8 ms·
Microsoft working with Washington State on suit against Trump immigration order
- losteric 10y agoAmazon lawyers are also part of this suit
- piker 10y agoFor the Con Law/Fed Courts/Civ Pro scholars out there: is there precedent for standing here with a state suing over immigration?
- ChemicalWarfare 10y agoImmigration and border protection fall under the fed's jurisdiction. Which is why Obama sued Arizona when their governor signed the law to essentially enforce the existing federal laws lol.
- geofft 10y agoIANAL, but the current United States v. Texas case seems to imply yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Texas tl;dr if I'm reading right: Texas and 26 other states sued the federal government over Obama's DAPA executive order. The district court said Texas had standing and issued a preliminary injunction against DAPA. The court of appeals also said Texas had standing and affirmed the injunction, and SCOTUS 4-4 did not reverse them. (Alas, poor Merrick!)
- rayiner 10y agoStates get "special solicitude" in the standing analysis when they sue over federal policies that affect their interests. The Supreme Court recently affirmed that idea in Mass. v. EPA, which held states had standing to challenge EPA regulation of greenhouse gasses.
- melling 10y agoIt's a 90 day travel ban. How fast can a lawsuit reach the courts? It'll be over before it goes to trial. I guess it could be ready if the ban is extended.
- infinitone 10y agoYou do realize it can become indefinite right? It is 90 days only if the countries share 'data' which the trump regime poorly defined. And its highly unlikely countries like Iran would accept that.
- nacs 10y agoExactly, this is only the start of a very slippery slope. It'll start with this 90 day Muslim ban and devolve into something much longer and much worse.
- edblarney 10y ago"You do realize it can become indefinite right?" Legally, it could be, but politically, it probably won't. This temporary ban is political theatre. First - migrants from different parts of the world already face very different degrees of scrutiny - this has been ongoing for a very long time, certainly under Obama etc.. - so the issue of 'national discrimination' will hold up under legal pressure, I think. Second - the commenters point is pragmatically valid because this exec order is a political means for Trump to show that 'he's doing what he said he would do' and to give impetus to his base. That's mostly it. It's not a real operational measure. After 90 days, Trump will declare that 'we've made changes to the vetting process and have 'extreme vetting' (even though there was already 'extreme vetting' under Obama) - and this will be over. Caveat - your point about Iran is valid - but Iran is a very different country than the others, and is on the list for different reasons. I believe that stronger restrictions may be put in place for Iranian citizens after 90 days - this is the beginning of the 're-establishment' of a new Iran-USA relationship which will go in the opposite direction Obama had it going in, for better or worse. Probably worse, but hey. Remember that Trump promised to 'end' the deal that Obama made with Iran - and this ban is going to be part of Trump's 'negotiating process', if you can call it that. It may be worthwhile to legally challenge the order anyhow - for local political reasons (institutions and governments want to seem like they are 'doing something about this injustice) - but also to make sure that, as you say, this could go on for longer than 90 days - but I doubt that. Anyhow - it's important to look at this from a political perspective as much as a legal one, because the game that's being played is mostly political.
- jdonaldson 10y agoMicrosoft has a Vancouver office which is set up to handle H1B candidates that miss the cut on a given year. I wonder if they believe that is at risk as well.
- imchillyb 10y agoIf none of these companies hired non US citizen cheap-labor, would they still be suing? Would they still care? Cheap-labor is the only reason any of these companies gives a rat's-ass about the 90day travel restrictions. President Obama signed heavy travel-restrictions into law in 2015, not a peep from this forum. Not a peep from Microsoft. Not a peep from Amazon. But all of a sudden, NOW we care! Yeah right... ------- http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/29/politics/how-the-trump-administration-chose-the-7-countries/ http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/29/politics/how-the-trump-adminis... ------- > In December 2015, President Obama signed into law a measure placing limited restrictions on certain travelers who had visited Iran, Iraq, Sudan, or Syria on or after March 1, 2011. Two months later, the Obama administration added Libya, Somalia, and Yemen to the list, in what it called an effort to address "the growing threat from foreign terrorist fighters." > The restrictions specifically limited what is known as visa-waiver travel by those who had visited one of the seven countries within the specified time period. People who previously could have entered the United States without a visa were instead required to apply for one if they had traveled to one of the seven countries. > Under the law, dual citizens of visa-waiver countries and Iran, Iraq, Sudan, or Syria could no longer travel to the U.S. without a visa. Dual citizens of Libya, Somalia, and Yemen could, however, still use the visa-waiver program if they hadn't traveled to any of the seven countries after March 2011. ------- Trump's order is much broader. It bans all citizens from those seven countries from entering the U.S. and leaves green card holders subject to being rescreened after visiting those countries. ------- President Trump may have enhanced the restrictions, but he's not the President that enacted them. Where were you Armchair Justice Warriors then? You sure weren't here posting about the -exceedingly heavy- restrictions in 2015. Nope, not a single one of you...
- Dagwoodie 10y agoI know this will be unpopular, but I'm so sick of this topic already. Partly because there has been so much emotion and as a result, misinformation disseminated as part of this action from the media to social media. First, it was alleged that Trump was only banning Muslims from countries he wasn't doing business in. Then, it turns out it's not even a Muslim ban at all, since ~80% of the world's Muslim population is unaffected, and the countries chosen were actually chosen by the Obama administration in 2011. Then, there were major protests that clogged up the airports this weekend, which turned out to be a Delta computer failure that stranded everyone. Then there is the usual parade of cries of fascism and comparison to Hitler, when no evidence can be offered to support those claims. The simple fact is that these 'refugees' have been spat upon by their own countries, neighboring countries and muslim brothers/sisters who have turned them away. They're desperate and someone should help them, but the US doesn't owe these people anything, so unless we are sending them straight to death camps or shooting them right off the boat/plane, the twitter-verse is making a lot of people act like fools by acting like everyone agrees that these people have all rights outlined in the constitution. That said, we should help these people as best we can, but a permanent home in the US for any people that have no love for our laws, our people or constitution doesn't do them or us any favors by letting them stay permanently. The question is, who wants to conform to our way of life and who doesn't? Can we keep inviting everyone in unconditionally before we pay a very serious price?
- FireBeyond 10y ago"but the US doesn't owe these people anything" except for those Green Card holders and citizens returning from these countries who have a not unreasonable expectation that we gave them that they have a home here (and mostly, already, have a life here), right?
- rayiner 10y agoI don't think any US citizens got caught up in this. But yes, dragging people with valid visas and green cards into this is what caused the shit storm.
- 10y ago
- tomohawk 10y agoCubans are trying to escape a repressive regime and face real consequences if caught or sent back. Obama sides with the regime and starts sending the refugees back, unilaterally changing longstanding US policy in the last week of being in office. All I heard was crickets. In this case, we have 7 countries already designated as requiring enhanced vetting due to terrorist concerns. Suddenly, outrage.
- thatfrenchguy 10y agoThose are two very different things and you know it.
- tomohawk 10y agoYou're right. The Cubans face serious repercussions once they get back. What about the other guys? They're from countries that actively sponsor terrorism or who can't properly vet people. And what about the chaos at the airports for the Cubans when Obama's order went out? http://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/sur-de-la-florida/article126749329.html http://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/sur-de-la-florida/arti... http://www.diariolasamericas.com/florida/cubanos-visas-turismo-estarian-retenidos-el-aeropuerto-miami-n4112383 http://www.diariolasamericas.com/florida/cubanos-visas-turis... http://www.martinoticias.com/a/cuba-deportan-cubanos-llegan-miami-visas-turista/137285.html http://www.martinoticias.com/a/cuba-deportan-cubanos-llegan-...
- sprafa 10y agoYou say one thing then demonstrate evidence of the opposite, there was plenty of media attention on Obama's order.
- CurtHagenlocher 10y agoThis is a little disingenuous. The largest part of the outrage is because these are people who have already gone through enhanced vetting and in many cases have lives and family in the US.
- bdrool 10y ago