10 ms·
How an 89-year-old cold warrior became America’s nuclear conscience
- saboot 10y agoI encourage everyone concerned about nuclear weapon safety to watch the Jan 10 premiere of the documentary version of Eric Schlosser's book "Command and Control" http://www.commandandcontrolfilm.com/ http://www.commandandcontrolfilm.com/
- arethuza 10y agoInteresting coincidence that the one place it has been shown in the UK was Sheffield: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threads https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threads
- tartuffe78 10y agoI'd say because of desensitization to a world (apparently) in constant crisis.
- cableshaft 10y agoThis. The news has tried to make us panic about literally everything for decades now, and it's getting a little tiring to be afraid or outraged of something 24/7. It's the Two Minutes Hate, stretched out to all day long, provided by the media, not the government.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoAnd that's because you did not listen to George Kennan.
- jseliger 10y agoI am: https://jakeseliger.com/2016/11/28/trump-fears-and-the-nuclear-apocalypse/ https://jakeseliger.com/2016/11/28/trump-fears-and-the-nucle... and when I tell others why they just look at me strangely. I hope they're right and I'm wrong.
- eternalban 10y agoYou know, I haven't drank the "kek" koolaid and given Mr. Trump's historic cozy relations with the mob (Roy Cohn, Casinos), his strange manner of draining swamps by filling it with the worst sort of toxic sludge from Wall Street, and his irrational and excessive love for Israel ("they will [never] pay for it"), am not willing to suspend disbelief regarding his being yet another distraction for the citizenry of this nation by the moneyed class, but you start off with: "In a best-case Trump scenario, he bumbles around for four years doing not much except embarrassing himself and the country." This guy does not have a history of bumbling around. He seems to be quite an effective man of action. I think you "embarrass" yourself by starting an analysis with that paragraph. Then a bit down below you say: "It can be fun to have secret, unchecked powers when your guy is in office, but is incredibly dangerous when the other guy does." It can be "fun" to have leadership with "unchecked power"? Man, get over your totalitarian urges before you decide to play cassandra for the rest of us who do not think it "fun" at all, under any circumstances, to have leaders with "secret unchecked powers" in our Republic. [fix minor typos]
- okreallywtf 10y agoWell hey, the right was terrified of Obama and he turned out to not be that bad so its basically the same thing right? The world is grey and fears about Trump are only as legitimate as fears about Obama and are all equally founded. /s
- wavefunction 10y agoThat's a false equivalency to be sure. Right wingers were afraid of what they claimed President Obama would pursue in policy. Critics of President-Elect Trump are fearful of _his own stated policies._
- okreallywtf 10y agoI was being sarcastic, not sure if /s was sufficient to flag it, I can't quite tell from your response. I agree and I've tried to explain that to my conservative friends and co-workers but it never quite makes it through. Because Sharia law and death-panels never came to be a lot of them feel fine in brushing off my concerns about Trump, despite the complete false equivalency between the two.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoI'm not terrified because I don't think Bill Perry is really terrified either, in his own words from the article: >“I do not think it is a probability this year or next year or anytime in the foreseeable future. But the consequence is so great, we have to take it seriously. And there are things to greatly lower those possibilities that we’re simply not doing.” A nuclear catastrophe, statistically, poses a much lower risk to my well being than tornado season. Also occasional flash flooding, especially while driving. Oh, and extremely dry summers with little rain that make for wildfire conditions. Also, there's heat stroke if I'm being active...I guess what I mean is I do believe, deep down, that there are people who genuinely care and will work on such serious matters. Serious people who take things seriously. I applaud them and hope my tax dollars support them appropriately, public and/or private sector. Sort of like geologists working to study the devastating potential of fault lines or volcanic activity. After seeing what extreme weather can do, and how resilient the US population seems to be, I'm honestly grateful to not have to have "Duck and Cover" as part of my everyday psyche.
- saboot 10y agoDid you read the entire article? He makes a point to discuss expectation values as the metric to judge the seriousness of addressing a nuclear event, not the statistical probability value > Perry wishes more people were familiar with the concept of “expected value.” That is a statistical way of understanding events of very large magnitude that have a low probability. The large magnitude event could be something good, like winning a lottery ticket. Or it could be something bad, like a nuclear bomb exploding. Because the odds of winning the lottery are so low, the rational thing is to save your money and not buy the ticket. As for a nuclear explosion, by Perry’s lights, the consequences are so grave that the rational thing would be for people in the United States and everywhere to be in a state of peak alarm about their vulnerability, and for political debate to be dominated by discussion of how to reduce the risk.
- mcguire 10y agoExpected value breaks down with what I like to think of as the Pascal's wager fallacy: if you consider the consequences effectively infinite, any positive probability means you should think about nothing else. It took a long time to get to the article's actual suggestions (eliminate all ICBMS?); until that, this was just fear mongering.
- tedunangst 10y agoWell, you see, it's possible, even likely, that there will be at least some survivors, so therefore nuclear war is a trivial concern compared to AI.
- jat850 10y agoAm I understanding your comment correctly that you are more afraid of AI than nuclear war?
- tedunangst 10y agoThe basilisk is coming! We need to build it before it gets here. But more seriously, low grade poorly trained sub intelligent AI seems a lot more likely to fuck up a lot more people's lives than nuclear Armageddon.
- codingdave 10y agoI think people are worried. But we have a split personality these days, of what is visible online and in the media vs. us older silent generations. The younger generation is more vocal online, and they are not as worried. I could speculate about how they did not grow up in the cold war, blah, blah, blah, whatever the reason is... but their lack of worry is more visible online and in the media. All the while, myself and my friends in our 40s and 50s are all worried. But we also all grew up in constant fear of it, so it is the same comfortable worry from our childhood, and we shrug it off instead of freaking out.
- daly 10y agoI have tried many times to get in touch with this effort without success. How can I help? There is an interesting movie called "Threads", a BBC drama by Barry Hines. Be sure to watch it.
- EdSharkey 10y agoWe (the US and allies) have been smacking the middle East hornet's nest for 25 years through invasions, occupations, dictator toppling, drone striking, antagonizing allies (Israel), antagonizing adversaries (Russia vis a vis Ukraine and now a half-assed proxy war efforts in Syria following the laughable "Russian reset"). Foreign policy hubris and fecklessness combined. And NOW suddenly we're supposed to be afraid of a total nuclear war? Don't insult my intelligence.
- zbyte64 10y agoIt is not your intelligence that is being questioned but the President-elect.
- specialist 10y agoAgree about the hubris, fecklessness. I've been terrified of nuclear war, terrorism, accidents, pollution since I can remember. Don't pretend this is a new concern.
- EdSharkey 10y agoExactly my point, excuse me if I wasn't clear: these things you list are not new concerns. I simply bristle at the notion that I should suddenly live in fear because a carnival barker I don't like just won an election. The US federal government has been a hot mess since the early 1900's. NOW I'm suddenly supposed to be alarmed? I consider anyone who suggests we should grow the federal government in its current configuration to be a busybody or a fool, sorry to be blunt. In my opinion, return power to the states or GTFO. For me to live in fear of things I can't control is not living. I refuse to snivel. When I can make a positive impact in my sphere, I try to do that; sorry I can't do any better.
- okreallywtf 10y agoI feel it is worth point out some of the terrifying close calls [1] that we've had in the last decades with nuclear weapons. Some people are so sure that because personal experience indicates that it hasn't happened that that is any indications of its likelihood of happening. By all accounts we have this man [2] to thank for at least one of those incidents not resulting in total nuclear apocalypse. [1] http://www.ucsusa.org/nuclear-weapons/hair-trigger-alert/close-calls#.WG-0mfkrJhE http://www.ucsusa.org/nuclear-weapons/hair-trigger-alert/clo... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov
- mikeash 10y agoThat doesn't even mention my "favorite" one, when Soviet submarine B-59 was intercepted by American ships during the Cuban Missile Crisis. The submarine had been out of contact for days and had no idea if a war had started. It carried a nuclear torpedo which required the authorization of three people to launch. Two of those people wanted to use it. The third, Vasili Arkhipov, was opposed, and managed to talk them down. If Arkhipov had been in a bad mood that day (maybe he missed his morning coffee or something) the world could have ended up looking very different. (This was before MAD was fully in place, so in the worst case outcome the US still would have survived the resulting conflict largely intact. Europe and the USSR would have been pretty much obliterated, though.)
- credit_guy 10y agoI know the story, and I don't really buy it. Exactly what happened between Arkhipov, Savitsky and Maslennikov will never be known. However, the premise that they didn't know if war had broken out or not is very shaky: the fact that the US Navy was using depth charges and not torpedoes on them was quite a clear message that they were not in "shoot to kill" mode. The wikipedia page on depth charges [1] explains the Cold War usage: "During the Cold War when it was necessary to inform submarines of the other side that they had been detected but without actually launching an attack, low-power "signalling depth charges" (also called "practice depth charges") were sometimes used, powerful enough to be detected when no other means of communication was possible, but not destructive." [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depth_charge#Signaling https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depth_charge#Signaling
- whack 10y agoTBH, I don't fear nuclear war with a nation like Russia or China anytime soon. Neither country has a deathwish or a desire to end the world. What does really scare me is the possibility of a terrorist attack involving nukes. A dirty bomb that goes off anywhere in the downtown of a major city. I'm glad that this hasn't happened in the past 10 years, but that isn't a very long time. Given the pace of technology, and the inevitable slipups that will happen, the cynic in me thinks it's only a matter of time. http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/10/opinion/a-nuclear-9-11.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/10/opinion/a-nuclear-9-11.htm...
- maxxxxx 10y agoCan't cite any papers by I have read somewhere that a "dirty bomb" is not really possible or would affect only a very small area.
- snrplfth 10y agoThe point of a dirty bomb is less so the actual effects of the radiation, and moreso the impression it gives and the fear it generates. The public is not easily reassured that an area that's been deliberately contaminated with radioactive particles has been sufficiently cleaned up to return. It's the doubt and uncertainty that really counts. And they are quite doable as weapons - it just takes some careful preparation and handling, and access to some mildly expensive materials.
- cr0sh 10y ago> it just takes some careful preparation and handling, and access to some mildly expensive materials. I'm not even sure that's necessary, if all you want to do is create terror...? For instance, read about David Hahn (aka, the "Nuclear Boy Scout") who recently passed away (of what, they don't say): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hahn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hahn He managed to contaminate his neighborhood using almost nothing but smoke detector components. How difficult would it be to collect smoke detector parts? You can easily find them used for cheap or free at garage sales and thrift stores. If there were a concerted effort to acquire the parts using only cash, it wouldn't take very long to gather up enough of the material... ...at that point, you just need the delivery device, and we all know that isn't difficult to procure or produce (all the parts can be easily bought at Walmart). TBH, I'm surprised it hasn't happened yet; as a terrorist weapon, it wouldn't matter that it didn't cause mass death via radiation poisoning (not in the near term at least), but that it has the perception to do so. At the very least, it would make people less likely to visit the "hot zone" left over afterward (in a financially important city area it might lead to economic problems).
- rbanffy 10y agoThe sinking feeling you get when you think you dodged a bullet and realize it's actually a very determined smart bomb who really, really wants to be with you...
- pidloopy 10y agoThe article I think specifies an important aspect to the world security situation that we must keep in mind constantly. It's worth adding context to the article, which breezes past some controversial bits maybe a bit too easily: for instance it writes "how to maximize the fearsome deterrent power of the U.S. arsenal, how to minimize the possibility that the old Soviet arsenal would obliterate the United States and much of the planet along the way". This places the blame of mutually assured destruction and global thermonuclear war, almost entirely on the Soviet Union. The US's nuclear deterrent is "fearsome". The Soviet Union has an "arsenal" (not a deterrent?), which would obliterate the whole planet. I'm sure the author didn't intend to do this, but he's contributing to the problem. The United States and Russia - as well as other nuclear powers - are partners in a dialogue. They share responsibility for the outcomes of the security situation, and for avoiding falling into security dilemmas. One can deeply criticize America for the nuclear security situation we are today, as it has done by far the most to weaken the now-stalled nuclear arms agreements (START, etc) that had once been in place. (This of course doesn't meet the bar for the article). When both sides start by accusing one another, they have to work back to a position where they can find common ground. When both sides are realistic, and accept their own blame there's a place to work from. For instance - it should not be controversial for an American to accept that the Soviet Union had a nuclear deterrent during the Cold War and to call it by such. Similarly we should accept that the US has a nuclear arsenal today (the US is a nuclear first-strike nation by policy) that, if used, would destroy most of the world. Much of the rest of the piece is similarly written with an undercurrent of us versus them, with "them" getting the lionshare of the blame even though it does not cohere with history. If you start the conversation with us versus them, you start the conversation with zero-sum mentality: the type of pitfall that led to the Cold War and its escalation to begin with. There is no good versus evil. Other nations have National Security interests too. Do the god damn hard work to deconflict as much of this as possible. Do the god damn hard work to build and maintain transparent dialog. Do the god damn hard work to eliminate strategic surprise, and the possibility for strategic surprise. And in the meantime, stop pointing fingers.
- baybal2 10y ago>Who wins in a nuclear war? The one who attacks first
- daltonlp 10y agoThat's certainly not true. The fundamental "strategy" of the cold war, specifically the production of ~70,000 nuclear weapons, was about ensuring that no aggressor would survive. Submarine-launched missles are the primary tactic.