11 ms·
The spreading of misinformation online (2015)
- superfad 10y ago> Digital misinformation has become so pervasive in online social media that it has been listed by the WEF as one of the main threats to human society. It might be a good time to bring back critical thinking to the education curriculum. I see that as the only real solution. It would be interesting to know how the spread of this misinformation differs from other types of regular news.
- loafa 10y ago> It might be a good time to bring back critical thinking to the education curriculum. I see that as the only real solution Contrary to the popular view, I don't think people in general lack critical thinking skills. When confronted with something that they don't want to believe, even the dullest and least educated among us are great at finding every single flaw in the argument. It's only when they're confronted with something that they want to believe that these skills fall apart. What people are bad at is not critical thinking skills, but critical thinking discipline. It takes real discipline to apply the same standards to everything whether you want to believe it or not, and I don't know many people who are up to it. Unfortunately like most virtues it's not something easily taught.
- rustynails 10y agoIt appears to be deeper than that. I'll try to illustrate using a modern example. In Australia, the media (and the overwhelming majority of feminists) refuse to acknowledge that Donestic Violence has female perpetrators or male victims. Mission Australia (a large charity organisation) even ran a smear campaign saying that men refuse to acknowlege it happens (a sleight of hand to redirect focus back on males). Some feminists even argued that domestic (of the home) violence only refers to female victims (I found that gem on ANC news). It even got worse when channel 9 and 1800 respect (a government department) took an aggressive gender based campaign that explicitly put the blame on young boys. "It's a boy thing" was one of the charming lines in the ads that saturated print time TV in 2016. Not one single feminist (not one that I could find) raised a single objection against any of this, despite it being a fundamental breach of human rights. In case you are wondering, the Australian Bureau of Statistics identified that 1 in 3 victims of domestic violence in New South Wales (our largest state) was male. These statistics are totally ignored by government, the media and feminism. You will see similar trends worldwide. For example, the majority of feminists in the U.K. Refuse to acknowledge many women were voting well before many men were and that women were running successful businesses long before they supposedly were according to the modern media (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/womens-politics/9933592/Women-voted-75-years-before-they-were-legally-allowed-to-in-1918.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/womens-politics/9933592/Wom...). This doesn't come down to critical discipline, it comes down to blatant pathological lying and bullying on a mass scale. Places like The Verge (among many media outlets) have embraced and driven this prejudice. The media is extremely manipulative. The bullying of little boys today by most media outlets and many businesses blows my mind. I can't imagine any period in the last 100 years has been so committed to such extreme sexism. Even educational material like Horrible Histories has joined in on the gendered attacks. I'm not sure what to put this down to. I usually use terms like feminism and political correctness. However, it's also the apathy of most decent people. It's a collective social issue, not just of individuals. People desperately need to take a stand against feminism and political correctness. This goes beyond critical discipline. This is a collective social disease.
- empressplay 10y agoThe point here is _everyone_ has an agenda. _Everyone_. There are "no clean hands". _Never_ forget it. Learn to live around it.
- bergoid 10y ago> I'm not sure what to put this down to. I usually use terms like feminism and political correctness. This is sometimes called "cultural marxism". It is in my opinion the dominant ideology that permeates our thinking, our language and our behavior nowadays. That's why it is so hard to put our finger on it. We are like a group of goldfish discussing the concept of "water". Dr. Jordan Peterson of the University of Toronto does a great job at explaining how emancipation movements that were born with the best of intentions can transition gradually into tyranny. Though he uses just the word "marxism". http://www.c2cjournal.ca/2016/12/were-teaching-university-students-lies-an-interview-with-dr-jordan-peterson/ http://www.c2cjournal.ca/2016/12/were-teaching-university-st... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04wyGK6k6HE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04wyGK6k6HE Of course there's also the fable "Animal Farm" by George Orwell which masterfully describes the cycle of emancipation from tyranny to a new form of tyranny. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Farm
- bruceb 10y ago> I can't imagine any period in the last 100 years has been >so committed to such extreme sexism. I guess the fact women couldn't vote in a number of western countries in the early and mid part of last century or there were almost no women in charge corporations or govt power until the last 30 years (with a very few exceptions) doesn't qualify as extreme sexism? One can decry the overreach and excesses of some "social justice warriors" without going red pill extremist. Do some women commit domestic violence? of course. But how many men have killed women vs women who have killed men? Save the extremism for some outraged subreddit.
- oculusthrift 10y agoi disagree. when confronted with something they don't want to believe their arguments are usually laughable at best. I don't see the critical thinking used when saying global warming is fake because it's cold outside in january and that obama is a muslim.
- dhimes 10y agoHis point isn't contrary to yours, though. His point is that they have the skills to think critically when they want to, such as when their basic ideas are being challenged, but they don't have the discipline to do it then. I hadn't thought of this before. Yes, teach critical thinking in schools. But also teach the necessity of thinking critically about everything. Here's a personal example: I used to teach physics at a community college, and would on occasion have some very young (15, 16 yo) homeschooled kids in the classes. These kids were very bright of course (and also very disciplined about their work, which accounted for a lot of their success). But they were also very religious. Now mind you, although they were smart they were still children. Of course, metaphysical discussions would arise when discussing science and the origins of the universe (or biological things and what-not). My instructions/advice to the class on these issues was always: (1) You will be tested on knowing the theory, you are not required to believe it; and (2) what I hope that you take away from the class is being able to tell the difference between scientific evidence and faith. We all take some things on faith- just know when that is, in fact, what you are doing. I think this message (perhaps better articulated) needs to be spread far and wide today.
- oculusthrift 10y agoI'm saying I don't see any clear indication that they have the skills, whether or not they apply them.
- tiagoafpereira 10y agoNo only critical thinking (which is paramount) but also make sure that we are able to create an adult society. The current POTUS choice shows the very real danger of electing a petulant teenager for the highest position in the governance of the United States of America. If a nation of soft minded people is given such a person as the example to follow and emulate you can rest assured that nothing good will come out of it
- atmosx 10y ago> It would be interesting to know how the spread of this misinformation differs from other types of regular news. That is the root of the problem: It does NOT[1]. Lying[2] is the core business of most respected media outlets. [1] The Deep State Goes to War With President-Elect, Using Unverified Claims, as Democrats Cheer: https://theintercept.com/2017/01/11/the-deep-state-goes-to-war-with-president-elect-using-unverified-claims-as-dems-cheer/ https://theintercept.com/2017/01/11/the-deep-state-goes-to-w... [2] A lie doesn't have to preposterous, e.g. "the Pope is routing for Trump!". Distorting reality, not revealing facts, etc. are all lies in the sense that the author in order to drive a point, actively distorts/hides/ignores facts. We're not talking regular people, we're talking professional journalists who are taught how to cover and approach a subject to minimise distortion effects.
- pg314 10y ago> That is the root of the problem: It does NOT[1]. Yes it does. There is a difference between saying there is an unverified report alleging kompromat on Trump and saying the pope supported Trump. The latter is categorically false, the former is simply a fact. Any critical reader can understand, just by reading the article, that the former are allegations which have not been verified. No such thing is possible with the latter without referring to other sources. Equating both is just muddling the discussion. > Lying[2] is the core business of most respected media outlets. You provide no justification for this bold statement. Just some hand-waving about distorting reality and hiding facts. By trying to spread this misinformation you are - possibly unwittingly - playing into the hand of those who would prefer the free, independent press to disappear.
- atmosx 10y ago> Any critical reader can understand, just by reading the article, that the former are allegations which have not been verified. So let me get this straight: The critical reader should understand that the Washington Post, the US gov, the Economist, Bill Maher[1] (political satirist on HBO) and MANY others, have taken an allegation and build-up an entire case as if it were true BUT somehow when fake news are pro-Trump the critical reader's IQ falls bellow temperature level and he doesn't understand that it's extremely unlikely that the Pope would actively routes towards one candidate over another, for whatever reason? I'm sorry, I'm having hard making sense. > You provide no justification for this bold statement. Just some hand-waving about distorting reality and hiding facts. By trying to spread this misinformation you are - possibly unwittingly - playing into the hand of those who would prefer the free, independent press to disappear. Did you read the linked article? Here's the summary: THERE IS A real danger here that this maneuver could harshly backfire, to the great benefit of Trump and to the great detriment of those who want to oppose him. If any of the significant claims in this “dossier” turn out to be provably false — such as Cohen’s trip to Prague — many people will conclude, with Trump’s encouragement, that large media outlets (CNN and BuzzFeed) and anti-Trump factions inside the government (CIA) are deploying “Fake News” to destroy him. In the eyes of many people, that will forever discredit — render impotent — future journalistic exposés that are based on actual, corroborated wrongdoing. Respect for free media, yes, absolute respect. Respect for propaganda or fake news from either side? No. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmIS1y0cUv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmIS1y0cUv0
- kneel 10y agoI really take issue with these kinds of articles. Misinformation, fake news, propaganda all pretty much the same thing and they've all been around for a long time. Our media is a reflection of who we are. Confused, misled, naive and easily persuaded. Suspension of disbelief happens to even the smartest cookies, no one escapes. Until a automatic reliable semantic fact checker comes along with 99% accuracy we're all in this swirling pile of garbage together.
- singingfish 10y agobah, you're right it's been going on for a long time. I would imagine the rate of information delivery (or even the potential rate), which for much of the population has increased exponentially in recent years along with the increased ability to form clusters at a greater rate might have an effect on this. It's an interesting research question not worthy of instant dismissal ;P
- csydas 10y agoI think the largest difference is just the volume of readily available information to support just about any point you want to make. The power of authoritative sources has eroded greatly as the increased access to information means you can argue about any point you wish and odds are there will be something online that supports your point of view - the reliability of said source of course will vary greatly, but that is irrelevant. Information access has improved and is now easier for people - this is wonderful. But this also comes with the fact that now we have far more information to process and more sources to keep discussions and arguments going far longer than they used to be. This isn't necessarily bad, but it also means that people are going to naturally be able to get more stubborn in the face of contrary evidence. News also has the ability to propagate far differently than it used to, and it has a much larger social stigma attached to it. Shares, likes, retweets, these are subtle but important influencers that news of the past didn't really have, and it's a lot easier to get someone to believe something if 20,000 other people seem to think it's kosher, especially if 20+ of those people are your close friends. I get what you're saying at it's core - this stuff has always existed, but our exposure to it, our ability to affirm our own beliefs and biases, and social pressure have basically shot up the fake news with meth and steroids to create a new type of monster to deal with. A piece of fake news only takes a few minutes to reach potentially millions of readers, while a properly researched response or answer takes much longer. When you have people used to responses and articles on a timeline of days or weeks, it's a bit easier to get that sort of properly researched response out. When people are used to a response in seconds or minutes, by the time you have a proper response ready, people have already moved on to the next scandal and have committed the previous news to memory as fact. it's the same material, but it's processed far differently than it used to be.
- pfd1986 10y ago"Our findings show that users mostly tend to select and share content according to a specific narrative and to ignore the rest. This suggests that the determinant for the formation of echo chambers is confirmation bias." No news there. I wonder, though, if science needs to fight back with better guns against confirmation bias.
- delegate 10y agoTo put it succinctly: most of the Internet exists due to advertising - which is - most of the time, misinformation and/or lies. Given the competition out there, you just have to misrepresent, overemphasise, paint in favourable light or use a good old lie to sell your product. We've long since accepted this as 'necessary evil' - everywhere - on TV, in print, on the streets and online. And so the 'mind-fucking' techniques have evolved over the decades - from 'facts' about products to emotional button-pressing voodoo, subliminal messages and click-baits. The doors to 'bullshit' are wide open in our minds, even though we think we can filter facts from crap, there are techniques that get us too. "The spread of misinformation" is not a new phenomena at all, in fact it's been here since before the dawn of the Internet. What changed is the object of bullshit, not the bullshit itself. In other words, "Enlarge your penis" is coming to your social network news article about your local politician and you won't believe it till you see it!
- coldtea 10y ago>To put it succinctly: most of the Internet exists due to advertising - which is - most of the time, misinformation and/or lies. Add to that social platforms like Facebook -- which make it easy to have few or none interactions outside your echo chamber of friends (and "unfollow" everybody that you disagree with). Those platforms' news feeds also want to keep you happy, so they show you the stuff you like to see (more stuff you agree with rather than less). They also want to keep you entertained, so more addictive and ever increasing stimulating titles and news, rather than more accurate ones. There's also the faulty idea that "revolution" or "awareness" will start with such misinformed people connecting through Twitter or similar (like the "Arab Spring" which ended just as a springboard for fundamentalists on one side, and western infatuated, unrepresentative of local sentiments, upper-middle/upper class people on the other -- the latter usually celebrated as bloggers "telling it from the ground" abroad). Unless people get a chance to discuss, read about and understand the issues in their society as they affect people from all walks of life, and especially the larger majority, the "social" aspect and "instant" communication don't help them, if it doesn't actively distract them.
- baq 10y agodisagree on >What changed is the object of bullshit, not the bullshit itself. (edit: after rereading, not sure i disagree anymore :)) due to removing of barriers to communication it's much much much easier to find people susceptible to bullshit than it used to and they even help spread the bullshit further which is what the article tries to analyze. in the limit you have results like brexit which are real decisions enabled by mostly bullshit assumptions. turns out truly free speech combined with democracy is a recipe for disaster. who would've though? /s china with it's total control over information and authoritarian government has much better chances of surviving the inevitable collapse of society that is the result of not having trustworthy elites.
- fareesh 10y agoThe internet essentially turned news into a free market commodity. The Editor has been replaced with the Eigenvector in that good ol' recommendation algorithm everyone uses (I assume some variation of PageRank), to infer what's most relevant to the current user. By virtue of this alone, an echo chamber is being packaged and delivered to users on content platforms. The seemingly insurmountable problem is to get people to consume content that challenges their preconceptions, as opposed to having them validated repeatedly in exchange for a dopamine hit.
- baq 10y ago> The seemingly insurmountable problem is to get people to consume content that challenges their preconceptions, as opposed to having them validated repeatedly in exchange for a dopamine hit. very well put, sir. people are addicted to information that confirms their beliefs. very good observation indeed. well played, mr zuckerberg, well played.
- PaulKeeble 10y agoCCP Greys discussion about thought germs is extremely interesting look on how and why misinformation spreads. I much less rigirous look at the topic but very accessible. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc
- EJTH 10y agoEverybody spreads misinformation. Most notoriously the established media. Just take a look at the newest rape case in sweden, where the perbs live streamed the whole ordeal on facebook. All media headlines are "Swedish men rapes woman live on facebook", if you saw a screendump from the video there is no doubt that the men are not "swedish men", and eventhough the video and screendumps are very easy to find, not a single media outlet (besides the "alternative" ones) have actually posted screenshots from the event.
- lomnakkus 10y ago> if you saw a screendump from the video there is no doubt that the men are not "swedish men" How does that work? How exactly can you tell if someone is Swedish just by looking at them? (Hint: You can't.)
- loafa 10y agoI assume EJTH meant genetically Swedish, not Swedish by citizenship.
- K0nserv 10y agoMost of the Swedish media explicitly takes the stance that they don't report based on ethnicity of alleged criminals.
- EJTH 10y agoI encourage you to see the video for yourselves, and then proclaim again that these perbs are swedish. I am even fairly sure that if you asked these people wether they identified as swedish they would decline.
- EJTH 10y agoMaybe you should just have answered the TSA's offensive questions? Sure beats having to live without your digital goodies.
- ideonexus 10y agoI appreciate the methodology of this study, especially using science news posts as the comparison against conspiracy and troll posts. I make it a point to remain friends with people who post conspiracy theories online, but I've long ago given up trying to engage them in meaningful dialogue. I simply find myself spinning and spinning in their circular rationalizations. Instead, I try to share posts from HN and science news sites. This means that I am setting the topic and the tone. It also makes my identity and culture as a nerd public. In my extremely diverse network of online friends, this means I am ever so gently prodding the overall culture in that direction. I think in a war of ideas, we have to make sure our empirically-supported fact-based beliefs need to be put out there in order to compete. We are playing a long-game here to influence our culture, and I believe that the majority of people will see over the long term the benefits of empiricism and healthy skepticism compared to the chaos and emotionalism of the conspiracy theorists and dogmatists.
- baq 10y ago> Instead, I try to share posts from HN and science news sites. if you share on facebook, the feed algorithm probably hides it from them, which makes the problem worse. echo chambers are profitable in the same sense being a drug dealer is profitable: you come for a fix that makes you feel good.
- ideonexus 10y agoIt has been my experience that my science posts get far fewer likes (and I assume fewer views) than the political posts my friends make.
- empath75 10y agoI think the reality of the situation is that the 'consensus reality' as agreed up in the west wasn't decided upon by a bunch of intellectuals in ivory towers carefully considering available facts and using logic to derive universal truths. It was decided in a paroxysm of violence that engulfed the entire world and led to the deaths of millions of people, and left us on the brink of nuclear annihilation. The liberal world order that Putin and Trump are in the middle of tearing apart was not stable, and now we're in a period like the 1840s or the interwar period where all of the questions that everyone had thought had been settled no longer seem as though they are, and there's really nobody left alive who remembers the cost of solving problems like this with bullets and bombs. So we're going to do it again. It's going to be a rough few years coming up.
- EekSnakePond 10y agoThe early internet couldn't verify identity. Thus, if someone said they were "18/f" we assumed they were 44/m. If they said anything younger than that, we assumed FBI. Everyone was bullshitting everyone because identity could not be proven. 56.6kb wasn't enough for rich media lifestreaming culture. It was only text and the occasional person who owned a scanner. You could call this version of the internet a Derrida paradise. As internet speeds became better, identity still couldn't be proven, but it could take on characteristics that were more natural for our senses: faces, motions, and sound. Compared to pure text identification, this development is quite the relief for minds used to living in such identity paranoia. Social media companies piggybacked off of this relief and built entire networks which incentivized positive identification, which was the core for the ad tech revolution. But, the problem with positive identity is that you will attract the very old, very battle-tested, and very entrenched wolves who know how to hack identity: the politicians, the social sciences, the charlatans, the trolls, mass media agents, the psyop engineers, the alphabets, and the rest of the industries who profit from poisoning the well of identity. And now, here we are, accusing each other of engaging in genocidal racism because we've turned pixels into the inputs of a Skinner box of ideological signaling.