5 ms·
Desktop CPUs are a mature market. Desktop applications tend to be either not performance limited or limited by something other than the CPU. Consider that the
by ajross 10y ago
Desktop CPUs are a mature market. Desktop applications tend to be either not performance limited or limited by something other than the CPU.
Consider that the 7700K in question gets similar performance to your Sandy Bridge box at probably 1/3 of the power draw. (I had a 4.2GHz 2600K for a few years and the socket pulled about 102W, so I'm guessing that's what you're looking at). A 3X increase in power efficiency is certainly not a lack of progress, it's just that you don't care.
- Retric 10y agoIt costs around 500$ to get similar performance. So ~500$ / (0.20$/kwh * 0.102kw * 2/3) that's ~37,000 hours or 24/7 for 4 years. So, no lower power is not a solid reason to upgrade.
- kogepathic 10y ago> that's ~37,000 hours or 24/7 for 4 years. That's 4 years running the CPU at full tilt. The 2600K will idle at a lot less than 102W
- mrmondo 10y ago102W is a /lot/ of power and heat...
- kogepathic 10y ago> 102W is a /lot/ of power Yeah, and OP was saying that was only the socket consumption, you've also got to add in chipset, memory, discrete GPU, hard drives, NIC, sound, etc... and power supply overhead as well. I bet that system was pulling 400-500W total under the load he described.
- Retric 10y agoA single old style light-bulb is not what most people think of as a lot of power and heat. https://www.1000bulbs.com/category/100-watt-standard-shape-light-bulbs/ https://www.1000bulbs.com/category/100-watt-standard-shape-l... Further the delta is only like 60w under full load.
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoIf they touched the light bulb, they might think otherwise.
- ajross 10y agoOn a desktop. I know you don't care, I said so. But Kaby Lake is a silicon product for a bunch of markets (of which "desktop" is a rapidly shrinking one), and in those markets it represents solid improvement over its predecessors.
- Retric 10y agoI don't think the desktop is shrinking as much as sales suggest. I would happily drop 2k on a new desktop if there where any reason to do so. Intel chose to waste 5 years of performance gain on a low end graphics capability's instead of bumping cheap multi core performance.
- ajross 10y agoThat use of "cheap" is doing too much work. Obviously Intel hasn't squandered many-core scalability either, c.f. Broadwell-E which is available with as many as 10 cores and targetted at exactly your market. It's just not cheap, being a 240mm2 die (almost twice what Kaby Lake is, with attendant yield penalties) targetted at a niche market with low volume. So your point isn't that Intel isn't innovating, it's that you want them to do it in a way that violates straightforward economics and hand it to you for less than it takes to produce. Basically: you got spoiled by the early days of the VLSI revolution. Silicon scaling isn't doing what you expect any more.
- Retric 10y agoAt Intel's scale having 4 core chips with integrated graphics or 6 core chips without integrated graphics and slightly smaller transistor count is not a significant cost, meaning they could both sell for similar prices. They don't do this because they have zero real completion and can milk the high end market. Further, by holding back performance gains they can extend the upgrade cycle as long as possible. PS: Cellphones are approaching Desktop chip performance.
- ajross 10y ago> At Intel's scale having 4 core chips with integrated graphics or 6 core chips without integrated graphics and slightly smaller transistor count is not a significant cost, meaning they could both sell for similar prices. Yeah, that's not how silicon manufacturing works. Tooling up for a new part of this size and ramping production gets into the tens to hundreds of millions of dollars. No one does niche-market (and yes, gaming desktops are niche) parts at the prices you expect. Low-volume big parts cost a thousand dollars or more, that's no different at Intel than it is anywhere else.
- Sammi 10y agoLower power means less demand for quickly spinning fans. Fan noise is quite a huge purchase decision factor for some people looking to buy a home pc (like me, I'm one of those people).
- marcosdumay 10y agoOn a desktop you will get much farther with bigger fans than with low power chips. That is, unless you want to be fanless, that is a expensive extreme.
- pcwalton 10y ago> Desktop applications tend to be either not performance limited or limited by something other than the CPU. The browser is a desktop application and, once the page is loaded off the network, is certainly CPU bound.
- mrmondo 10y agoHmm... I still find browsers more memory blind than anything, any machine with less than 16GB of RAM I find really struggles with JavaScript heavy sites, god damn JavaScript.
- pcwalton 10y agoYour JS heaps are not approaching 16GB unless you have thousands of tabs loaded. You can verify this in about:memory.
- tossedaway334 10y ago_something_ about the browser (either chrome or firefox, fresh profile, no extensions) is eating ungodly amounts of ram however, and it tends to be at its worst with JS heavy sites. EDIT: no addons either
- Senji 10y agoMaybe you have some random addons(not extensions) installed?
- Retric 10y agoThat would be more relevant id the choice was 15GB vs 16GB. However it's normally 8 vs 16 and that 8 is used by many processes. So, it can easily be comparing 0.5 of free memory vs 8.5 GB of free memory.
- duderific 10y agoIt's probably a combination of all the caching browsers do to improve observed performance and sloppy memory management in the browser software, not javascript.
- Aleroniponi 10y agoYep, efficiency is key here. That is where most improvement has done in terms of cpu design in recent years.
- mhurron 10y agoMy last round of upgrades for the wife's and my desktops was entirely motivated by upgrading to lower power parts that provided the same (or better in the case of video cards) performance. The office became noticeably cooler, it was a good upgrade.
- Declanomous 10y agoThis is entirely the reason I chose Intel and Nvidia over AMD/AMD. I run linux, and the open-source nature of AMD appeals to me, but I was so sick of the heat and the fan noise. Plus my old computer only ran at it's best during the winter.
- a-real-dinosaur 10y agoI wouldn't care unless I lived somewhere warmer. Energy can not disappear from a closed system and that inefficiency will keep you feet toasty. :)
- mark-r 10y agoI care more about fan noise than I do about heat.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]