12 ms·
Nullsoft: The death of the last maverick tech company (2004)
- kichik 10y agoThis is from 2004. What's new?
- gdulli 10y agoA whole generation of a potentially interested audience who was not yet aware of Nullsoft in 2004.
- ethbro 10y agoA generation who can't imagine the novelty of performing a first search on Napster or Direct Connect. Magic!
- nol13 10y agoDownloads on the campus direct connect network in '02 are still the fastest I've achieved real world then or since, with a selection probably at least comparable to any torrent site. They've just never seen real file sharing. Or is file sharing just now obsolete now? A bit out of the loop :/
- ethbro 10y agoOne of the campuses I was on had fiber to every dorm room. I remember the banners on DC++ servers exhorting users not to play movies directly across the network. The idea of streaming a movie off someone else's hard drive certainly seemed like witchcraft.
- joering2 10y agoAudiogalaxy. Was always impressed how easy it was to find 320kbit versions or even some extremely rare songs...
- krrrh 10y agoI remember audiogalaxy being the first web interface I saw that made use of ajax--clicking on the download buttons next to songs, not having the page refresh, and immediately viewing source to try to discover what wizardry this was.
- riffraff 10y agoAudiogalaxy was insanely effective at finding related music, due to, basically, human curation. I will always be grateful of having discovered lamb and goldfrapp through it.
- joering2 10y ago(OT) I discovered goldfrapp by watching Hard Candy. Awesome movie.
- eltoozero 10y agoUp-voted for dragging Lamb into an HN thread. ;) Somehow appropriate for a decade old article about 90's vintage desktop MP3 software. Now go and try to locate rips of episodes of AMP from MTV and complete your electronica collection.
- stuaxo 10y agoWill we ever see something as good as it again? It would be tricky, but surely not impossible.
- pimlottc 10y agoWhippersnapper. Back in my day, we searched for MP3s on anonymous FTP sites via oth.net!
- naranana 10y agoSoulSeek
- ue_ 10y agoI still use slsk and it's great :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eli 10y agoThere's a really excellent long piece in Ars from 2012 about Nullsoft/Winamp that has the advantage of nearly a decade more perspective: https://arstechnica.com/business/2012/06/winamp-how-greatest-mp3-player-undid-itself/ https://arstechnica.com/business/2012/06/winamp-how-greatest... The following year, AOL officially killed the Winamp product.
- LeoPanthera 10y agoWinAmp is back. http://www.winamp.com/ http://www.winamp.com/
- mizaru 10y agoIt's been 'back' since... around 2013?
- Sunset 10y agoIt's "back" as much as a zombie is "back". Yeah it works on the latest OS, but several features are broken. Shoutcast still working is a little miracle. Though I am quite pleased with the Podcast Downloading feature w/ RSS. ( for example you can pull stuff from soundcloud )
- LeoPanthera 10y agoThe Nullsoft brand was sold to Radionomy in 2014. nullsoft.com now redirects to winamp.com, which astonishingly still exists.
- symlinkk 10y agoI remember reading a few posts on the Winamp forums around a year ago that they were revitalizing development on Winamp, not sure if that went anywhere though.
- Teever 10y agoI have a feeling it isn't. I used to have winamp on my android phone and when I got a new phone a few months ago I discovered that they had removed winamp from the store. Which is unfortunate because winamp was surprisingly great on android too.
- Splines 10y agoI would be surprised if it has. For most people playing compressed music is a solved problem.
- baobrain 10y agoTheir site[0] says that they're revitalizing it, and the last dev tweet I could find was from October 2016 [1]. So I'd bet it's going along at a reasonable pace. [0]http://www.winamp.com/index.html http://www.winamp.com/index.html [1]https://twitter.com/Ed_Rich/status/788650603383754752 https://twitter.com/Ed_Rich/status/788650603383754752
- ereyes01 10y agoWhat kind of snot-nosed brat takes millions from AOL and then publishes software perfect for ripping off Time Warner's entire catalog? Frankel, a grunge-dressing slacker from Sedona, Ariz., was a teenage college dropout in 1997 when he wrote Winamp, the first program that made playing MP3s on a PC point-and-click simple. How times have changed. There's now so many snot-nosed grungy slackers who could buy the author's house in cash, just to make a point :-)
- hardwaresofton 10y agoWhile it's certainly true that there are many more 20-somethings/30-somethings with lots of money in tech these days, I think the attitude he had is pretty rare. Most people wouldn't dare to release software that might get them fired because they just wanted to make it, and thought it should exist. Of course, it's well within the rights of a company to fire an employee for doing so, but pretty sure most tech workers these days just stay in line, relegate open source work to when they're told they can do it (nights and weekends), and gnash teeth but ultimately submit when a company shoves something they don't like down their throat. Then again, he did have "fuck you" money after the acquisition so...
- bricss 10y agoSmall guide on How to use WASTE -> http://www.cs.montana.edu/~huff/waste/howto/Waste.html http://www.cs.montana.edu/~huff/waste/howto/Waste.html
- foxhop 10y agoI was just thinking about WASTE recently in the last 2 weeks since Trump took office. WASTE was written in Java and was sort of tricky to setup / understand. At one point about 10 years ago, I had a small 8 person "dark net" running with WASTE, shit was so 1337 for its time. Bit torrent was just making waves around this time and made downloading WAY faster, but was more risky then sharing directly over WASTE.
- bricss 10y agoWASTE was written on entire C++, you can find sources here http://slackerbitch.free.fr/waste/download.html http://slackerbitch.free.fr/waste/download.html or somewhere here https://sourceforge.net/projects/waste/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/waste/
- foxhop 10y agoHmmm, maybe I found an "open source" client that was written in Java then. I remember having to mess with JAR files.
- neolithic 10y agoWhat's today's equivalent to WASTE? Especially on a Mac. How do people securely (encrypted) share files between themselves? Edit: Can't find a mac client/server of WASTE. And some of those download links seem to be down.
- neotek 10y agoMan I would kill for an ultra-simple, ultra-lightweight, robust music player for macOS that was just like Winamp 2.81, the last good version. No, not foobar.
- derefr 10y ago"Ultra-lightweight" can mean two very different (and nearly opposite) things: some people want a player that has no external dependencies (and thus must do everything itself, like VLC); while others want a player with minimal binary size (which thus will then rely on the OS's AV frameworks as much as possible for media support.) Personally, I prefer the second definition, but it's the harder of the two to satisfy. I don't really understand why the approach Perian undertook was abandoned when Perian itself was. It'd be very nice to just have macOS "natively" support every media format+codec under the sun, and then just play media files in Quicktime or iTunes or any other player GUI you prefer.
- ww520 10y agoAre there license fees or patents for some of the audio format decoding? Relying on the OS for decoding audio would be one way to get around that problem.
- mrpippy 10y ago> I don't really understand why the approach Perian undertook was abandoned when Perian itself was. Perian's approach was to implement additional codec/container support as a QuickTime component. QuickTime has been deprecated for several years, and AVFoundation doesn't provide any component or plugin interface for 3rd parties to add codecs.
- majkinetor 10y agoVLC is great, but UI sux tbh. Also, SMplayer is great, but UI sux even more for audio. The level of 'it just works' for those 2 products is just not comparable to anything else. Plus they are cross platform, works on pretty much anything in existence. That is the reason I tollerate UI and use them every day. Also, while it lacks audio management, SMPlayer is the best video player, period.
- SwellJoe 10y agoFor what it's worth, Justin Frankel continues to produce great software. He founded Cockos Incorporated, which produces REAPER; I think it's pretty widely accepted in the audio recording community that REAPER is the best value in the multitrack recording DAW market, and among the best overall tools for the purpose. He's obviously wealthy enough to never need to work again. It's clear Frankel just loves music, and wants to make meaningful contributions in the field. So, I think that's pretty cool. (I've also been a very happy REAPER user/customer for many years.)
- hardwaresofton 10y agoAlso, don't forget Licecap, one of the easiest to use and most consistent cross-platform gif-screen-capture tools: http://www.cockos.com/licecap/ http://www.cockos.com/licecap/ I said a very audible "holy shit, this is that guy?" when the link to jesussonic took me to Cockos.
- koolba 10y agoWow I didn't know he made licecap as well. As far as gif recordings go, it really whips the llamas ass!
- hardwaresofton 10y agoLicecap definitely changed how I worked. If you want the rest of your frontend development team to think you're a god, include licecap or other gifs of features/bugfixes on code reviews. It's a thing most developers don't even think of doing (at least most didn't in my experience). Makes it easy for stake holders (if they're allowed near your code reviews/tickets/whatever), devs, qa, to easily see how functionality has changed. I first learned of it from a young QA at a company I previously worked at, and I am so grateful I met him and was able to learn from him.
- Terr_ 10y agoI'd like to give an honorable mention to Debugmode Wink [0] which for a long time was my go-to freeware application for recording and presenting screen-activity on Windows. [0] http://www.debugmode.com/wink/ http://www.debugmode.com/wink/
- jojohack 10y agoNSIS (created also by Nullsoft) was particularly awesome, made it a breeze to build a Windows installer. There was also a photo gallery script Justin created which I thought was ahead of its time back then.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat was good. I remember using it over Visual Studio a few times. One of those things that shows you that your main vendor is making things way more complicated than they need to be.
- dchest 10y agoIt's still alive — latest release December 11, 2016! Two years ago I worked on an Electron-based app for Windows. I tested* it right on my dev machine in Electron for Linux _and_ the whole build process, including the NSIS-based installed also ran on Linux via makensis utility, so I didn't even have to touch Windows until the final QA phase. This was very nice.
- sigil 10y agoNSIS is more than alive for Electron apps -- it's about to become the default windows installer in electron-builder! Squirrel.windows will be deprecated soon.
- raverbashing 10y agoOh I had forgotten about that I used this in a couple of projects, and it was one of the easiest to use (still, it had good scripting possibilities)
- nickcw 10y agoNSIS aka Nullsoft Superpimp Install System was a great program, and the fact you could run the installer creator on Linux was a boon. I seem to remember the scripting language was a bit... eccentric, but it got the job done for us in the mid 2000s distributing a cross platform C++ app which was cross compiled on Linux.
- myrandomcomment 10y agoFor me I stopped using Winamp when I went full OSX and iPod. There was no reason to use anything else. Now, I hate iTunes but it is not easy to change. Right now I only use it for managing the library as a source of truth. The files are on a network share and played in Kodi on the compute stick plugged into the TV thought an external DAC to a tube amp. ;)
- pfarnsworth 10y agoI still use winamp as my mp3 player, one of the first things I install when I reinstall my Windows. It's everything that I need without the BS.
- scott_karana 10y agoI'm also a fan of Foobar2000: not as pretty, but surpremely small and functional :)
- guitarbill 10y agoThere's no accounting for taste. I found Winamp gaudy, and actually preferred Foobar. The black theme was quite nice once the font colour was changed to off-white. I cannot recommend Foobar enough, the tools for fixing up dodgy mp3s are very useful. It isn't so hot with mp4 tags though.
- gcp 10y agoIt isn't so hot with mp4 tags though. What do you mean exactly? mp4 tags in all variations, including various iTunes oddities, are fully supported.
- guitarbill 10y agoWay back in 2009/2010, I remember there being some issues. But that's coincidentally when I switched to a Mac, and started doing all my tagging in iTunes instead. Come to think of it, it's likely they've fixed it by now. I have used foobar since, but mainly for playback.
- zerr 10y agoSo far to my knowledge only Winamp is able to open a dir with a lot of mp3's and subdirs in a blink of an eye and have all the functionality, including search/jump available. Others (foobar, XMMS) fail badly. I killed the foobar2000 task after waiting for several minutes.
- nikcub 10y agoDespite the "change the world.. break the rules, etc." rhetoric, Silicon Valley couldn't be more different today. I find it hard to imagine a Google employee releasing an ad blocker[0], or Popcorn Time raising a Series A round, or startups shipping crypto that breaks the law, or a startup selling offensive security software (there's a reason that business has been pushed overseas) Today, startups that push the boundaries on bad laws and regulations are more likely to be roundly criticized than praised. DMCA notices are automatically complied with without question via automated systems. The tech companies have become the media companies. Founders in file sharing or media make a point in investment pitches that they'll be conformist. YouTube's ContentID system means thousands of legal satire and parody videos are removed every day. Not to mention whatever is/was happening between SV and the intelligence agencies. It's pretty hard today to find projects or communities that have similar levels of energy and disregard for rules. When you do find them it's no coincidence that they're usually on the periphery of what SV touches. [0] Brian Kennish quit Google and released Disconnect, a privacy plugin for browsers.
- kabouseng 10y agoWell you might be forgetting about Uber and AirBnB disregarding laws in their operations.
- nikcub 10y agothat's who I was referring to - they get criticized it's pretty hard to be innovative and not be illegal somewhere. Difference is many today see being illegal in China, Turkey, Iran, or wherever as a good thing while being illegal or borderline illegal in the USA is a bad thing The USA has regulatory capture that is just as bad as ideological or dogmatic religious capture is in those other nations. It just happens that the largest markets with monopolies or cartels that are super profitable and ripe for tech disruption also usually/sometimes also markets that have built a moat via government regulation.
- csydas 10y agoI think the criticism lobbied against AirBnB and Uber is for a reason, and the reason isn't the same "up-yours" attitude of past maverick tech companies. It's a little easier to buy the maverick attitude of something like gnutella when the author isn't getting close to billion dollar revenue yearly. It may seem a little strange, but the ethos is a bit easier to believe when you stay outside the system and benefit everyone instead of just looking out for yourself alone. The reason Uber and AirBnB are the subject of scrutiny is simply because the difference between them and any other business is non-discernable except that they have the money to stall out legal issues. Just from a "feel" perspective, they don't really feel like they're fighting the fight for everyone, they're just trying to line their pockets. There's a world of difference between what they do (offer a service at cost) to something like bit torrent or gnutella. I can't really say where or what the limit is on something like this, when a software maverick stops being a maverick and starts playing the game, but admittedly I haven't really carefully analyzed it beyond just "here's why I see a difference". Uber and AirBnB (and quite frankly, many other SV start ups) don't really have that hacker feel to them like we'd see with older projects - instead it feels much more like they're rooted in business and business alone.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWinamp was a great, music player back in my day that combined features with great, skinnable appearance and visualizations that could leave you in a trance. Plus it had a funnier opening than the competition at the time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaF-nRS_CWM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HaF-nRS_CWM
- shaan7 10y agoWell NSIS (Nullsoft Scriptable Install System) is one thing that came out of Nullsoft which continues to be very widely used even today. Makes it child's play to write simple installers which are in mere KBs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nstj 10y ago> Conventional wisdom says Frankel is more likely to join the millionaire has-beens who dot the hills in my San Francisco neighborhood or become a trophy hire at a tech startup, like contemporaries Fanning, Marc Andreessen, and Linus Torvalds. Heh.
- anjc 10y agoI don't know if this is how Winamp was meant to be used (I suspect it wasn't) but its default behaviour from its launch - with all of your music in a big giant list which you could muddle around, and a randomize play-order button - almost invited me to explore music in a way that I haven't seen since. It seems like ever since then the UIs try their best to force you to dig down into a specific album. If a track's id3 tags are incorrect then they're effectively lost in that UI because you don't know where to look for them. Yeah you can randomize play in iTunes or Zune, but you have to make arbitrary playlists explicitly. You can drag tracks around in VLC but the UI isn't helpful. I would say I knew 90% of the songs in my music collection then and probably know 10% now despite it being about the same size, purely because of a few 'helpful' UI constraints. People sort of suggest that music changed when MP3s and Napster bloomed, but the 'end of an era' in my mind, the time when my experience of music definitely changed, is when I was obligated to stop using Winamp and start using iTunes etc in the mid 2000s.
- fooza 10y agoZune? What year is this?
- anjc 10y agoI went through a whole heap of players on Windows 10 trying to get consistent playback from my Onedrive collection, and only Zune worked consistently for some reason. I don't know why.
- mhurron 10y agoA master playlist of all songs in your library exists in iTunes (and as far as I know, always has). I used WinAmp the same way you did, one big list of everything I had. I use iTunes the same way. I only create playlists to transfer music to my phone because it can't hold the whole library.
- Ndymium 10y agoiTunes has had a list view of all tracks for as long as I have used it, and it is still they main way I play music: https://files.nytsoi.net/l5cR.png https://files.nytsoi.net/l5cR.png
- richev 10y agoEaster egg at http://www.winamp.com http://www.winamp.com Click the llama's ass.
- appleflaxen 10y agoWaste was released before my time... Can anyone comment on what the scene was like when it was new?
- standardhuman 10y agoI recently encountered an episode of the Internet History Podcast that featured a long interview with Frankel. It touches on many of the points in the Slate article (working relationship at AOL, end of Nullsoft, etc.), and was recorded in 2015. Might be a nice companion to the article for those looking for a little more insight: http://www.internethistorypodcast.com/2015/07/justin-frankel-creator-of-winamp/ http://www.internethistorypodcast.com/2015/07/justin-frankel...