9 ms·
Customers are getting caught up as banks de-risk due to money laundering laws
- torrent-of-ions 10y agoSo people are starting to realise that they can't actually trust the organisations that control their money. I wonder if this sort of thing will raise awareness about who we actually trust, and whether we should be trusting anyone at all.
- csomar 10y agoI think the law is the problem. First, banks should not be held responsible for wrong doings by their customers. (think if hosting companies were responsible for the content their customers publish). Second, the law gives them power without a recourse. This is because the law makes them responsible in case one of their customers were laundering money.
- kagamine 10y agoReasons I can think of for why the banks are responsible for the wrong-doings of their customers, as you put it, is because HSBC among others have been caught laundering money[1] (or at the very least not preventing it). So making them responsible is similar to making barmen responsible for checking IDs before serving alcohol. Sure, the underage drinker is the one perpetuating the crime, but by criminalizing the barman you insist upon a check in the system. The hosting company comparison doesn't fit, you can publish a myriad of content and quickly to a host, checking all of it, against laws for explicit content and copyright alone would be a mammoth task. Banks only offer financial services they themselves choose to provide. In essence they only provide FTP and the only file you can FTP is a number (to put it simply). Banks need regulating (is there anyone alive in this day and age who doubts this?), not just on an international level, but locally and for the 'little man' too. My own experience this last year involved making a formal complaint to the consumer financial complaints body where I live about an error made by the bank, freely admitted to by the bank, and the result was "suck it up", including the financial cost. Banking is in a poor state, having lost the faith of the public. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Controversies
- meanduck 10y agoSo you are saying we are gonna let banks get away with it because Govts cant find better revenue source ? The amount of overreaching laws just to ensure Govts revenue is staggering. I shudder to think what would happen if UBI is added into the mix.
- kagamine 10y ago> So you are saying we are gonna let banks get away with it I said nothing of the sort. > overreaching laws just to ensure Govts revenue Follow the link from my previous post, are you suggesting that laundering the profits from trade in opiates and helping fund terrorism is better than some laws that require banks to be accountable for their actions? Those money laundering transactions are processed for a fee. HSBC made money from people suffering and from people dying/being killed. It looks to me as though in the case of Mohammad Rahman that the banks have been given a procedure by the government to be followed but have neglected to implement a workable solution, based on there being no recourse for individual customers. It appears, at least in the case of Mohammad Rahman that the bank failed in their duty to the customer while citing "it's not our fault and we don't really care anyway". Followed by "oh shit, bad press! Remedy at 12 o'clock!" but that nothing will change in the long term because they still don't care either morally or ethically. If banks want to be in the business of banking then they ought to make banking their job and that does not only involve profit at the cost of everyone and everything, not excuse themselves with a shrug every time demands are placed on the banking system.
- meanduck 10y agoThe laws that powers banks to withhold someone money are the same laws that Govts use to maximize tax revenue. Drug/Terrorism is mostly irrelevent.
- kagamine 10y agoIt isn't irrelevant at all when the law allowing them to seize funds exists directly due to the law being changed in order to prevent HSBC and others having been caught laundering money from cartels and terrorists. It really is not irrelevant.
- candiodari 10y agoIf the purpose behind is is to get the government to force banks to responsibly handle money ... you forget it's the government that requires these rules in the first place. Barclays obviously carries the biggest part of the blame, but when consulting for a bank, we were constantly reminded that there are EU regulations stating that any transaction above 10.000 euros is to be automatically flagged and reported, and if such a transaction is "unusual" (yes that's what the government rule says), it is to be blocked, along with all other transactions on the account, until evidence is provided that the transaction was (a) legitimate (b) not made with the purpose of evading tax. Note that the owner of the blocked account needs to prove the tax department has no issues (for instance a letter stating no outstanding debts). If Barclays is anything like my local banks, it sucks, but chances are they're not doing this just to spite their customers. Since that job I carry 1000 euros in cash in my wallet, and never again shall I have a single bank account again. I managed to have a third account in a separate country last year under a not-identical name (if you're married in the EU chances are you have the right to use any combination of yours and your spouses names, including both of them with or without a dash in between).
- Silhouette 10y agoIf the purpose behind is is to get the government to force banks to responsibly handle money ... you forget it's the government that requires these rules in the first place. But the government rules do not require the bank to continue to lock up the money even after evidence of legitimacy is provided or to make further errors that prevent the customer from demonstrating the legitimacy in the required way even if they want to. Both of those things appear to have happened here.
- informatimago 10y agoNotice that 10,000 euros is nothing; as a free lance consultant, you can invoice easily much more than that monthly. So basically they're tracking everybody.
- kuschku 10y agoSomething like 60% of the people only do transfers over 10'000 Euro once a year or less. Most people earn far less, and only ever transfer such large amounts when they buy a car.
- sleepychu 10y agoIt hurts but I've just accepted I need to go and see my bank in person if I'm doing anything 'unusual' in the near future. The alternative is ending up in this situation where they cannot talk to you because your account is subject to ongoing fraud investigation and the people investigating you do not care because the potential fraud is so inconsequential.
- Silhouette 10y agoUnfortunately, even going and seeing your bank in person is no guarantee of getting sensible results. I've been told I've failed an identity check while on a call from a branch, when that call had been started by a member of staff from that branch who had identified themselves and was standing next to me at the time, while I was in possession of more photo ID and proof of current address than I've ever needed to open any account in my life. And all that member of staff could do afterwards was apologize and share a half-hearted laugh with me as I left. This happened while signing up for a new service, and ironically I was in the branch in the first place because I'd been unable to answer a security question on a call from my own phone. That was because the only two answers I was allowed to choose were both obviously incorrect, because the subject of that question was also the reason for my call, but again the person on the phone apparently wasn't allowed to accept that and continue.
- DanBC 10y agoThe article says that he did go and see them in person, several times, and that the bank gave him conflicting incorrect advice and sent him to different departments.
- Silhouette 10y agoThe most important points in the article seem to be summed up in just a few lines: “Customers making and receiving genuine transactions have absolutely nothing to fear,” a [Barclays] spokesperson says. Except Rahman is not a criminal and has spent three months without access to his money. He might still be without it if the Observer had not intervened shortly before Christmas. The rest is a sad but educational story of how much we now depend on big business to live normal lives and how the big, automated systems used by those businesses make no allowances for the human consequences when they make mistakes.
- yunolisten 10y ago> and how the big, automated systems used by those businesses make no allowances for the human consequences when they make mistakes. From experience, nor do the wage slaves simply enforcing the 'rules' as dictated by their employers.
- Silhouette 10y agoBut in those days if something was obviously wrong you could ask to speak to someone more senior, and typically at least the duty manager in the branch had the authority to do something about an obvious problem. Now it seems if the computer says no, you just get a practised smile and some variation of "I'm very sorry, but there's nothing I can do to help you today."
- vidarh 10y agoThere is a reason the "computer says no" sketches in Little Britain resonated with people.
- gambiting 10y ago>>“Customers making and receiving genuine transactions have absolutely nothing to fear,” a [Barclays] spokesperson says. the problem with this statement is exactly the same as with the "if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear" argument. What if you get flagged up as a terrorist in some database somewhere, because you sent an email to a friend from Iran that you met at uni? Suddenly, your entire life is turned upside down, and there's no easy way to fix it. But hey, if you have nothing to hide, you wouldn't have this problem, right??? /s
- popol12 10y agoOne more reason to use Bitcoin.
- kefka 10y agoyeah, because we can introduce a max cap of 5 transactions/second. Sounds like a great idea :/ Bitcoin isn't the answer. Sane banks with good laws, however are.
- dest 10y agoTo be fair, the max cap of btc transactions may not last forever, with off-chain or alt-chain transactions. Of course sane banks with good laws are desirable. But bitcoin can be seen as a way to put pressure on the regulating entities, so that the laws are designed with more protections for the citizen.
- dnautics 10y agodid you not notice how this 'good law' suddenly became racist?
- Ensorceled 10y agoIt's not racist, it's nationalist. I'm sure it's not flagging Japanese because they come from a low crime country despite they're being of non Northern European descent. Not necessarily defending it, but please name the bigotry correctly.
- pjc50 10y agoThat enables you to lose the £440k instantly and with no recourse instead.
- elcct 10y agoYeah, if you freeze your own wallet somehow :)
- 10y ago
- muse900 10y agoI personally think he should seek with his solicitor if there is a way to claim that the bank withhold his legally acquired money for 3 months and have them pay way more than the around £9k they are trying to get away with. Barclays is bad with legalities I had issues with them in the past but I guess every bank is... They asked me to come in and proof my address while I have an account with them for over 10 years, money comes in and out every month from my employer, I got a credit card with them as well etc etc and generally I bank with them for 10 years without ever doing anything suspicious... I found it very odd that they asked me to go in and verify me address after that long... then I read online they've done it to many others including a guy working as a bank manager with them.
- krona 10y agoI know people who have had the same experience (e.g. having to prove their identity on multiple occasions.) Mentioning the words "Bob Diamond" seemed to be the most efficient way to resolve the issue.
- muse900 10y agoI personally think he should seek with his solicitor if there is a way to claim that the bank withhold his legally acquired money for 3 months and have them pay way more than the around £9k they are trying to get away with. Barclays is bad with legalities I had issues with them in the past but I guess every bank is... They asked me to come in and proof my address while I have an account with them for over 10 years, money comes in and out every month from my employer, I got a credit card with them as well etc etc and generally I bank with them for 10 years without ever doing anything suspicious... I found it very odd that they asked me to go in and verify me address after that long... then I read online they've done it to many others including a guy working as a bank manager with them.
- rlpb 10y ago> ...if criminal behaviour is suspected, facilities can be legally withdrawn. This is unacceptable. The UK government has pushed all the risk to the bank, and this quasi-legal removal of the rule of law with respect to citizens having control of their own money is the result. It should not be legal for the bank to withdraw access to funds for an extended period of time without a criminal standard of evidence.
- Silhouette 10y agoIndeed. I think it would be helpful if our society could have some forum that would make an officially recognised determination of whether someone suspected of criminal activity had actually committed those criminal acts, based on the available evidence either way, on a case by case basis. That same forum would also be well placed to determine any temporary measures that were necessary and proportionate to protect the interests of all concerned until it reached its final decision. I don't think commercial service providers are likely to be a good choice for that forum, though. We should probably consider something else.
- retube 10y agoIt's a direct result of the regulatory and reputational risks that banks now face. Threatened with multi-billion dollar fines for facilitating money laundering they're not taking any chances.
- rlpb 10y agoSure. What I'm saying is that the bank should also face consequential damages when they suspend an account for an extended period of time without a criminal standard of proof. This will help redress the balance. Instead of them "not taking any chances", they will be forced to consider the situation and make a real determination.
- zigzigzag 10y agoAnti-money laundering laws explicitly do not require a criminal standard of proof. This is by design - governments and in particular the US government which insists on all this stuff regardless of what other countries thing absolutely love a system that fights crime, as they see it, without all the hassle of due process and court cases. AML account closures only require 'suspicion', for example, a name match against a blacklist compiled by a government agency is 'suspicious' even if it wouldn't hold up in a traditional court of law.
- samdoidge 10y agoThis is why I believe Bitcoin can succeed.
- 019801200 10y agoIf Bitcoin succeeds, out totalitarian governments will find a way to control it. There is no longer any banking secrecy, no telephone secrecy, and there won't be computing secrecy if the civil servant parasites fear that their pensions are at stake.
- elcct 10y agoIn order for socialism to work, it needs access to every bit of money a worker earns so the part of it can be successfully redistributed. Because countries that implement socialism sooner or later will run out of money (as socialism by its nature is not sustainable), they will go to enormous lengths to discover any funds that are not declared and can be redistributed. Some countries are so desperate they want to stop using the cash at all. Humanity will always find solution to the oppression, one is the Bitcoin.
- crististm 10y agoAnalogy. This is a problem in telecommunications as well. You broadcast a strong signal and foreign stations pick up your message. A solution is to use spread-spectrum and go below the margin of spectral noise. In this case, random, small transactions much less than the threshold for scrutiny.
- zb 10y agoNote that, unlike anything the guy in the article did, what you're suggesting actually is illegal. He at least got his money back eventually because he was demonstrably 100% above-board. If you get caught structuring transactions to avoid scrutiny - and your strategy is probably not nearly as sophisticated as you think - then you will not be so lucky. Do not try this.
- devoply 10y agoThat my friend is called factoring, and that too is illegal and they have algos to detect that as well.
- arca_vorago 10y agoA few years ago a few researchers started using math to map inter-corporate board ties and ownership structures and came out with the conclusion that there were 147 mega corporations with more power than imagined. At the top of that list, was Barclay's. When you are that powerful, with that much money, consequences essentially don't exist. Welcome to the future, neo feudal corporate oligarchy.
- Neliquat 10y agoLink/Source?
- arca_vorago 10y agohttps://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1107/1107.5728v2.pdf https://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1107/1107.5728v2.pdf
- tomxor 10y agoThis isn't just the government changing laws... Barclays has recently shown a very blasé attitude towards closing accounts. I was a victim of this: Being an existing customer for many years, I opened a shared account with my partner for paying bills etc. It's used for very specific purpose, with regular payments in and out and a stable balance. never more than 2k. After a few months with the account Barclays sent us a letter notifying us that they will be closing the account due to us ignoring multiple requests for proof of identity (we never received any, and also needed to give this to open the account in the first place a few months ago anyway). The letter ended with "we will not be able to offer you any services in the future"... In branch - no explanation, they told us we can only continue to hold the account if we provide identity (again) and gave no explanation as to the "final" nature of the letter or what prompted it. This is what happens when you automate account management and just plug some new rules in without thinking... Roll on bitcoin for utility companies.
- xbmcuser 10y agoWow this is bullshit government doesn't want you to use cash but then if you keep your money in a bank the bank is allowed to take it.
- chaz6 10y agoPrecisely, if your money is in a bank, the government controls it. We need to bring back the gold standard ASAP.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoIn the US a while ago Citibank had a promotion that required signing up for a new account and depositing $15,000. So I did. My account was then frozen for "suspicious activity" due to a "large transfer into a new account" until I called them. Luckily a phone call was enough for them to unfreeze my account. I just found it so odd to consider doing a promotional requirement as suspicious... and I didn't know how long they could just keep my funds frozen like that. Seemed sketchy. What if I had checks that needed to clear?
- id122015 10y agoSo first he received £500000 in compensation benefits, and now he receives yet more £8000 as compensation for compensation.
- jackskell 10y agoI've been discussing basic cash solvency with my small circle of influence for years. My credibility went up with the folks when I had to wire thousands of dollars to them when they were vacationing in Europe. And, if I were in this man's situation, my second stop would have been the local FBI office to report bank theft. ACTUAL bank theft.