6 ms·
..."other tools of persuasion" like posing as your own fan on message boards to defend and flatter yourself, after you're criticized for claiming that women are
by DonHopkins 10y ago
..."other tools of persuasion" like posing as your own fan on message boards to defend and flatter yourself, after you're criticized for claiming that women are "treated differently by society for exactly the same reason that children and the mentally handicapped are treated differently. It’s just easier this way for everyone."
http://comicsalliance.com/scott-adams-plannedchaos-sockpuppet/ http://comicsalliance.com/scott-adams-plannedchaos-sockpuppe...
Scott Adams, talking about Scott Adams in the third person, while pretending not to be Scott Adams:
- [0] plannedchaos -21 points 4 months ago
If an idiot and a genius disagree, the idiot generally thinks the genius is wrong. He also has a lot of idiot reasons to back his idiot belief. That's how the idiot mind is wired.
It's fair to say you disagree with Adams. But you can't rule out the hypothesis that you're too dumb to understand what he's saying.
And he's a certified genius. Just sayin'.
- swanson 10y agoI won't defend those actions. I just got a chuckle about this comment since it's an ad hominem -- not rational, but rather designed to appeal to emotion ("I'm mad about him doing that") or identify ("I'm an advocate for women"). Meanwhile, the rest of this thread devolves to pedantry about definitions and analogies. Good persuasion :)
- sctb 10y agoControversial threads have way more escape energy than others, and this subthread has definitely left topical orbit. We've detached it from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13382789 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13382789 and marked it off-topic.
- Chris2048 10y agoYou could argue that sock-puppeting defeats/is an antidote to Argumentum ad populum, and is as such a valid tactic. In this case also, it would be seen as arrogant to tell someone they aren't smart enough to understand your argument, but not so with a third party, i.e. maybe it's appropriate for playing devils advocate informally. That said, he was also antagonizing if using "idiot", rather than being more polite himself. If he spoke through his own handle, he might have cared more about civility.
- skylan_q 10y agoGood job. This is an example of falling into the 3rd category and not the first.
- DonHopkins 10y agoActually, there is a fourth category just for people like Scott Adams, that he neglected to mention.
- hashkb 10y ago4. Machiavellian Princes?
- marcosdumay 10y agoPersuasive trolls? One of the later 1% that does not even care what he's persuading people about. Just plays the game for fun.
- tw04 10y agoThe "certified genius" is a rabid Trump supporter. Nuff said.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThat guy won an election where more than half of the people didn't even see him coming. Why do people insist there are no smart people working on his campaign?
- hirsin 10y agoGoalposts a galloping. His team might have smart people on it, that does not make the people who voted for him smart.
- dashundchen 10y agoScott Adams is also a MRA who equates being a woman with being mentally handicapped. http://comicsalliance.com/scott-adam-sexist-mens-rights/ http://comicsalliance.com/scott-adam-sexist-mens-rights/ He is a climate change denier with the senseless circular reasoning, that if he can't understand the science of climate change himself, why should he ever trust climate scientists and other experts in the field, because their models are complicated. https://twitter.com/ScottAdamsSays/status/814133681711263744 https://twitter.com/ScottAdamsSays/status/814133681711263744 Later in the thread, when presented with any scientific explanation of climate change, he reverts to repeating "how can I trust it?", all the while accusing climate scientists of having a financial incentive to push climate change, not providing proof himself.
- Chris2048 10y ago> who equates being a woman with being mentally handicapped Literally, or he just used a metaphor? I can say "black people are like bowling balls, they are both black". You could respond "oh my god! black people are people, not objects! How dare you!" But this would not be a reasonable response - The implication of the metaphor was not that black people share the property of being an object. That would be a purposeful mis-interpretation. Granted, the use of metaphor can sometimes be suspect, precisely because of the ambiguity of implication, but that's all it is - ambiguous in meaning/intent.
- mistermann 10y agoI don't think he is a denier, I honestly believe he is poking fun at the supremely confident masses who are absolutely sure climate change is precisely as the scientists say, and that anyone that disagress in the slightest is a denier/idiot/whatever. He also happens to be correct, the general public doesn't understand the intricacies of climate change. I'm no denier either, but you'll have to pardon me if I choose to not join the unthinking hordes who insist we must do something now, and no we will not think while we are doing this. Dissension is explicitly not allowed. Oh, is that not exaaaaaaaaaaaactly what the message is? Of course not, but there is some truth there. There are highly trained scientists who don't fully support the party line, and they are not allowed to speak. I believe it is not an intellectually honest conversation, and I'm old enough to remember other situations where dissent was not allowed and it turned out not so good. Also, don't forget that Scott is a humorist author, and part of his schtick is to deliberately cause outrage, especially with people who take themselves way too seriously.
- arethuza 10y agoNow you have me trying to combine this categorization with Sociopath|Clueless|Loser...