7 ms·
If I could do it all over again I would probably opt for Google. The Kubernetes support is wonderful and the overall user experience blows AWS out of the water.
by whalesalad 10y ago
If I could do it all over again I would probably opt for Google. The Kubernetes support is wonderful and the overall user experience blows AWS out of the water.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWhy opt for Google if you're going to use containers in Kubernetes? You then become cloud agnostic. You can even move to your own datacenter at some point (relatively) easily. Dropbox built out their own environment (and did it migrating 500PB out of S3) [1] [1a]. As did Twitter [2]. And Facebook [3]. And GitLab [4] (too soon?) As well as Mixpanel [5]. Even Twilio is multi-cloud (last time I checked it was split between AWS and Rackspace; this was several years ago during an interview, so maybe its changed). Sure, start in Google, or AWS, but at some point you will either need to use multiple compute/storage providers (redundancy) or go to your own gear (redundancy and cost). Example: "In 2014, Moz CEO Sarah Bird said that it was spending “$6.2 million at Amazon Web Services, and a mere $2.8 million on [its] own data centers.” Simply put, the cloud killed its margins." [6] EDIT: simonebrunozzi: Forgive me, but when you're talking about hundreds of millions of dollars in spend, "easy" is relative. It is much easier when you're not relying on underlying primitives that are difficult to reproduce on your own at another provider (witness how terrible Open Stack is; no one wants to do that if they don't have to). Am I minimizing the effort involved for this discussion? For sure. But the money involved...it solves most problems you would have migrating between providers. > It seems to me that you have no serious experience in the real world. You are entitled to your opinion. I have seen the pain, and it is relative. Its easier when someone says, "Here is the budget, just fix the problem", and your vendor's (AWS/Google) margins are 20-40% (these are real margins pulled from earnings reports); that's a lot of money you can put back in your own (or your shareholders') pockets. If you we're spending $2 billion dollars, and I told you I could save you $400 million by spending $100 million, wouldn't you take that deal? Even at $200 million, its a bargain! For less than what Snap is spending on Google cloud infrastructure, SpaceX built a rocket that can take a payload to orbit and return the first stage successfully (SpaceX has taken on ~$1.2 billion in funding over the last 14 years). Moving out of a cloud provider is comparatively hard? EDIT: Maybe this is a roundabout way to kick back to Google in order to get preferential treatment on the Ad network. It sure isn't a logical decision. EDIT 2: @ashayh: I'm not saying go back to good ol' bare metal. For $2 billion, you could build your own cloud provider out as an internal operation. The amount that's being spent on Google Cloud is egregious, and worse yet, common shares have no voting rights to push back against poor decisions like this. EDIT 3: @hueving: HN throttles my posting; editing this comment is my only way to respond. Sorry about that! [1] https://www.wired.com/2016/03/epic-story-dropboxs-exodus-amazon-cloud-empire/ https://www.wired.com/2016/03/epic-story-dropboxs-exodus-ama... [1a] http://www.informationweek.com/cloud/cloud-storage/how-dropbox-moved-500pb-of-customer-files-off-aws/d/d-id/1325721 http://www.informationweek.com/cloud/cloud-storage/how-dropb... [2] https://blog.twitter.com/2016/overview-of-the-twitter-cloud-platform-compute https://blog.twitter.com/2016/overview-of-the-twitter-cloud-... [3] https://code.facebook.com/hardware/ https://code.facebook.com/hardware/ | http://www.zdnet.com/pictures/facebooks-data-centers-worldwide-by-the-numbers-and-in-pictures/ http://www.zdnet.com/pictures/facebooks-data-centers-worldwi... [4] https://about.gitlab.com/2016/11/10/why-choose-bare-metal/ https://about.gitlab.com/2016/11/10/why-choose-bare-metal/ [5] https://code.mixpanel.com/2011/10/27/why-we-moved-off-the-cloud/ https://code.mixpanel.com/2011/10/27/why-we-moved-off-the-cl... [6] http://www.thewhir.com/blog/moving-away-from-aws-cloud-dropbox-isnt-an-anomaly-and-heres-why http://www.thewhir.com/blog/moving-away-from-aws-cloud-dropb...
- Yodoshi 10y agoBecause of google container engine (hosted kubernetes). https://cloud.google.com/container-engine/ https://cloud.google.com/container-engine/ Also them starting the project along with the knowledge they have internally scaling containers helps.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nikcub 10y agoCan anyone here provide some info or make a comparison with the Azure Container Service here, or any AWS option? I'm going to go through all of the service offerings this weekend - from Docker Inc's Docker for Azure and Docker for AWS to the native container services on each.
- ryanl-ee 10y agoAzure Container Service is simply a PaaS-ish offering of Swam, DC/OS, or Kubernetes. It still spins up VMs that you can log into, but handles deployment/provisioning of the product, and makes some assumptions about your use case. It's a great way to push a button and have a "real" deployment of those services to evaluate, especially if your goal is a platform-agnostic target. I work for an Azure-focused cloud consultancy and for any serious production environment we still build out a more custom deployment using a combination of Terraform, Chef, Cloud-Init, CoreOS, etc.
- nikcub 10y agoThanks for the comment - I'm going to try it out. Want to email me your consultancy (email in profile) - I work with a bunch of diff companies who use Azue
- hatred 10y ago> Also them starting the project along with the knowledge they have internally scaling containers helps. FWIW, Most of this are advertising gimmicks though and Google has a pretty different internal infrastructure for orchestrating containers that has hardly much to do with K8s.
- hosh 10y agoI did do it all over again (at a different company) and tried Google. And it does blow AWS out of the water. I don't regret hand-installing Kubernetes on AWS, if only because I know a lot more about how it works now. But I rather just spin it up with GKE.
- alex-mohr 10y agoGlad to hear GKE's working well for you -- thanks hosh and whalesalad! We do invest a lot in making Google Container Engine a great experience, including integrating it with other parts of GCP (e.g., IAM [1]), but at the same time, the core is plain vanilla Kubernetes. [1] https://cloud.google.com/container-engine/docs/iam-integration https://cloud.google.com/container-engine/docs/iam-integrati...