14 ms·
San Francisco Asks: Where Have All the Children Gone?
- gruglife 10y agoOakland/Marin/south bay
- santaclaus 10y ago> Oakland I've lived in Oakland for almost a year and I can count on one hand the number of times I've seen a child older than an infant.
- Naritai 10y agoMuch more accurate to say Walnut Creek / Tri-Valley as far as the East bay goes.
- ubernostrum 10y agoI strongly suspect the answer to "do you see a lot of children around" depends heavily on neighborhood.
- stuckagain 10y agoWhat do you do, just walk back and forth between Temescal and Uptown? If you look at the actual numbers, 21% of Oaklanders are children and 25% of households include a child. http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/cities/Oakland.htm http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/cities/Oakland.htm
- stvswn 10y agoPeninsula? I live here with my two kids, it's full of kids. Burlingame, San Mateo, Belmont, San Carlos, redwood city, Menlo park all seem full of people who moved from the city when their oldest was ready for school.
- niftich 10y agoI wonder, where in particular does SF's children-to-family rate diverge from the national metrics? Are all races having fewer children in SF than nationally, or just some? Are all incomes having fewer children, or just some? Not that the overall stats aren't illustrative, but it's often enlightening to drill down. The 53,000 public schoolchildren, who are they demographically and socioeconomically, and how do they differ from, say, NYC, Chicago, LA?
- Naritai 10y agoThe article alludes to an important point - it never quite asserts that anybody is having fewer children. Instead, when people decide to have children, they move to a suburb.
- _dark_matter_ 10y agoShouldn't the schools in SF be incredible? I mean with the skyrocketing costs of residences intersected with the hugely decreased student populations, $/pupil should be higher than ever. Seems like a great place to start to draw families back into the city.
- dragonwriter 10y ago$/pupil in public school operating costs is mandated to be equal across the state; local tax base may make more money available for capital improvements, but doesn't make any more available for classroom operations (even to keep pay of faculty and staff in line with living costs.)
- _dark_matter_ 10y agoThank you for the reply. While I understand the idea behind that law, it seems untenable for a teacher in SF to be making the same as a teacher in Bakersfield.
- JauntTrooper 10y agoSF children are also assigned a school via a lottery. Kids can't go to the school that's closest to them unless they get lucky. My co-worker was assigned a school with a terrible commute, so he reluctantly chose a private school instead. I think it was done to improve racial/socioeconomic integration, but in practice it means wealthier parents withdraw from the system and send their kids to private schools instead. The results: 58% of SF public school students are on free/reduced-price lunches, higher than the national average. That means they're in families making $43k for a family of four (quite tough in SF). The racial impact is also striking. San Francisco is 42% white, but in 2013-2014, only 13% of SF public school students were white. That number is 9% for high schoolers.
- spullara 10y agoThis is exactly right. All the poorest kids get to go to a bad school far away. The rich kids go to a great school far away. One of the reasons that I wouldn't move back while my kids are in school.
- santaclaus 10y ago> The city has also invested millions in upgrading parks, according to Phil Ginsburg, the general manager of the city’s Recreation and Parks Department. I'm not sure infrastructure is the issue here. Bay area parks can be a bit, well, heavy on needles and doodoo.
- quanticle 10y agoThe main problem is the cost of housing. You can have the best parks. You can have the best schools. But when your city's median home price is seven figures and rising, it's not affordable for people to raise a family in your city.
- wyager 10y agoWealthy people raise families too. The GP is right, the problem is that SF parks are unsafe for children. Needles, human waste, etc. SF parks are very hard-hit by the homeless problem. I don't claim to know how to fix it, but I notice that many plausible solutions are struck down because, roughly speaking, they're not nice to the homeless people leaving shit and needles everywhere.
- pmiller2 10y agoBoth points are correct. Unsafe parks are bad, but wealthy people also tend to raise smaller families than less wealthy people.
- geebee 10y agoAs someone with two school aged kids in SF, I can say with some confidence that you are overstating this. I live south of 280, and I've gone to a ton of playgrounds around glen park, sunny side, mission terrace, and the sunset. Yes, there is a homeless presence in and near playgrounds, and some areas get pretty bad. But the hyperbole gets ridiculous. Seriously, you'd think you're dodging human shit and needles every third step in every corner of SF. I have spent a great deal of time in SF playgrounds over the last decade (in the aforementioned neighborhoods), and the playgrounds are very safe for children, and don't have shit and needles everyone.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lets-tryagain 10y agothe SF school lottery system is the primary culprit
- pccheck12117 10y agoOne should not discount the triumph of feminist ideology in this city, that contributed to this result.
- mdasen 10y agoFor me, it feels like the article could have been a lot shorter. "San Francisco housing prices have gone so high that people can't afford to have kids here." It never really delved into many of the underlying incentives and such. Yea, other locations might have some good draws like schools or a lack of fog. Yes, SF might have more LGBTQ folk. Neither of those are going to be a good explanation for the exodus. Ultimately, I'm not sure cities see this as a problem that needs solving (regardless of what public officials might say to a reporter). I live in a similarly expensive city. Schools are expensive and I have no kids so that's a win for the city. I have high income and can bid up property values which is a win for the city. The city is building a lot of office space which pays very high property taxes while using comparatively few city resources (compared to residential). The abundance of jobs drives property values even higher which drives tax revenue to the city. Why would a city actually want kids? I think a big driver of this in SF is that the software industry skews young. Software is a relatively new field unlike, say, medicine where you'll find a broader range of ages because computers have become a much bigger part of life more recently. Software can also be concentrated in certain cities in a way that doctors are going to be spread out a lot more. So, SF has an army of young, childless software engineers with more money than they know what to do with who might not have reached an age where they're thinking about saving willing to replace anyone looking to have kids who might move out. So SF has no incentive to make it a better place for kids. If you want kids, leave and the city will replace you with a young childless person who can plunge their money into the city rather than asking for city services. I think it's gone on too long to really course correct at this point. If you try to take steps to deal with housing prices, you're going to get a lot of opposition from your voters who have bought property in the city (and sunk their life savings into it). If I've paid $1M for a condo in SF, I don't want the city embarking on a big new plan to double the amount of housing. If anything, I want the opposite. It's an unfortunate circumstance that wasn't addressed soon enough.
- intopieces 10y ago>Why would a city actually want kids? School districts want kids for the same reason start-ups want customers: it's hard to scale with smaller demand. Yesterday when I was in SF, I saw a sign hanging on the fence of a schoolyard: "SUPPORT YOUR SCHOOL - BUY SCHOOL LUNCHES!" Apparently, so few students were buying school lunches (and instead bringing their own) that it was becoming more expensive to provide it for the ones that do buy it. Children who grow up in a city go on to invest in that city. Children also require services that drive the local economy, from babysitting to clothing/toys/food. I know you don't like sitting next to a table full of kids at a restaurant. Me neither. But children are necessary components of a thriving community.
- Naritai 10y agoPersonal story here. I have a 2-year old, and used to own a condo in what is now called Mission Bay. Here are some factors that we had to consider when planning on a child: -we are not sure how many children we want, and didn't want to lock ourselves into a lifestyle where that decision was driven by finances. -our 1-bdm 900-sqft condo is not a bad size but still woefully undersized for 1, much less 2, children. The couple on the floor above us had a baby in their unit, and they told us it was hellish. - there was a park nearby, which is nice, but the number of dogs we see reliving themselves on that patch of grass makes me think I'll never let my child play on that grass. -people drive aggressively through my street, and I'd be terrified to let my child play on my sidewalk. -it's really hard to find daycare in SF, and what you do find is expensive. A co-worker told me she got on a school's waiting list before she got pregnant. And when you do find a space, it'll be $2k+ per month per child. -the public education system in SF is opaque and confusing; there is no assurance that your child will be sent to the school geographically closest, and everybody has a horror story about a friend's cousin's brother who moved away from SF after getting their child assigned to a terrible school across town. I don't know that I'll be able to afford private school if needed (and, see aforementioned comment about finances). -when it comes right down to it, I want my child to have the sort of childhood I had, which is from a middle American suburb, with the parks, bike rides, and lemonade stands that that entails. Are any of these 100% accurate? probably not. Maybe I was horribly misinformed. As you note, most of my info came from conversations with other people who already had kids. But that's how most people learn, and I imagine it's how others learn the info they use to make their decisions too. So here I sit, commenting from my home in the East bay. I miss SF, sure, but you know what? It's pretty nice out here, too.
- laurencerowe 10y agoIt's a shame most new build apartments ins SF are so horribly designed. 900-sqft is enough for a comfortable 3 bedroom apartment. In an SF new build it probably means a deep, dark open plan space with windows on only one small wall.
- kelnos 10y agoI'm not sure I'd say comfortable. Three 10'x10' bedrooms would leave you with 600 sqft remaining to play with, and that's not a lot of room for two bathrooms and a decent-sized living space and kitchen, not to mention closets and any kind of storage space (which the need for increases with the number of people who live there). My 1BR is around 900 sq ft, and I'm having trouble envisioning how you'd carve two more bedrooms out of it and still have a nice space. One more bedroom, sure, but two more feels like it would be a stretch.
- settsu 10y agoI've observed what seems to be a growing sentiment among 20- to early 30-somethings that is... "child hostile" (?)—no babies or young children doing in public spaces what babies or young children are wont to do: cry, fuss, whine, speak loudly, etc. Just seemed to be a notable trend, especially when it came to places like restaurants and airplanes. I'm not suggesting this is the sole root of the problem, just that it could be a factor when you have a city flush with a demographic that is probably the least likely, after teenagers, to want to stand out for the "wrong" reasons. Who wants to be "those people" at the trendy restaurant?
- spullara 10y agoDo you have kids? Because, as a parent, I don't care what might be bothering some childless 20 something. On the other hand, who brings their kid to the trendy restaurant?
- J-dawg 10y ago>I don't care what might be bothering [someone] Sorry, but people like you are what creates this 'hostile' attitude. You're supposed to care whether your kids are bothering people.
- fierarul 10y agoThe problem is some people are so out of touch with a reality that includes children that they become too easily bothered. A child throwing a tantrum is bothering. A child just saying something out loud or running around a bit is just being a child.
- sidlls 10y agoThat's a fairly self-centered view you have there. Why should anyone care what bothers you?
- J-dawg 10y agoIn my opinion the more self-centered view is going around doing exactly what you want without any concession to how it affects other people. I regularly think about whether my actions are bothering anyone else. It's the opposite of self-centeredness, and something that many modern parents fail to do.
- brd529 10y agoI don't agree with Peter Thiel often but I do agree with his quote mentioned in the article - SF is "structurally hostile to families." As someone who is trying to raise school-age kids in San Francsico the insanity of the school lottery process is one of the greatest problems. We have so many friends who drive an extra hour every morning to take their kids to their algorithmically chosen school across the city. This when there is a great school in walking distance. Don't get me started on Algebra. SF school district has banned algebra in middle schools. My happiest friends with kids in the city home-school. Public transportation is OK for adults, but if you have more than one kid good luck. That's why you see in this report that parents with kids are driving everywhere. And of course, space. Since SF won't build, there is no space. The parks are great, the playgrounds are great. Most neighborhoods give you everything you need in walking distance: park, playground, library, grocery. Except schools. You're going to drive past your local school to get to the "fairly chosen" one. We had three candidates running for school board who supported neighborhood schools and an end to this madness. They all lost.
- cesarbs 10y ago> SF school district has banned algebra in middle schools. WTF? What's their rationale?
- yoloswagins 10y agoWhile this article on [1] priceonomics covers the issue really well, the given reason is to ensure all kids enter highschool at the same level. [1] https://priceonomics.com/why-did-san-francisco-schools-stop-teaching/ https://priceonomics.com/why-did-san-francisco-schools-stop-...
- cesarbs 10y agoUgh. So sad. Essentially disincentivizing higher performing kids from getting ahead. Hope I never have to deal with that in our school district.
- 10y ago
- amasad 10y agoOne other cause could be that silicon valley tech companies "is about infantilizing people" in the words of the late Aaron Swartz (about Google employees in this case). They make it so easy to not know how to feed yourself, clean your clothes, or even make friends outside work. Now the decision to care for another human being becomes much much scarier. http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/googlife http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/googlife
- cperciva 10y agoIf you have no children around, what’s our future? This question at least has a simple answer, and it's exactly the same as San Francisco's future has been for decades: Immigration.
- thekevan 10y agoSo what? With its insanely high rent and notoriously overworked populous, isn't SF a perfect place for people that don't have kids? There are millions of other places in the U.S. that are extremely kid friendly. Having one or two that aren't might even be a good thing. (Meaning you always need an alternative to the norm)
- pacala 10y agoRaising children is the ultimate expense. It makes zero economic sense, it only makes biological sense. Biological, as in a people with no children ceases to exist in a historical blip. Our metrics and the policies they drive are solely concerned with improving the economy. The gradient is stronger in the more expensive place, thus more noticeable. Hence pieces in NYT.
- redditmigrant 10y agoPeople, or most people atleast, dont have kids for biologically progressing their clan. They have kids because it brings them emotional fulfillment and happiness. Its gives people a sense of family. So even though it makes little raw economic sense, it makes lot of sense if you start valuing your happiness and your happiness depends on a sense of family.
- shostack 10y agoHaving kids for emotional fulfillment vs economic assistance (free labor) is a relatively new concept in the history of civilization and America though. Unfortunately the last couple of generations had economic factors that enabled this attitude, but now the current crop of potential parents are finding all the pressure and drive to mimic their childhood but a distinctly worse economic climate. I foresee a weakening of the concept of the traditional family if it keeps up.
- kelnos 10y agoOne could argue that happiness being so traditionally tied to a sense of family is a part of the biological imperative, or at the very least strongly encoded in our social and cultural mores. People get pressured by their friends and extended family to get settle down, get married, and have kids. If you look at a place like Japan, they're starting to lose that social pressure. It's worrisome for their economy and for care of the elderly in the longer term, but I find it fascinating to see what people do (and don't do) when societal pressures change or go away.
- rpcope1 10y ago> It makes zero economic sense, This is patently false in the bigger economic picture, and dubious still thinking about it from a microeconomic view. Japan is perhaps our leading indicator of why having less (or no kids) has a huge impact economically. Fundamentally, because our economy is at it's core driven by growth, if the number of consumers doesn't increase (or even stay stagnant), the economy will fall flat on its face, and we'll have a huge glut of older peak (again like Japan) with no one to carry the torch forward (or even to take card of the elderly).
- tabeth 10y agoMaybe I'm naive (I don't have children), but many of these articles basically can be reduced to "I want it all." [1] Nothing is wrong with that, but considering the popularity and ideal climate one can't expect to live in the bay area without a few caveats, right? The first thing I thought when I saw the title was, "oh, just move." Then I thought, "ah, people won't want to move because it's San Francisco." And so I see three options for anyone who complains about anything in any city: 1. Move 2. Pay extra for whatever convenience(s) you require (e.g. private school, a home closer to the school, etc.) 3. Attempt to change the law. So, when there's an issue like the one of schools, doesn't it just mean there are not enough people interested in (3) or are not affected by it sufficiently? Or maybe (3) is just too much effort. Regardless, if people REALLY wanted it and there were a sufficient amount of people affected, the problem would be fixed, no? I think also that the problem is compounded by conflicts of interest. Maybe people paying extra for private school makes it more difficult to change the law. Disclaimer: I have no knowledge of city politics. [1] Seriously though. > “Everybody talks about children being our future,” said Norman Yee, a member of San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors. “If you have no children around, what’s our future?” The future is being kicked out or becoming like Detroit (if god forbid the tech industry somehow collapses). Isn't this literally what happened to the past inhabitants of SF? They were kicked out once the higher paid people started coming in droves? The same will happen to everyone else once the wage(s) become sufficiently high. Isn't this just the free market or whatever, at work? Even if SF was a good place for kids and there were tons of kids, it would only be available for people of sufficiently high income. This article, then, would be titled "San Francisco Asks: Where have all of the regular families gone?" and would lament how no one goes to public school. Well, NYT has written similar articles already (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/25/us/backlash-by-the-bay-tech-riches-alter-a-city.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/25/us/backlash-by-the-bay-tec...).
- jamespitts 10y agoIt is not just price IMO, even though this is obviously a major factor. Several other things make this place hostile to families: - school system creates a somewhat unpredictable situation - not enough decent parks spread throughout the city - units on the market are often inappropriate for families - all new buildings are designed for young, single tenants - due to rent control and housing scarcity, many older apartments are not well-maintained - 40% the city sidewalks are a noisy polluted clusterfsck, 40% are desolate and boring - few trees or covered sidewalks, reducing shelter from sun and elements, walking around unpleasant - streets are extremely wide in many parts of the city, creating a dangerous environment for children
- skewart 10y agoThe lack of street trees and the wide, busy streets make SF sidewalks really unpleasant. Another thing is that so many of the row houses have garages and driveways to the street, not an alley. So not only are sidewalks uglier - in many parts of the city it's mostly pavement all around you, with walls of garage doors - but also you have to watch out for cars coming in and out of garages. Some neighborhoods in SF are really pleasant and walkable, but overall the city isn't really pedestrian-friendly at all. It's not designed for walking, and it isn't dense enough. It's more of a high-density car-oriented city, which is kind of the worst of both worlds.
- stuckagain 10y agoThe article tries to pin the phenomenon on high housing prices, Google, Twitter, etc but the numbers aren't really there. The big drop in the percent of families with children in SF happened between the 1970 and 1990 census. In 1970 24% of households had children, then 19% in 1980, 19% in 1990, and 19% and 16% in the subsequent decades. The share of children in the population had already fallen from 25% to 15% by 1990, and is down to 13% today. All of that happened before software was even a thing in this region, when the major industries were defense and semiconductors. And it happened regardless of housing prices going up or down.
- boulos 10y agoUmm, you realize that the crazy housing bubble of the 1970s is what got us Prop 13, right? 1980 in San Francisco was quite the crazy time (I think someone had linked to a great nytimes article from that period on HN in the last year or so).
- janlukacs 10y ago"Why would a city actually want kids?" "School districts want kids for the same reason start-ups want customers: it's hard to scale with smaller demand." "I know you don't like sitting next to a table full of kids at a restaurant. Me neither. But children are necessary components of a thriving community" I believe in capitalism, i'm not sure if this is representative of SF (never been) but this hyper capitalism with no soul/morals/religion where everything is a transaction, an asset, a business is simply scary and starting to feel like Logan's Run. Will you be paying breeders in "poor" areas to supply "kids" for your startups next? (let the down votes pour)
- Toine 10y agoI cannot believe some of the comments I'm reading...
- PeterisP 10y agoAren't we already doing this? A mechanism where people are born and raised in cheap areas and in their twenties go to a expensive place to live and work is (a) in general, already happening in SF; (b) unusual, but kind of works and (c) could be sustained indefinitely, at least without any obvious factors preventing that.
- tlogan 10y agoI'm a parent with two children living in SF (sunset) and depending on middle school lottery results we will be forced to move. It is not that we are moving because of lifestyle, because it is expensive (yes it is), etc. The problem is: if our middle school kid ended up begin placed in middle school at other side of the town (Mission, Marina, etc.) it will theoretically impossible for us get them to and from the school. So two things needs to be fixed and we will stay: - public transit system and/or - school system
- achou 10y agoI'm a parent with two children living in SF. Before I had children, I had no idea how difficult it was going to be, even putting aside finances. Most people without children just don't get how much more difficult ordinary life becomes. There is a deep reason that the "boring" suburbs beckon. Yes, the schools and the lower housing costs are a part of it. But there's also just the easier lifestyle, where you don't need to compete as much for everything. Parking, sidewalks, aggressive cars, daycare, schools, a seat on the bus, and very much avoiding crazy people who might harm your children. It is extremely stressful to walk your young child across a busy intersection in SOMA where a driver is aggressively trying to turn, where a crazy person is screaming at the top of his lungs, where a street that smells of urine awaits you on the other side. Putting SF aside, it's extremely difficult to maintain a good relationship with your spouse when a demanding job takes up a huge amount of time, and when that job seems like a vacation compared with the weekends with the kids. Almost universally every parent I know says that going to work on Monday is a relief, the beginning of their temporary vacation from the intensity of nuclear family life. The children themselves create the vast majority of the stress. Parents need environments that help reduce that burden, not merely keep inconveniences at bay. At our school the #1 wish of parents, by far, is for faraway grandparents to move nearby and help. If they could afford it. If they could survive in this city hostile to the elderly. If they were willing to give up their comfortable retirement travel adventures to shoulder some of the burden. Very, very few have this arrangement in SF.
- untilHellbanned 10y ago100% on point. That's why I'm insanely happy to live in St. Louis now right as our kids were born one mile from grandparents. We avoid most of that stress. As long as you work at a thriving place it feels virtually no different intellectually than SF. After all think about how many people you interact with meaningfully day to day. Seems like most people's work are little bubbles so the city you live in isn't super relevant.
- geerlingguy 10y agoSTL here too. Also happy to be in flyover country with my family, close to a major city, working remote for a coastal startup.
- ltbarcly3 10y agoWhy I didn't move to SF (even though pretty much all my friends live and/or work there): Cost used to be a factor but I think I could afford to live in SF at this point in my career if I made a few sacrifices. Really it comes down to: _Homeless people_ They are everywhere. They are yelling (tourette?). They are drunk. They are falling asleep standing up at the bus stop (heroin). They have followed me, calling me a 'billionaire', demanding money and making awful comments about my wife. They pee in the street right in front of you. Half the city smells like urine, and EVERY enclosed space that homeless people can get into smells like urine. Why would anyone want to have their children near that every day?
- Al-Khwarizmi 10y agoI read comments about this phenomenon in SF regularly here, so it must be really bad. But as an European who has made some trips to America but never been to SF in particular, it's difficult to understand why there is such a high density of unpleasant homeless people specifically in that city, and not in others. Anyone care to explain or hypothesize on reasons?
- varelse 10y agoAccording to this study of homeless people in nearby Santa Cruz (https://blog.civinomics.com/2015/04/07/the-reality-of-homelessness-in-santa-cruz/ https://blog.civinomics.com/2015/04/07/the-reality-of-homele...), ~1/3 the climate, ~1/5 each the social programs and lifestyle, followed by several other factors. I imagine the views of SF homeless are similar.
- Inconel 10y agoI'll do my best to give some reasons but this list is by no means exhaustive. In general I would say there are two main issues at play, one is that SF is relatively welcoming of homeless people, the second is that most other US cities are incredibly unwelcoming. So you end up with a homeless population both being pulled to SF and at the same time pushed into SF by other cities. Some of this is simple geography. It's much easier to be homeless in a dense (by US standards) city than a sprawled out suburb. SF also has decent public transit, again largely due to the necessary density, which makes being homeless easier. SF also has a relatively mild climate. Yes, the fog and the dampness/rain do suck, but it rarely gets either extremely cold or hot. Outside of geography, some cities are known for being extremely hostile to the homeless through policy and actively try and push their homeless out. I believe some cities, Las Vegas if my memory is correct, have been caught giving bus tickets to SF to their homeless. I know there are cities in Orange County where the police have been known to pick up homeless people and drop them off in neighboring cities. So, SF tends to get stuck with homeless problems that should be shared between many other cities/regions. SF also tends to have pretty good homeless services in terms of things like food kitchens and temporary housing/shelters. I will also add that having grown up partly in SF, and having spent some time living on the streets (more accurately parks) there, I don't think SF's reputation as a dirty city is entirely due to the homeless population. The people in SF, even those with multi million dollars houses, just don't really seem to care much. I've seen plenty of what I assume to be well employed people litter and no one really bats an eye. It also isn't unusual to see non-homeless people urinating in the streets after bars close. Again, I just don't think there is a critical mass of people that care enough, and I get the strong impression that those that do care don't really want to say anything since it could be interpreted as being intolerant. I think the fact that you have a large number of young single tech workers who probably don't have plans to stay in the city long term leads to a lack of civic pride. Additionally, while there are many wonderful aspects of the tolerance that SF is know for, I do believe that many people end up being too accepting of what is and isn't acceptable public behavior. This is probably complicated by the fact that I don't actually think SF is nearly as progressive as it claims, it's mostly virtue signaling. It's much easier to say you're progressive by tolerating all sort of behaviors that aren't particularly healthy, than it is to try and help the underlying causes of those behaviors. It's very late here so my apologies if this wasn't a good explanation.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoOne thing to point out-- the inefficiency of Prop 13 makes it much more difficult for families to grow. As this article[0] points out, only 30% of three-bedroom households in SF have any children at all. [0] http://sf.curbed.com/2017/1/19/14327998/san-francisco-families-children-housing-report http://sf.curbed.com/2017/1/19/14327998/san-francisco-famili...
- Inconel 10y agoProp 13, along with rent control, at least the non-means tested variety, are definitely huge impediments to allowing SF to become a more family friendly city. Much of the anti density/development uproar is rooted in those issues.
- SwellJoe 10y agoIt's kind of a no dogs kind of city, as well. I see people with dogs around San Francisco and the bay area, but I don't know where they're living. When I lived there I had to search for ages to find a place that allowed dogs, and it was a house, a lot more expensive than I'd hoped to spend on housing (I took it and lived there for three years...never moving to a cheaper place even when my girlfriend moved out and I was covering rent by myself). The search for an apartment around the bay area when you have a dog goes something like this: 1. Search by size, location, price range. Get back hundreds of results. 2. Narrow search with a filter: Allows pets. Get back two dozen results. 3. Oops. Many of these don't allow dogs, only cats and goldfish. Narrow search again, allows dogs. Now, we've got eight to choose from in the entire region. 4. Notice that many have a size limit...dogs under 25 pounds. Ok, read every ad through to the end to find out whether they allow real dogs, or only barking cats. Great. Two options, both more expensive and farther away from the train and a downtown than I really wanted. Not that I'm bitter. But, I don't live in the valley, anymore. At least if you have kids, you're protected by law. Landlords cannot prevent you from renting because you have children. But, they can refuse to rent to someone with a dog.
- jessaustin 10y ago...they can refuse to rent to someone with a dog. Thank goodness, although one wonders how much longer we'll be spared from that.
- SwellJoe 10y agoOh, I'm not suggesting the law should change. I'm just saying that housing is a sellers market in the bay area, to an extreme degree; sellers can set whatever ridiculous terms they want, and someone will still buy. What needs to change in the bay area is the housing supply. There just needs to be a lot more of it, so landlords stop being so picky and charging so much. It can cost several thousand dollars to move in the bay area, right now, by the time you cover deposit, first and last months rent, etc. And those are the kinds of terms you find on housing in the bay area. It's just an absurdly lopsided market, where renters have so little negotiating power. Every rental market is a little tougher for dog owners, but nowhere have I seen such an extreme disparity as in the bay area. That's really all I'm saying.
- denverpeterson 10y agoMy wife and I just moved from SF to Minneapolis two weeks ago. She's an SF native and I'm from Minnesota. I work in tech for a company based in SOMA. Our daughter was born in April. We managed in our one bedroom in the Tenderloin for nine months. We probably could have stuck it out longer, but we certainly weren't saving any money and the looming thought of child care costs and school were enough to push us to our decision.
- cobbzilla 10y agoShort Answer: The East Bay.
- ranndino 10y agoAmerica is really killing itself slowly (if people stop having kids we'll die out eventually but terrible economic consequences will hit much earlier) because of how bad the policies here are. Family values is just something conservatives like to blather about while doing everything to make people not wanna have full fledged families. Having kids shouldn't be this difficult and it isn't in countries where the government has common sense policies to actually support family values but in US half the country has been brainwashed to think of them as evil socialism. I know many Europeans with kids and they seem to be much less stressed out than Americans, still have time for hobbies and are genuinely enjoying having kids. It turns out that having kids doesn't have to be completely overwhelming when you have long maternity leave, government providing free day care and great public schools in your area (none of that lottery politically correct idiocy) plus parents who aren't living thousands of miles who prefer spending their retirement playing infinite rounds of golf and going on cruises over being involved grandparents. The government system and the individualistic, selfish mindset of Americans (both things that we delusionally pride ourselves on) is the cause of many major problems here and many people are still unwilling to even admit them.
- oppositelock 10y agoEurope's natural population growth is largely negative too, so it's no utopia over there either. I grew up in eastern Europe, and work in the US, so I've got perspective on both cultures. The biggest difference that I can see is that families in Europe tend to stay closer together, and grandparents, aunts and uncles help with child rearing, which is a huge help! Here, in the SF Bay Area, we're a society of immigrants who have severed those links. I've been working in tech in and around SF for 20+ years, and it's rare to meet someone with family in the area. All the growth here has been from immigration, foreign and domestic. People in the US really do seem to move a lot for work.
- GoreonKnows 10y agohttp://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN? US - 1.9 births per woman EU - 1.5 births per woman In many places in western Europe we look at US policies to try to increase births.
- czep 10y agoHigh rent and home prices in SF have in recent history been driven by the finance industry, not tech. This trend has been ongoing since the mid 1980s. Articles and popular sentiment calling out the tech industry divert attention away from the true causes of this inflation on the demand side. On the supply side, of course SF has failed dramatically due to Nimbyism and the powerful entrenched interests of the landed gentry and real estate industries who work to keep housing supply limited. As a SF resident since 2010 with a now 3 year old (Pac Heights pre-kid, Outer Richmond post), we are most likely to leave the city before he starts kindergarten. Although our preference would be to stay, the major factors are 1) home prices and 2) the school situation. We are renting at what would now be considered a reasonable rate, but our building has recently changed hands and the new owner's modus operandi is to Ellis or OMI as soon as our protected status is ended this summer. While we could afford to buy in the city, we would not be able to simultaneously budget for private schools. The public school system is in our opinion, far too much risk. Yes there are good schools, but even the best have crowd control problems for simple demographic reasons. Fully one third of SF school children attend private schools, and among the remaining two thirds there is an unfortunately sizable constituent whose family backgrounds are not as committed to education as we are. While we chafe at the insular homogeneity of the suburbs, we are also not so blind as to place our son in a school where significant resources must be expended on crowd control at the expense of quality education. It's a tough bind to be in. Just yesterday I attended the grand opening ceremony for Alamo school's playground where supervisor Mark Farrell and Sandra Lee Fewer were both highly encouraging for families to stay in the Richmond. I don't doubt their sincerity and I do believe they are doing everything in their power to make the city more family friendly. But my household simply does not have the resouces to compete with all-cash offers from overseas investors or investment bankers. It will be sad to bid farewell to this city, but education for my son is far more important to me.
- ransom1538 10y agoI found the amount of 'all-cash' offers in sf totally disturbing. SF homes are from 1-3million in a decent area. That amount of money can't be saved by working. That is money passed down or achieved by some nutty liquidity event - but those are quite rare. Where is this money coming from? This money is from Trusts [1] with hidden directors and foreigners (from politically unstable areas) using land as a great place to secure their money. If you own a deed that is registered with sf county - good luck to china, venezula, or russian officials trying to take it. Transferring titles is a circus - even if you live here. Thus your cash is secure, and you can continue your shady dealings in those countries not to worry about the current political winds. Example of trusts: [1] http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/SF-suing-Academy-of-Art-over-real-estate-empire-7396553.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/SF-suing-Academy-of-Ar... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/09/03/all-cash-buyers-real-estate_n_3861227.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/09/03/all-cash-buyers-rea...
- fblp 10y agoWhat is it like raising kids in east bay? does anyone have experiences to share?
- stuckagain 10y ago"The East Bay" is extremely large, so this question cannot be answered. I am raising children in north Oakland, near Berkeley. I think the combination of those two cities offers me what I want: enough interesting urban amenities, sufficient transit system, plenty of other kids for my kids to play with, and enough open space. But as I said the east bay runs practically all the way to Tracy, so no one answer can suffice.
- emmelaich 10y agoI recently visited SF for the first time. The hills make it hostile to kids already; you simply could not trust you kid to go out on most places with a bike or a skateboard. Of course it's always been like that so what matters is how much it (kid pop.) has declined. Which I couldn't actually find in the article.
- bennettfeely 10y agoI wonder how much of this can be attributed to the Roe Effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_effect
- funeralfunk 10y agoMy wife and I decided to move from SF to Walnut Creek some months before she gave birth. We're paying slightly more for rent, but instead of a 1-bedroom, we now live in a townhouse. Aside from more space, this has other perks: we don't have to deal with loud neighbors, crappy Victorian radiators, communal appliances, and playing garage Tetris. The commute sucks, but the benefits outweigh this drawback.
- Pocketsnakes 10y agoPeople know instinctively that smog and dens of homosexuality and degeneracy are not safe for children. For those discussing daycare: It's basically an abandonment simulation run daily and it destroys your child's psyche.
- dirkg 10y agoIts really sad and terrifying that most people think spending all day taking care of and raising their children is terrifying, boring, unproductive, undesirable because of a variety of reasons etc etc. No one has mentioned the joys. And raising your kid and being a good parent is not supposed to be easy or enjoyable. Its a lifelong task. Your parents did it. Its your responsibility.