4 ms·
Do you have an example of a trade agreement that wasn't negotiated "in secret" and which involved "civil society". Treaties, free trade treaties foremost among
by ajross 10y ago
Do you have an example of a trade agreement that wasn't negotiated "in secret" and which involved "civil society".
Treaties, free trade treaties foremost among them, are almost never public before the final text is available, because if they were they'd never get that far. Too many interests.
Look, it's a free trade agreement. It says, basically, "no tariffs at all for trade between the signatories". Except of course that every signatory has a list of a thousand "but..." clauses to protect whatever proprietary interests have their ear. So the end results is a big mess of exceptions and clarifications, which is why everyone hates it. There is literally something in there in there that everyone will hate! By design!
I mean, look: it's hardly the most important bill of the decade, and I'm not crying that it failed. But to pretend that this was some collusion of the global illuminati to stick it to the hippies, or white nationalists, or whoever you happen to identify with is just insane.
It's a ?!@#!$ trade treaty, for god's sake.
- digler999 10y ago> It's a ?!@#!$ trade treaty, for god's sake. its ramifications would have affected billions of people just as if it were a new civil and criminal law, that's what was so scary about it. Citizens aren't bound to obey international treaties. That's why we have governments.
- gech 10y agoOh i guess no big deal then, can't criticize something that wasn't even made available, for god's sake. Insane
- Gargoyle 10y agoThe fact that it's always been done that way is not a sufficient excuse.
- jordanb 10y agoThe fact that most trade agreements are negotiated in secret by special interests doesn't make it right. The TPP was full of provisions that would have made profits higher for corporations and very little that would genuinely protect workers and the environment. This is understandable given that most the voices in the room were representing corporations.
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoWere it totally open you'd see something analogous to NIMBYism, would you not?
- themusicgod1 10y ago"Were countries not ruled by kings we'd be arguing back and forth on the triviality of legislation. We need to make sure that there's one strong voice that is capable of deciding everything"
- y_u_no_rust 10y agoWell it's true isn't it? I'd take a well meaning aristocracy over democracy anyday
- Analemma_ 10y ago> if they were they'd never get that far. Too many interests. "That's a feature, not a bug. Whence this argument that trade negotiations are somehow different from every single other aspect of good governance? For all other mechanisms of government, everyone agrees that transparency is a vital mechanism for preventing corruption, and that whatever inefficiencies it introduces into the system are a necessary evil. Yet somehow free trade agreements operate on a different set of rules; even though time after time it's been shown that this invites boatloads of the exact corruption that government transparency is meant to combat." (This argument gets trotted out with such reliability in TPP threads that I can just copy-paste my response from a previous one)
- jimbokun 10y agoThere have been serious arguments made that too much transparency is crippling the US government's ability to function. Used to be a lot more compromises made in private, to come up with trade offs both sides could live with but the partisan core supporters would shoot down immediately if they knew. Which leads to our current government, where compromise with the other side of any kind is political suicide.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe partisanship in the US traces primarily to the voting system. Replace it with something like range voting or approval voting and you would have twelve parties instead of two, at which point passing anything would require a coalition government and cooperation with other parties would be a mandatory prerequisite for government action.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agopassing anything would require a coalition government Yeah, because "coalition governments" have worked so well in countries like Italy. Have they hit the 100 mark yet for number of "coalition governments" formed since WWII? And the Liberal Democrats made out really well in the "coalition government" that was formed in the UK after the 2010 elections. They went from 57 MPs after 2010 to 8 MPs after 2015. Even Charlie Sheen wouldn't call that "winning".
- arca_vorago 10y ago"But to pretend that this was some collusion of the global illuminati to stick it to the hippies, or white nationalists, or whoever you happen to identify with is just insane." This is a complete strawman argument, and lacks rational coherence.
- ggame 10y agoAn aside; I recently found out about the Nipster movement, Nazi Hipsters. Be afraid be very afraid
- ajross 10y agoYou literally snipped the joke out of the middle of the rationally coherent text to argue against it in isolation. Seriously, who's strawmaning here?
- jessaustin 10y agoJokes are funny.