4 ms·
Arrington is clearly wrong. It's clear that nobody told him to copy paste the whole content, or gave him the permission. He just trolls now for more hits. But h
by acqq 17y ago
Arrington is clearly wrong. It's clear that nobody told him to copy paste the whole content, or gave him the permission.
He just trolls now for more hits.
But he'd just lose if he'd come to court.
- iron_ball 17y agoThey did say "post on" the excerpts instead of "post" the excerpts. That's a syntactic nicety which must have gone unnoticed by Arrington, but which was presumably clear in the mind of the Fortune rep.
- Lazlo_Nibble 17y agoThey also repeatedly refer to the excerpt(s) as "FORTUNE's exclusive". It's not an "exclusive excerpt" if TechCrunch is republishing it in its entirety, which makes it extremely unlikely that FORTUNE believed it was offering to let Arrington do so. And I find it really, really hard to believe that Arrington wouldn't have realized this before agreeing to anything.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe excerpts were Fortune's exclusive because they got to print them first and TechCrunch to post later, marking Fortune as the originators of the scoop.
- smallblacksun 17y agoThe Fortune PR person explicitly asked him to have his posts about the excepts put up at the same time as the actual excerpts on the Fortune site.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago>"There were rules, said Fortune. We had to prominently link to their articles printing the excerpts. And agree not to post _until_ they had posted their stuff." Until (my emphasis), means that they couldn't post simultaneously, nor before. I deduced then they were required to post after. There most have been a counter statement elsewhere given your upvotes, sorry I missed it, what was it?
- sjsivak 17y agoMaybe I misread the article, but it looks like the Fortune PR person never, ever states that TechCrunch is only supposed to post portions of the excerpts. This is the closest I could find: > And if you don’t mind, once you’ve read the excerpts, please let me know if you choose not to post on one and not the other or both, which of course we would love. Now, IANAL but nowhere in there does it say to not post the excerpts.
- devinj 17y agoCopyright is reserved unless explicitly given. That is, what you have said may be perfectly true, and Arrington could still be in the wrong. All they have to have done is to not give him explicit permission.
- jimbokun 17y agoAnd I'm surprised so many here seem to be getting this wrong. Copyright law is very important for anyone interested in the software business to understand.
- MichaelSalib 17y agoPractically speaking, he is not in the wrong at all. What exactly do you think Simon&Schuster can do, sue him? Can you imagine going up to a federal judge and seeking an injunction for infringement for a guy who posted excerpts of a book that were already online? What exactly are the damages?