24 ms·
Seven years is still a long time for whistle blowing. I'm glad to see she is still getting released though. It's important to note commuting the sentence is not
by djsumdog 10y ago
Seven years is still a long time for whistle blowing. I'm glad to see she is still getting released though. It's important to note commuting the sentence is not a pardon. Chelsea will still have this conviction for the rest of her life.
I know there is a lot of controversy with Manning compared to Wikileaks et. al. as far as not redacting documents or using a discriminating news source to filter them. Still, I oppose state secrets and the Hillary e-mails are actually very chilling when you start reading through them. I still side with Manning. Too many of the Snowden documents were redacted with critical information (like which hardware encryption chips were compromised by the US government). No one has the actual Pentagon Papers outside of very specific news agencies. Manning gave the entire story to the people .. and I find it more sad that we didn't see more outrage and change from that release.
I also see another message here. Obama is trying to leave a positive view of the Democratic legacy with this lasting memory. It helps people forget about the predator drones, secret kill lists, continuation of torture, NSA spying and the expansion of war, military and the American hegemony throughout the world. I wish people would see this manipulation; this handout to the left to keep them angry at the incoming administration and not at the government that continues to spy on them and kill people without trial in and endless sea of never ending conflict.
- rthomas6 10y agoI have mixed feelings on this. Manning did commit a crime. They were entrusted with classified information and they released it on purpose. For all of the corruption and wrongdoing the release of those cables uncovered, didn't it also do things like give away the positions of some undercover agents? And harm US diplomatic relations with other countries? Look at it from the POV of the government: How could they not punish Manning? It would do a lot to encourage others to indiscriminately leak classified info. Which would be bad.
- mhurron 10y agoClassifying material should not be a way for the Government to hide corruption and wrongdoing. Whistle blowing is the only way that prevents that. Chelsea Manning acted on her conscience, which is the best we can expect anyone to do. The governments punishment was to prevent that happening again.
- ythn 10y agoYou can spin any type of classified material as "corruption" and "wrongdoing". Who draws the line? What if someone indiscriminately leaked everything on the Manhattan project during WW2? Would they be a hero because they "acted on their conscience" and showed the world that the big bad USA was secretly developing WMDs? Or would they be a villain because they just taught other countries how to do the same? To the peace loving left he would be a hero, to the nationalist right he would be an enemy. Bradley/Chelsea Manning is no different.
- chc 10y agoDo you really believe that the government should be able to do whatever it wants in any area with no transparency or oversight? That's what you're saying — that nobody should be allowed to disclose something that government officials don't want them to, without any further consideration — but I have trouble believing that's what you mean to say.
- hackinthebochs 10y ago>That's what you're saying No thats not what's being said. I would hope we could all be above strawmen.
- chc 10y agoAs I said, I have a hard time believing that is what's meant, but I think that is a pretty fair summary of the big-picture implications of that proposal. If you don't think so, please explain how rather than throwing out the word "strawmen" and pretending you've debunked something.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mason240 10y agoNo, Manning did not act on "conscience." Manning had no idea what was being released. This was in retaliation for being a bad soldier who couldn't handle even a cushy role.
- _delirium 10y agoObama doesn't seem to completely disagree, since he didn't pardon her. He instead commuted the sentence from 35 years to 7 years' imprisonment. In my personal opinion that's still too long for the crime, but it's at least less completely insane than 35 years.
- kzrdude 10y agoThe military justice has a possibility for parole release before the term, unlike U.S. federal civil justice. So there was always the possibility of a such release. https://www.emptywheel.net/2013/08/21/bradley-mannings-sentence-parole-and-appeal-implications/ https://www.emptywheel.net/2013/08/21/bradley-mannings-sente...
- _delirium 10y agoThanks, I didn't realize the military had retained parole after the rest of the federal government abolished it. If I'm reading the link correctly, 10 years would have been the minimum time served in this case. If it were likely that parole would be granted at the earliest point of eligibility (would it be? I have no idea), this commutation then amounts to knocking 3 years off the minimum sentence. Which is not nothing, but less dramatic than the headline 28 years.
- Shivetya 10y agohe did pardon Marine General James Cartwright who released details about the cyber attacks on Iran. That one is was a surprise
- greedo 10y agoHe didn't release details. He lied to investigators to deflect their attention from the real leaker. Sort of like how Martha Stewart was convicted of making false statements to Federal agents.
- _delirium 10y agoIs that the conventional wisdom? I thought the consensus was that he probably was the source for David Sanger's book, but that the federal government didn't want the exposure of litigating the case, so it was resolved in the end by him agreeing to plead guilty to a lesser offense of, roughly, "lying under oath about not being the leaker", without being actually charged with the leak itself.
- mrb 10y ago"How could they not punish Manning?" But she was punished. With 7 years that she already spent in jail. I don't think that reducing her sentence from 35 years to 7 years "encourage others to leak".
- clashmoore 10y agoThe book, "The Spy Who Couldn't Spell: A Dyslexic Traitor, an Unbreakable Code, and the FBI's Hunt for America's Stolen Secrets" by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee tells the story of an American intelligence worker who tried to pass off information to other governments just prior to Sept. 11th. His motivation was money (selling his secrets for millions of dollars) and when he was caught, he was hoping to have his sentence reduced to 8 years so he may be with his family. I think it would be encouraging to others to leak if the risk of making millions for their families to getting caught still allows them to live life if the punishment is anything less than life.
- rosser 10y agoDifferent circumstances. Spying for money should be treated radically differently than spying for conscience.
- ishields 10y ago> It would do a lot to encourage others to indiscriminately leak classified info A one-time presidential commute or pardon would do no such thing. Saying that "this specific case has been looked at and deemed to be okay" doesn't automatically equate to "everyone can do this and they won't get in trouble." There's a huge difference between whistleblowing and treason
- Natsu 10y agoThat's understandable, but Manning's sentence has been unusually cruel in its execution, and unjust when compared to other people who did without being punished at all. See, e.g. the conduct that Colin Powell described in this email: https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/30324 https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/30324 [EDIT: click to view the PDF to find the actual content.]
- the_duke 10y agoIs there a list of emails that contain actual unfavorable/damning information?
- Natsu 10y agoYes, although IMHO it's not a very good one. Some of these should be taken with salt - http://www.mostdamagingwikileaks.com/ http://www.mostdamagingwikileaks.com/
- sjy 10y agoFor example, #6 claims that 'Hillary's campaign' wants an 'unaware and compliant citizenry,' on the basis of an unsolicited email to Podesta using that phrase to describe Trump's campaign strategy!
- Natsu 10y agoAssuming you're talking about this email - https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/3599 https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/3599 It's oversold, yes, but as far as I can tell, it's this Bill Ivey (NEA chairman under Clinton, Obama transition team member) and not some random spammer - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ivey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ivey Other correspondence can be found here - https://search.wikileaks.org/?q=bi%40globalculturalstrategies.com https://search.wikileaks.org/?q=bi%40globalculturalstrategie...
- Natsu 10y agoI should also mention that it's fairly incomplete. E.G. no mention of this one that Wikileaks tweeted earlier regarding Taiwan - https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/23730#efmAEGAEhAHiAIYANlAOG https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/23730#efmAEGAEh...
- rand77763 10y agoThe POV of the government should be nothing more than the POV of the people.
- cderwin 10y agoThere is no POV of "the people". A bunch of individuals comprise the people, and some of those individuals also comprise the government. But "the people" as a group do not have a POV.
- rtkwe 10y agoThat's a shay position given how wrong a majority of the country has been at various times in history. Forced school desegregation was wildly unpopular in a lot of the country (even the north) but it was the right thing to do, some issues shouldn't be left to the whims of a populace. It also treats the view of the people as a singular entity when it's vastly fractured and multifaceted.
- tropo 10y agoForced school desegregation is not active for most kids. Many people buy into expensive school districts. Cupertino, Mountain View, Palo Alto, and other fine cities are not exactly desegregated. Even in more mixed areas, the school zones are seldom mixed. Then, for those without the money to isolate themselves by zip code, there is homeschooling. Kids do not get bused from one homeschooling family to another.
- Legion 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
- hnbro 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristocracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristocracy
- acalderaro 10y agoYea, from the POV of the government having the public realize all the illegal, unethical and irresponsible things you've been doing with their tax dollars would be absolutely terrible. Someone may end up getting jail time - or even worse - lose their reelection! /s Anyone who is able to condemn Manning would also condemn the soldiers of Hitler's army who chose to disobey orders to kill Jews because it would have been against the law. Just because something is illegal doesn't mean it's wrong. And if our government didn't engage in illegal activity (like torture, political uprisings, wire tapping) then perhaps people like Manning wouldn't have to leak information that could compromise a few undercover agents. In this case, the benefits far outweigh the costs. Find me a politician or soldier who got jail time for committing acts of torture in Baghdad and then we can talk about penalizing Manning.
- thrill 10y agoYou sure jumped to Nazi comparisons rather quickly.
- Zooper 10y agoRather than being an example of Godwin's law, though, this is a historically analogous comparison of US war crimes justifications in Iraq to the Nuremberg defense and doesn't suggest impending ethnic genocide where there is none.
- acalderaro 10y agoBecause the comparisons are blatantly obvious.
- golergka 10y agoIs there a single thing in those files to make Nazi comparison justifiable?
- acalderaro 10y agoNazis tortured and massacred civilians in eastern Europe. US Soldiers did so in Iraq. Did you even bother to read the reports?
- pvg 10y agoThere really wasn't much in the way of corruption and wrongdoing in the diplomatic cables. If anything they showed that the mundane private details of US diplomacy match US public diplomatic stances quite closely.
- baddox 10y agoAccording to this article, the prosecution failed to provide evidence that anyone was killed due to the leaks. I don't know if anyone was harmed, but it really doesn't seem like it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adrienne 10y agoManning is a woman; is there some reason you're calling her a "they"?
- rabidrat 10y ago"He" is the pronoun that was used in their past, "she" is the pronoun for the present. When we're talking about the past+present for this person, I think "they" is not unreasonable. At least, it's more reasonable than trying to call someone out for their pronoun usage when the discussion is about a much more serious topic.
- adrienne 10y agoNo, the correct way to do this is to use the individual's pronouns. Please note that the AP and the NYT have basically adopted the GLAAD style guide on this issue: http://www.glaad.org/reference/transgender http://www.glaad.org/reference/transgender The NYT correctly stated in the parent article, "Ms. Manning was still known as Bradley Manning when she deployed with her unit to Iraq in late 2009." See how that works? She was always a she, even though she was presenting as a man at the time.
- rabidrat 10y ago> She was always a she, even though she was presenting as a man at the time. Sorry, I don't agree. Gender should not be retconned. Please do your activism in a different forum.
- wtbob 10y ago> No, the correct way to do this is to use the individual's pronouns. No, the correct way to do this is to use the correct pronouns, at least in the third person. One might refer to someone who believes he is Napoleon to his face as 'Your Majesty,' in order not to cause mental distress, but one is under no compunction to refer to him in the third person as 'His Majesty.' Likewise, no-one is under any compunction to refer to a man who believes that he is a woman in the feminine third person (although, in languages which have gendered second persons, it might be kind to use it face-to-face, again in order to avoid mental distress).
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoWe live within a rules-based system. For Manning the rule was "We'll give you this security clearance, here are 100 classes about not spilling the things you know to anyone else." I too am troubled by the decision, but it does seem a bit out of whack with the total lack of punishment for the higher echelons of government. Lately it seems like the rules-based system we have been living under is cracking.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoYears in solitary confinement isn't "total lack of punishment". And an intelligence contractor flunky isn't "higher echelons"
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoI was referring to Powell and HRC. What were you referring to?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beedogs 10y agoIt's okay to call her "she", you know. "They" is a little... odd, when referring to a person.
- dcposch 10y agoIt's becoming increasingly common. Personally I think esoteric pronouns like "ve" are a silly idea that won't catch on, but I like the idea of using "they" as a gender neutral way to refer to one or more people. It's a straightforward expansion of the current usage: as a gender neutral way to refer to two or more people.
- bluehex 10y agoMy problem with "they" is that it's overloading the plural pronoun and using it like a singular. This can cause confusion, for example, it makes the comment we're discussing a bit hard to read when in one sentence "they" means Manning and in the next sentence "they" means the government.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hnbro 10y agoi think it's only odd to some because of prescriptive "style guide" insistence over the years. it makes a great deal of sense.
- kriro 10y agoRegarding the harm it did to US relations with other countries...I think long term it would be more positive for relations with all countries if there's decent treatment of whistle blowers. Sure short term it sucks to have info along the lines of "we did X to harm your country" leaked but let's face it most sane governments assume that the U.S. is doing some very shady things and has a huge budget to execute that fairly "well". At the end of the day I'd much rather have a U.S. doing shady things and some people shining a light on it every now and then than just the U.S. doing shady things.
- EdHominem 10y ago> Manning did commit a crime. Not actually. Manning was required by law to refuse and report illegal orders. And not just make a show of reporting it and then back to business as usual. > didn't it also do things like give away the positions of some undercover agents? No, but that'd be our fault anyways, for mixing legal and illegal. > And harm US diplomatic relations with other countries? The truth didn't harm relations, doing the things that the allies found out about in the first place was the problem. > Look at it from the POV of the government: How could they not punish Manning? Um, admitting fault and correcting it. But yeah, we know that'd never happen so what could they do but shoot the messenger? > It would do a lot to encourage others to indiscriminately leak classified info. Doubtful. The motivator in Manning's case wasn't the ease or difficulty of leaking, but the crimes that needed exposing.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoHe has male parts you scientifically illutilerate dumbfuck.
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoyeah, maybe, but I guess I would also say that maybe he did the decent thing when he judged it would no longer bear a political cost to do so - because I bet being a politician means you have to take those political costs into consideration. (certain exceptions do spring to mind)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 10y ago> Obama is trying to leave a positive view of the Democratic legacy with this lasting memory. It helps people forget How do you know what Obama's motive is? Were you at the meetings? Did you read the memos? Do you have a brain-to-brain interface or have you hacked his Blackberry? Should he do nothing good or positive, so that you don't suspect him of manipulating people?
- hawkice 10y ago> Should he do nothing good or positive, so that you don't suspect him of manipulating people? I mean, the crime, conviction, sentencing, and multiple suicide attempts all happened while Obama had the power to commute the sentence. If there was a principle at play here, if Obama thought it was a moral good to have this person avoid a prison sentence, I'm having a hard time imagining what the roadblock was. Was it that the massive leak and subsequent prosecution didn't get enough media coverage, so he was unaware of the situation? No, that doesn't sound right, it was widely known at every stage in the process. If commuting someone sends a message, the delay sends a message too. Perhaps he's just trying to do the right thing when the consequences won't hurt him. Perhaps it's all for show. But I think it's fair to conclusively rule out the theory about this decision being made in order to maximize the welfare of Manning. Something else was in the calculus here.
- the_duke 10y agoIf he did it during the campaining, which was basically the last 18 months, the Republicans would have been all over it. Not that I'm praising him, he's been terrible wrt surveilance and transparency.
- kbenson 10y ago> if Obama thought it was a moral good to have this person avoid a prison sentence What if he thought it was good to avoid too long of a sentence? One possible interpretation is that he wanted punishment because it was against the law and as a deterrence, but didn't want to be too harsh. Sentencing isn't within his control, but commuting a sentence is. > If commuting someone sends a message, the delay sends a message too. Sure, everything sends a message, but not every message is intentional. It's undisputable that these actions send messages, but impossible to know for sure what the reasoning was and what messages were intentional and what were byproducts. The traditional time for a president to commute and pardon is at the end of their presidency, so reading a purposeful message into the delay may or may not be useful.
- cm2187 10y agoWhistle blowing requires the knowledge of wrong doing, and exposing these wrong doings. As far as I am aware that guy leaked the data in bulk without looking at it, and without any knowledge of the US diplomacy, and the leaks didn't expose any major wrongdoing. Only some gory videos, that don't really teach us anything (everyone knows bombs make "collateral damages", the US army even maintains statistics on them). And everything I read from people who reviewed the diplomatic cables suggest that US diplomats are doing rather well their jobs. I am a libertarian, pro-pardoning Snowden, who did expose deliberately major wrong doings. But I am struggling to call Manning a whistleblower.
- TillE 10y ago> Only some gory videos, that don't really teach us anything (everyone knows bombs make "collateral damages" So you've never actually watched (or read about) the Collateral Murder video, huh? It's a helicopter crew killing people with guns, not bombs. And they kill exactly who they intend to. Maybe don't form strong opinions when you don't have the slightest clue what the facts are.
- mason240 10y agoManning had no knowledge of the video. It happened to be in the blind data dump.
- hendersoon 10y agoThat is not true, and is easily verifiable by reading Chelsea's chat logs with Adrian Lamo.
- cm2187 10y agoAs far as I know they have mistaken a TV crew for some armed people. Big deal. This sort of fuckups happen all the time in any war. That's called "collateral damage". If you don't want any you can't shoot on people from a helicopter 300m away from your target, through a low res B&W video. In fact there are very few things any army could do if we wanted to have zero collateral damage. When congress authorizes a war, the reality is that they authorize the fact that these things may happen. I'm not pro-Irak war, quite the contrary. But the fact that civilians have been killed isn't exactly a hidden secret that was uncovered by the leaks > Maybe don't form strong opinions when you don't have the slightest clue what the facts are. This sort of insults has nothing to do on HN
- cowardlydragon 10y ago7 years isolation, not just 7 years
- copperx 10y agoWoah, still enough to make anyone go insane.
- bjourne 10y ago> I oppose state secrets and the Hillary e-mails are actually very chilling when you start reading through them. Weren't they from the DNC leak? The DNC is not affiliated with the US state. I read some of the mails, and I found nothing chilling so I'm curious to know what chilling mails you found.
- e40 10y agoI'd like the answer to that, too. From everything I've read, this seems to be FUD.
- AwfulCaptain 10y agoI think what's chilling is the inconsistent application of the law regarding sensitive information (for example, emails). Secretary of State Clinton, who deletes government emails and communicates state secrets through her own private email server, receives no punishment, while people who blow the whistle on questionable government behavior receive maximum punishment. That lack of consistency in applying the law is what makes it unfair...for everybody.
- bjourne 10y agoYou're on a different subject. What was chilling according to the parent was the contents of the leaked emails. The private email server controversy had nothing to do with that.
- bwooceli 10y agoNot a whistle blower. The cable leaks were just a bulk drop of decades worth of material.
- karmacondon 10y agoBy definition, a whistle blower must reveal evidence of the commission of a crime. The term does not extend to "actions by the government that I disagree with" or "things that violate my personal interpretations of the Constitution" If you misuse the term, you make it more difficult for legitimate whistle blowers to get the protection they deserve.
- themartorana 10y agoMurder, torture, blanket domestic spying etc., are not (or have not recently been) considered crimes when the federal government is the actor. The line isn't so clear.
- grzm 10y agoWhen they're given those labels, they are. The question is whether the actions are accurately described by those particular words. That's why phrases like "enhanced interrogation techniques" are employed, to make a distinction between that and torture, for example. (Note, I'm not arguing that I think any particular actions are or are not criminal. I'm too ignorant of the details to meaningfully speak one way or the other.)
- serge2k 10y ago> That's why phrases like "enhanced interrogation techniques" are employed, to make a distinction between that and torture, for example. I'm not sure what you are saying here. Using a euphemism doesn't make torture any better.
- grzm 10y agoIn the spirit of Pascal, I apologize in advance for not having a more eloquent, concise reply, though on my part its more exhaustion and laziness rather than lack of time. People have different definitions of what constitutes torture. There is also a legal definition of torture (which may be vague, but will be determined judicially if it comes to that). By definition, torture is against the law. As people have different definitions of what constitutes torture, some acts will meet the legal definition, while others will not even though they meets the definition held by someone else. I happen to agree with you that "enhanced interrogation techniques" is a euphemism for torture. By defining certain acts as such, it gives proponents of using such acts a legal basis of arguing that they're not torture, whether it's ultimately justified or not. Does that make sense? I'm not asking whether or not you agree with the distinction (which would be hard to do as I haven't defined which acts fall under either). I'm just asking whether the argument follows, that you understand why the language matters. A similar distinction is made for killing in war and murder. Some people believe all killing is wrong and murder. That said, there's a legal distinction between the two. Which term is applied is legally important.
- afterburner 10y ago"the Hillary e-mails are actually very chilling when you start reading through them" What chilled you, specifically?
- markdown 10y agoCollusion with the media and a debate moderator should chill anyone. Add to that the fact that the DNC basically anointed her by not giving Sanders a fair shake... democrats were told who to vote for using the media to give them the illusion of free choice. Put another way, the emails revealed that it's very possibly that Trump will be President because Clinton had corrupted the DNC.
- fullshark 10y ago> Collusion with the media and a debate moderator should chill anyone. That is really the only significant dirt that came from that leak. The Sanders stuff was overblown.
- cwkoss 10y agoHave you read the leaks? What parts do you think are overblown? From what I've read, it appears the DNC directly violated their own bylaws by (strongly) preferring one candidate before the primary. Repeatedly and flagrantly. If the DNC isn't even accountable to itself, how should American voters feel about them having control over the duopoly of private parties which are allowed to select presidential candidates? At best, their actions were revealed to be grossly unethical. At worst, criminal.
- arrosenberg 10y agoHow could a private organization violating their charter extend to criminality? Most of the leaks showing the DNC "favoring" Clinton came after it was clear she was going to win the primary, and most of DNC wanted to focus on the general election. On top of that, individual staffers having a preference for the person they are very close to over the guy who joined the party just to run shouldn't be that surprising, but I haven't seen any evidence that it translated in substantial action to tilt the field in favor of Hillary. I'll concede the debate question issue was a bad look, but again, what advantage was conferred by telling the HRC team that a debate in Flint would feature a question about the Flint Water Crisis?
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoPlease don't forget Aaron Swartz.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dopamean 10y agoDumping tons of classified documents in the way that she did is not whistleblowing. I think Obama did the right thing here but not because she was a whistleblower (she's not).
- eevilspock 10y ago"Just in: President Barack Obama has largely commuted Chelsea Manning's remaining prison sentence. She has been jailed for nearly seven years, and her 35-year sentence was by far the longest punishment ever imposed in the United States for a leak conviction." - The Marshall Project https://www.facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org/posts/1863963983819021 https://www.facebook.com/TheMarshallProject.org/posts/186396... I highly recommend subscribing to the Marshall Project Opening Statement: https://www.themarshallproject.org/subscribe https://www.themarshallproject.org/subscribe
- egberts1 10y agoExcept that Chelsea did not exercise the Whistleblower Act.
- nxc18 10y agoPresident Obama inherited all of those "bad" things you mention. The real problem with all of those things is that they are politically impossible to roll back, unless the perceived cost exceeds the perceived benefit. Until your best friend ends up on a kill list, that isn't going to happen. Imagine the following scenario: President Obama ends NSA spying, kills the drone problem, gets rid of kill lists (and presumably also killing), and stops torture (the one and only useless thing on this list). Following that, any terrorism-related incident occurs. The right destroys him for weakening our country (as they are already doing regardless). The left destroys him for weakening our country. And the trick is, predator drones, kill lists, and presumably NSA spying (which will be even more useful with the newly announced inter-agency collaboration) all do help achieve our foreign policy goals (mostly dead terrorists). They also help achieve our domestic policy goals, which partially include not having lots of deployed soldiers dying. We can't even roll back the TSA, which is widely known to be useless, despite long waits, missed flights, thefts, bizarre restrictions, and all the other things people love about post-9/11 air travel. For better or worse (mostly for worse), "the American voter" does not care in the slightest about scary brown people being killed (usually deservedly) in a desert half a world away. President Obama is doing what the American people want, and right now that means commuting sentences, spying, and killing people in the desert.
- rayiner 10y ago> President Obama inherited all of those "bad" things you mention. I agree Obama is doing what the American people want, but he did not inherit all of these programs. E.g. he substantially expanded the program for drone strikes: http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2016/01/12/reflecting-on-obamas-presidency/obamas-embrace-of-drone-strikes-will-be-a-lasting-legacy http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2016/01/12/reflecting-o...
- Retra 10y agoDrone strike programs will expand everywhere for the foreseeable future, regardless of what Obama did. They're a nearly ideal weapon. There isn't a military on this planet that would not choose to employ them over almost any other tactic.
- bb611 10y agoI appreciate many of your points but this: > No one has the actual Pentagon Papers outside of very specific news agencies is patently false, they're available in full from the National Archives: https://www.archives.gov/research/pentagon-papers https://www.archives.gov/research/pentagon-papers There are very good arguments made elsewhere in this thread about releasing in full vs. releasing to a group that has the ability and willingness to appropriately vet documents before release. Certainly Wikileaks' blanket release caused a large amount of unnecessary controversy that could have been strategically avoided, and would have served as less distraction from the issues presented in them.
- austincheney 10y agoIt's not really whistle blowing though if you find evidence of 1 crime and then then choose to release 700,000 unrelated other documents with it. It is just a crime. During the trial the defense didn't even pretend that this was whistle blowing. Also, intention is relevant in criminal law. Was the intention to right a wrong or to throw a depression induced tantrum? There was a substantial amount of evidence on this matter.
- knodi123 10y ago> Chelsea will still have this conviction As if anybody will ever do a background check and say "gasp, you have a conviction".
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> I wish people would see this manipulation Is it really manipulation? Most/all world leaders have done a lot of good and a lot of bad. You can be angry at both the outgoing and incoming administration. There is no need to pick sides. Hopefully commuting this sentence will decrease any deterrence the administration has given to whistleblowers, because we need them to hold our governments accountable more than ever. Any checks and balances we think we have don't seem to be working.
- philliphaydon 10y agoManning will be released May this year tho. It's 35 years which includes time already served (7) and she was due for release in 2040.
- pbreit 10y agoWhat was chilling about the Hillary emails? They seemed quite inoffensive to me.
- NotSammyHagar 10y agoThe pentagon papers were released in 2011. A wikipedia search would have found the complete set at the national archives: https://www.archives.gov/research/pentagon-papers https://www.archives.gov/research/pentagon-papers. I believe they wanted to keep this secret not because it hurt us to leak some secret, it was to hide the fact that every president from Truman on had lied about their actions to get us more involved in vietnam. It's still pretty shocking today. Read the wikipedia page for more info. I don't think it will happen, but I'd be happy if Obama were somehow able to legally forgive Snowden for his whistle blowing also.