any "new" houses in the boonies are crappy little manufactured homes.
- nunez 10y agoWhat's wrong with the grocery at Walmart??????
- marssaxman 10y agoThis shift was already happening with "gen X" - you are describing my attitude. But owning a home was never a "dream" for me - honestly it's kind of a hassle. I've recently been thinking about selling mine, turning all that imaginary equity into real money, and going back to renting. I'd be able to move back in closer to where the action is, and I'd waste less of my time and money dealing with unpredictable maintenance problems. Homeownership can be an OK investment, but it's not really that great, and you can have a lot more flexibility and security if you just stick all that money into an index fund.
- fulafel 10y agoGeometry says you can fit exponentially more people near city centers as the radius of the dense center grows linearly. IOW, marginal increase in dense city housing should be cheap per apartment.
- nunez 10y agoUh, not all of us do? I hated living in NYC.