17 ms·
Obama Expands Surveillance Powers on His Way Out
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pawadu 10y agoSo same amount of information gathered but distributed among a larger group? Can't decide if this is good or bad.
- choward 10y agoI honestly can't tell if this is supposed to be sarcasm or not.
- pawadu 10y agoits not :) from what I understand intelligence agencies in some other countries work in this fashion: one agency does the "data gathering" and provides other agencies with information upon request. in theory, this means fewer agencies snooping in your private life and that there is some sort of gate keeper that limits circulation of data based on need-to-know. so back to my not sarcastic questions: is this a good or bad thing?
- tekism 10y agoI don't know but this sounds scary to me, we just went from threats to national security to any crime. However—and this is especially troubling—“if analysts stumble across evidence that an American has committed any crime, they will send it to the Justice Department,” the Times wrote. So information that was collected without a warrant—or indeed any involvement by a court at all—for foreign intelligence purposes with little to no privacy protections, can be accessed raw and unfiltered by domestic law enforcement agencies to prosecute Americans with no involvement in threats to national security."
- bbddg 10y agoThis is a horrible thing for privacy but would information collected this way even be admissible in court? They could use it to inform investigations but I think they would have a very hard time trying to use this information to prosecute.
- pawadu 10y agookay, fair point. I assume they still cant use the information in court but that really doesn't make it much better.
- HalcyonicStorm 10y agoI'm sure this is where parallel construction will come into play.
- tdb7893 10y agoHopefully larger awareness leads to more oversight
- fixxer 10y agoWell, are we surprised?
- adam12 10y agoI voted for Obama twice. I feel duped.
- nolepointer 10y agoThat should have been obvious to you before the 2012 election. But okay.
- tunap 10y agoI believe Obama's pick for VP was an obvious enough contradiction of his platform. Retaining Gates & Geitner solidified, IMO, "change" was not in the cards. Trump is an anomoly to the vetted & selected candidates we usually get to "elect", for better or worse. His cabinet picks hint at the latter, time(not the MSM) will tell.
- acjohnson55 10y agoI'm pissed, but I don't feel duped. But that's simply because no serious presidential contender, save maybe Bernie Sanders, would have done otherwise. Well, maybe Trump. But I believe his distrust of the intelligence community is only due to the fact that he thinks their findings regarding Russia undermine his legitimacy. Once that blows over, I expect he'll be more than happy having the authoritarian tools of the intelligence community, if he's smart enough to heal the rift. What blows my mind a bit is that the rise of Trump should make it crystal clear just how dangerous these powers could be in the wrong hands. Obama should understand this more than anyone.
- EGreg 10y agoRon Paul
- ordbajsare 10y ago"save maybe Bernie Sander" Pray for an asteroid! The strong will survive, and cunts like your will rot into forgotten memory.
- pavlov 10y ago
- intralizee 10y agoToo bad there isn't a focus on expanding the openness of how many rights are being violated by surveillance. I can understand why Obama is so pro surveillance. When you belong to the minority spectrum that has already made it past the point where surveillance will only help. I just wonder what minority is going to face more of a struggle to get to the point where Obama's minority now is in history.
- enlightenedfool 10y agoQuestion: In the last few years, how many such online petitions have resulted in some positive, effective action?
- str33t_punk 10y agoSOPA is the only one I can think of and then they rebranded it
- cwiggs 10y agoI would love to see some data on this. A lot of times people tell me that one way to solve social issues to get start some type of activism (march to the capital, start a rally in your town, etc). However, I haven't seen much data on the effectiveness of those things.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI would guess actually marching or attending a rally is much more effective than online petitions, because it shows people are already across the mobilization threshold. Implicit in a march at the capital is "This many people could be here with torches and guns". By contrast, people clicking online aren't very active.
- xorfish 10y agoPetition only work if there is actual political power behind them. There is at least one country that allows petitions to force a referendum on any law. Switzerland. Naturally such a system develops to a consensus democracy. The reason beeing that a group that is big enough can force a referendum on any law that is passed. So the laws that are passed are usually some sort of consensus.
- swanson 10y agoI had the same thought a few weeks ago (specifically about Change.org petitions). Here is a page I found that shows petitions that achieved some action: https://www.change.org/victories https://www.change.org/victories No idea on how many did not succeed.
- jessaustin 10y agoI guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right? Right?
- rayiner 10y agoThat's a bit of a straw man. Nobody says voting will get you the government you want. I can't get any of my liberal friends (core Hilary voters) to care about surveillance. To the extent they're nervous about surveillance as a general concept, they trust Obama has struck the balance necessitated by what he knows about threats to the country. Not everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting.
- eternalban 10y ago> Not everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting. That's funny. Reminded me of this: https://twitter.com/sinderbrand/status/819315489021325312 https://twitter.com/sinderbrand/status/819315489021325312
- dack 10y ago> If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting. There's still a big reason to vote: pick the candidate with the least amount of problems that has a chance of winning. But I do agree that voting is usually too-little-too-late if you don't already have the majority of voters knowing about your cause.
- r3bl 10y agoYes, in a classical two-party system, voting for lesser of two evils is the only option. But in the US, there's also the question in which state you live in. For example, there's no point voting Republican in California, nor Democrat in Texas.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y ago
- blauditore 10y agoBut why? I don't think Trump has a more privacy-oriented stance on surveillance, so what motivation does Obama have to still rush this in?
- auganov 10y agoWell unless proven otherwise I'd just assume it wasn't meant to be particularly political/strategic and leave it at that. The only potential "anti-Trump move" angle I can see is it directly empowers the intelligence community only. So if Obama is counting on a continued strained relationship between the Trump administration and the intelligence community insiders then this could be it. But I wouldn't personally believe it to be too likely.
- rayiner 10y agoObama is pro surveillance. Being President got rid of a lot of his initial idealism. Key was killing Osama, which probably cinched him a second term.
- jballanc 10y agoExcept that, as I understand it, Osama was tracked down using "good ol' fashion HumInt", not surveillance. Obama's attitude toward intelligence gathering has been one of the more perplexing contradictions of his entire administration. All I can figure is there is some trusted figure advising him on these matters who has an agenda of some sort.
- stefantalpalaru 10y ago> Osama was tracked down using "good ol' fashion HumInt", not surveillance It was actually diplomatic negotiation with the Pakistani government that held him prisoner: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v37/n10/seymour-m-hersh/the-killing-of-osama-bin-laden http://www.lrb.co.uk/v37/n10/seymour-m-hersh/the-killing-of-...
- joering2 10y agoI wish it was all conspiracy theory (just like NSA registering your calls, right?) but ibn Laden is known to be death somewhere around 2003 due to kidney failure. He had very serious health issues for many years - sort of issues you most likely die even when taken care of by best doctors in west hospitals, not in caves somewhere in remote mountains in Afghanistan. Its a matter of time. Shapiro proved Obama birth certificate is fraudulent fake [1] and we know from gossips the photo op from ibn Laden capture was fake (then convenience bury at seat with no photos and whole team 6 conveniently dying on helicopter crash) - its a matter of time when someone somewhere is going to prove it. [1] http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/apr/27/obamas-birth-certificate-proves-america-782351195/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/apr/27/obamas-birth...
- akerro 10y agoWO WO WO WO Look how bad Trump is!
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments.
- divineihr 10y agoHow about mods stop auto banning new accounts?
- beenshadowbnd 10y agoAll my comments are auto killed they aren't even posted and killed they don't make it past your fascist filtersCan't be too classy when you're complicit in torture by refusing to enforce it's prosecution, be on watch while your military commits war crimes or hell, be at war every day of your 8 year watch. Real classy for a warmongering mass murderer. Oh and kill lists, super classy stuff. People who call Obama classy are clueless.
- outlace 10y agoAs an ordinary citizen, I'm definitely wary and suspicious of government surveillance. I probably prefer a slightly increased risk of terrorism vs an increase in government surveillance powers. But I wonder if I was the president and faced with a constant threat and paranoia of a terrorist attack under my watch if I would compromise my own usual ideals to protect the country. It's definitely a rock and a hard place situation.
- skylan_q 10y agoAn option: Stop immigration from places that are prone to terrorist attacks happening and then you won't have to give up nearly as much privacy in the name of fighting terror at home.
- pjc50 10y agoThe 9/11 hijackers were mostly on tourist visas from a place with almost no history of terror attacks: http://www.fairus.org/issue/identity-and-immigration-status-of-9-11-terrorists http://www.fairus.org/issue/identity-and-immigration-status-... And of course most deaths from terrorism in the US are from "mass shooters", who tend to be self-radicalised US nationals with fringe political beliefs.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The 9/11 hijackers were mostly on tourist visas from a place with almost no history of terror attacks: Your source (correctly) says they were mostly from Saudi Arabia, which has a rather extensive history over several decades of terrorist attacks (both attacks in Saudi Arabia, and attackers outside of Saudi Arabia by Saudi nationals and/or with Saudi sponsors.) There is no sense in which Saudi Arabia is (or could be fairly described in 2001 as) "a place with almost no history of terror attacks."
- BeetleB 10y agoPrior to 2001, it had a very low history. Two bombings in the country in the 90's. UAE had no history.
- artursapek 10y ago> However—and this is especially troubling—“if analysts stumble across evidence that an American has committed any crime, they will send it to the Justice Department,” the Times wrote. So information that was collected without a warrant—or indeed any involvement by a court at all—for foreign intelligence purposes with little to no privacy protections, can be accessed raw and unfiltered by domestic law enforcement agencies to prosecute Americans with no involvement in threats to national security. Sweet, Thanks Obama.
- jcadam 10y agoI'm not sure I like your tone, comrade. What are you hiding?
- Roboprog 10y agoNot much, apparently :-) Oh, and we noticed that you got gas here, then had something to eat there, and there were only N minutes elapsed between them. Here is your speeding ticket and DMV record update notification.
- andrei_says_ 10y agoOnly a matter of time ;)
- javiramos 10y agoI feel like we are a living example of history repeating itself. 9/11 -> hysteria -> implement fear-driven tactics -> suppress rights -> profit. I believe Obama has a created a fantastic movement based on his image and figure - classic American self-superation story. But when you dig into the details of the Obama years you can quickly see that he has been a gigantic letdown in a lot of basic things that I feel are important to the long-term well-being of the country (e.g. privacy rights, drone foreign policy etc.). In the end, I think Obama didn't end up being too different from any other politician.
- ocdtrekkie 10y ago
- HugoDaniel 10y ago"We kill people based on metadata"[0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdQiz0Vavmc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdQiz0Vavmc
- stefantalpalaru 10y agoIt's worse. They use algorithms to designate targets. Algorithms that don't usually get bug reports or bug fixes: http://arstechnica.co.uk/security/2016/02/the-nsas-skynet-program-may-be-killing-thousands-of-innocent-people/ http://arstechnica.co.uk/security/2016/02/the-nsas-skynet-pr...
- thatwebdude 10y agoThe first time I heard this, it really struck me. Still gives me chills a bit thinking how inexplicably I could have matched meta data to people on a list they're actively seeking.
- pjc50 10y agoIt sounds fourth amendment activists need to learn from second amendment activists and develop a bloc of voters for whom this is a key issue.
- vibrio 10y agoI completely agree with your sentiment, but privacy is a bit harder to sell--guns are badass and cool to collect, privacy is geeky and suspicious. Another key difference is that the second amendment is big business (Smith Ruger & co stock went up >500% during Obama). There are big businesses that could get behind anti-encryption, but mass appeal is more difficult- perhaps at least until something spectacular happens.
- jff 10y agoSecond Amendment supporters are often interested in the Fourth as well; I think you would find a very solid group of them (particularly those who concealed-carry, rather than just hunters) are strongly opposed to this sort of thing.
- vibrio 10y agoAgreed that there is a spectrum of second amendment supporters even amongst my acquaintances. "What should be do about Snowden?"is a conversation that can be fun to start over beers with mixed company.
- xaa 10y agoRight. I live in Oklahoma which has...a strong 2nd Amendment contingent. The OK state government is taking a lot of heat from the federal government for refusing to implement the Real ID requirements for state DLs. I'm not a conservative, but I can see the reasoning behind it: they know very well that this is one important step towards building a national database of personal information (or more likely, augmenting one that already exists). Actually, I have found more on the right concerned about privacy, government surveillance, etc, than on the left because this concern naturally meshes with the right's "small federal government" stance. Remember how Social Security numbers were "just for Social Security -- not any kind of personal identifier"? But perhaps the left, which has just as much ability to be hypocritical as the right, will see the light starting...oh, say, 12pm on January 20.
- benmcnelly 10y agoThis is a bad time to be a liberal. Let me explain. On nearly the eve of handing over the country to Trump, Obama is laying the groundwork for policy that has huge potential to be abused. I am confused, because if anything you would think he would do the opposite, but I refuse to believe it was done to give him a noose to hang himself, but why? Why is it a bad time to be a liberal? Because there is a good chance you will disagree with a lot of upcoming policy. But with this in place, criticizing your government or standing against tyranny could make you a target, one that is now easier than ever to trudge through an archive of your online life for anything remotely wrong, and prosecute you, retroactively, for it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- piffey 10y agoThis is a thought exercise, not my opinion as it's too complex/conspiracy theory-ish and more the plot of a Tom Clancy novel, but what if Obama is expanding the power and handing the reins over to intelligence groups that Trump has sidelined? The NSA/CIA are fantastic at collapsing and running foreign governments -- why not ours?
- rudolf0 10y agoThat is an interesting thought. We do know Obama (like most presidents) is pretty cozy with the Intelligence Community. We know Trump isn't. I think a coup d'etat or shadow government is too much of a stretch, but this may at least let them work around Trump to an extent. Also, we're living in interesting times where thoughts like "the intelligence agencies are covertly trying to work around the President!" are actually considered a neutral or good thing by many.
- chris11 10y agoI've heard rumors that a decent number of people will resign from their jobs in the Intelligence Community. This will allow Trump to appoint more political employees. I don't know if this is true or not, but Trump's relationship with those agencies might get less hostile.
- throw2016 10y agoif it doesn't ensure accountability to the people its not democracy. There is now enough evidence that democracy is not serving the people and is increasingly looking like posturing and tokenism every 4 or 5 years while vested and special interests lobby everyday and capture the regulatory framework to further their interests. It has all the underpinnings of a ruling class. Inspite of the Snowden revelations nothing has changed, no one is punished and folks like Clapper lie and get promoted. Obama may posture differently but he is the biggest supporter of security services and given his behavior against Syria and Russia an unrepentant warmonger. Bankers tank the economy and are rewarded with bailouts in a country that worships capitalism and hates unearned benefits. And they get away lightly with attorney generals in one state after another unwilling to prosecute and more keen on fines which do not ensure any kind of proportional accountability. This is not democracy as we understand it. 4 or 5 years is too long and there must be multiple processes along the way to ensure things are on track. Things like lobbying, revolving doors, political corruption and abuse of power, corporate interests over public interest and critical decisions around fundamental rights and war must be strongly secured with laws and processes that work.
- throw7 10y agoHe didn't care on the way in, why would he care on the way out? He voted for warrantless wiretapping.
- jimnotgym 10y agoWelcome to our dystopian future In the UK Teresa May just passed the 'Snoopers Charter'(Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act) which is at least as bad as this. Agencies like the 'Food standards agency', and 'Health and safety executive' now have powers to read your browsing history without a warrant. Somehow this is supposed to stop terrorism? Now we have the 'Digital Economy bill' which is where the UK's 'Great Firewall' begins under the guise of protecting our children from porn. Its Orwellian and it is disgusting. What is worst is how the press ignored it and the Corbyn opposition abstained from voting on it! I will never vote for a politician who did not vote against it, and that is a very small number!
- dmix 10y agoConsidering EU's various proclamations against surveillance had zero effect on any of this it's probably good that Brexit happened. The problem will be easier to solve internally with a smaller government without the baggage of having to solve France/Germany's security problems thanks to EU open borders. Whether or not the people care is then the primary question. Who knows, maybe the youth today will be the ones who realize that judicial oversight over law enforcement and intel agencies was a good thing.
- angry-hacker 10y agoWho were the brave ones? Small players? UKIP?
- nvarsj 10y agoLibDems and SNP.
- _greim_ 10y agoThe effect of an attack like 9/11 is primarily nationalistic outrage, and a subsequent power-grab by whichever parties or individuals conduct their politics accordingly. Now ask yourself, which parties and/or individuals in American politics stand to benefit most from being handed a Mount-Everest-sized pile of nationalistic outrage, should another 9/11 level event occur? How much power would they try to grab? What would be the outcome for the US, and the world for that matter? Obama isn't acting on ideals, he's choosing a path in an ugly world.
- autobahnaccrs 10y agoApparently citing facts that are critical of Obama results in auto shadow banningCan't be too classy when you're complicit in torture by refusing to enforce it's prosecution, be on watch while your military commits war crimes or hell, be at war every day of your 8 year watch. Real classy for a warmongering mass murderer. Oh and kill lists, super classy stuff. People who call Obama classy are clueless.
- beenshadowbnd 10y agoMy comments are systemically removed from hacker news because they are critical or the government.
- grzm 10y agoWhat are other accounts you've used in the past? Given the language of your other comment[0], I suspect you've been banned for being uncivil and perhaps only discussing politics, which is not the intent of HN. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13392911 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13392911 You can also contact the mods directly via email using the Contact link in the footer. That would likely be more effective than posting comments like this.
- shadbnd22 10y agoI've been banned many times for many reasons mostly they are silly, once I got banned for 'generic' views. Today being critical of Obama gets you auto banned It's classic case of mods controlling the conversation to be more pro Government. It's seen they allow sock puppets and allow upvotinf manipulation and flagging to support a pro government narrative.
- sctb 10y agoI'm sorry, but creating new accounts just to violate the guidelines isn't OK. The bar for participation on Hacker News is civility and substantiveness. We've detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13392542 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13392542. https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ienndbnf 10y agoMy accounts have been banned before they violated guidelines, they've been banned for reasons not in the guidelines, seriously review some reasons why you and other mods ban accounts, they don't always match up. You control the narrative here to be less critical of the Government.
- didibus 10y agoEverybody in this thread should explain why they think what they are saying. I don't really know much about what Obama did or did not, but I'm not saying anyone providing me that information, just a bunch of people taking about their opinions. So I'd really appreciate if people could share their reasons for them.
- random_upvoter 10y agoIs there anyone left who actually believes that it's Obama who makes these decisions? I find it amazing that nobody looks at Obama's insipid presidency as the main explanation for Trump's election. When Trump says "Russia? Everybody spies on us!", that resonates with people because they know it is the truth and no other politician says it so openly and so bluntly.
- gumby 10y ago> "if analysts stumble across evidence that an American has committed any crime, they will send it to the Justice Department" This is troubling on many levels, but the one that concerns me the most is game theory. We want people to pay taxes on criminal activity (because it's economic activity and uses services taxes pay for) without the tax authorities "narcing" on the source. IRS is doing the right think by not leaking Trump's tax info even if people within the IRS think the public have a legitimate right to know. You are required to look after your kids yet you can drop off a baby you can't look after, no questions asked. Hospitals have to treat patients no matter if they can pay or not, and no matter if they became ill due to criminal behavior because we don't want people with tuberculosis or Hep C wandering around (not to mention presumption of innocence). Every time we add a "mandatory reporter" rule we actually endanger ourselves, so we should tread carefully.
- deavmi 10y agoGood.