25 ms·
Renewing Medium’s focus
- niftich 10y agoMedium downsizes by 33%, disenchanted by the ad-supported model. Pledges to pivot to heretofore undefined but different publishing model.
- mgiannopoulos 10y ago/me reads the word "focus" in the title. Then reads this in the text: "It is too soon to say exactly what this will look like." I thought the content would have more "focus"...
- Hydraulix989 10y ago^ This should be the real title of this post. "Renewing Medium’s focus" is a pretty underhanded way of saying "Medium downsizes by 33%"
- eva1984 10y agoThis is a glorified article saying 'no one is buying our ads'
- kevinwang 10y agoI hope that trying a non-ad based model will be successful for them. It would be a huge breakthrough if it happens.
- minimaxir 10y agoSwitching away from ads from a moral standpoint as presented in the article is a harder sell when the content publishing industry as a whole is having issues making money off of it.
- barkingcat 10y agoAd driven media has been crumbling for decades. It's good that Medium is seeing the light. Even a startup gets blinded by the fake money that ads promise. I would hope that this move starts something in the media industry to stop thinking about ads as a revenue source.
- disordinary 10y agoI hope they know what they're doing, because that post was extremely vague. I guess downsizing gives them more runway to pivot. The obvious alternative to advertising is micropayments, either behind a paywall or on a donation basis - similar to what Brave is trying to do. The problem is our habits as consumers are so deeply ingrained to expect content as free it's going to be a huge uphill battle if that's what they're thinking.
- WA 10y agoCould also be a huge pile of money that gets distributed to writers based on words read or something like that. Just like Amazon's KDP Select Global Fund. Although I guess on Medium, this would result in even more click-baity shallow articles, which doesn't seem aligned with the mission to make people smarter every day.
- minimaxir 10y ago> So, we are shifting our resources and attention to defining a new model for writers and creators to be rewarded, based on the value they’re creating for people. There's an incentive alignment issue with these types of models which try to quantify "value" from a holistic perspective. You could say those Facebook Pages which steal memes and do likes-as-votes shennanigans "create value" for people too as they generate tons of Likes and EdgeRank exposure. Medium was always a hub for clickbait thought pieces, but a revenue model like the ones implied would only make it worse.
- franzen 10y agoIf you check out all of the "sponsored" or "partnership" content on Medium, like: https://theringer.com/ https://theringer.com/ https://electricliterature.com/ https://electricliterature.com/ https://medium.com/the-economist https://medium.com/the-economist https://medium.com/@generalelectric https://medium.com/@generalelectric https://medium.com/@Starbucks https://medium.com/@Starbucks You'll notice the engagement is absolutely terrible. Between 10-100 likes, and even those stats are inflated by (no doubt terrified) Medium employees. Keep in mind, the rough "like" to "view" ratio is ~1:100, so hardly any of these posts are even cracking 10,000 views. Those are okay numbers when you're paying your writer/marketing guy $200 per post. Hardly the foundation for a company valued last year at $400M. Of course, Medium could monetize with banner ads like every other site, and it does have enough traffic to do that (it's the 371th most visited site in the world.) However, most writers only write on Medium because there aren't any ads. If Medium suddenly started monetizing on my content "YouTube style" I would leave them for Wordpress in a second. The Medium community is fine (they'll drive 100-1000 views per post on my pieces) but that's not enough to justify graffitying my content with ads. It seems like there's a major identity crisis going on here. On one hand, a lot of great pieces are published on Medium. (Perhaps not as many since Medium de-funded/spun-out their flagship in-house publications, Matter and Backchannel). But there's also a crazy amount of crap. The top stories on Medium are almost invariably listicles and trite "How I Xed my Y in Z days". I get the feeling Medium set out to position itself as a curated Wordpress (which might justify that gargantuan valuation) but these days it feels pretty much like an awkward, less popular, and slightly more erudite Buzzfeed.* *Buzzfeed is not without its own problems. See traffic stats here: http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/buzzfeed.com http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/buzzfeed.com
- douche 10y agoI used to love Grantland, it's sad to see it reduced to such a pale (and strikingly partisan) imitation as The Ringer has become. The Bill Simmons media empire has crashed and burned.
- tonystubblebine 10y agoI'm in your boat and was pretty disappointed by the initial incarnation of The Ringer. I heard Bill say on a podcast that he had a different theory about where media had gone. It was faster, mobile and more immediate. So the initial implementation of The Ringer seemed like short, trite pieces produced quickly. Like you'd get a dumb Game of Thrones piece within 15 minutes of an episode airing. Thankfully, they seem to have backed off and gone back to long form, loving fan pieces with obscure links and embeds. For example, this Donald Glover piece: https://theringer.com/you-have-to-take-donald-glover-seriously-now-56363bf513d3#.i452f5fho https://theringer.com/you-have-to-take-donald-glover-serious... TLDR; I'm curious what you think of the more recent Ringer stuff. Because to me, it's so much better and is exactly why I loved the old Grantland.
- ccostes 10y agoI applaud Medium for renewing their focus on achieving what seems to be the holy grail for virtually all content producers, but especially writers: getting people to pay directly for content. Netflix and the like seem to have it figured out for video, but somehow it is a much harder nut to crack for text. I agree that it would be better, both for producers and consumers, to find a different model, so I hope they can figure it out!
- dchuk 10y agoI just don't get why people consider Medium to be so remarkable or innovative. It's just Blogger 2.0, in a prettier outfit. It's just a whole bunch of networked blogs, started by a really popular Silicon Valley dude. And now they've realized that ads slapped onto content isn't sustainable. Gee whiz, welcome to the wonderful world of content publishing, that all other newspapers and magazines have been made painfully aware of in recent times. It sucks that a bunch of people lost their jobs today, but really, to think that Medium was doing literally one single thing in an innovative way was just plain naive.
- whyileft 10y agoEspecially now that video is eating up bigger and bigger chunks of the content market everyday.
- strictnein 10y agoI think their main innovation was [HUGE IMAGE AT TOP OF ARTICLE].
- 6stringmerc 10y agoAs a pretty committed Medium writer, I've been impressed by their platform and how it has worked for my purposes. Very similar to SoundCloud. I haven't ever really figured out how either intended - or will eventually - turn a profit. I'm quite familiar with the "value gap" argument and the acrimonious relationship between, ahem, content and tech heavyweights in the US. >So, we are shifting our resources and attention to defining a new model for writers and creators to be rewarded, based on the value they’re creating for people. And toward building a transformational product for curious humans who want to get smarter about the world every day. It is too soon to say exactly what this will look like. Oh, I've got a guess, and it certainly doesn't involve me getting paid more per view or read than I do via Spotify or any other "Artistic Content as Commodity" platform. Medium has been a decent trade-off: They don't charge me, and I don't expect anything but "exposure" in the grand sense. Not surprised this isn't exactly rolling in dough as a business model, but I'll stick around to see how they fare. https://medium.com/@6StringMerc/media-analytics-prtsc-beer-december-2016-edf3d2e76ed0#.ejkxri9vi https://medium.com/@6StringMerc/media-analytics-prtsc-beer-d...
- lancewiggs 10y agoYou are helping them build their business by providing your content for free, as did contributors to Huffington Post. How do you feel the balance of compensation is, and how do you feel about your control - or lack of - of your own content?
- 6stringmerc 10y agoAs with Huffington Post, the hosting platform of Medium also sets an expectation floor for audiences / readers that the format will likely be to their preference. Thus the chicken-or-the-egg syndrome somewhat: Do they come to Medium for my Content, or did they discover my Content because it is on Medium? I think both avenues are realistic. Equal? I dunno, really I don't, and I think that's the secret sauce too a "community" of getting people to latch on and stay in it (e.g. Facebook). I think the balance of compensation is fine for my purposes. I don't recoup the $19.99 annual fee via DistroKid that gets me into iTunes, Spotify, etc, so I'm generally a skewed perspective. In practical terms though - and this I truly believe is important - I think less than 1% of the Content Creator Population in any given Commercial Art Enterprise in the United States earns a Middle-Class Living (Wage + Benefits). Basically I think it's unfair in Modern Times to think that Musicians and Writers really had a lot of opportunities to make a good living before technology came around. Of course I'd like that to change, and maybe Spotify and Medium can play a role in that, but breaking the grip of RIAA and AP/Reuters isn't exactly an overnight proposition.
- matt4077 10y agoIt's disheartening to learn that advertisement apparently isn't even profitable (enough) for a platform that doesn't even pay for its content. Just let it sink in what that means for journalism. If the economics of the internet come to be all-encompassing, there will be no revenue model to support any professional publications. There's obviously no shortage of hate for "mainstream media" right now, so probably many people can't await the demise of that industry. I'm just wondering which blogger we'll send to cover Ebola in Guinea-Bissau and which twitterer will file & finance 14 FOIA lawsuits[0]. But maybe democracy works just as well without people digging into "Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court documents". [0]: http://www.charliesavage.com/?page_id=303 http://www.charliesavage.com/?page_id=303
- FT_intern 10y agoI don't think these difficulties of Medium can be generalized to the wider industry. The CEO/founder Evan Williams is a billionaire who set out to create a good publishing platform for everyday Joes and Sues with little to no focus on monetization (as far as I can tell). Other text content based sites are more willing to sacrifice UX for higher ad revenue.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RivieraKid 10y agoThey would be profitable if they reduced the employee count 10x. Which should be doable, it's just a blog platform.
- pathy 10y agoAutomattic has over 500 employees, yet they are also "Just a blog platform" Though I believe they are actually profitable.
- EduardoBautista 10y agoAutomattic has other services that compliment Wordpress.
- jtth 10y agoI'm astonished there were 150 people working at medium. I'm still astonished there are 100 people worked at medium.
- skc 10y agoYes, I'd really like some insight into why they need _that_ many people.
- barkingcat 10y agoYes! This is what I was looking for from Medium when I heard of their ad driven plans: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13089574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13089574 Ad driven content basically is a sham. It's a way to let companies do whatever they want with people's minds.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mi100hael 10y ago> As of today, we are reducing our team by about one third — eliminating 50 jobs, mostly in sales, support, and other business functions. We are also changing our business model to more directly drive the mission we set out on originally. This is an enormous failing on the part of management as well as Silicon Valley culture in general. These startups hire far too many people far too early, piss away a bunch of money, and then lay off half their workforce and "pivot" once they realize their business plan actually sucked balls from the start.
- beat 10y agoMeh. It's a hard balance to strike, between being poised for growth, and knowing the growth will work. It's expensive and failure-prone, but if you don't do it that way, you get passed up or hit an upper boundary.
- eropple 10y agoYou also hurt people in the process, and that's something that tends to fall out of the calculus. At the end of the day, humans are pretty much the only thing that matters.
- toennisforst 10y agoWhat would you prefer instead? That they not hire these 50 people at all?
- eropple 10y agoI'd prefer that they adopt a sane and reasonable growth strategy that doesn't depend on pump-and-crash cycles. There's a certain pernicious idea in business in general and in startups particularly that your worth is in large part how many people are working for you (I've heard multiple people answer "hey, how are things going" with "we just hired five people!" and my blood runs cold) rather than the efficacy with which you are achieving your goals. (I'm a little less sympathetic in the case of engineers, who are an in-demand resource and so their opportunity costs are less, but the opportunity cost of your support people is higher and the recovery from the problems that that failed explosive growth phase cause is much worse.)
- Aardwolf 10y agoSemi on topic: how does this "top highlight" work? I select sentences and paragraphs while reading as a marker - but it's unrelated to the content, it's to track where I am. Do other people only select text they find important or so?
- douche 10y agoIf you select a chunk of text, a tooltip pops up and one of the options there, is some kind of icon that vaguely looks like a highlighter and has the CSS class 'svgIcon--highlighter'. I assume clicking that registers as a highlight?
- avian 10y agoThis post explains it. It's related to Medium's "Highlight" feature, not the ordinary text selection: https://blog.medium.com/introducing-highlights-a4df69e8ed43 https://blog.medium.com/introducing-highlights-a4df69e8ed43
- WA 10y ago> but it's unrelated to the content, it's to track where I am If you're reading a lot of stuff on Medium, you stop this behavior after a while, because the tooltip is too annoying. But generally speaking: No, you're not alone with this.
- dzink 10y agoThey may try a central Medium subscription setup that trickles funds to authors based on some criteria, or maybe medium as a subscription manager for authors. Google played with this approach. Does anyone know if they've had success?
- ohstopitu 10y agoIn my opinion, Medium has a problem - It's not really a product that is supposed to make a LOT of revenue (for it's size). In all honesty, it's very easy to technically build & maintain Medium with as few as 5 engineers. Add a few more people (say 5 - 6 more) and you have a good business (not a crazy growth startup) that can generate revenue and most importantly be sustainable. As for generating revenue: it's very easy to charge people a few $ / m for stuff I'd consider extra features (premium themes and custom domains). It's sad those 50 people lost jobs (I feel for them - I had lost my previous job when a startup decided to downsize), but in all honesty - what do 150 do at Medium and more importantly, WTF did Medium do with ~123 Million [0]? [0] - https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/medium#/entity https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/medium#/entity
- the_duke 10y agoWell, 6 years in business, offices in NY, DC and SF (all expensive locations), 3 company acquisitions, salaries for 100+ employees. I can see them getting to 120 million easily. Now why you need 150 people to build a pretty straight forward blog platform is a very valid question...
- hk__2 10y ago> Now why you need 150 people to build a pretty straight forward blog platform is a very valid question Because it’s not straightforward, and it’ not that many people? Facebook has 100x that number. Twitter has 25x. Airbnb hired almost 10x that number in 2015 alone. Stripe has almost 4x that number.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWhat these unrelated services did doesn't refute the point that a small team can put together a blogging service. Most components you need even already exist as pre-packaged FOSS. On top of it, one company on your list had a complex product that was built by a hand-full of college students in its early days. The Instagram company they bought also had just 13 employees.
- falloutx 10y ago> We decided we needed to take a different — and bolder — approach to this problem. I don't know what model they can come up with except the Ad-revenue model from per post views. This is not a tech issue, but an issue with the business of Internet. Since they have got a lot of good quality publishers, they may go for a subscription model, but then it would not seem very open to new publishers/readers. They may go for a per-blog subscription model for some high-quality publishers like The Economist, Backchannel etc. Another thing about Medium that gets me boiling is their news feed, its always populated by very popular bloggers and I have to literally scroll a mile to get any post from a new or a small blogger with less than 10K followers on twitter. So it becomes about Popularity rather than Quality(Starbucks articles about Christmas gifts is not as good as my CS Professor's ramblings). So to get those posts I would have to unfollow other popular bloggers. There is nothing like Facebook's "See it First" approach. Only reason I use Facebook these days is for its "See it First Feature" which lets me control my news feed really well. This really looks like failing CEO's post from here. But they have got so much content from good posters like Addy Osmani, Kevin Rose etc, that it would be hard to see it go. I don't know why many posters on Medium gave up their own managed blogs. I know it makes posts look pretty, but so does Wordpress (which even gives a lot of customization options).
- RivieraKid 10y agoWait, they had 150 employees? Wow...
- herplederp 10y agoNewly ex-Median here. This was not a huge surprise. On the surface, this is a change in product strategy. The underlying story is the company positioning itself so it can survive an adverse environment if it needs to. It's hard to fault managers for dealing with that potential (and its hard to deny that the next 2-4 years could be really bad). Hopefully not, but it would be malpractice not to prepare. So better to focus resources now than be walking dead in a year or so, jettison unnecessary products/projects, and hope for the best. It's a great product, and with time and luck, they'll sort out a good business model, but like the rest of the publishing world, they're still sorting things out. Despite being one of those made redundant, I enjoyed being there, and wish them the best. On that note, you should ask yourself if you are prepared for winter, because winter is coming.
- ivraatiems 10y agoWhat do you mean by an "adverse environment over the next 2-4 years"? Please be more explicit.
- herplederp 10y agoLocal picture: the revenue model for online publishing is still broken, Medium is in the publishing business. Big picture: Donald J Trump, and the potential to cause widespread disruption that benefits nobody. Hopefully that will not be the case, but if it is, money for startups with hazy revenue models will not be cheap. In either case, reducing your burn rate by $10M per year is a smart move.
- antisthenes 10y agoReally? Blaming Trump for a terrible business model? No matter how far you are in the SV bubble, even you must admit that was one hell of logical leap. > Hopefully that will not be the case, but if it is, money for startups with hazy revenue models will not be cheap. Sounds like a great thing to me.
- orf 10y ago
- Touche 10y agotldr; they aren't making enough money and don't have an idea on how to change that. They are laying people off who worked on the old failed model and are winding down to maintenance mode until when/if they can figure out a new model that no one else has been able to figure out.
- eva1984 10y agoMy biggest issue about Medium so far, is the content. Too much opinion, not that enough investigation, like junk food dressed as fine dining with clucky javascript.
- ghaff 10y agoSo you object to blogging in general. Which is what Medium is.
- eva1984 10y agoGithub pages are good, if that could be classified as blogging, I am a big fan!
- jasonthevillain 10y agoNo surprise. Investigative reporting is very resource intensive, and the people who are good at it don't do it for free. Opinions, on the other hand...
- sfilargi 10y agoIt would be interesting to know what Medium's main expense is? Is it the people? The infra? Also would be very curious to know how much do they earn for advertising.
- pcsanwald 10y agopeople's salaries is by far the biggest expense for most software startups.
- forgotAgain 10y agoMaybe it's not focus but quality of content. When I see that a story is from medium I don't bother with it. History has taught me that once in a while something there might be of value but mostly it's very light reading and not worth the time to explore.
- coldtea 10y agoPlus a whole lot of "first world's problems" and "white person's activism".
- sakabaro 10y ago> We believe people who write and share ideas should be rewarded on their ability to enlighten and inform, not simply their ability to attract a few seconds of attention. Does that mean they are going to start paying people blogging? "Rewards" is a bit unclear.
- lowglow 10y agoMy hunch is they're going to go to a subscription/patreon model.
- raiyu 10y agoUnfortunately this is a bit of a flawed blog post on Medium's behalf. The facts are that 50 people were fired due to burn rate and lack of revenue. The second fact is that "NO" fact is given to how this will be rectified in the future. The third issue is an opinion. That people need to be paid for the content they produce. This isn't true. There are plenty of people that are happy to contribute purely for the common good or for fame. Just look at Open Source and Linux. It's obvious that Linus is no where near compensated for the imprint that his work has had on technology, yet he did it and continues to do it anyway. Lastly, if you do provide a platform people can monetize their following, just like Instagram and Snapchat celebrities can monetize their following on their own with Instagram or Snapchat providing them a direct tool for that. No blogging platform outside of Wordpress has succeeded to monetize and self-sustain and it is the exception that proves the rule. Basically that the content generated on blogs is too long form with a disjoint following and not enough focus on entertainment which is the primary driver of ad revenue to survive. It's the same issue that is facing the news today, they either pander to the lowest common denominator or they aren't compensated enough to sustain themselves. That or they just have too much overhead. Overall the reality is that many people lost their jobs and the response is just a bit of fluff, when the reality is we screwed up our business model and had to make cuts would have been much more honest. Instead they are trying to revolutionize something? It just sounds empty.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoIt's interesting because I think that the means of distribution of information is getting revolutionized, and it's needed (e.g. wikipedia, youtube). However, medium saying "Well, we're pivoting away from click-baity profit-mongering to solving society's problems because we always cared, and it's just a coincidence we were losing money" is hard to swallow.
- jraedisch 10y agoI'm still willing to give them the benefit of a doubt and would like to read more press releases by media outlets searching for alternatives to ads/tracking – preferably without the firing part.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI don't have any strong opinion about Medium, but generally when a firm lets 1/3 of its workforce go it's a Big Problem. This is hot news insofar as it tells us something about the future of the media market, but bigger point to me is that 50 jobs is such a tiny number. Of course it sucks for those let go, but 50 new unemployed people won't dramatically reshape the SF tech landscape and Medium is a well-known firm, so most of those folk will likely land on their feet. The reason I think it's news is that it's a glaring example of how network effects leverage employee productivity so drastically. The tech industry is always looking for more people, but it's simply never going to employ the same huge numbers of people that other sectors like manufacturing have. google only has ~60k employees, which is only about 1/5 as many as IBM. Jobs are a form of political currency, and while it may be a lot harder to fill 50 tech jobs than 5000 warehouse jobs people often choose quantity over quality. I would expect the tech sector to carry much less weight under the new administration and that the next 2 years will be characterized by vicious competition and consolidation.
- WA 10y agoMedium set out to solve the impossible. They want to reward writers who have an impact. But impact is actually hard to measure, maybe even impossible. You need to have some metric to calculate impact. Likes and views can't have too much weight in the equation, because they can be gamed. Furthermore, page views are heavily influenced by Medium's recommendation engine. I, as a nobody, won't be read. So I need to gather followers. I do so in the traditional way of commenting, liking, recommending, doing all kinds of community stuff. But again, this can be gamed. This is not impact, but merely hours put into the social game. Ultimately, Medium might introduce something like Amazon's KDP Select Global Fund that pays money to writers based on some metric, but I doubt that it will be much better than what've got. Why? Human nature. The current media landscape is refined to perfection already, in a way. "Modern" articles push our buttons, we are like junkies waiting for their next fix of information (I guess every HN reader can relate to this – I certainly can). That's what we really want. We read what tingles our senses, preselected by a relatively stupid algorithm and social proof. How on earth would you construct a better algorithm that truly measures impact on our lives?
- coldtea 10y ago>Medium set out to solve the impossible. They want to reward writers who have an impact. But impact is actually hard to measure, maybe even impossible. That's not the problem. The problem is that most people could not care less about either impact or rewarding the writers -- and the kind of writing on Medium is not the kind that has a paying fanbase (like e.g. fiction might).
- chipotle_coyote 10y agoWell, my impression from the start is that Medium was much more of a "we want to try some new things for blogging and see what works" model; the assertions Ev and company have been making that they're on a noble mission to save the web from itself are relatively recent. They didn't set out to solve the impossible; they set out to apply what they learned from Blogger to do something better. I think an argument can be made that Ev is right that the advertising model for web content is broken, but there's no sign that they have any idea how to fix it. My own posts on Medium perform wildly inconsistently -- views from highs around 45K to lows around two or three dozen -- and at least for me, the main differentiator seems to be links from outside Medium. Articles that get selected for attention by Medium editors also get increased traffic, but I suspect it's hard to get that attention unless you're already getting recommendations. I'm enjoying a lot of things about Medium, although 2017 may be the year I quietly move all my stuff back onto my own platform again, just cross-posting certain articles over to Medium.
- jimbokun 10y agoThat was a very meandering, unfocused article about renewing focus. Granted, the important news about cutting 50 jobs is in the first paragraph, but the rest just seems like an attempt to distract from that fact without saying anything substantive.
- ergothus 10y ago> So, we are shifting our resources and attention to defining a new model for writers and creators to be rewarded, based on the value they’re creating for people. And toward building a transformational product for curious humans who want to get smarter about the world every day. > It is too soon to say exactly what this will look like. I like the general message - acknowledging that the ad model is broken, not being a jerk to the (many) people they are laying off. I am, however, uninspired that nothing was actually said about how or what their new model will be. I can see NOT putting that in the "we just laid off a bunch of people" message, but that's when you mention that you'll be going into more detail next week, or at such-and-such conference, or ANYTHING to indicate this isn't a sign that the company is doomed and this is just the first step.
- gooseus 10y agoI wrote a response to this medium post, figured I'd copy it here since I'm unsure of the overlap in forum participants: I had an idea for a model last week that I think would be worth consideration. It’s sort of a Humble Bundle x Kickstarter x Patreon model. I’m envisioning a system that allows consumers to pay what they want for access to the content they value, but also allows creators to establish a threshold point where the content would become freely available. So Ev Williams does a bunch of research and writes an article and says “Awesome article Ev! I probably put 10 hours into it and if I got $500 in return for that work I’d be super psyched… but I also want EVERYONE to read my awesome article cause it’s important…” I would propose a system by which the article is published with a paywall indicating that the article is only available to contributors until $500 threshold is reached. After the $500 threshold is reached, the article is released publicly and those contributors who paid get Patron/Contributor credits on the article (or some other social reward). Consumers interested in AI will pay for AI content, those interested in Marketing will pay for marketing content and any content in any subject good enough to reach the threshold can be enjoyed by everyone. This is off the cuff and I’m sure there are issues, but I think this category of model is worth exploring since it compensates creators for their work, allows eventual free distribution of information and doesn’t make the platform or creators beholden to advertisers.
- ews 10y agoNot a bad idea, I was working on something very very similar until few months ago.
- CodeTheInternet 10y ago> article is only available to contributors So contribute $1 then copy-paste to pastebin?
- gooseus 10y agoSure, just like signing up for a 30 day trial of Netflix and then ripping all the content to bit torrent. While I'm sure it's a concern I don't think Netflix looking to change their model over it. Good actors still outnumber bad actors.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- moomin 10y agoAds are a serious problem, and they're failing. However, the standard alternative (people paying directly) has serious problems of its own. Basically people pay for what they want to hear. Woodward and Bernstein wouldn't have survived that model.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoIs this just an extremely well written PR piece to handle layoffs? Or are they actually making some concrete changes to their focus? I was genuinely curious to hear how they were going to switch their focus, and agreed with most of what he was saying throughout the article, but after having finished the article, I came away with no new information. It made me feel like it was the former--an extremely well written PR piece to cover for the layoffs. Am I missing something?
- rayalez 10y agoAs a creator of a publication that got invited to join the beta test of their new monetization strategy, I am very happy about their decision to pivot away from ads. I was very disappointed when they have introduced the ads, it never made sense to me, it flies in the face of their main value prop - clean, elegant, beautiful, distraction-free blogging platform. On the other hand, they are in a great position to create a content monetization system, where people are paying for the content they enjoy. So far, most of such systems have failed, but I think that Medium is one of the few companies that can actually make it work. I'm really looking forward to what they will do with this during the next few months.
- coldtea 10y ago>So, we are shifting our resources and attention to defining a new model for writers and creators to be rewarded, based on the value they’re creating for people. And toward building a transformational product for curious humans who want to get smarter about the world every day. It is too soon to say exactly what this will look like. Could this be any more vague and Silicon Valley baloney-ish?
- dilemma 10y agoMedium's customer isn't readers nor advertisers. It's publishers - they're a B2B business and should syndicate content to publications around the world.
- nickjj 10y agoI'm not sold on using Medium, or definitely not exclusively. Why would a content creator publish content on the Medium platform when you can't even get the e-mail addresses of your subscribers unless THEY pay you for a membership (that's what I got from their membership FAQ). In other words, Medium expects content providers to produce top content in order to grow the Medium platform while the content provider has no way to realistically obtain a following that's not directly tied into Medium. That means when Medium goes down, you lose not only all of your posts but your entire following as a content producer.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoI split the difference and setup a custom domain for my Medium blog. I own the content URLs. If Medium dies then I'll pick a new blog format and new web host. It won't be the first time and it won't be the last I'll have to make such a change.
- nickjj 10y agoYeah but if you have a bunch of followers on Medium, all of them will no longer receive updates when you post new content. Sure, some percentage of them will know your domain name and check manually but you're going to lose a huge amount of readers. My concern isn't so much with Medium dying, it's spending 3 years building a brand around yourself and eventually figuring out how to monetizing your audience but now you can't because you have "Medium followers" instead of your own subscriber list.
- coffeemug 10y ago> However, in building out this model, we realized we didn’t yet have the right solution to the big question of driving payment for quality content. You can't make people buy something they don't want.
- scotchio 10y agoCalling it now. Medium.com pivots to become marketplace where you can either publish for free on their platform or put your writing in an auction for other publications to buy it. Journalist/writers/whatever all write in a single location and get published to multiple publications. The new model. === Shameless plug: Consider writing a guest post on scotch.io. Great exposure, help others, and get paid https://scotch.io/write-for-us https://scotch.io/write-for-us
- CN7R 10y agoWhat about the twitch model? Writers rely on donations and subscriptions.
- rahrahrah 10y ago> Upon further reflection, it’s clear that the broken system is ad-driven media on the internet. Haha this guy used to be CEO of Twitter.
- tlogan 10y agoI'm very very surprised that Medium has issues and they needed to cut 50 employees. And sad. I was thinking they were doing quite well. Now, I'm concern that there are other startups which have similar problems like Medium even if they are considered as success stories. So I'm not even sure which companies I should use as example of "this is how to run the startup". What you think about following companies? - Slack: maybe it is just a temporary hype? - Uber & Lyft: maybe rides should be 100% more expensive? - AirBnB: a lot of money is spent on fighting regulations - but elections are every 4 years and regulators will change... - Dropbox: maybe it is the end of PC <-> cloud sync? - Github: maybe it is just hype because they are have free option? Maybe large companies are not ready to source dev to github? - Stripe: Maybe they have high valuation just because a lot of small startups are using them - but as soon as startups grow they move to cheaper systems?
- untilHellbanned 10y agoYes all valid concerns. You and I will get downvoted for even mentioning these companies in a pessimistic light but it doesn't make it less true.
- CN7R 10y agoSlack: used it at a hackathon and found it better than Facebook or Skype or whatever groups use to organize; happy that the club I joined recently as an officer is using it for communication Uber & Lyft: haven't used it personally because public transportation is cheaper and I can wait, even though they were giving out free credit on my campus; I think carsharing is here to stay, especially if selfdriving cars become mainstream. AirBnB: surprisingly cheap, found a $200 a night place in downtown LA for 6 people; I enjoy the concept of people sharing their homes and introducing tourists to local culture; however, some regulation is needed to protect both homeowners (from issues like squatting), customers, and renters -- no home should be used for the sole intent of renting to AirBnB and acting as a hotel. Dropbox: I only use Google Drice so I can't say. GitHub: hasn't this company been around long enough so that it isn't just hype -- anyhow they should find a way to stop burning so much money. Stripe: I've heard their API is easier to use than competitors, and it seems they launched Atlas this year to diversify themselves from process payments to include business incorporation.
- vonnik 10y agoI don't think Medium understood the online media economy when it began, and I don't think they understand it now. With the advent of the Internet, content creators like newspapers and television networks saw the barriers to competition slip away. They were confronted simultaneously with burgeoning supply (which pushes prices for that supply down the curve) as well as more rigorous methods to track how people respond to advertising. One reason why online ads cost less than those in the print edition of newspapers is because they can be tracked, and the results show that people don't respond that much to them. The argument for pricing print ads higher is that print editions have actual subscribers, and therefore disposable income. That subscription model was the basis of a golden age of news for decades, because publishers could be assured of their income, and disengage their reporters from the battle for clicks. They were free to pursue the most newsworthy news. It was a kind of ivory tower. Now that tower is crumbling, faster every year, even if Trump's election caused an uptick in subscriptions in the digital editions of some newspapers. Online subscribers will always be a tiny minority of all readers (I subscribe to some publications, but I understand why many don't), because of the river of free content. In an age of disintermediation, content has gone in the opposite direction, handing more and more money over to middlemen like the ad networks and search engines and social networks, while content creators get less and less of every dollar. They are, in a sense, like farmers, who raise our food from the earth but receive very little compared to the distributors. Laying off 50 people and changing one's business model won't change that dynamic one bit.
- oliebol 10y agoPeople who say Medium is "just a blogging platform" obviously haven't written many blog posts. Writing a post is easy. The interface to do that is easy. Distribution is hard - that's the bit Medium solves in a revolutionary way: getting people to read your stuff.
- kumarski 10y agoThe tldr story seems to be: Be a better version of Patreon somehow.
- mtw 10y agoInterestingly, all products tied to Twitter are struggling (twitter, medium, vine, periscoope etc.) And all products tied to Facebook are thriving (fb, instagram, whatsapp, messenger)i
- neovive 10y agoIt would be interesting to see if Medium pivots into a model similar to Spotify or similar streaming music services that charge a subscription and work out some sort of revenue split with writers/publications. However, they would still need ads to supplement free users. Should be interesting...
- jfornear 10y agoIMO, Medium (like Twitter/Blogger) is about self-expression, not publishing. Medium should optimize more for fostering self-expression and community discussion and decouple from Twitter. Perceived consumer demand to fix publishing is overstated and solves the wrong nonproblem. Consumers arguably like fake news and click-bait, deriving self-reinforcement and entertainment value. I wonder if hiring content marketers to write in verticals with high paying affiliate programs could get them profitable without compromising their social mission.
- kevinbluer 10y agoDoes anyone have any insight into what happened to Svbtle (svbtle.com)? In its heyday it seemed to have a ton of momentum / buzz, albeit on a smaller scale than Medium does today.
- Huhty 10y agoStill around.
- abalone 10y ago> We believe people who write and share ideas should be rewarded on their ability to enlighten and inform So they are going to start charging for reader access[1] but they don't yet know how. Is there any other interpretation? I am sad they did not explore a restrained, regulated advertising model. As much of a dirty word it is, it's not in practice as disliked as "paywall". Daring Fireball does good ads. Even Google (at least in its earlier days) had restrained approach to text-only, short, clearly separated ads that people were ok with. [1] Note: as I read it the quote specifically precludes a paywall-free approach such as charging writers for premium features a la other hosting platforms (sans paywall, at least). They want writers to receive compensation and they don't want ads.
- jv22222 10y agoI hope they try micropayments for content. Paying authors 1 cent per read, taken from the readers account, for example. I've been waiting for someone to do a really good job of that, since the good 'ol days of Gopher. These guys have a big enough audience to make a genuine attempt at it.
- samnwa 10y agoHere's a medium alternative built by one guy: www.allthink.com.
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoTLDR: Not meeting profitability targets. Starting to run out of money. Selling ads isn't making enough. Fired a bunch of people. VC's want us to get back to hyper growth, whatever that means. Hoping for the best.
- andygambles 10y agoSome people who publish on Medium (me included) have a commercial arm which is trying to gain recognition from publishing. Better known examples would be 37Signals and Buffer. Increasing sales via the commercial arm is the aim and so being rewarded for publishing is not completely necessary. In fact I would consider paying for more premium features. Such as ability to restrict read next to particular publications or even pay for greater reach in other publishers "read next" areas which could then compensate them. I also use Medium to publish personally with no real need for financial reward. I use Medium because it is easy and I don't get distracted playing with navigation or sidebar or thinking "I could stick Adsense on this and earn $2.00 a month".
- hiby007 10y ago“The current system causes increasing amounts of misinformation…and pressure to put out more content more cheaply — depth, originality, or quality be damned. It’s unsustainable and unsatisfying for producers and consumers alike...We need a new model.” This statement sums up today's social media state.
- adamcharnock 10y agoI agree with a lot of the discussion here around what 150 employees are/were actually doing. I also wonder – as some other commenters have mentioned – what Facebook/Twitter/Google do with their many thousand employees. However, the more I reflect on it the less I feel this is isolated to tech. What on Earth do 55,000[1] employees find to do at Morgen Stanley for example, or 200,000[2] employees at Ford? I see two possible options: 1. This is just a limit of human perception. Companies do so much stuff it is hard for us to conceptualise. 2. Some combination of bullshit jobs & making work for ourselves. I find the former believable simply because there are a hell of a lot of humans and 90% ish have a job. The latter quickly leads to me to wonder: do we as a society bias towards job creation regardless of its function. I therefore suspect both are the case, at least to some extent. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgan_Stanley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgan_Stanley [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Motor_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Motor_Company
- ascorbic 10y agoIt's mostly 1 in your examples. Morgan Stanley and Google do lots of different things, which requires lots of different people. Ford does lots of labour intensive stuff with a heavily unionised workforce. Facebook and Twitter do more than you'd think, but more importantly do it at massive scale. Medium, however, has one relatively simple website, at a scale nothing like Facebook/Twitter/Google. I struggle to imagine what they all did.
- hawski 10y agoFord has about 65 factories. Assembly plant in Chicago employs about 4500 people. If factory has to work 24h/day you have to have 3 shifts and probably something extra for the weekend and holidays. For me 200k employed at Ford seem reasonable.
- hownottowrite 10y ago"blog.medium.com" - Why does Medium have a blog?
- __ddd__ 10y agoTo those speculating as to the new monitization model: NLP. Improvements in NLP will open new opportunities for data mining behavioral trends. A company like Medium is very well positioned to benefit from this coming trend.
- johndoe4589 10y agoI love to read on Medium but it nly works for me when I NEVER recommend, reply or even read anything that's not outside my focused interest, which is programming topics. Their algorithm is bad , way too sensible. I read a single opiniated post about politics or what have you and the next day my mostly Javascript / Front End feed is flooded with angry women talking about feminism, or people talking about Trump, or that idiot "SF Ali" writing pointless drivel. They really need to add a way to make magazines of sorts, to be able to have different feeds. The notion of mixing together all kind of interests doesn't make sense. WHen I want to read about web development, I don't want to read about Trump. And vice versa. I think the design of Medium gave it a certain "chic" but I quickly began to realize it's just another blogging platform and there are a LOT of badly written articles on there. I wish there was something like Medium focused on creating ediucative content, where banter and personal opinions are frowned upon. So I can go to a feed, and just LEARN things. I don't know if it's even possible to do that though.
- johnalamos 10y agoMedium.com and their propaganda can all go to hell. This site was doomed from the moment they started taking money from politicians.