6 ms·
The long term effects of alcohol on mental health are also not much fun: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_alcohol_consumption#Mental_health_ef
by rwmj 10y ago
The long term effects of alcohol on mental health are also not much fun: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_alcohol_consumption#Mental_health_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_alcohol_c...
- throwanem 10y agoI should think the same is true of many psychoactive substances, and effectively all drugs of abuse. Experience and observation tend to bear out this surmise. A more useful question might be why this is such a controversial point when it comes to cannabis, and cannabis alone.
- streetsweeper 10y agoPerhaps the focus is politically motivated. For a large part of the 20th century masturbation was considered a cause of schizophrenia. It's worth noting how broadly defined and poorly understood the condition of schizophrenia is, and that the diagnosis is made purely upon subjective social behaviors, rather than objective scientific pathology. Diagnostic behaviors of schizophrenia include: lack of motivation, anxiety, and reduced social engagement. With such broadly defined symptoms, it could be argued that everyone who smokes a joint is a schizophrenic.
- narag 10y agoBecause it's a popular drug that's mostly harmless for most people in "normal" dosage and there has been a lot of disinformation spread by authorities. Now most cannabis consumers tend to see everything like a government conspiration, not believing even true adverse effects. Heavy use for enough time will get you in a mist of passivity and poor memory. Every experienced weed smoker would have told you so much, a few years ago. Now there's a resistance to concede even that.
- givinguflac 10y agoYour last paragraph is conjecture based on hearsay, and I disagree. I know many consistent "users" and all are successful, hardworking people who are engaged in their lives. Is it nice to relax for a night and chill? Of course. But to say that it affects how a person acts throughout their life is just wrong. But, lazy/passive people will find any excuse that isn't personal responsibility, so I think your study is flawed at best.
- throwawaycanada 10y agoConsistent users that are successful and hardworking are not usually also extremely heavy users. When I picture a heavy user I picture someone who gets high all day, every day.
- metaphorm 10y ago> When I picture a heavy user I picture someone who gets high all day, every day. that's what I think of as well. however, many people will interpret "heavy user" as meaning like, someone who smokes a joint with any regularity at all. once a week might count as a heavy user by some definitions. the disagreement on what counts as heavy use is really the problem here. what you're describing is someone who is basically high all the time. very little disagreement that being high on cannabis profoundly effects your concentration and memory while you're high. a lot of controversy and ambiguity about what happens the day after.
- bsenftner 10y agoIf you have to "picture a heavy user" that implies you are using your imagination. That implies you don't know any. I personally know many daily, heavy users that are very successful, research scientists, 3D developers, media production digital artists, producers, and even studio heads. The idea that cannabis makes people passive is simply wrong. The idea that it impacts creativity or drive also simply wrong. If you don't have examples of successful daily pot users, those around you either hide it from you, or your circles do not have any. I work in technology's creative industries, and I have examples all around me.
- metaphorm 10y ago> Heavy use for enough time will get you in a mist of passivity and poor memory. Every experienced weed smoker would have told you so much, a few years ago. Now there's a resistance to concede even that. depends on what you're counting as "heavy use" and "enough time". also depends on whether or not you still smoke, and how much, and how often. I don't disagree that there are some values for those parameters that do lead to "passivity and poor memory". we just don't really have a clear view on what the range of effects is across different values for those parameters, and how much variability there is within individuals. heavy use for one person might only be moderate use for another. the resistance to conceding those obvious points is really just based on ambiguity. yeah, every experienced smoker is familiar with the cannabis haze. the questions are really more about the specifics than the generals.
- JPKab 10y agoThere's certainly a debate about what constitutes "heavy use". My thoughts on it are that once or twice a week, single doses that intoxicate probably aren't that bad. The issue is that there are some people who ingest cannabis not only on a daily basis, but throughout each of those days they are consistently ingesting it. I can't imagine this not having a detrimental effect, at least while they are using it this way.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- panzagl 10y agoWeed is a religion. My most downvoted comment on Reddit was about stoned elementary school kids coming to my wife's class in the morning- apparently it doesn't happen and it's all just hearsay and gov't conspiracies.
- natdempk 10y agoThis may be a bit odd, but I looked up this comment pretty easily because I was curious what it said to elicit such a strong response and I feel like you misrepresent it here. The comment is here: https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/5bm3kp/colorado_cannabis_retailers_dont_sell_to_minors/d9pvi4m/ https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/5bm3kp/colorado_ca... It isn't your most down-voted comment. It has -3 and you have about 10 other comments with lower scores. In the comment you solely mention the smell of kids. This doesn't mean that they are using cannabis at all. This could easily be similar to kids whose parents smoke cigarettes. Yes second hand smoke is bad for the kids over time, but that doesn't make them stoned by any means. I don't disagree with you though that there are dogmatists around cannabis. There definitely are and they don't help anything.
- panzagl 10y agoHah, I forgot about baiting the French in that WWII thread... My wife works at a low socio-economic status school. They're not using directly, no they're not stoned to the 'whoa, dude' level, it's more of a general 'grogginess' that kind of goes away late in the morning. It's definitely 'anec-data' of the finest sort, but it's something the teachers notice and comment on. What I don't understand is why no one ever thinks that suddenly 'legalizing' a drug that produces a docile population is somehow more ominous than the previous gov't action to suppress it.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoHow does she differentiate between those kids and the ones that simply have a biological clock mis-matched with school? Do they all definitely smell of the smoke? I ask mostly because I could have been that kid. I'm that adult. I smoke now, but my parents didn't and I didn't start while I was in school. My mother fought to get me awake for years: I wouldn't even wake up early for Santa Clause presents. Seriously, I chose to sleep and wait to open them until after we went to Grandma's house.
- simplyluke 10y agoEveryone knows people from high school/college too who started off as great high performing students and absolutely burned out at least in part due to abuse. Part of the problem is it makes you okay with not improving your condition.
- eonw 10y agoThough cannabis use can increase apathy, i don't think there is a lot of correlation, lots of kids step out of sports and other activities as they age, for many reasons. I am a daily user and have always had a burning desire to improve myself, my situation and the world around me. My list of hobbies and interests increases constantly and I haven't dropped very many, even the ones I suck at. Blanket statements are rarely correct.
- simplyluke 10y agoEveryone knows people from high school/college too who started off as great high performing students and absolutely burned out at least in part due to abuse. Part of the problem is it makes you okay with not improving your condition.
- spoiledtechie 10y agoStop trying to steer the conversation to alc, it does nobody any good, each drug holds It's own ground. This one, we are now talking about is MJ.
- Retric 10y agoDosage is an important factor though. At low dosage alcohol has minimal long term impacts, alcoholism has a lot of associated mental and physical effects. I don't thing we have a good idea what the long term effects for a moderate smoker are. So, There is moderate evidence of no statistical association between cannabis use and: • Incidence of lung cancer (cannabis smoking) (5-1) may be true, but again I think the data is rather poor and short term. Back to your point, statistics linking mental Heath issues to smoking is not causual especially when There is moderate evidence of a statistical association between cannabis use and: • Better cognitive performance among individuals with psychotic disorders and a history of cannabis use (12-2a)
- at-fates-hands 10y agoWhy is it that every time someone mentions some negative effects of marijuana, someone has to chirp in and say that alcohol is so much worse?
- Kinnard 10y agoBecause it is and given its prevalence that has important health implications for everyone on earth even teetotalists?
- makmanalp 10y agoI say this as someone who doesn't have a horse in this race: because pot is demonized as a "drug" and so the health effects are exaggerated. So it's helpful to have a constant reminder that a lot of us regularly consume alcohol, which is has high addictive potential and very negative long term effects, and yet is not demonized by society and moderate drinkers are perfectly fine. The basis of comparison to something that we're very familiar with helps put things into perspective. It's not to say that the negative effects don't exist, but that we as a society tolerate something with similarly negative effects all the time and live normal lives.
- rconti 10y agoBecause the negative effects are being used as an argument to support continued prohibition, when full-scale legalization could well cause a reduction in overall negative drug-related social effects -- both from reductions/moderations in worse-drug use (eg, alcohol), and from the negative effects of the criminal justice system.
- sv123 10y agoBecause the negative effects are always mentioned around cannabis as justification to keep it highly illegal. If we apply the same standards, then alcohol would be prohibited, and we all know that doesn't work.