11 ms·
Fearful of Hacking, Dutch Will Count Ballots by Hand
- John23832 10y agoLearning from the mistakes of others is a good thing. Though counting by hand has it's own issues (waves at Florida)
- vkou 10y agoThe problem in Florida was not hand-counting - but rather, an absolutely insane (One could almost say 'deliberately sabotaged.') ballot design.
- redether 10y agoCan someone eli5 how an entire country that includes (big-fat assumption here) n > 0 computer scientist(s) is "fearful of hacking." Are we really at this point giving up on technology and becoming luddites?
- the-dude 10y agoEquipment/proces was found vulnerable. And this is only about aggregating sub-results. Voting computers for the actual vote ( public ) have been abandonded years ago, again because of vulnerabilities. This ban was pursued by an old school hacker ( Rob Grongrijp ). https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wij_vertrouwen_stemcomputers_niet https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wij_vertrouwen_stemcomputers_n...
- detaro 10y agoComputer scientists and computer security experts are the ones that commonly advise against voting machines and other things like that, pointing out vulnerabilities and the inability to verify them.
- wila 10y agoSure, read this > https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcoming-dutch-elections https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcomi...
- John23832 10y agoA couple things. 1) Not all computer scientist are security experts. 2) The security experts came to the conclusion that hardening the system to the point where you could depend on its integrity (and the system still be widely usable) wasn't feasible. 3) Making one process manual in order to protect the outcome != giving up on technology and becoming a luddite.
- nkrisc 10y agoThe integrity of the outcome is more important than the means of the process.
- sidlls 10y agoWhen one's only tool is a hammer every "problem" seems like a nail, eh? Some things simply aren't improved by the introduction of computers.
- gunnihinn 10y agoSome more context: https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcoming-dutch-elections https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcomi...
- wila 10y agoThis is due to a Dutch ethical hacker (Sijmen Ruwhof) investigating the way that our elections work. He had posted a great research document [0] that showed how bad our current system was. Two days later, we're back to paper. Thanks Sijmen :) [0] https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcoming-dutch-elections https://sijmen.ruwhof.net/weblog/1166-how-to-hack-the-upcomi...
- saycheese 10y agoHere's the related HN post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13524466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13524466
- mladenkovacevic 10y agoWhy does everyone think that hacking the DNC amounted to "hacking the election". Did anyone complain when Iceland PM resigned as a result of the Panama Papers leak and the large-scale protests that ensued? You wouldn't say that that somebody hacked Iceland's democracy. The truth came out and whatever happened was a natural result of that.
- vkou 10y ago> You wouldn't say that that somebody hacked Iceland's democracy. No, you wouldn't. The wailing and gnashing of teeth over the DNC hacks are all because the Democratic leadership is unwilling to accept responsibility for putting forward a bad candidate. Better blame the Russians, instead! If only the public didn't know the truth, we would have won!
- mattnewton 10y agoYou aren't wrong about the Democratic Party putting forth a weak candidate, but it is concerning that there weren't similar actions on the other side. The attacks were targeting a specific party alone and seem to be motivated by foreign geopolitical interests, not in the American public's interest. There is a reason we want equal time laws for example, because if I constantly hear one side of the argument, it doesn't matter how true those arguments are, I will come to biased conclusions.
- stretchwithme 10y agoWe only every needed technology to make sure ballots get encoded correctly. We could do that with open source software, commodity PCs and card punch machines and readers. Then validating that your choices were encoded correctly would be easier. So would counting. You could count at the voting location to get fast results and recount once the ballots arrive at the central office to confirm that the reported count was correct. You could keep the initial counts at the polling place. Then later compare those numbers with the second count's to confirm that nothing happened to the ballots. You also should have a unique number on each ballot that you can later use to look up how your ballot was recorded. None of this should require advanced technology, new inventions or secrecy.
- cynwoody 10y ago>You also should have a unique number on each ballot that you can later use to look up how your ballot was recorded. The standard objection to such a practice is that it facilitates vote buying / selling / coercion by giving the voter a means of proving how he voted. However, I think it's a good idea nonetheless. All the ballots, randomly numbered, should go into a file available for download. That way, anyone can count them, and any voter can verify that his particular ballot was recorded correctly.
- stretchwithme 10y agoGood points all. People could use their phone to record the entire time they are in the booth.
- 3pt14159 10y agoNo I don't want you to move my vote before I can see it. Use computers to do the count fast and first if you want to, but I want paper receipts also stuffed into a box and I want to be able to observe the whole process and I want to be able to observe the votes being physically counted at the end. Democracy gives so much legitimacy to her government that it will be gamed if it's possible.
- 10y ago
- kome 10y agoI participated in the experimental deployment of digital ballot box in a rich north Italian region, during regional elections. The system worked, and worked well. But overall, it was a failure. Putting the digital in something as simple as voting, just increase the risks at all levels: security, deployment, rechecking, etc. Pen and paper it's just so much better: simple, cost-effective, safe and understandable by anyone.
- bmj 10y agoI develop software and devices used for data collection during clinical drug trials, and our single biggest "competitor" is the old paper diary. Despite evidence showing that electronic data collection for certain types of trials provides better data, people just don't "trust" anything but pen and paper (never mind the fact that patients could sit in their cars before an appointment and fill in a month's worth of data by just "remembering" how they felt two weeks ago, or how much of a particular medication they took).
- detaro 10y ago> people just don't "trust" anything but pen and paper Who is people here? Participants, scientists, people in other roles?
- bmj 10y agoTypically sponsors, or clinical research organizations. Sometimes investigators themselves, but that will only affect us if they have the ear of the sponsor.
- sidlls 10y agoThat's quite a different use case from a one-time event with the results evaluated immediately.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- draw_down 10y ago
- derefr 10y agoThere are options beyond "hand counting" and "computer software." IBM was founded, way back when, on what were basically electrical (but not electronic!) census-punch-card-tabulating machines. One could use a similar, or slightly improved, design just as easily, along with correspondent electrical "polling machines" that are essentially a grid of buttons hooked up to pre-patterned card punches. The whole design could be done by one or two electrical + mechanical engineers in a couple of days (based on previous designs whose patents have long expired) and then given months of testing.
- kens 10y agoNote that you're reinventing the Votomatic voting machine [1] which is used to punch holes in a standard-sized IBM punched card. It was invented in 1963 and has been used in multiple US elections. I like IBM punched card equipment as much as anyone [2], but I feel obligated to point out that punched-card voting led to big problems in the 2000 election when ballots in Florida had "hanging chad" and the election ended up being decided by the Supreme Court. (I wonder what fraction of HN readers remember this, and what fraction consider this ancient history.) [1] http://americanhistory.si.edu/vote/resources_votomatic.html http://americanhistory.si.edu/vote/resources_votomatic.html [2] http://www.righto.com/2016/05/inside-card-sorters-1920s-data.html http://www.righto.com/2016/05/inside-card-sorters-1920s-data...
- DrScump 10y agoballots in Florida had "hanging chad" To clarify, those were not machine punched, they were pre-perforated with the appropriate hole to be punched by the user, using a stylus, via a printed template that contained the card (holes not referenced directly). We still use the same mechanism in Silicon Valley, sad to say.
- Jraf 10y agoIn France we count all ballots by hand. As every ballot station count only his ballots, it's quick. For a presidential election, maybe 30 minutes. The counting is done by the citizens, so no (easy) frauds are possible. All ballots are visible, the process is transparent, no suspicion. I personally think that a 30min delay to get the election results is worth the wait.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- emptyfile 10y agoSame in my country, never thought of this as being outdated, just the simplest most cost effective solution for a system that has to be totally secure.
- Someone 10y agoThis isn't about that step, as that is done by hand in the Netherlands, too. It is about what happens after that. The electronic steps after that are deemed not secure enough.
- kordless 10y agoHow are the results transmitted and tabulated by hand?
- mantas 10y agoNot the OP, but my country runs a similar system. Each election station counts the ballots by hand. Anyone can signup for counting and/or watch the counting. It's mostly reps from all participating parties. Sometimes few independent citizens show up as well. After all people in the station agree on their total count (they can recount if needed), they phone in their numbers to the central station. Raw numbers of each station are available publicly. The people who did the counting can check if their numbers were transmitted correctly. Parties usually have preliminary results from their people at stations way before the centralised system processes & publicises them. They'd easily spot any issues. Paper ballots are stored in secured bags and can be recounted if there is a need.
- lcfcjs 10y agoThanks Trump.
- pepve 10y agoThe article confuses two things. First there is voting by paper ballot and manually counting them. We have been doing that for about nine years now. Second is aggregating the votes from all the polling stations, this used to be done with software, but with this decision it will be done manually. The immediate reason for this is an investigation into the security of that software which concluded that it was not safe, and the resulting media attention. It is yet unclear what "manual aggregation" exactly means. Electronic calculators and Excel were suggested.
- secfirstmd 10y agoThis is total, total aside. But having been in vote counting centres for hours on end during elections here in Ireland. You really feel the democratic process (also how badly educated some people are about how to fill out something basic like a ballot). A shift to digital methods would really change that, and it's something I will miss. Sometimes, tradition, like Prime Ministers Question time in the UK, is something that has important effects worth keeping. You really see the democracy in action!
- kordless 10y agoI live in Contra Costa County, California. When my wife and I went to vote during the election, my wife's name "had a problem". A lady came out with a binder to compare to the roll where people sign before grabbing their forms. I got my forms, but my wife was told she had to take an absentee ballot because her name was not in the binder, but was on the roll list. Her name was highlighted in the list on the roll that I signed, just above my name. My name was not highlighted and I was allowed to sign the roll and then get my ballot to vote. I only saw a few pages of the roll, but there were at least three people highlighted on the two pages that were open to signing. The other pages definitely had highlighted entries and my comment to my wife was something along the lines of "why is a substantial number of people highlighted?" when we first walked up. After a bit of back and forth, someone in charge agreed to let her vote given she was in the roll book, which is the "truth" of who can vote and who cannot. One lady was still somewhat insistent she be given an absentee ballot. I'm still wondering about it today given all the claims around "hacking".
- DrScump 10y agoBut an "absentee" ballot and a conventional paper ballot are processed the same. Could you instead mean to say a provisional ballot?
- gumby 10y agoAt least they interviewed a computer scientist. I was amazed in 2001 and have continued to be amazed at "civilians'" (i.e. those not in the industry) faith in all things electronic. I remember this also from when I was on the school board. The parents and the administration were eager to augment the young kids' curriculum with "technology skills" -- by which they meant Word and Powerpoint. The only opposition was from board members and parents in the computing industry. Of course now my teenager doesn't even use those tools and had to learn actual technical skills on his own. None of those kids learned anything about what a computer is, or even what "technology" is.