11 ms·
This seems interesting because it addresses the issue of "show your work." Many years ago, I spent a semester teaching the freshman algebra course at the nearby
by analog31 10y ago
This seems interesting because it addresses the issue of "show your work." Many years ago, I spent a semester teaching the freshman algebra course at the nearby Big 10 university. This is the course that you take if you don't get into calculus. My students were bright kids -- they were all admitted to the state flagship school -- but not mathematicians.
There was huge variation in the preparation that kids brought with them from high school. In particular, very few of them understood what "show your work" means. They were told "show your work," but nobody told them what it really entails. Is it just to provide evidence that you did some work, to deter cheating, or is it something else? Many of my students were taught "test taking skills" such as the guess-and-try method. So on one exam, a question was:
x^3 = 27
One student's work:
1^3 = 1
2^3 = 8
3^3 = 27
Answer = 3
I asked the professors to tell me what "show your work" means. None of them had a good answer! These were the top mathematicians in the world. I wanted to talk with my students about it, but I'm not even sure that my own answer was very good.
But if we did well in math, then we just know what it means. It's not just evidence that you did the work. It doesn't mean "turn in all of your chicken scratch along with the answers." It means something along the lines of supplying a step-by-step argument, identifying the premises and connecting them with the conclusion, in a language that is "accepted," i.e., that mimics the language of the textbook / teacher. In fact, the reason to read the textbook and attend lectures, is to learn that language. (It's not so different in the humanities courses).
At least, that's my take on it, as just one teacher with one semester's worth of experience.
In my view, a problem solving tool that actually addresses the process of building the argument and not just determining the answer, would be beneficial to students.
- poseid 10y agowithout training, our brains confuses numbers easily from my experience. my niece is learning multiplication tables right now, and she confuses 8 * 7 = 56. we tried to teach her these numbers with a story, or a shortcut, e.g. 5 6 7 8 . see the groups 56 and 7*8. but still she rather found this kind of symbol processing painful and preferred to play with other things. another approach we tried to show her a visual representation of the multiplication but not sure what her current progress is.
- pryelluw 10y agoMy kid just learned by memorizing the results in order. Like: 8, 16, 24, 32, etc. If the problem is 5x8 then she knows its the fifth number in the sequence. Did not take her a lot of time to then learn the whole formula. Now that I think about it, this is like calculating results in a hash table for easy retrieval later. We used this video (and channel) and it helped lots: https://youtu.be/IjPjks1R6Ng https://youtu.be/IjPjks1R6Ng
- charmonium 10y agowhen you get to 5x + x = 6x, you can't simply memorize a similar sequence. Knowing how the sequence is created is much more valuable than memorizing the sequence. You do loose some speed, but critical thinking is more important than speed, especially with the onset of cheap personal computers and calculators.
- drsopp 10y agoI made this: http://trondal.com/m http://trondal.com/m Maybe it can help her.
- komali2 10y agoMaybe it's because I'm on mobile but I have no idea what's happening. There a number at the bottom with some sort of countdown (I think) happening, I click a number, screen flashes red, there's a small Sudoku board on the right. Total confusion haha, can you explain?
- drsopp 10y agoIt's not good on mobile. I tried making it language free, and relatively easy to figure out if you explore the buttons and see what happens. The top middle number is your problem. Your task is to click on the solution. If the solution is wrong, the screen flashes red. The bottom shows statistics of how much time you spend on each problem. The top left and right numbers lets you decide what factors are chosen in the problem. The sudoku board lets you toggle showing you relevant solutions based on chosen factors.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- graycat 10y ago> None of them had a good answer! These were the top mathematicians in the world. I can believe that. Why? I'm not one of "the top mathematicians in the world", but I do hold a Ph.D. in applied math from a world class research university and have published peer-reviewed research in math. My view is that (A) the problem, solve for x in x^3 = 27, (B) the request "show your work", and (C) the objective of the work of the OP to "simplify" some algebraic expressions are at best flawed introductions to math as pure/applied mathematicians do it and in our educational system as efforts in, call it, pedagogy. IMHO the goal of "simplify" an algebraic expression is especially flawed; that began to dawn on me in high school, and I so concluded in college and since. Why? To "simplify" an algebraic expression is mostly a matter of style often without clear criteria or a unique answer; such simplification can at times be to illustrate something particular to the context but not be general. Really, in math, we manipulate/leave algebraic expressions in whatever form is useful for what we are doing with the expressions and, IMHO, essentially never much for a goal of mere style or simplification. E.g., an important manipulation of algebraic expressions was taking the algebra for discrete Fourier transforms and, essentially, manipulating it to illustrate how to do the calculations of the fast Fourier transform (FFT) -- work mostly of J. Tukey, supposedly at a US Presidential Science Advisers meeting to answer a question of R. Garwin. The FFT is darned important, and curiously the main point can be discovered and illustrated just by manipulating the algebraic expression to be in one of several particular forms. Too much in math as commonly taught in K-12 and early college isn't really close to math as done by people really using math in, say, the STEM fields but is stuffed in there by the teachers as part of pedagogy or having a source of exercises and test questions. In response, generally it would be good to lower the emphasis on such make work pedagogy, get the students through it (minimize it and have lenient grading of it), and get on to what is important in math and its applications, research, etc. E.g., currently a big problem and hot topic in applied/research math is over fitting. Well, hush, don't tell anyone, but in some important cases can make some surprisingly good progress on over-fitting, realliy, get rid of the concerns, by essentially rewriting some of the algebra and just looking and observing. How 'bout that! No, I don't offer to fill in the details! Uh, in some cases, this work can also be a great way around some really nasty numerical stability problems. But, right, simplifying some algebra can be important when have an important objective in mine, and style is not such an objective and, really, is not a good guide to what would be a simplification useful for some important objective. Or, with the FFT and over-fitting, I've given two cases where there is an important objective for simplifying an algebraic expression -- alas, in both cases, without the important objective in mind, neither simplification would be seen to have better style!
- baldfat 10y agoI worked in college as a Digital Librarian and my degrees were Theology and Library Science (Not many of us) PROBLEM: It is a socially acceptable to be bad at math and I am talking 4th or 3rd grade math! 2nd Problem: We teach pure math (Think algebra) to soon and place applied maths like Trigonometry and Calculus where only a handful of student will ever even attempt and God help them if they have a weak math teacher.
- Ar-Curunir 10y agoYou need algebra to do calculus with any sort of rigor... Your suggestions are the real problem with teaching mathematics; do people learn science only to learn practical stuff? Read literature only to gain literacy skills? No! That is not how classes are taught. Mathematics is seen only as a tool, but if it was taught as an art, or even a science, people wouldn't hate it!
- baldfat 10y agoWhy do we have to only get to calculus or pre-calculus concepts so late and why is it so extreme like it is all or nothing? There is plenty in Applied math in calculus that doesn't hing on algebra. Children natural love pattern recognition and we don't teach anything pattern based till we have beaten them into boring show your work work sheets? See (A Mathematician’s Lament by Paul Lockhart) http://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf http://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.p... "In fact, if I had to design a mechanism for the express purpose of destroying a child’s natural curiosity and love of pattern-making, I couldn’t possibly do as good a job as currently being done— I simply wouldn’t have the imagination to come up with the kind of senseless, soulcrushing ideas that constitute contemporary mathematics education." > Rigor My trigger word!!! Rigor, the most hatred word in all of education philosophy!!!! > Three Dirty Words are Killing Education by Deb Jensen RIGOR VS. RELEVANCE The second problem term is rigor (also known as “high” standards). The term is associated particularly with college readiness. The term might call up images of learned individuals from the 1800s, but today's rigor is imposed artificially — it requires only more algebra or more credits. While the mind needs information to build beyond the concrete to the abstract, much of the random information is actually screened out. http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/003172171009200120 http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/003172171009200...
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoShow your work means that when you are tested on your knowledge of a specific pen-and-pencil algorithm, you are expected to show a trace of execution of that algorithm. You're not being tested on solving the problem, but on knowing the algorithm.
- 0x45696e6172 10y agoUntil recently I didn't even know there existed such a pen-and-paper algorithm resembling long division: https://xlinux.nist.gov/dads/HTML/cubeRoot.html https://xlinux.nist.gov/dads/HTML/cubeRoot.html
- charmonium 10y agoPerhaps math classes should focus less on remembering algorithms and more on inventing your own algorithms by solving novel problems. In that context showing work is much more meaningful.
- Ar-Curunir 10y agoI don't mean to be mean, but people who don't know basic algebra are unlikely to be making algorithmic breakthroughs.
- nitrogen 10y agoThe parent comment probably meant that students would learn how to derive the necessary algorithm from the problem description, rather than memorizing a bunch of rote algorithms without being able to disassemble and reassemble them.
- nitrogen 10y agoThen you have parents complaining about the difficulty of "story problems" and claiming math class shouldn't be reading class.
- posterboy 10y agoas per the curry howard isomorphism (programs as proofs), there is no difference, except that a few symbols are arbitrarilly bound but without loss of generality (as could be proven by induction).
- yequalsx 10y agoShow your work means that the process for doing the problem works in a sufficiently generic situation. The student's methodology would not work for solving the equation: x^3 = 7 Hence I would mark the student's answer wrong. At least at the level of a college algebra course. Guess and try is fine for getting an intuition for a problem but it is not fine as a solution. EDIT: I don't care about down votes but I'm interested why there is disagreement with what I wrote. I've been teaching mathematics at the college level for 20 years and I believe my answer above fits with what most college level teachers think about the topic. So, why do you disagree with what I wrote?
- analog31 10y agoNote that I didn't downvote you. I actually consider the answer wrong too, and the professors agreed too. One of them said: "Obviously the student doesn't understand the problem." I thought to myself: "You understand the problem because you know the answer." But I held my tongue. But at the present state of the art, the student has no idea why the answer is wrong. That's where I think their high school math background failed them.
- yequalsx 10y agoThe danger of always using nice numbers! I've taught topics where I thought I had the best lecture, the best examples and that it would be impossible for a student to misinterpret the method. Some still did come up with flawed thinking. It's hard.
- AlexCoventry 10y ago> The student's methodology would not work for solving the equation: x^3 = 7 It would if the results they reported were the initial steps of a binary search which got very lucky.
- Eliezer 10y agoI HATED "show your work". You want a proof, ask me for a proof. It's not my fault I can solve your problem in my head. Especially horrifying is if you want me to solve the problem a particular way. There is no better way of turning the fun and freedom of math into drudgework. You are licensed to ask me to arrive at the correct answer, or to prove a theorem from premises; telling me how to do it is mathematical abuse.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoThis equation can not be a real university exam question. Edit: I have seen the other post in this thread. My apologies, this seems to be the university math level in the states. God help us!
- empath75 10y agofreshman college algebra is really basic in the us. It's about what I took in the 10th grade. Most people getting math degrees will skip it because they got it in high school.
- analog31 10y agoIndeed, I observed that among those of us qualified to teach the course, absolutely none of us had ever taken it. Here's what I learned about it, which may be unique to the US: Just before starting freshman classes, the students took a math exam, and were sorted into three levels: 1. Calculus. 2. College Algebra, which like you say is a repeat of 10th grade algebra. Its curriculum is defined by the requirements for the minimum level of math that can be offered for credit at an accredited college. 3. "Remedial" math, which cannot be offered for credit, but is a preparation for college algebra. I estimate that about half of the students were in calculus, and the other half in the lower two tracks. For all intents and purposes, if you're not ready for calculus as a freshman, you're not going to be a math or "hard" STEM major. It's the sorting hat. The opinion of the professors was that the algebra students didn't even belong in college, so the lower math courses were conducted under a black cloud. The rigidity of the accreditation requirements may have led to the rigidity of the curriculum, which I thought didn't belong in any century that I've lived in. For instance the course made no meaningful use of computers. Since this was the state flagship university, the students represented K-12 math preparation throughout the state. The variation is huge. Some school districts offer two years of calculus. The high school that my kids attend has a deal with the university for kids to take college math classes beyond calculus. Some schools have no calculus. Some of the kids in my college algebra class had gotten A's in high school calculus, but somehow couldn't pass an algebra exam.
- NumberCruncher 10y ago
- olalonde 10y agoWhat is the expected way to show the work on this? IIRC (long time ago), the method I learned for computing cube roots involved knowing the cubes of single digit numbers (e.g. 3^3 = 27, being one of them).
- vkou 10y agoPresumably, it consists of verifying that 3 x 3 x 3 = 27. But who the hell knows. Alternatively, maybe it expects a binary search through the decision space? 2 x 2 x 2 = 8 < 27. Too bad this breaks down when the problem is trivially adjusted - not in the X^3 = 28 way (As binary search can approximate that), but in the X^3.3 = 27 way.
- mkeyhani 10y agoHere's Feynman's take on learning algebra: Around that time my cousin, who was three years older, was in high school. He was having considerable difficulty with his algebra, so a tutor would come. I was allowed to sit in a corner while the tutor would try to teach my cousin algebra. I'd hear him talking about x. I said to my cousin, “What are you trying to do?” He says, “I'm trying to find out what x is, like in 2x + 7 = 15,” I say, “you mean 4.” He says, “Yeah, but you did it with arithmetic. You have to do it by algebra.” I learned algebra, fortunately, not by going to school, but by finding my aunt's old schoolbook in the attic, and understanding the whole idea was to find out what x is – it didn’t make any difference how you do it For me, there was no such thing as doing it “by arithmetic,” or doing it “by algebra.” “Doing it by algebra” was a set of rules which, if you followed them blindly, could produce the answer: “subtract 7 from both sides; if you have a multiplier, divide both sides by the multiplier,” and so on – a series of steps by which you could get the answer if you didn't understand what you where trying to do. The rules had been invented so that the children who have to study algebra can all pass it. And that’s why my cousin was never able to do algebra.” (from What Do You Care What Other People Think?) (Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VW6LYuli7VU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VW6LYuli7VU)