12 ms·
So this seems like a reorganization of the market of sorts, isn't it? As retail stores like Macy's, Sears report losses after losses, Amazon keeps adding more p
by pm90 10y ago
So this seems like a reorganization of the market of sorts, isn't it? As retail stores like Macy's, Sears report losses after losses, Amazon keeps adding more people to support its merchandise business. Love how the free market works!
- simias 10y agoMaybe, but don't forget to factor in the relative quality of the jobs that are being replaced. I don't really have a strong opinion on the matter, and it would be a bit hypocritical of me as an amazon prime customer to complain about the working conditions at Amazon but not every job is equal to any other. Furthermore I wouldn't be surprised if many of these new jobs ended up being automated in the near future. The free market still hasn't figured out a solution to that particular problem last I checked.
- colechristensen 10y agoProduction efficiencies have been driving human civilization since the very beginning when humans were wandering around in small hunter-gatherer bands. This round of automation won't be the ruin of humanity much the same as it has been for the last 5000 years.
- ASpring 10y agoOf course not in the long term but it's worth thinking that losing entire classes of jobs containing millions of people in a decade might have seriously detrimental effects for some time.
- marvin 10y agoIn a democracy, one negative consequence of fast job loss followed by poverty is the election of populist leaders and governments. We have recently seen a prominent example of this phenomenon. If the reduced quality of life of the affected people isn't addressed, their reaction will likely become even less pleasant.
- hsitz 10y agoYou seem to use 'populist' as a pejorative term. I would suggest that populism can be a good thing. I'm opposed to Trump, but not because he's populist. I'm not even sure he is a populist, since I don't believe he or his administration have any real concern for the democratic masses; they're riding a populist wave out they're out to gain power and wealth for themselves. This contrasts strongly with, e.g., the New Deal or Civil Rights reforms, which were real populism.
- dragonwriter 10y ago"populism" without a modifier is quite often used in the specific sense in which others use the more specific "authoritarian populism"; that is, demagoguery which features use of populist rhetoric to build support for authoritarianism. This can be a source of much confusion because it is often unclear from a single encounter whether someone criticizing "populism" is an elitist opposed to politics genuinely directed at the interests of the masses, or simply warning of authoritarian demagoguery.
- colechristensen 10y agoBut is impeding change helpful or harmful? There is something to be said for mild conservatism taking slow deliberate steps forward, but it's very easy to create false economies protecting an obsolete past and impeding progress.
- ska 10y agoIs it an either/or? Surely you can choose to accept a fast rate of change and also try and do something practical about the consequences at the same time?
- Gargoyle 10y agoDescribe the new jobs which can not be automated in the near future.
- thmsths 10y agoSounds like a good job for AI.
- ars 10y ago> Maybe, but don't forget to factor in the relative quality of the jobs that are being replaced. Retail vs Warehouse? I don't think it's much different in quality. A ton of Retail is Warehouse anyway, just inside a store with customers vs a building with robots.
- patja 10y agoI suspect working in an Amazon warehouse is much more physically intensive with commensurate increases in injuries and other job-induced ailments as compared to most retail jobs.
- ars 10y agoYou are thinking of retail as cashiers, because that's what you see. But a lot of retail jobs involve the stockroom with heavy boxes and crates, and a lot of bending and lifting to put products on shelves. And much of Amazon jobs involve retrieving lightweight items from shelves to put in a bin. The jobs are not that different.
- cr0sh 10y ago> And much of Amazon jobs involve retrieving lightweight items from shelves to put in a bin. Haven't they transitioned all their warehouses to the model where the person stays stationary, and robots bring product to the person? Or is that only in selected warehouses? That's not to say standing in one position is any better or less stressful (might even be more so, if you've ever seen videos of the robots in action on the floor).
- ars 10y agoFrom the videos I've seen, different warehouses do different things. I think that packing the shipping boxes is still all manual in all the warehouses.
- jdreaver 10y ago> The free market still hasn't figured out a solution to that particular problem last I checked. Interesting, I think the entire industrial revolution is a very strong counter example to that statement. We repeatedly automated the majority of jobs on the planet every few decades and we saw the largest expansion of wealth and prosperity for the majority of humans in all of history. Should we lament over those subsistence farming jobs that were automated away? The free market isn't some singular entity that figures out problems before they arrive and sends us all an executive summary of its plan. We currently don't have mass unemployment from automation, and I don't agree with many of the reasons people express for worrying. The only arguments I've seen against mass automation are hints of some dystopian future where somehow robots are prohibitively expensive for all but the richest people, and goods will somehow be cheap enough from automation that non-automated manufacturing can't compete, but still expensive enough that if we don't work 40 hours a week we'll starve.
- smallnamespace 10y agoI agree with you, but just a reminder that the Industrial Revolution was also a time of mass civil unrest, war, nationalism, and the growth of revolutionary groups advocating the overthrow of the existing social and economic order (some of which succeeded, e.g. Leninist Russia). You could make a fairly strong argument that is was the very real threat of Communist revolution in Western Europe (e.g. Germany in the 1930s, or Italy and France post-WW2) that forced governments to adopt socialist programs that moderated many of the excesses of the market, or in the US, the massive government investment in the middle class as well as draconian anti-left measures that prevented a similar threat. We've so far ended up in a somewhat decent place, but if history is any measure, we're going to have a rocky next few decades if technology does end up destroying or transforming demand for labor. People generally don't go quietly when their livelihoods or place in the social order are threatened.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWar and civil unrest has been extremely common throughout the world long before the industrial revolution. If anything war and violence have declined since the industrial revolution started (read Steven Pinker's Why Violence Declined). So I don't see how you can blame the industrial revolution for any residual unrest.
- djsumdog 10y agoI chose not to shop at Amazon after returning to the US. To me it felt like the new Wal-Mart (which I stopped shopping at around 2009). Their business practices are terrible and their boom has really hurt everyone not in tech in their home of Seattle. They're another piece, but quite a large piece, in a consumption based world that's simply not sustainable. We are in a world today where we simply buy things, all the time. Companies like Amazon have a vested interest in ensuring we never stop making purchases.
- adamsea 10y agoYou should probably find and share the number of jobs lost by Macys, Sears, etc, before making that assertion, otherwise, it is difficult to have any reasonable confidence in what you say.
- eitally 10y agohttps://www.thebalance.com/macys-store-closings-2892434 https://www.thebalance.com/macys-store-closings-2892434 http://www.clark.com/kmart-sears-closing-2017 http://www.clark.com/kmart-sears-closing-2017 I thought it was pretty common knowledge that traditional B&M consumer goods retailers have been struggling for a long time.
- devonkim 10y agoI think Macy's announced 4K last January and in January 2017 announced 10k job cuts. Not sure about Sears but I saw a 5400+ number as it closes low performing stores.
- ue_ 10y ago>Love how the free market works! I don't. Being forced to sell your labour in order to survive doesn't sound all that good to me. Nor the environmental damage due to pursuit of profits.
- pavanky 10y agoWhat kind of a system doesn't involve selling your labour (that doesn't include selling somebody else's labour) ?
- gowld 10y agoself-sustaining micro- farming, energy generation/harvesting and manufacturing. /r/Futurology for more.
- ue_ 10y agoCommunism, in which you recieve the fruits of your labour.
- pavanky 10y agoWhy should communism get a leash when the real world examples have consistently shown that they lead up to corruption as well as unregulated free markets ?
- ue_ 10y ago>when the real world examples have consistently shown There are many valid critiques to be made of governments which have attempted to implement Communism or Socialism, I'm not here to defend them, merely to propose that their failure does not, at least necessarily, implicate Communism. Furthermore by the same logic, I cannot see why capitalism ought to be get a leash when the real world examples have consistently shown that it leads to exploitation and recklessness or active harm to the environment globally and locally, and the resulting inbalance of wealth leading to poverty. Capitalism is no meritocracy. It's better than feudalism, and that's about it.
- grillvogel 10y ago>Love how the free market works! are you being sarcastic dude
- gaplus 10y agoNot exactly. It turns out, AMZN cuts 4 jobs for any 1 job that it adds. The full report is truly alarming and has pretty disturbing implications for the overall economy: https://ilsr.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/ILSR_AmazonReport_final.pdf https://ilsr.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/ILSR_AmazonRepor...
- misja111 10y agoI was reading the report because I was interested in the net effect that Amazon has on the retail job market. But I am disappointed at how poorly the report is written. For instance, the claim of the 4 job cuts for every job that Amazon creates is based on the following statistics: the number of new hires at Amazon in a certain period, against the number of jobs lost in the brick and mortar retail industry in the same period. Apparently the assumption is made that every single job loss in the brick and mortar retail industry is to blame on Amazon. As if Amazon is the only Internet retail shop in the USA. The rest of the report is full with other weak claims and sensational titles as well. It appears that the writers had their conclusions already made up before they started investigating ...
- metaphorm 10y ago> Love how the free market works! 1. it's not a free market. that was a thought experiment actually. there is no such thing as a free market, and even if there was, the U.S. economy isn't one. 2. market fundamentalism is unbecoming
- joelthelion 10y ago> Love how the free market works! Bet you'll love it a lot less when Amazon has eliminated most competition and will start increasing their margins to pay back shareholders.