15 ms·
American chestnut trees are “technically extinct”
- orasis 10y agoThe real tragedy was that people were implored to chop down blighted trees. A few of those may have had genetic resistance that could have kept the species going.
- aresant 10y agoFrom Wikipedia: "Salvage logging during the early years of the blight may have unwittingly destroyed trees which had high levels of resistance to this disease and thus aggravated the calamity." One of many good examples of humanities best intentions having adverse effects on an ecosystem or species. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_chestnut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_chestnut
- tabeth 10y agoIsn't salvage logging entirely just to make money? Humanity reaps what it sows.
- ash_gti 10y agoSalvage logging is to cut down trees damaged by something to protect the rest of the tree (fire damage, disease, etc.).
- tabeth 10y agoFirst. As far as the purpose of salvage logging. It is economic. [0] > "the term 'salvage' is appropriate for operations in which the primary objective of postfire logging is economic..." From the link the parent posted, it sounds like there's little evidence that it does any of that (the things you mentioned). [1] [2] The one paper cited on Wikipedia as being pro-logging goes against it in the conclusion: > "We know enough about both logging activity and structural change to recommend caution. Although ground-based logging activity could mitigate for erosion problems under certain conditions, it is more likely that it will either have no effect or produce more sediment than that is produced by the fire..." [3] This was published in 2000. I stand by my original comment. Humanity reaps what it sows. I'd be interested to see contradicting evidence if there is any. My comment came from reading the Wikipedia article. [0] pg 1. http://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1957/5114/PB2000103407.pdf?sequence=1 http://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/195... [1] http://science.sciencemag.org/content/311/5759/352 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/311/5759/352 [2] http://www.californiachaparral.com/images/Lindenmayer_et_al_Salvage_Harvesting_Science_2004.pdf http://www.californiachaparral.com/images/Lindenmayer_et_al_... [3] pg 21. http://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1957/5114/PB2000103407.pdf?sequence=1 http://ir.library.oregonstate.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/195...
- ralfd 10y agoThough the original statement in the Wiki article is only a Google link to a book from 2015 which I can't seem to read more about? If 4 billion trees were affected in only a few years, people couldn't have chopped down so many trees, couldn't they? If there were natural resistant chest nuts at least a few should have endured.
- kbutler 10y agoThe implication that anything done to make money is automatically bad is completely false. The economic effects of "the invisible hand", whereby voluntary exchange yields benefits to both parties and provides an economic surplus, is a "win-win" whereby both parties are better off. This is not without possible negative effects ("negative externalities") but it is the most effective way to improve people's lives we've found so far. Remember that nature and natural selection works by a more damaging mechanism - "take what you can" - and yet still manages to produce beneficial results - though obviously not better for every individual or species.
- tabeth 10y agoI made no implication saying it's bad or good (if I unintentionally did, I explicitly state that it was not here). "You reap what you sow" is an idiom that simply says everything that happens to you is a result of your own actions. [1] It does have a religious context that has a more negative, connotation however. Also, as I showed in the sibling post, we've known about the negative effects of salvage logging for at least 20 years. We're still doing it, by the way. [2] Humanity will also "reap what it sows" in regards to our lack of action on regards to climate change. I intend to make no positive or negative claim. Simply stating the facts (I hope). [1] http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/You+reap+what+you+sow http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/You+reap+what+you+sow [2] https://www.google.com/search?q=salvage+logging&oq=salvage+logging&aqs=chrome.0.0l6.2238j0j9&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#tbs=qdr:m&q=salvage+logging+california https://www.google.com/search?q=salvage+logging&oq=salvage+l...
- panglott 10y agoMuch of the economic history of economic exploitation has been "take what you can" rather than free exchange. It leads to the liquidation of a valuable long-term resource for a quick short-term gain. A fishery that would be worth many billions over centuries is liquidated for millions in a few years, for example. This is especially true in the US, where so many plants and animals did not live within a system of property. The American bison was saved only because one or two landowner had a sentimental attachment to a local herd and spared them from the carnage. The passenger pigeon was exterminated for cheap meat with industrial hunting methods. Markets create positive sum games, but this was just destruction. The opportunity cost of billions of American chestnuts producing valuable nuts and timber over the last century is incalculable.
- toodlebunions 10y agoThey were all turned into peanut butter. True facts!
- jacobush 10y agoEh, alternative facts.
- joecool1029 10y agoEverytime I hike in the region I wonder what it might have looked like 100 years ago with these trees. I still find myself looking for them sometimes, have spotted a few here and there, many old giants that keep trying to send up shoots only to have them re-infected and die again.
- nickparker 10y agoLost biodiversity fills me with a bizarrely deep sense of sadness. I'm really hoping biotech will advance far enough to A) stop the anthropocene extinction and B) eventually reverse it, if not by reviving species then by creating new and wonderful additions to our ecosystems. On an odder tangent, this is also part of why I'm really excited about space habitats and eventual Mars habitats. When we start creating massive enclosed spaces where we fully control the conditions, I think we'll start seeing some beautiful engineered ecosystems. Utilitarian stuff at first, like those ugly-yet-functional urban hydroponics setups you see today, but eventually I'm hopeful we'll create some 'natural' beauty.
- annnnd 10y agoOn a different tangent: do you think thus created nature will be beautiful to us? Will it be beautiful to people who are born there? I wonder why the trees are beautiful to us.. Maybe because we are used to them and connect nice memories to the image of trees?
- nickparker 10y agoI don't think we'll create anything radically different enough to not be beautiful. Modifying what already exists is usually easier than creating something from nothing, and I would expect that to apply for engineering new organisms. If you mean will the ecosystems be beautiful to us, as in, will a forest in a space station really be a forest, or more of a gaudy tourist attraction and/or a sterile research environment, I'm hopeful that we'll choose to include some allowance for beauty in our planning. Kim Stanley Robertson's Mars trilogy touches on these themes a lot, and I'm also drawing to some degree from the Culture series' vision of orbitals. We're clearly centuries (at least) from being able to build orbitals, but I think far smaller ring structures - and even more likely mere two-body tether set ups - may be just decades ahead.
- yareally 10y agoThe short-term focus of humanity sometimes worries me as we keep making mistakes that are likely irreversible and preventable. Passenger pigeons were once estimated to be the most abundant bird in the world. There were so many that no one thought they could ever go extinct, until they did in the early 20th century. Ignorance befell twice when people failed to realize a bird that would "darken the skies" could go extinct like any creature and that their breeding habits weren't as straight forward as one would assume. Passenger pigeons would only breed in large flocks, so by the time that anyone realized they were doomed and tried to breed them, there weren't enough pigeons left to form a flock of significant size. Some might argue the pigeons or even the chestnut/elm/ash are not a regrettable loss, but miss the point--that our assumption we can easily undo the damage we cause to the planet is not always possible. The trees might make a comeback from genetic engineering eventually, but bringing animals back from extinction is still more theory than application.
- pogba101 10y agoThis makes me very sad. I love eating roasted chestnuts as a snack. This might be part of the reason why I find chestnuts to be so expensive when compared to back home (spain). Seriously, try to get some chestnuts and roast them (oven or microwave) with some salt. They are delicious, especially during the cold months.
- wyclif 10y agoI ate them all the time when I was a kid. I associate the taste with childhood.
- lbebber 10y agoSame for me, together with pinhões from Araucaria[1] trees, which are also unfortunately endangered. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Araucaria_angustifolia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Araucaria_angustifolia
- VeejayRampay 10y agoThey're also delicious steam-cooked in a pressure cooker. We still have lots of chestnut trees in France, I hope it stays that way.
- geon 10y agoHere in Sweden, we have plenty of chestnut but they are all poisonous.
- robin_reala 10y agoIn Sweden you have Horse Chestnut[1], whereas in France there’s both that and the Sweet Chestnut[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aesculus_hippocastanum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aesculus_hippocastanum [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castanea_sativa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castanea_sativa
- david-given 10y ago
- spqr0a1 10y agoGood news! this article understates the current stage of development for at least one of the reintroduction projects. A blight resistance gene (oxalate oxidase) has been added by state university researchers in new york. The genetically modified trees are being crossed with pure-bred chestnuts for improved genetic diversity before wider distribution. http://www.esf.edu/chestnut/ http://www.esf.edu/chestnut/ The plan is to distribute seeds from these trees within 5 years through a partnership between SUNY-ESF and the NY chapter of The American Chestnut Foundation. I've committed to planting at least 4500 of these trees (interspersed across 60+ acres) in their native forest setting once available. If you care about the chestnut or ecology but agroforestry isn't your thing, these organizations could really use donations to ensure this project continues.
- apaprocki 10y agoHow did you commit to planting the trees? Is that an organized program?
- gravypod 10y agoI'm going to choose to belive that the commenter is planing a heist to plant all of the seeds in the forest by themselves in a Robinhood fashion. They're asking for donations because they're going to hit the vault on their way out.
- jerf 10y agoIf you are going to make that joke, the correct reference is Johnny Appleseed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Appleseed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Appleseed
- bluejekyll 10y agoI don't know if it understates the status of these new breeds. They haven't been proven, yet. It could be 50 years before it's clear that they are resistant. My parents are also doing this on their property, it is exciting, and I hope this new breed is resistant to the fungus.
- wyclif 10y agoI'm old enough to remember large chestnut trees on our old farm in eastern Pennsylvania, but they're all gone now. It's a genuine tragedy, and I hope botanists can produce a blight-resistant tree soon.
- doomlaser 10y agoThe emerald ash borer is currently having the same effect on the billions of ash trees in North America. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emerald_ash_borer#Invasiveness_and_spread https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emerald_ash_borer#Invasiveness... It's a similar story. The species was accidentally introduced from Asia in the 1990s, and it's spreading dramatically across the continent. No effective strategy has been discovered to stop the destruction as of yet.
- _nalply 10y agoSame in Switzerland. The local newspaper (Berner Zeitung) has an article today about how the ash trees needed to be felled in a Bernese park and removed by helicopter because of difficult topography.
- ommunist 10y agoThese bugs can be defeated by aerial spray of species-specific viral infection. But that weapon has to be designed first. In 70-ies, the USSR by such means successfully combated Lymantria dispar invasion in Siberia, which devastated pine forests on unimaginable scale. Though it took about 7 years and if memory serves, 3 research institutions to make insights into immune system of this species and make effective species-specific virus. The strain is still available.
- kodfodrasz 10y agoDo you have any literature on this story?
- ommunist 10y agoSince this was long before the Internet, I doubt it is available on www. However quick search gives this, you can feed it to Google Translate. http://www.libussr.ru/doc_ussr/usr_9772.htm http://www.libussr.ru/doc_ussr/usr_9772.htm. Name of strain is "вирин-ЭНШ" This is final document with instruction of strain usage http://www.libussr.ru/doc_ussr/usr_10557.htm http://www.libussr.ru/doc_ussr/usr_10557.htm
- 10y ago
- ttoinou 10y agoI always wondered if Americans cook chestnut spread ?
- lutusp 10y ago> There used to be 4B American chestnut trees, but they all disappeared Not long ago this would have been rendered as, "There once were four billion American chestnut trees, all now gone." People are no longer learning how to write, they're learning how to type.
- CalRobert 10y agoCan you elaborate? The title, as presented here, is nothing spectacular, but it's not necessarily inadequate to the task. Also, the "all now gone" phrase in your alternate strikes me as somewhat awkward. While reading your version I also wondered why you might go with "There once were" rather than "There were once"? We all have our own pet peeves, though. I weep at the loss of the subjunctive in English (For most usages it's "I wish I WERE there", not "I wish I WAS there", dammit!!!)
- lutusp 10y ago> The title, as presented here, is nothing spectacular, but it's not necessarily inadequate to the task. I just see too many uses of "There used to be", which to me is a crude way to concatenate two stock phrases without reflection, but in a awkward way that grates on my ear. Also I think Strunk & White's concision emphasis still rings true. > I also wondered why you might go with "There once were" rather than "There were once"? Voicing the candidates shows the difference. I imagine speaking anything I write, which reveals phrasings that would be hard to say out loud. > We all have our own pet peeves, though. I weep at the loss of the subjunctive in English (For most usages it's "I wish I WERE there", not "I wish I WAS there", dammit!!!) I have a funny story about that. A depressed child enters the kitchen and says, "I wish I was dead!" The child's mother says, "Oh no! Not that! Don't you mean 'I wish I were dead'?" :) > Also, the "all now gone" phrase in your alternate strikes me as somewhat awkward. Perhaps, but in my view not compared to "They all disappeared," which suggests proactive agency (did they run away?) rather than passive fate.
- CalRobert 10y ago'Perhaps, but in my view not compared to "They all disappeared," which suggests proactive agency (did they run away?) rather than passive fate' Ah, I see your point. Sadly I think a generation or two of teachers maniacally chastising their students for ever using the passive form could have something to do with this. Even in this forum, you'll find plenty of people saying that all writing need be direct, simple, and brief. There's virtue in that for quick memoranda, but to say that there's no place in the world for complex, abstract writing or the expression of nuance in careful word choice (as you describe) is a real shame. Too often I've been corrected by people who say "you mean 'I wish I _was_' because the subject is singular". There's some evidence that language is what makes abstract thought even possible. Perhaps we're leaving our minds unable to comprehend abstractions when we reduce that available in our language. More discussion is at https://neuroanthropology.net/2010/07/21/life-without-language/ https://neuroanthropology.net/2010/07/21/life-without-langua.... Or maybe I just need to get over it. I overcame my violent aversion to starting sentences with "or" and "and", after all.
- ommunist 10y agoI will be very happy to see a blight-resistant chestnut in the US as a result of some genetic engineering. I am even ready to donate for such a good cause if this effort will ever be crowdfunded by known biologists in the field. Heck, I am even ready to get the US visa just to take part in planting them back, once they get saplings. Guys, do it!
- bhouston 10y agoThe North American Elm tree is also being wiped out as we speak in a similar very thorough manner: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_elm_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_elm_disease
- ComputerGuru 10y agoYup. We lost two, massive elms in our yard this past spring to Dutch Elm Disease. By the time you spot it, it's too late.
- gyrgtyn 10y agoI hope we've learned from the Chestnut fiasco that the 'solution' to this is probably not to cut down all Elm trees.
- keithly 10y agoThere are at least a couple resistant varieties ("Princeton" comes to mind) but none are fully immune. Resistance seems to depend on the type of beetle infesting the tree and other stressors.
- eppp 10y agoThere are a few still alive near my house. Several professors have come to take the seeds for use in these projects.
- dmm 10y agoPerhaps they were acting on behalf of the American Chestnut Cooperators Foundation, they have been working to cross various American Chestnuts with demonstrated blight resistance to create a fully resistant strain. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Chestnut_Cooperators_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Chestnut_Cooperators_...
- Washuu 10y agoI actually had no idea this was the case. There is an old chestnut tree in my parents back yard that has been there for 40+ years at least.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoThe American chestnut has become some sort of poster child for GMO advocates, but there is no need to resort to genetic modification to bring it back. There have been and are blight resistant trees developed through conventional breeding programs. I have hybrids on my own property that are blight resistant. There are some that are 95%+ American chestnut genetics and are not blight susceptible. There are programmes in both Canada and the U.S. breeding these trees. Marker assisted selection might be used which I suppose is a kind of GM technology, but there is no need to resort to gene _editing_ or _splicing_. That is a far more expensive and has the disadvantage of having extremely bad PR. Same thing for the non-browning apple, BTW. There was no _need_ beyond availability of funding and various ag department/company politics to resort to GM for that. There have been non-browning apple strains around since the 19th century. I should also point out that there are rare instances of what appear to be naturally blight resistant mature trees in the wild found here or there. Maybe they're natural hybrids, or just lucky to avoid the blight, but if you find one, various breeding groups would love to know.
- Neliquat 10y agoThis is the kind of anti science drivel I never expect to see on HN, but here goes. You paint this as being a 'gmo posterchild' when clearly, it is humans, scrambling with Every technology at our disposal, to save a species. Your whole rambling post harbors the implicit notion that 'GMO BAD, "Natural" GOOD' with no statement to support that backward notion. The GM strains are superior in apples for a plethora of reasons, or they would use your obscure, bitter, non-browning, and less disease resistant apples requiring even more pesticides. But they do not. I concede that quite likely we can use thousand year old tech to accomplish these goals. However the timeframe may be much longer (omitting red tape) for a result, and time is of the essence. If you can substantiate the unsaid evils of GM vs breeding by selected random mutations, please, be my guest.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoYou could do without the tone in this comment, and could stick to the facts instead of trying to smear me. I am not even anti-GM. Nowhere in my comment did I say GM was evil. Go back and actually read. I'm trying to point out a fact: mass selection has advantages, GMO in the "gene splicing" way is here is not necessary, and is a _political_ liability. You want to reforest the wild with GMO organisms? It won't be me trying to stop you, but others definitely will. So it's a dumb way to do it. BTW, what I am talking about is not "thousand year old tech" -- mass selection breeding is under a century old. Luther Burbank died in 1926. And mass selection is now done with marker assistance, a very modern "GM" technology. _Would_ that medieval monks knew anything about breeding and mass selection. They did not. Also you might want to do some research before making claims about non-browning apples that you can't back up with facts. It is you who are violating the community standards of HN with your personal attacks. Do not call someone's comments drivel -- especially if you can't even be bothered to read them.
- panglott 10y agoThis article almost criminally understates the amount of success the restoration program has had in the last few years. The American Chestnut Foundation's effort to backcross the American chestnut with blight-resistant Chinese chestnuts has been successfully producing trees for over 10 years. Our local parks department has planted a number of these in our urban forest, including an orchard of a dozen trees or more. http://www.kychestnut.org/louisville-american-chestnuts http://www.kychestnut.org/louisville-american-chestnuts
- virtualwhys 10y agoCambridge, MA. Lone chestnut tree Enchanting fruit To a 70s child Long gone now :\
- driverdan 10y agoThey have it backwards. They're technically not extinct, just rare. I've seen them in the wild. My parents have one in their front yard they planted around 30 years ago from a sapling they found while camping. It makes me wonder if it's a resistant strain.
- DashRattlesnake 10y agoIt sounds like reproduction has basically stopped in the wild, and extinction is a foregone conclusion without human intervention. It's an interesting grey area.
- aacook 10y agoI think the term is "functionally extinct". The blight doesn't affect them until they're 20-30 years old. There's a very good chance they'll die. I don't think they've found a blight-resistant strain yet, just isolated trees, which always eventually get blighted.
- ausjke 10y agoCan I buy trees from lowes or homedepot or walmart to plant them? At Texas we do have some chestnut trees, but not too many.
- mvidal01 10y agoIf you want to help the Chestnut tree join The American Chestnut Foundation - http://www.acf.org/ http://www.acf.org/. They do research into developing disease resistant varieties of Chestnut.
- devy 10y agoAnd there is this promising news recently. http://scienceline.org/2017/01/american-chestnut-tree-good-shot-making-comeback/ http://scienceline.org/2017/01/american-chestnut-tree-good-s...
- billfor 10y agoThere are a number of hybrid American chestnuts that are blight resistant. I have a Dunstan Chestnut that is doing rather well after a few years. It still gets the blight but heals itself over time.
- droithomme 10y agoDidn't realize it was that bad. I'll continue to keep secret the location of the small grove of ancient mature trees where I gather the nuts each year. If word got out you'd have the crazies showing up wanting to cut them all down.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoGrowing up in CA, I had no idea about the former glory or struggle of the chestnut tree, and so found this piece quite interesting.
- mac01021 10y agoThe best kind of extinct.
- Pica_soO 10y agoHack its genom? Grow kevlar crusted chestnuts! There under the chest-nuttree, i betrayed humanity and it betrayed me. Curious question- is there a law against CRISPR-terrorism?
- 51Cards 10y agoThere is one in Stanley Park in Vancouver. I came across it and didn't know what the nuts were so collected several off the ground to look up. I didn't know anything about the tree before that. For the curious: http://imgur.com/a/eis4a http://imgur.com/a/eis4a
- patall 10y agoI am not a botanist and cannot say from the pictures but that might as well have been a european sweet chestnut, as its outside of the natural range either way and the european is probably more common. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castanea_sativa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castanea_sativa
- Pxtl 10y agoButternut is also on its way out too thanks to canker fungus, but some have been identified that are resistant so those are getting bred.
- petre 10y agoIt's always a fungus or a bug imported from Asia. The Emerald Ash Borer, the Asian Longhorned Beetle etc.