20 ms·
His Doctors Were Stumped, Then He Took Over
- dkokelley 10y agoCan we get the title changed? The current title does not provide me with enough information to know what the article is about. How about, "Doctor diagnosed with rare Castleman disease leads charge for cure"?
- dang 10y agoI hear you, but not all titles on HN have to be self-explanatory. It's good for readers to have to work a little sometimes.
- jessriedel 10y agoHow does this further the aims of HN?
- sn9 10y agoBy forcing people to respond to or otherwise discuss the contents of the article instead of the headline.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- theoh 10y agoActually it seems like dang was making a moralistic point that I'm not sure about. Sometimes a suggestive, catchy but perhaps uninformative title is linkbait (and should be replaced), but sometimes such a title is not "bait" but instead something we just have to accept as given? Hmmm.
- tomhoward 10y agoThere's a difference between piquing curiosity and exploiting emotions. Of course there's a grey area, and this story may be closer to the line than usual, but wherever the line is, it's fair enough for dang to judge that this title is on the right side of it. Personally I don't see how the title misrepresents the content in the article, or tricks anyone into reading something they'd be better off not to have read.
- jessriedel 10y agoThat would suggest removing all titles.
- baddox 10y agoThere is delightful irony in that statement in this comment thread.
- dang 10y agoGood question! I've posted about this from time to time. Here are some links if you care: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10077754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10077754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11979596 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11979596 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10161193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10161193 https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix&page=0&query=by:dang%20%22work%20a%20little%22 https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment&query=by:dang%20reflexive%20slow https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=... The bottom line is that occasionally having to stop and work a little acts as a speed bump that slows down the usual internet reflexes, making reflective responses a bit more likely. Reflective responses are what we're hoping for here. If you introspect a bit you can catch yourself getting irritably impatient at having to take 5 seconds rather than half a second to process something on the internet. That's the reflex I'm talking about. The problem is that in that mode our responses are automatic, therefore predictable, therefore uninteresting.
- jessriedel 10y agoI read the first three comments and they all say roughly the same thing. But I can't figure why you think this functions as you hypothesize. Do you have data? Why not move the buttons on HN to random parts of the page? Or randomize the article titles every time you reload HN, so you're never sure whether you've already read an article? Or swap one comment between threads to keep people on their toes? Wouldn't those all be equally plausible ways to get people to read things more carefully by sacrificing usability? Your other comments suggest that you would be against tl;dr's, which outside the internet are known as "abstracts", and (like descriptive titles) are known to be highly useful.
- paulcole 10y agoYeah it is refreshing to read an article and find out the headline was misleading. I really enjoyed putting that effort in.
- nickpeterson 10y agoHN commenters hate when people question the purpose of an article. In fact, even suggesting that HN should allow a short description is considered blasphemy. Also people on HN have no sense of humor because 95% of them are on the spectrum.
- marviel 10y agoSome broad strokes there...
- nickpeterson 10y agoSorry, life has made me bitter.
- striking 10y agoIt amuses me that you complain about people taking things too seriously, being humorless, when that's exactly what you did... My life hasn't been the easiest either, but at least I don't rely on that as an excuse. There's plenty of positivity out there, as long as you're willing to seek it out. Have a nice day, hope you find peace.
- nickpeterson 10y agoI'm confused, did you not think the response was a joke?
- robert_tweed 10y agoThis particular title reeks of clickbait though. Have to strongly disagree with your defence of it, especially in the light of a good alternative being suggested.
- pvg 10y agoThe guideline is 'unless the original title is misleading or clickbait'. This one is neither, it's just not explicit.
- robert_tweed 10y agoIs it only clickbait if factually incorrect? Wouldn't that make the term redundant given that such a title would also be misleading? Note that we're currently engaged in an unhelpful meta-discussion about whether or not the title is clickbait, which IMO is exactly what the guidelines are designed to prevent. While I didn't say so earlier, I largely object to the needlessly inflammatory word "stumped" which perpetuates the meme that patients frequently know better than doctors. This case is an interesting exception, not the rule. There's a debate to be had about the fact people do indeed know their own case history than their often time-starved doctors, but whether or not the article has merit, the title is a distraction.
- pvg 10y agoNo, it's just not clickbait. I'm not sure how the meta-thing suggests that it is. It's just a title. I mean, read these titles http://www.paulgraham.com/articles.html http://www.paulgraham.com/articles.html
- dang 10y agoIf it helps, we agree on the 'law' that clickbait titles need to be changed (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), just not on the facts of this case. The NYT title doesn't seem to me to reek of clickbait, though I grant you there's a touch of it.
- tomohawk 10y agoI know many doctors are caring and well trained, but they work in systems that often prevent them from seeing what they should or taking actions that they would like to take. You really need to take charge of your treatment. It can mean the difference between life or death, or the difference between being a victim or living a normal life. In my own personal experience, I've unraveled medical mysteries affecting my health that have stumped some pretty good docs, and in one case, a super specialist. On the other hand, I've been greatly helped by docs. All I can say is don't give up just because docs say they don't know or don't seem to be making you better.
- Nomentatus 10y agoI agree. Chances are your "specialist" has to cover an immense amount of ground. Spend a couple weeks, or maybe a couple of months, grinding at pubmed.com (with a good online medical dictionary at hand) and you can certainly outread him or her on a narrow topic that affects you if it's unusual, and have a lot of knowledge at hand he or she doesn't, if you grind at it. Just be humble about all the context for that knowledge that you don't simply don't have, and don't imply they should know everything. There isn't time enough in the day for them to read everything useful to them clinically. Watson and similar A.I. helpers are really needed, and coming. Sadly, a lot of doctors just make shit up out of thin air to help gloss over what they can't be expected to read, which is probably a good time to consider switching doctors.
- DanBC 10y ago> All I can say is don't give up just because docs say they don't know or don't seem to be making you better. Can you describe how this process differs between people with an illness like cancer and people with an illness like Morgellons?
- tomohawk 10y agoI know many doctors are caring and well trained, but they work in systems that often prevent them from seeing what they should or taking actions that they would like to take. You really need to take charge of your treatment. It can mean the difference between life or death, or the difference between being a victim or living a normal life. In my own personal experience, I've unraveled medical mysteries affecting my health that have stumped some pretty good docs, and in one case, a super specialist. On the other hand, I've been greatly helped by docs. All I can say is don't give up just because docs say they don't know or don't seem to be making you better.
- tominous 10y agoI wrote my thoughts about how to work with your doctor here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12266170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12266170 My wife has since passed away unfortunately. I really need to write this all up at some point to close it off. Anyway, I've come to understand that most doctors look at the scientific evidence indirectly. They often have an excellent ability to follow a decision tree and work through the differential diagnosis. However, that decision tree is based on (a) observations and (b) what other doctors have tried. There's no attempt to look at the underlying mechanism to find novel solutions. So new basic research (e.g. on mTOR and VEGF as in the article) will have no effect on practice until it is proven in trials or until enough mavericks (like the patient in the article) have created a precedent. It does make sense in terms of avoiding cost and harm -- biology is very complicated -- but I do think this conservative bias goes too far in cases where the treatments have been already proven safe in other contexts, or in cases where the alternative is already bleak.
- foota 10y agoI'm sorry for your loss.
- sjg007 10y agoI agree. I am hopeful that precision medicine trials will change things.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoI think that many people don't understand that clinicians are not investigators and generally do not have any research experience, despite having the title of 'doctor' (a fairly recent appellation outside of academia). They are, as you say, trained to arrive at a diagnosis to the best of their ability and provide treatment. A challenging diagnosis, however, is a fully-fledged scientific investigation. This is where clinical researchers (MD PhD) can really shine, but it's hard to apply this to individuals; the typical direction follows funding first, which may not be of much help to any given patient. At any rate, this approach ultimately does not scale. My hope is that new tools (accessible databases, better data collection, and a dash of ML) will get more patients in front of the right pair of eyes more often. The situation with life-threatening diseases is bad enough, but there are also huge opportunities for improved quality of life from vague, nagging, or intermittent illness diagnosis.
- karcass 10y agoMy wife had a tumor on her pituitary gland. Four different MDs came up empty on her symptoms. The fourth doctor ran the right endocrine system test, but was only able to conclude "it's not [her] thyroid." It took me about thirty minutes with the test results and Google to make the diagnosis. I was lucky, in that I had a colleague who was acquainted with the head of Stanford endocrinology, who confirmed the diagnosis and found us a good surgeon. Wife is fine today. It's anecdotal, but my experience with the medical system is that nearly all doctors see the same handful of things day in and day out, and are not trained to see beyond their expertise.
- xbmcuser 10y agoThis is why I feel AI could be the greatest help in diagnosing diseases. Mds learn to identify problems through expierence you could feed millions of cases into an AI it would start diagnosing better than the avg MD or at least list the most likely diseases for the MD to check.
- lbatx 10y agoAlready done. IBM Watson has been doing this for more than three years. Was world class already in 2014. http://www.businessinsider.com/ibms-watson-may-soon-be-the-best-doctor-in-the-world-2014-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/ibms-watson-may-soon-be-the-b...
- dorfsmay 10y agoThe article doesn't mention public access. I assume it's not available? I'd pay a small fee to get access!
- ClassyJacket 10y agoThat's awful. I, too, have turned to Google M.D. before. I went to five different doctors for throat discomfort and chest pain. The first four didn't see anything in my mouth, so told me I can't be having any symptoms if they don't see anything after a two second glance at my mouth and refused to do anything further. I was in enough discomfort I lost sleep, and after a few months of these symptoms I couldn't stop thinking the worst. I had to practically threaten the last doctor to do an infection test which turned out a positive result for mono. Not my imagination after all. As for my chest, I described my symptoms to my mother, who almost immediately suggested acid reflux. Sure enough, as later confirmed by a throat specialist, that's what it was, and the medication fixed my symptoms pretty much the next day. If you're a young male, doctors don't want anything to do with you. I usually Google things and make my own decisions now. I've started to view GPs as nothing but an unfortunate barrier on my way to a useful prescription or specialist.
- leesalminen 10y agoA couple years back I started seeing a "hippy" doctor in my town (Boulder). He's a licensed MD and doesn't accept insurance; cash only at $300 an hour. Totally worth every penny. He actually listens, and is willing to get creative with things. If you're not satisfied with your PC provider, find a cash only doctor. I think you'll find they care more.
- arkades 10y agoIME, it's not that they care more - it's that they have the time to pause and think. A buddy of mine is a world-renowned specialist, but in a niche too small to allow him to go all-cash. He gets a patient a couple of years back who came with literally boxes of medical records, years of failed doctor visits, and in excess of 100k$ in worth of tests and interventions. He spent two days poring over her records, and got her the diagnosis no one else did - got her on the right tx, and gave her her life back. Insurance reimbursed him precisely the same (<$300 gross) that it would have for an ordinary visit of ordinary length, more or less. (Fine, he billed a level 5 eval and management instead of a level 3; difference of nearly peanuts). How often do you think he sets aside the time to pause and really think deeply on a problem? If he was charging cash and had the chance to charge people for his time and expertise, knowing him, he'd be happy to do nothing but spend days at a time tackling the hardest problems available.
- csydas 10y ago>He spent two days poring over her records, and got her the diagnosis no one else did - got her on the right tx, and gave her her life back. Well, quite frankly, this is part of the problem and it's a social adjustment we need to make as well. We see this with virtually any position where you need to diagnose; 99% of the time it's a simple issue from column A, but occasionally you get a symptom that looks like the issue is from column A but it's actually in column B. In technology, we fly through column A solutions because they're cheap, fast to test, and often done without cost, and column B solutions are more drastic, more expensive, and sometimes more dangerous. The difficulty in translating this to medicine is that a lot of times column B solutions are dangerous to the point of no return. Combine this with the fact that there really aren't rollbacks when it comes to health, you have actual life or death decisions to be made. Taking the time to review the whole history can really help with this and to get a full timeline of events, but even then it's hard to get past the column A/B thinking. I've been dealing with a very annoying sinus issue for 3 years across about 8 doctors from across the planet (due to moving because of work). Every time I've started anew with a doctor, they go down the exact same treatment list as the previous, and when they're told that I've done that already, they just want a repeat. I understand this thought process (what if I'm lying, what if they bungled the test, what if something changed, etc), but I've done this 8 times now. I've been told each time it's an allergy, but every time we see an allergist, they can't get me to react to any allergen they have available to test for and are left scratching their heads as to why antihistamines don't have any effect. They also can't find a common cause that fits with allergies, but in their minds, it just looks so much like allergies they're not sure what else to test. I secretly suspect that if I could just get a doctor to spend more than 20 minutes in a consult to review the case and what I've done so far we could try something else, but regardless of where I've been, I just can't get a doctor to look too much longer. They either don't believe the symptoms as I report them, don't believe the steps I've already tried to resolve it, or they just don't have the time to care past the initial look at the symptoms. I appreciate the difficulty in having to do this: when column A fails, it looks great if you pick the right item from column B, but it also gets really expensive while you shop around to find the right item from column B. They make it look so easy on House, but no place is willing to really do that sort of patient history and testing, and if the condition is not life threatening, then it's just a "deal with it" situation, we're gonna keep throwing the easy stuff at the symptoms until the person stops complaining. I don't know what the problem is or how to embolden doctors to take a little more time, but some change would be nice. Though, hearing stories from my mother who has been a nurse for 20+ years, sometimes emboldened doctors look for problems that aren't there so they can look like heroes. It's a crazy thing with health and unfortunately the value of such emboldened decisions tends to be a very ad-hoc assessment. If it worked well, it was a gutsy but necessary maneuver. If it did nothing, it was reckless. If it caused harm, it was malpractice.
- fian 10y agoThe approach he took to analysing his condition reminds me of bug fixes through logging and debugging. He took and analysed blood samples over many months -> logging. When he identified something in the logs that looked odd, he took a drug that should affect that behaviour -> debugging.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- niceperson 10y agoEveryone's saying that there is a lack of doctors that are ready to think outside the reular prescriptions and diseases, but is this really a fault of the doctors or is this something that has been enforced by the system? I think that giving doctors equal pay irrespective ofthe work they do, or the patients they treat is very stupid and dangerous. It eradicates a standard of value. https://campus.aynrand.org/works/1985/01/01/medicine-the-death-of-a-profession https://campus.aynrand.org/works/1985/01/01/medicine-the-dea...
- puzzle 10y agoThe Mayo Clinic is one of the best hospitals on the planet and is even mentioned in the article, since they have diagnostic labs that specialize in so-called esoteric testing. Their doctors are paid a salary, which is market-based, reaches a plateau after a number of years you have the same title and is not tied to the number of patients you see. Not only there's no incentive for them to cram as many patients in a day as possible, but they call each other consultants because they will bring in colleagues when there's a tough case that warrants a second or third opinion.
- arkades 10y agoIn fairness, it's the Mayo Clinic's enormous prestige that acts as a supplemental non-cash reimbursement to the physicians that practice there. It's, more generally, a trait of hospital systems to substitute reimbursing physicians with culture rather than cash. They get a flat salary, and in some places a volume-based bonus. In places where the culture isn't earnest, insufficiently prestigious, or both, this cultural currency falls flat and physicians (and other staff) absolutely start to suck more. Outside of hospitals (hospitals and physicians are not equivalent; think Walmart and your local mom-and-pop shop, if you want a better idea of the relationship between the two), physicians are reimbursed directly by volume. Not quality, though - just volume.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jaboutboul 10y agoTL;DR Dad got a condition precipitated by anesthesia from surgery. Lots of docs couldn't figure it out. I solved it using Google in less than 5 minutes. It's amazing how many doctors operate in "tunnel vision." A few years back after a routine procedure that put him under, my dad awoke to non stop hiccups. At first the anesthesiologist said it was a temporary side effect of the anesthesia and brushed it off. Well the hiccups continued for 2 freaking weeks non stop. As you can imagine this is a) a major disruption to a normal life (he couldn't sleep, couldn't eat, couldn't do anything for two weeks) and b) annoying as hell to everyone around you. We went his GP multiples times, consulted the same idiot anesthesiologist and went to the emergency room 4 times over those two weeks and the reactions varied. Everything from the doctor literally laughing out loud seeing a middle age man in agony over non stop hiccups to another doctor prescribing pineapple juice. Yup, pineapple juice. Apparently some people use that to stop hiccups. After the third trip, with no seeming progress and my dad basically asking us to kill him so that he can get some normal rest, I decided to start googling, which I should have done when this all started. I found a interesting research paper from Cal Berkeley which described a similar case after surgery, which described the mechanism that actually causes hiccups (its a spasm of the diaphragm cause by the vagal nerve) and how they were able to treat it. We decided to go to a more than decent hospital in the big city armed with this paper in hand. In to the emergency room, after the standard tests they did at the other places and the scopes and all that, the doctor goes yeah we have no idea what's going on let me look up some stuff and I'll be right back. He went to some computer terminal and started clacking away while I was watching over his shoulder unbeknownst to him. After about 3 minutes of searching some medical portal the hospital uses and seeing his head shake repeatedly I walked over, tapped him on the shoulder and said, hey I think I might have found something helpful on my ipad and handed it to him. He read the paper in 2 minutes flat said "oh my god," called his supervisor (he was the attending physician, not a resident) they both agreed to call this doctor at Cal and after a 5 minute phone call wrote a script for a drug called Baclofen which treats muscle spams. 2 of the worst weeks of my Dad and our lives' came to an end within 15 minutes. I was glad this place being a teaching hospital, was open minded enough to consider what they were presented The hospital thought I was some kind of Doogie Howser and the head of the ER goes to me "You should really consider becoming a doctor." I replied with "Why would I ever do something silly like that. I'm an engineer." The doctor was both amused and not amused at the same time. Just goes to show you, how narrow their field of vision is. Most doctors get trained a certain way with certain tools and for the rest of their career that is all they know.
- sametmax 10y agoThis is a problem with our notion of "expertise". We rely too much on them and delegate everything in our society to them. But first, there are varying degree of quality among experts. The delta is huge. Secondly, they are only human, and make mistake all the time. Thirdly, they have an agenda too. It may not be to help you the best they can, but to make a living with the least problem possible. Now another problem is that a lot of people reject expertise in a such a way that any honest attempt will look terrible after them. The typical anti-vaxer speech has no credibility at all, preventing any sane debate on vaccines. The pro consider it "not even a question". But everybody should always raise questions about any medical act before deciding to got for it or not. This include vaccines, band aids, whatever. The notion or "expert" also tends to remove responsibility from the people. But your health is YOUR concern, you choose take great responsibility in it. In the end, we should all learn to not ask experts to solve our problems, but to use them so we can solve our problems.
- allpratik 10y agoThis is a remarkable story, atleast for me. It highlights the importance to find patterns in data and then map those patterns to something X. Agreed it takes time to do this and is exhausting as well but results are far more amazing. Same thing happened with recent tremors related non-invasive surgery at Imperial college London. Data played extremely crucial part to localize it. (http://www.bbc.com/news/health-38157770 http://www.bbc.com/news/health-38157770) Really excited to envision a purely data-driven healthcare system. It will have a significant impact on our understanding of different diseases. Anyone knows where to find such anonymous health/disease related data for further research?
- carbocation 10y agoIn this thread there is a fair amount of "Google, MD" talk, so I'll add my own story. In medical school we were tasked with identifying an unusual cause of a baby's fussiness after eating. For the first time, everyone got the right answer. My professor wasn't sure whether to be proud of us for all doing deep reading into rare disease or to be angry that we had collaborated. But in fact, everyone had just popped the unusual findings into Google, which spat back the diagnosis of ALCAPA (anomalous left coronary artery from the pulmonary artery). Your doctor's brain is not the world's best device for information retrieval.
- ythn 10y agoI think this phenomenon is starting to extend to every field. For example, My wife's car would sometimes fail to start. However, later it would start with no problems. After a while I noticed it had a much higher no start rate when it was raining outside. We took it to the shop and I explained the situation, so they did a "wet test" and it turned up nothing. They explained that they were powerless to fix it without being able to reproduce it. I wasn't satisfied with that answer so I did my own research on google with the make/model of the car and concluded pretty quickly that the distributor cap was the problem. I took it back to the shop and specifically requested that they replace the distributor cap. They did, and the problem was resolved.
- shiven 10y agoYour doctor's brain is not the world's best device for information retrieval. As a former doctor, agree 100%. Still the medical profession seems to look down upon "information aid"-like technology. Beyond accurate physical examination and correctly entering the patient's history into a well-trained pattern-matching AI engine, doctors really don't need to be doing much in a first-world country. They need to be re-inserted into the workflow only if the treatment recommended by the automated/AI approach does not help. The brutal truth is that the vast majority of doctors, even specialists, will be incapable of correctly diagnosing and treating the very uncommon, rare and extremely rare medical conditions. "The eyes see what the mind thinks" - is absolutely applicable to 99% of doctors, who, for various reasons, would be more concerned with helping the 95% of their patients with obvious/common/easily-identifiable conditions that respond to their first or at most second line of treatment, than bother spending an inordinate amount of time, effort and energy on the remaining 5% who's death/suffering may well be considered the "cost of doing business". Bitter truth, from experience.
- eptcyka 10y agoHe was browsing through hackernews, and you will never believe what headline really pissed him off.
- stretchwithme 10y agoI found this discussion of medical reversal very interesting. Particularly, how proxies for things are often used. Treating a symptom sometimes instead of a root cause. I think we also have that same problem in economics. People consume more when times are good, so let's get them to consume more and times will be good. http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2016/02/adam_cifu_on_en.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2016/02/adam_cifu_on_en.htm...
- oska 10y agoThis is just speculation on my part but I wonder if he overstressed his system by being such a ‘beast’ prior to getting sick. The photo of him doing a football drill does not look so healthy to me. His body looks over-developed. I don't mean any disrespect by this comment. Clearly he is an extraordinary individual.