5 ms·
These stories have been around forever. Customs officials in all countries have broad latitude to inspect incoming passengers and baggage. Fucking around with
by Spooky23 10y ago
These stories have been around forever.
Customs officials in all countries have broad latitude to inspect incoming passengers and baggage. Fucking around with them and refusing to answer or evading questions is franking a stupid strategy.
What has changed is that there is more inspections and more theatre. They are more consistent(-ly awful) everywhere, including sleepy Canadian broader crossings.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoAre you saying doing everything they say is the better strategy. I worry that likely leads to a world with less liberty.
- krastanov 10y agoThere is a big difference between upholding your rights of privacy while being respectful to the border agents and while being a smart-Aleck. You do not have to do everything they say, but you can stand your ground without trying to antagonize them unnecessarily.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoNot really. There is no right to privacy at the U.S. border, so any "upholding" or "stand your ground" is, actually, being a smart aleck / unnecessary antagonization.
- krastanov 10y agoDo you not see the difference between being polite and being obnoxious when you decline the search of a device in your possession? Indeed, the border agents can refuse to let you enter the country either way, but the probability of that happening would probably differ in the two cases.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoNo, I don't see the difference, because people crossing the U.S. border simply don't have any right to decline searches: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- krastanov 10y agoYou can decline the search in which case they can decline to let you in the country. The EFF FAQ has more details.
- tacostakohashi 10y agoInteresting - I don't suppose you have a link to relevant part of this FAQ?
- krastanov 10y agoSorry, I was on mobile when writing the previous comment. Here is the lengthy document I remember: https://www.eff.org/document/defending-privacy-us-border-guide-travelers-carrying-digital-devices https://www.eff.org/document/defending-privacy-us-border-gui... They can demand a password from you, you can refuse to give it, and they can then decide not to let you in the country. Being polite and respectful in your refusal to share an encryption key can mean less trouble. A point that might have caused confusion: they can seize your device. The document does not specify what happens if you decline to give the device (as in whether you are arrested or simply declined entry to the country). As far as I understand the references, courts have not had to decide on this question yet.
- Spooky23 10y agoCustoms is different than dealing with the police. There is no liberty at any border.
- oneplane 10y agoIt's not that, it's more that you want to get in and you have to make sure they don't have a reason to say no. They have something you want (access) and you don't have anything they'd want to grant that. So as soon as you make it hard you're bound to have trouble.
- DennisP 10y agoIt's illegal for them to deny entry to U.S. citizens.
- gexcolo 10y agoI'm the author of OP's post. Can you provide me more information about this? I've always wondered if that was the case, but I was once given a lengthy interview in the Amsterdam airport on my way to DEFCON last year, which gave the opposite impression.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 10y agoIf you are a US citizen, US immigration cannot legally refuse you entry. They can make your life miserable (via private questioning, etc.), and US CBP can also make your life miserable (going through all your stuff, questioning you at length, etc.), but they are legally required to allow you into the US if you are a citizen. If they can pin something illegal on you, they can of course detain you and refer you to local or federal authorities, but they must (as a part of that) allow you back into the country. They can't force you to stay in the international zone at the airport, and can't send you to another country. Now, this only applies to US citizens returning to the US. A US citizen arriving, for example, at Amsterdam, can certainly be turned away for any reason whatsoever.
- gexcolo 10y agoThanks for this information. In my example, I was departing Amsterdam for the U.S.
- dboreham 10y agoI cross the US/Canadian border in such a sleepy location once or twice every year. My experience is that the Canadian officials are professional and friendly whereas the US officers are sarcastic assholes. Note: I am a white US citizen.
- jskopek 10y agoFunnily enough, I tend to get the opposite reaction. Have has some pretty miserable treatment from Canadian border guards at the Peace Arch crossing, but never the same from their American counterparts. I'm Canadian. Of course, this might just be luck of the draw.
- refurb 10y agoSame here, Canadian citizen as well. I've been absolutely grilled by the Canadians, but never by the US side.
- brianwawok 10y agoAmerican and Canadians grill me more. What is my wife's birthday? How many days are we staying? What day of the week are we leaving? American guard is like "do you have more than 5 bottles of wine you need to declare? No, cool"
- kahnpro 10y agoI've never been grilled by either. But the Americans always ask mor questions. Canadians are "welcome home", Americans usually ask a few standard questions to probe my reasons but nothing approaching a grilling. Just a light toasting. Contrast with Russian customs who looked at my passport and said "Canada? Okay go"
- kasey_junk 10y agoI've found it varies dramatically by crossing point. As an American driving across the border I frequently get lots of questions on either side. Flying it has been full grilling to basically nothing on either side. Flying into Toronto City airport I frequently just get a nod and hand wave.
- herbst 10y agoIve been all around the world and never got closer inspected. Given i never were in the U.S. mostly because i am afraid that they know me to well. But nearly all my friends had trouble in the airport when they were. You can not tell me this is normal