8 ms·
Foxconn Weighs $7B U.S. Display Plant
- cobookman 10y agoI wonder what Trump's concessions would be for this plant. He criticized apple directly in his campaign, and this plant would be a big win for him.
- astrodust 10y agoIf it's anything like the Carrier "deal" he'd throw them bags of cash to create a handful of jobs.
- adventured 10y agoYour information is wrong. Carrier didn't get bags of cash to create a handful of jobs. It's a thousand jobs at an average of $31 per hour in wages, not to mention benefits. It's up to $7m in incentives spanning ten years. The jobs are worth about $850 million to $1 billion in total compensation over ten years. The $7 million represents less than 1% of that value. The income taxes, sales taxes, local spending, etc, etc, etc. is worth drastically more to that community and the state than the tiny $700k per year incentive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- astrodust 10y agoIt's all smoke and bullshit. Hype up the "creation", completely ignore the general strategy of Carrier to shift jobs out of the country. Even Forbes thinks it's bullshit: http://www.forbes.com/sites/eriksherman/2016/12/04/trumps-carrier-deal-means-nothing-for-future-jobs/#32ac08394c7b http://www.forbes.com/sites/eriksherman/2016/12/04/trumps-ca...
- agildehaus 10y agoNot to mention Carrier plans to use the money to further automate the plant: http://www.newsmax.com/Finance/StreetTalk/united-tech-donald-trump-carrier-jobs/2016/12/07/id/762633/ http://www.newsmax.com/Finance/StreetTalk/united-tech-donald...
- stephancoral 10y agoYou have many incorrect points. Firt of all, it's much less than a thousand jobs if you discount the white collar managerial jobs that were never planned to be relocated. The number of overall jobs saved is around 800. Of those 800, a significant number of them will be eventually automated or are already in the works. So your ten year figure is, in my opinion, a bit overly optimistic. It was a symbolic show. Even if Trump did a Carrier-type deal every month for his entire presidency, it would be far less than one percent of jobs lost due to automation and offshoring in the past 20 years.
- norea-armozel 10y agoBut the same company is planning on automating away jobs in that plant and closing the Huntington one. So it's not 1-to-1 gains here. The reality is Carrier is placating an administration for larger contracts (parent company of Carrier).
- dmix 10y agoThat's a good question but it's not necessarily something Trump controls directly (nor should he), it is more likely up to the local government/state where the plant is located who could work on incentivizes. That's what happened with the Carrier deal in Indiana largely because that was Pence's state and he could help directly. This is how it happens in China too. The article mentions that a Chinese city would help invest $8.7 billion, rather than the central state. > On Dec. 30, Gou announced that Osaka-based subsidiary Sakai Display Products and the southern Chinese city of Guangzhou would jointly invest 61 billion yuan ($8.77 billion) in an advanced panel facility. And Pennsylvania trade office is working with Foxconn on another plant. > In addition to the proposed display facility, Gou said Foxconn plans a new molding facility in the U.S., with the state of Pennsylvania a possible site following investment discussions with local officials. A representative from the Pennsylvania trade office attended Foxconn's party Sunday. It's typically not the exec branches job to set up those deals. But it is great that Trump is willing to get on the phone to help get the deals done, that's seems unprecedented in recent years. Most likely Trump would be focusing on the trade policy more generally or working with congress to reduce federal regulations. The Dept of Commerce could help promote the idea of operating in America. As well as via the Treasury Dept to simplify the tax code. And Congress to reduce taxation. Again this would apply to all companies, or whole industries, and (most likely) not give any individual companies special benefits in return for opening up shop.
- blackguardx 10y agoI think we need "free trade zones" like they have in some asian countries. If you have a mfg business in the zone, you pay zero or reduced taxes on your produced goods and inventory. Maybe throw in some subsides to help comply with regulations as well. These zones can be spread all throughout the country in economically depressed regions. These programs should be open to all companies, not just the Teslas and tbe Apples of the world. Governors and Presidents should not intervene on behalf of a single company. That isn't capitalism.
- dmix 10y agoI'm more in favor of a federalist approach instead of specialized city states. Basically less federal oversight and more state oversight (besides maybe environmental stuff which crosses state lines, or give money to other states based on your carbon output). That way if you want to live in a euro-style social services high tax area you can move to Washington. Or if you want mixed go to New York. Market oriented people can go to Texas - for example. States can set up voluntary cross border zones so the regulations and taxation is more consistent for industries that are more disparate. Cross state trade wouldn't be regulated and federal law can focused on national security, foreign trade, currency, and tax collection. That way if something does work better (like ending the drug war) in one state, there will be a ton of data to reference and eventually good ideas will be adopted by other states. States like California are big enough to be their own small countries anyway. This was basically the idea when the US was founded but the federal government has only grown and every 4yrs the presidency becomes more important and given responsibility for everything. So no wonder the exec branch is growing in power - the citizens keep expecting them to be responsible for everything. It'd also protect against Donald Trump's from happening, the whims of one man should never be so influential.
- justavoice 10y agoHe could work to give Apple a better deal repatriating their cash horde. But the 10% tax he offered up during his campaign seems more than reasonable.
- yabatopia 10y agoOr you could wonder how the Chinese government would react to Foxconn's intentions to open a factory in the US, and not in China. Foxconn gets lots of concessions from the Chinese government. It's easy for Beijing to twist Foxconn's arm a little bit, just enough to reconsider a US investment. Or maybe they will allow it as some kind of sop to the Trump administration.
- brianshaler 10y ago> questioning whether U.S. consumers will be willing to pay much higher prices for equipment of equal quality There's also the threat of substantially increased tariffs that could make a panel manufactured by a <$3/hour worker cost as much or more than a panel manufactured by a >$10/hour American worker.
- Nokinside 10y agoAnd by manufacturing essential parts exclusively in US where costs are higher, Apple would turn it's back to Chinese and Asian markets, essentially cutting it's growth potential.
- Eridrus 10y agoBoth of those indicate an increase in price though, which may dampen demand.
- codeddesign 10y agoJust keep in mind that you will not find $10 workers in a mass factory setting. After you bring in labor unions + healthcare + workers comp + misc. addionals, it easily brings u.s based factory workers to $18+. This does not include the fact that you have to train people and have a plethora of workers to support this (hr, trainers, etc.) While everyone in the U.S. I think would agree that securing jobs for Americans would be great, you just can't bend the math enough to make it economical.
- bsder 10y ago> While everyone in the U.S. I think would agree that securing jobs for Americans would be great, you just can't bend the math enough to make it economical. Why? Everything in that plant is going to be automated anyway. Quoting a number of jobs at "30,000" is laughable. The only reason Foxconn would employ 30,000 people is because labor is so pathetically cheap in China. In reality, they will probably employ 300-500 so there is zero reason why they couldn't pay $18+ per hour. The idea that Foxconn would be automated less than a steel mill is absurd: http://triblive.com/business/headlines/9409484-74/ati-workers-mill http://triblive.com/business/headlines/9409484-74/ati-worker... "Only 32 workers are needed to operate Allegheny Technologies Inc.'s new $1.2 billion hot-rolling mill in Harrison, company officials say." I am all for Foxconn having a plant here. We need to pull some of the semiconductor and electronics manufacturing back to the US for many reasons (keeping the knowledge, lower transport costs, quicker turnaround, etc.). Unfortunately, large numbers of jobs really isn't one of reasons.
- funkyy 10y agoI do not understand why such a company would not go for central European company where it would get the price for quality ratio much better than in the US. I know that building a factory by Foxconn is probably a way to pay building tax, but the question is if that outweighs revenue.
- saycheese 10y ago(1) >> "rising demand for larger displays makes domestic U.S. production a better solution than shipping from China" Europe would likely cost more than less for shipping. (2) >> "may create an eventual 30,000 to 50,000 jobs" Apple is a US company and likely trying to earn some goodwill with Trumps and the public. Foxconn is also looking for good will and to hedge against a possible trade war. (3) >> "Apple is willing to invest in the facility together" Speaks for itself.
- many_bells_down 10y agoCentral Europe, unlike central America, does not have Trump as its champion.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoIs Trump popular in Central America? I thought his whole anti Mexico spiel would make him very unpopular.
- funkyy 10y agoIt's sad that YN gets extremely political lately. "Trump" is a bad word here lately...
- Girlang 10y agoHuh?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Cyph0n 10y ago
- Nokinside 10y agoLink to orginal, more complete article: http://asia.nikkei.com/Business/AC/Foxconn-considers-7bn-US-display-facility-with-Apple?page=2 http://asia.nikkei.com/Business/AC/Foxconn-considers-7bn-US-... >"In the future they may be paying some $500 more for [U.S.] products, but those do not necessarily work better than a $300 phone," he said, after urging U.S. authorities to provide concessions on land and electricity to facilitate Foxconn's manufacturing operations. >Despite such U.S. investment, China remains a key market and the primary manufacturing base for Apple and Foxconn, and neither company is leaving anytime soon. >"Yes, we will continue to add to our investments in China," Gou told reporters. "China is the world's biggest market, and why should we turn down the biggest market?" >Meanwhile, although Apple's sales in the greater China region declined 30% year-on-year through the end of the September quarter, chief executive Tim Cook remained optimistic about the Chinese market. This is another piece in the puzzle. For Apple, defending North American market is essential. Starting manufacturing in US might be admitting that it has lost Chinese and Asian markets. Is China the biggest market as Gou told? For many consumer products and electronics China is the biggest or becoming the biggest market. Surprisingly many products are released first China only. http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/14/news/economy/china-middle-class-growing/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/14/news/economy/china-middle-cl... >China's middle class is now the biggest in the world, and growing much faster than America's, according to research by Credit Suisse. There are 109 million Chinese with wealth of between $50,000 and $500,000.
- ec109685 10y agoWhy do you think they would exclusively manufacture components in the US?
- saretired 10y agoTaiwanese companies such as Foxconn with extensive operations on the mainland may be particularly vulnerable if the Trump government insists on making the one China policy a bargaining chip in trade negotiations. We’ll see how it all plays out, but the worst case would obviously impact Apple and a few other US tech companies.
- dmix 10y agoThe original article is much more informative. Note is has multiple pages. http://asia.nikkei.com/Business/AC/Foxconn-considers-7bn-US-display-facility-with-Apple http://asia.nikkei.com/Business/AC/Foxconn-considers-7bn-US-...
- dilemma 10y agoThe purchasing power arbitrage is disappearing as Chinese wages increase, the yuan appreciates, and real American wages stagnate or decrease together with the dollar. I think this, along with augmented production systems requiring fewer workers, is why this factory is being contemplated.
- adventured 10y agoReal American wages increase with the dollar, not decrease. The dollar climb has boosted American purchasing power dramatically. That is especially important for a nation that imports as much as the US does. Americans can buy more with their wages than they could prior to the dollar climb. That covers nearly every economy the US imports from, as the dollar has gained against essentially every currency on the planet. Simultaneously, real wage growth has been outpacing inflation for years now and is set to continue to climb at an accelerating pace due to a dramatic decrease in labor slack in the last five years.
- DrScump 10y agoReal American wages increase with the dollar I don't follow. I can see how the wage earners' buying power for imports improves with the dollar's rise against corresponding foreign currencies, but not a generalized wage increase.
- pyromine 10y agoIn general, an increasing dollar does not have effects on the real price of domestic goods, but decreases the real price of imports. Because that is no change and increased purchasing, it results in a real increase in purchasing power which is therefore an increase in real wages. You can buy a larger basket of goods because the imports cost less.
- throwaway40483 10y agoA strong dollar also reduces export, so how does this pan out net-net?
- theptip 10y agoThis might be a good prize to offer Trump in exchange for allowing Apple's untaxed offshore profits to be repatriated at a discount rate.
- caseysoftware 10y agoI think this part is the key. They have $billions sitting in Ireland and elsewhere that they can't invest in US-based operations. If they could bring that back in under some sort of deal, that could mean massive investments, acquisitions, R&D, dividends, and a variety of other things I'm not qualified to guess.
- tootie 10y agoFoxconn is building it, not Apple. If Trump wants to encourage it, he's going to have to back all his anti-trade policy with China.
- theptip 10y agoThe first words of the article are > Foxconn Technology Group Chairman Terry Gou told reporters in Taipei the company is considering a joint investment with Apple Inc. for a display manufacturing facility in the U.S. I think that provides enough of a kernel of truthiness for Trump to declare "Apple is building a $7b factory, it's going to be yuge!".
- wycx 10y agoRemember that Foxconn is from Taiwan, not PRC.
- imron 10y agoIsn't he already going to be doing that? The discounted rate will be 10% compared to the current 35%, but for all companies not just Apple. https://www.ft.com/content/c715e806-a66e-11e6-8b69-02899e8bd9d1 https://www.ft.com/content/c715e806-a66e-11e6-8b69-02899e8bd...
- siculars 10y agoBut, uh, I thought manufacturing jobs were never coming back stateside. So strange...
- photogrammetry 10y agoGarbage comment.
- geomark 10y agoMaybe most of the jobs in the factory will be performed by robots and not humans.
- jfoutz 10y agoAlso, why ship the panels half way around the world for assembly? Part of China's glory is having manufacturing for everything close by.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- snarfy 10y agoHow long before those jobs are done by robots? https://www.engadget.com/2016/05/25/foxconn-replaces-60000-humans-workers-with-robots/ https://www.engadget.com/2016/05/25/foxconn-replaces-60000-h...
- norea-armozel 10y agoThis part of the article I find amusing: Gou told reporters according to Reuters. “There is such a plan, but it is not a promise. It is a wish.” So much for Trump's claim that the 50 billion investment is a guarantee. This is why I despise anyone who aids him in making up stuff. It gives false hope when we need to buckle down and realign our economy and government.
- delluminatus 10y agoAccording to the article, this plant would employ 30k-50k people. The secondary effects of these jobs would be equally massive. While I would prefer an American company operating the plant, merely employing this many people would be a serious boon.
- woodandsteel 10y agoBut Foxcon is pushing very hard on replacing most of its workers with robots. The numbers will probably be more like 3k-5K, not 30k-50k. And they will be high-tech jobs that most of those millions of unemployed factory workers in our country couldn't qualify for.