24 ms·
I've removed all ad network code from my blog
- yuvadam 10y agoKudos for removing all 3rd party scripts, not only ad networks. As builders of web systems, we need to be conscious of which 3rd parties are gaining access to private user data. There's no reason in hell any Google or Facebook widget should be embedded in my health care providers website, yet somehow that's a thing. Any other website is usually even worse. I personally use NoScript with whitelisted scripts when I know I need them, else I am protected by default. This shouldn't be required, especially for users who have no idea about these scripts and what they actually do. Fuck that.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoHe hasn't removed all third party scripts. A quick check shows Google Analytics and Disqus (which uses an iframe), there is also some webfont stuff going on.
- thejosh 10y agofacebook as well...
- d2p 10y agoFacebook is actually coming via Disqus! See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13338841 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13338841 https://blog.dantup.com/2017/01/visiting-a-site-that-uses-disqus-comments-when-not-logged-in-sends-the-url-to-facebook/ https://blog.dantup.com/2017/01/visiting-a-site-that-uses-di...
- tapirl 10y ago> we need to be conscious of which 3rd parties are gaining access to private user data. Many big websites are hosted on IaaS services, such as AWS. The IaaS providers know most of your activities, without your awareness.
- zer0gravity 10y agoCommodity has its price. Move fast and disregard all privacy isn't always an option, especially if you care about a certain moral hygene. But who cares in the post-truth epoch right ?
- monatron 10y agoI find a lot of value in federated login through Google and Facebook. I'd rather have the hardest parts of authentication handled by their services than relying on thousands of different developers rolling their own solutions with varying levels of sanity.
- criddell 10y agoWhy do blogs need readers to log in?
- saint_fiasco 10y agoSo commenters have to go through a registration process before commenting. It makes moderation easier.
- pmlnr 10y ago> It makes moderation easier. This is why there is no spam on self-hosted WordPress. Oh, wait.
- monatron 10y agothis was in response to: > As builders of web systems, we need to be conscious of which 3rd parties are gaining access to private user data. There's no reason in hell any Google or Facebook widget should be embedded in my health care providers website, yet somehow that's a thing. Any other website is usually even worse.
- pweissbrod 10y agoThe advertisement he refers to was a plain text bar at the top of the page with no tracking nor any distracting visuals. And when you scroll down into the article it disappears. I dont see any problem with this kind of innocent unobtrusive level of advertising and frankly wish he kept it for his own financial gain and others used it as a model.
- GordonS 10y agoHe still has this sponsorship message (which I am also totally fine with), but it seems to be blocked by uBlock Origin, if you are using that?
- jmgordon 10y agoWith uBlock Origin I was able to see the sponsorship message by clicking the "Toggle cosmetic filtering for this site" button.
- NoGravitas 10y agoI'm using uBlock Origin; after the previous article was published, I whitelisted this site.
- hoorayimhelping 10y agoDaring Fireball has similar curated, unobtrusive ads. This is the ideal ad-sponsored content, but it seems like it takes a very large audience to be viable and worth the time.
- Grue3 10y agoAnd I didn't even notice it before I saw the screenshot in the blog post that shows how it should look like. I scrolled back to the top, and there it was! The click through rates on that thing are probably terrible.
- fiatjaf 10y agoOk, you have a sponsorship model that works because you're probably very famous. That doesn't solve anyone's problem, because almost no one is famous. How can we replace ad networks with something better and saner?
- yoz-y 10y agoI had an idea at some point, but I do not know it if would be feasible. For me it seems that sponsorships/native ads are better than the usual banner style intrusive ads. Would it be possible to still have a syndicated ad network, but that it would feed you articles in some structured format, that you would get on your backend, and then insert as articles into your blog/website? This way you could format them any way you want. Of course the payment model would have to shift from displays to something like overall performance of the ads (by scanning outbound clicks and associating them with purchases) and pay by month. And some policing in order to avoid stuff like getting the ad from the network and never actually displaying it.
- blauditore 10y agoWhat you describe sounds similar to affiliate marketing [1]: Post a link to external services and get commission for clicks (maybe depending on conversion). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affiliate_marketing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affiliate_marketing
- yoz-y 10y agoBut in the case of affiliate marketing you get the links and as content creator you create the ad copy. What I was thinking was kind of an automation of these kind of posts: http://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/12/23/storyworth http://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/12/23/storyworth Or some other way to deliver ads with copy and images, but through the backend. (that way the website author has complete power on what an ad actually can do on their website)
- sirclueless 10y ago
- pcora 10y agoYes! 100 times yes! Great move. I am not against ads. But I am against trackers. Wanna show an ad on your mysite.com ? then host the freaking file on mysite.com/assets/banner.{png,jpg,gif,whatever). but don't host it on ad networks. Those are blocked by my browser and I will not unblock. Its for the ad networks to figure out a way to fix the way they see the numbers. specially since the numbers are all wrong anyway. lets face it. you have no idea who visits your website nowadays. g analytics is a mess.
- pcora 10y agoThis is a very honest and upfront article about analytics: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160915/18183535533/traffic-is-fake-audience-numbers-are-garbage-nobody-knows-how-many-people-see-anything.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160915/18183535533/traff...
- ambirex 10y agoExcept that he is still using Disqus, which is free to use because they have moved to ad supported model (for the most part). Even if he isn't running the ads, they are using the script to track users across sites and then feeding that into ad networks.
- dbg31415 10y agoAn alternative to Disqus. * Discourse || https://www.discourse.org/ https://www.discourse.org/ * Embedding Discourse Comments via Javascript - howto - Discourse Meta || https://meta.discourse.org/t/embedding-discourse-comments-via-javascript/31963 https://meta.discourse.org/t/embedding-discourse-comments-vi... EDIT: Love the instant downvotes without any comments on why. Downvotes are totally helpful and not the least bit petty and stupid. I have 2 client using Discourse on their production sites and it works great.
- icebraining 10y agoDunno why you were downvoted. I dislike Discourse, but it's open source, and even the hosted version has a business model not based on ads.
- dustinmoris 10y agoDidn't down vote you, but I very much dislike Discourse. It is sold to be a better forum/discussion system, but it feels very unpleasant to use. They tried to break things just for the sake of breaking. Like having an endless scroll instead of paging is driving me nuts. I hate endless scroll, this is the most anti pattern that exists on the web probably.
- dbg31415 10y agoHmm, so that's a good point. They should have the option to turn it off, but they don't. Endless scroll isn't good UX or SEO.
- newscracker 10y ago"Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." [1] [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- alkonaut 10y agoThis is a perfect example of how online advertising should work. Get a sponsor, show their unobtrusive message. Done. Can't find a sponsor? Can't have them trust you, or accept advertising that doesn't track user or show targeted ads? Can't afford the time to chase sponsors and manage the advertising? Then try a paywall. What, no one subscribes? Then take the content off the internet. You have an unsustainable business model.
- andybak 10y ago> You have an unsustainable business model. You have an unsustainable business model given current available technical solutions that meet your ethical criteria. That's quite different.
- alkonaut 10y agoWell, yes, it's unsustainable in the current about-to-die system of online advertising. I'm pretty sure that the death of online advertising as we know it will take a ton of small time sites down with it. That's sad in many cases, but unavoidable. Once advertising is back to a sustainable model, e.g. one where advertisers will pay reasonable money for displaying non-targeted non-tracking image ads - the possibility to have ad-sponsored content will return. Another future possibiliyt is some kind of successful micropayment network. But until we have that, there is just no saving a small ad-network funded site.
- andybak 10y agoI think that the minute it looks like online advertising is dying somebody will spot a gap in the market and create a less odious network. There probably already is a few. We just need to keep up the pressure and awareness. For me - serving malware is unforgivable - and something we can all get behind no matter where we stand on the more nuanced issues around tracking and personalization.
- r1ch 10y agoYou'll be surprised how much faster pages feel without ad scripts - I noticed significant improvements after implementing a no-ads premium option on our website. Even with an ad blocker, things just feel snappier if the scripts simply aren't there in the first place. I decided to go one step further with my personal site and eliminate all JS completely. I don't get enough traffic to make any kind of analytics or ad code worthwhile.
- brianwawok 10y agoThe anti SPA. Love it. I don't really browse on my phone because the JS situation is so bad.
- K0nserv 10y agoMe too, I used to spend a fair amount of time looking at the tiny amount of traffic I got in GA. But just like you I decided the extra JS wasn't worth it and I'd rather have my website be completely void of JS even if that meant I'd loose visibility from not having GA. Cloudflare's analytics is good enough for me. As a result of being strict about JS and keeping the CSS down my website is super snappy and tiny.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoSame for me. I make money when people hire me as a consultant or buy my books. I started recently rewriting my sites as simple static content (and wrote about how I do this http://blog.markwatson.com/2016/12/benefits-of-static-web-sites-hosted-on.html http://blog.markwatson.com/2016/12/benefits-of-static-web-si...) I still have JS from bootstrap, and I am looking at bootstrap alternatives that are CSS only.
- StavrosK 10y ago> I don't get enough traffic to make any kind of analytics or ad code worthwhile. On a related note, does anyone else see GA being wildly inaccurate? My blog was on the HN front page a while ago, and CloudFront got ~600k hits, which should translate to about ~100k uniques (I cache), yet GA only showed 8k uniques. I'm guessing the HN crowd runs uBlock or some other blocker in its vast majority, so JS-based analytics are completely untrustworthy.
- billpg 10y agoI completely missed that the sponsor's message was even there until I scrolled back to look at it.
- johansch 10y agoHow about removing that giant self-advertisement at the top of the blog? :)
- johansch 10y ago(Potential down-voters: It was actually removed within 8 minutes of me posting that. I was impressed. :) )
- superkuh 10y agoThis is about equivalent to saying, "I've stopped beating my wife." only almost everyone beats their wife in the scenario. It's not that you've done good. You've just stopped being bad. Why does your personal website need sponsorship at all? Why should people pay you for it? This commercial mindset is very weird to me.
- coldtea 10y ago>Why does your personal website need sponsorship at all? Why should people pay you for it? This commercial mindset is very weird to me. Because personal blogging can also be a business for some? It's not like every personal blog does it -- the huge majority are their for free, with no ads or anything. But if you devote the time and effort, and have an audience, why not? It's like saying pro dancers shouldn't exist, because tons of people also dance for free.
- ryandrake 10y agoI don't know--GP post has a valid point of view even if people disagree. I also feel it takes a bit of nerve to think that you should be financially compensated for writing your personal blog, no matter how big your audience is or how much time or effort you devote to it. Just because you CAN monetize something doesn't mean you should.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>I also feel it takes a bit of nerve to think that you should be financially compensated for writing your personal blog // Surely it depends on whether you're writing for your own benefit or the benefit of others. If you write to benefit - by the action, catharsis, etc., of writing - yourself then of course not but if you write to entertain, inform, etc. others then it seems reasonable that those who consume that writing to that end should get their costs covered in some way. I guess we could have arms length government managed blogging platforms, that would enable people to blog, others to consume the beneficial ones and avoid commercial entities being involved in the system (I think if you look current free blogging platforms probably can be traced back to advertised commercial entities?). It probably all depends on what sort of profit a blog is making. If they're actually paying themselves a living wage from their personal blog then arguably that shows it has value and that they should be socially allowed the opportunity to be paid (through the proxy of advertising) for that blog. I'd warrant from my experience that most blogs don't cover costs with the advertising they carry if you considered the act of writing them a commercial undertaking (eg UK min wage is ~£8 ph, so a blog writer would need to receive enough to cover ~£12ph to be covering wage cost alone; how many of the millions of blogs ever made do that?)?
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoPresumably an ad network helps get you to the position where you can negotiate sponsorship. I am most aware of the sponsorship journey that Grey and Brady discuss on their podcast Hello Internet [0] (I can't remember which episode), where they discuss the difficulty of using an ad network for a podcast and their eventual preference of sponsors. Notably they came to the negotiating table with successful youtube channels and their established audiences. The typical sponsorship model requires a track record, for one-off sites and gambles (whattimeisitinflorida.com ?) it doesn't really work. Maybe there is room for the equivalent of a recruiter but for sponsors? [0] - http://www.hellointernet.fm/ http://www.hellointernet.fm/
- gpvos 10y agoIt's worth clicking through to the article linked near the bottom, "Ad blockers are part of the problem".[0] What he explains there is why I don't use any of the curated lists such as EasyList, but instead maintain my own personal whitelist. It's more hassle,[1] but fairer. [0] https://www.troyhunt.com/ad-blockers-are-part-of-the-problem/ https://www.troyhunt.com/ad-blockers-are-part-of-the-problem... [1] Although unfortunately, it defeats the privacy-protecting aspect of using a generic whitelist to the extent that if the FBI finds the whitelist on my computer, they will have some extra info on my browsing habits. But I also don't delete my browsing history, so that doesn't really matter.
- overcast 10y agoSo as long as you've got a huge enough following, that is willing to pay for anything you give them, it should be no problem. Not realistic for majority of sites. Reminds me of big musicians, giving their new album away for free. After thirty years of making millions. Very poetic.
- jasonlotito 10y agoIf you don't have a huge following, if you don't have a huge audience already, what kind of money are you really making with an advertising network?
- overcast 10y agoA living.
- jasonlotito 10y agoI'll bite: what does that mean exactly? "A living" implies something different to me than you.
- overcast 10y agoIt means enough to pay bills, like everyone else's definition of a living.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoA nibble of data for you: I'm getting between 1800 and 2600 page-views per month, eyeballed [mean] average 2100 on my blog. I just decided before Christmas to drop Amazon ads. Amazon made me something like 80p [~1USD, ~1EUR] last year, for the whole year. Google Adsense made me about £80 [100USD, 94EUR] for the same period. Which pays for the hosting and may be a meal for the family, or a piece of computer equipment but nothing else. I basically do nothing to optimise my advertising, I just stick it on there and forget it. Occasionally I've mentioned a product in the blog but never had anything significant in return. Google has the best position (top-right sidebar), Amazon had the most impressions (repeated automatically in the sidebar down the page IIRC, I have ublock!).
- finid 10y agoI don't like the total irrelevancy of much of the ad content. It could be tailored to my browsing habits, but then I'm not overly fond of the tracking. Not "overly fond of the tracking", but you're using Disqus for commenting. I've got news for you. Disqus tracks you everywhere you go. And those ads are not particularly irrelevant, because most are contextual, which means they are generated based on the page content. What I've done for my site is stopped running AdSense (Google) ads.
- jeena 10y agoI never told you that, but now I feel that I have too, I never had any ads on my website and I removed the google fonts thing to make my page load faster. That was around 5 years ago.
- kaybe 10y agoHere is another argument for curated ads or ads that are matching the page content, not the viewer: Seeing ads that are for something very different than the page content give me a high mental overhead, such as ads for games when I search for programming, or ads for food when I look for games. They are highjacking my though processes and I have to extend effort to manage all these things in my head. On the other hand, if the ads match what I'm trying to do, such as programming ressources for programming, games for games etc, I even find them helpful sometimes, and there is very little mental overhead. Not all ads are the same level of annoying. I wish we could go back to tracking-free advertisement, not just because tracking is bad in itself.
- tenpoundhammer 10y agoWith the current ad networks, it's easy to have well-tailored ad's, but most publishers choose not to do so in order to increase the revenue on their inventory.
- Romajashi 10y agoAnd I myself bought a bottle of juice today and drank it all. Do I need to write an article about that?
- muninn_ 10y agoI think instead of lambasting somebody for removing ads from their site because they have an alternative way of funding it, and thus forgoing ad revenue, we should commend them.
- facepalm 10y agoWhat are efficient ways to find sponsors?
- amorphid 10y agoHave decent traffic, and they'll probably find you.
- AndrewStephens 10y agoI went a step further and designed my blog (https://sheep.horse/ https://sheep.horse/) not to use any third-party resources at all. This was easy for me because I am never going to make money from my ramblings about Rogue One or the last book I read. I am actually not against advertising in principle, or even tracking if that is what you want, but the current trend to pull in lots of resources (ads, tracking scripts, web fonts, CDN javascript libraries) from third parties scares me. When you serve a page to a user, you are responsible (morally and legally) for what happens on the user's computer. Ad network serves up malicious code? Your fault. Tracker places cookie on user's machine even if your privacy policy says you won't? Your fault. New version of that CDN'ed Javascript library does something you don't expect? Your fault. I wish more sites would arrange their own advertising like this guy, but I imagine it is a pain in the neck. [edit] I wrote a post expanding on this idea: https://sheep.horse/2016/6/a_website_manifesto_-_introducing_sheep.horse.html https://sheep.horse/2016/6/a_website_manifesto_-_introducing...
- mi100hael 10y ago> New version of that CDN'ed Javascript library does something you don't expect? Your fault. That's what the "integrity" field is for. If the CDN tries to change the file surreptitiously, it'll have a different checksum and the browser won't run it.
- AndrewStephens 10y agoTrue, that is a step in the right direction. Ideally that would work for any resource - fonts, images, etc.
- andygates 10y ago> When you serve a page to a user, you are responsible (morally and legally) for what happens on the user's computer. Ad network serves up malicious code? Your fault. Morally, absolutely, but has it been tested legally? I can see sites weaselling out by saying that they trusted their ad networks to do good, etc, etc, and nobody learning from it.
- _joel 10y agoI'd still classify Google Analytics as an ad network, personally. Here's what I just captured from uMatrix - http://imgur.com/uNLC5RO http://imgur.com/uNLC5RO
- phkahler 10y agoHe says ad blockers are part of the problem, and yet he's effectively doing ad-blocking on his end too. Ad blockers prevent the kind of stuff he doesn't like from getting in on the client side, he's manually rejected them on the server side. Notice that his "sponsorship" banners are not going to be blocked by ad blockers. There are two fundamental problems that gave rise to the ad networks: 1) Scale - nobody wants to have humans involved in bringing in ads. and 2) Fraud - Nobody wants to pay for ads that aren't actually seen by a human, this has even escalated to "clicked by a human". I worked briefly for a company that did auditing of print and television ads. The agents (I'm not sure the correct term) would arrange for an ad to run in the paper, on TV, or whatever. Money would be set aside in an escrow for that ad and one of this companies people would verify that the ad ran before the money could go through. The whole business seems to be base on a lack of trust. The ad-man might try to divert funds from his ad budget to somewhere else, the paper or TV station might collect money and never run the ad. You could say it was all just "verification" but it's based on distrust. One step toward relieving ad fraud on the internet is to eliminate anonymity by default so you'd know where clicks are coming from for example (I'm still in favor of anonymization in many cases, but you'd know it's in effect).
- busterarm 10y agoIf I had to pick between relative anonymity and ads, I would pick anonymity every time. I'd love for the internet to go full São Paulo. Don't care what services I have to lose or pay for in the process either.
- phkahler 10y agoI would pick anonymity many times, and it can be achieved as a feature. But once you start out anonymous it's really hard to add verifiable identity to that. In other words is easy to strip identity but hard to establish it.
- busterarm 10y agoThe US military has done a pretty good job of this via the Common Access Card. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Access_Card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Access_Card The great part about a system like that is that it's up to the user whether they want to participate in something like that or not. Anonymity truly would be by default. If you're using your card, you can assume everything you're doing is tracked. I'm sure some service providers would make it an access requirement, but then it's up to the market to decide.
- devinp 10y agoGood for you but i don't think this will work for small publishers
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoThe sponsorship model is once again becoming popular on the web, something I'm not sure if I'm happy about. On the one hand, it's a lot nicer than ads, but OTOH, it makes me more suspicious any recommendations from people who have been sponsored. Did you recommend that we use that product because you genuinely like it, and thus accepted sponsorship from them, or are you only pretending to like it because you're getting paid? It's hard to tell. The "sponsored by viewers like you" approach (aka Patreon, the NPR pledge drive, etc) solves this problem, but it's rare that anything has an audience big enough to support it. But hey, one of the benefits of sponsored content is that at least the ads (if that's how the sponsorship works: it usually is in podcasts and video, which are where this is really taking off, moreso than blogs) are entertaining. I skip ads as quickly as possible for the most part. OTOH, I have repeatedly watched an hour-long compilation of ads for SquareSpace taken from the Co-Optional podcast. Which were compiled by popular demand. So that's a benefit to sponsorship for companies: if you can get me to willingly watch your ads, because they're that good, you've effectively won.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- protomikron 10y ago> I don't mind ads on websites as a concept, [...] I already disagree with the first sentence. Now I do not have an idea how we should compensate content creators, but ads are inherently a terrible model.
- joekrill 10y agoWasn't this basically Google's model when the first started serving ads? 2 or 3 line text-ads only? I guess it's too bad that devolved into what we have today. Or maybe they still offer that? I have no idea.
- my123 10y agoThat is Google AdWords mostly, used by themselves.
- intrasight 10y agoOne thing I've always admired about Apple is that they use no third-party scripts. And I thus always think "If that works for Apple, which is arguable the most successful company, why don't other companies follow their successful model?" I still have no good answer to that question. Also, I followed this troyhunt.com post to the "Ad blockers are part of the problem" post - which I found to be an even more interesting read, particularly: "When ad blockers are stooping to the same low level as advertisers themselves are in order to force their own agendas, something is very, very wrong. Deliberately modifying sites like mine which are making a conscious effort to get us away from the very things about ads that led to ad blockers in the first place makes them part of the problem. Ad blockers like this need to clean up their act." And because he is "famous", the ad blocker did clean up its act - for his site. Sucks all around in my opinion.
- doodpants 10y agoArguably, his sponsored links are ads, and ad blockers block ads. Sure, there is a case to be made that only problematic ads should be blocked, but I don't think it's so cut and dry.
- intrasight 10y agoI personally do discriminate between ads and sponsorship but certainly it is not so cut and dry. Would you call all these sponsored sports stadiums ads? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sponsored_sports_stadiums https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sponsored_sports_stadi...
- doodpants 10y agoThe sponsorship itself is not an ad, nor is the stadium. But signs posted at the stadiums indicating the sponsorship could be considered ads. Likewise in the case of the website, the text indicating that the site is sponsored, which will take the user to the sponsor's site when clicked, is an ad. Thus, it is not unreasonable that an ad blocker would block it, even if it isn't "intrusive" advertising.
- 10y ago
- vintageseltzer 10y agoI often wonder why an open-source advertising system (like a self-hosted AdWords) hasn't caught on. When it comes to ads on my site, I'd love to cut out the middle man and be able to manage my own clients, content, tracking and payments, all served from my own domain. I've seen a few sites managing this on their own, and the result has been great: well-targeted, nicely-designed ads that the site owners and advertisers stand behind. It definitely takes more work, but I don't see anything wrong with that.
- sgustard 10y agoThis is great, and now let's say I want to productize this "sponsored by X" feature so other sites can use it. I can't assume every site owner wants to deal with figuring out who's the sponsor each week, so we'll automate that with some backend that serves the correct sponsor. We'll want to know how many people see the link and how many click on it, because we (and our sponsors) want to know how well these links work. Haven't I just re-implemented an ad network at this point? Is what I've implemented objectionable now, or only later as other bloatware features are added?
- huehehue 10y agoObviously the latter is more objectionable, but the big factors here are control and transparency. For example, I'm uncomfortable serving ads from large networks because I don't know what the end-user will see and because it's nearly impossible for me to know how my users are being tracked. If your proposed solution was open-sourced and gave me full control of user data, I think that would make all the difference. With existing solutions, company A tracks users and iframes company B in so they can get in on the action. And maybe company B wants to loop company C in, too? Many advertisers deliberately obscure these things because they're either unethical or part of their "secret sauce" -- it's less users having an issue with their view & click being recorded.
- gkya 10y ago> We'll want to know how many people see the link and how many click on it, because we (and our sponsors) want to know how well these links work. That's an assumption not a fact. Presumably if I sponsor a blog I have an idea for the value of it. Ad networks on the other hand detach the publisher from the sponsor so that all the latter has to know the effect of their campaign is bulk data from surveillance. Direct sponsoring or good networks like the Deck on the other hand don't require that.
- codazoda 10y agoThis is commonly what advertisers want to see but it probably shouldn't matter how many people see it or click on it. All that should matter is how many of the people who clicked on it took action on your website (email signups, orders, etc). If all advertisers looked at those metrics instead of tracking everyone on other sites they would probably have more effective advertising.
- nickbauman 10y agoWelcome to the future of advertising.
- hartator 10y agoWithout actual numbers of the revenue being giving up, I feel making this sort of claims aren't worth a lot.
- maglavaitss 10y agoGoogle Analytics code is still there, so I guess, no ad networks were harmed during the making of this blog post.
- manigandham 10y agoIdea: we previously built an ad-blocker that would remove all ads/tracking and was paid by a monthly subscription, that was then divided by time spent per domain. Similar to the Youtube Red model but for the rest of the internet. Wanted to get it to the ISPs so it would just be a bundled add-on (internet + premium content sub) and would also give access to premium sites like NYT, WSJ, FT, etc. Nobody wanted to work with us. Failure in cooperation is causing failure across the rest of the media landscape. I wonder if we should try again...
- a3_nm 10y agoMisleading headline. According to uMatrix, the page still loads at least: cloudflare.com, disqus.com, fonts.googleapis.com, gravatar.com, gstatic.com, google-analytics.com.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 10y agoBTW, my ad blockers do not remove sponsorship message, despite what is claimed in a linked article. Neither Ghostery nor uBlock Origin nor Privacy Badger do anything to it.
- bootload 10y ago"What I'm trying to do with sponsors is what I strongly believe is the most responsible middle ground that keeps the greatest number of people happy, myself included." The like the fact Troy has his ^own^ blog and can make his own call. There are alternatives ways to think about ^how^ a blog makes money. [0] [0] Dave Winer, "How I made over $2 million with this blog" ~ http://scripting.com/stories/2009/02/11/howIMadeOver2MillionWithTh.html http://scripting.com/stories/2009/02/11/howIMadeOver2Million...
- zenpaul 10y agoI love the direct sponsorship model just because it seems more authentic, which is important for content creators. Is there a platform for that kind of direct sponsorship? It would be helpful to discover, schedule, manage content, track and handle payments for sponsorships. The platform would be helpful whether the platform serves the ads directly via JS or indirectly via manual or API based content integration.
- EIGHTime 10y agohttps://teespring.com/fr/robot-1846#pid=2&cid=2397&sid=front https://teespring.com/fr/robot-1846#pid=2&cid=2397&sid=front https://teespring.com/fr/get-home-run#pid=2&cid=581&sid=front https://teespring.com/fr/get-home-run#pid=2&cid=581&sid=fron...