13 ms·
‘Routine’ Jobs Are Disappearing
- nerdponx 10y agoHasn't this been a recognized trend since the "jobless recovery" of 2009?
- tptacek 10y agoThe actual research finds that this is a phenomenon associated with every jobless recovery (there have been 3 in the last 40 years or so): each time there's a recession that ends without restoring pre-recession jobs, the routine manual job market appears to take a permanent hit. Here's the chart from an earlier paper by the same authors: https://www.dropbox.com/s/782zelpi8r2nwua/Screenshot%202017-01-03%2011.51.07.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/782zelpi8r2nwua/Screenshot%202017-... So a big question here is about causality. It's possible (maybe probable) that the phenomenon of long term declines in routine manual jobs is in fact the cause of jobless recoveries: it creates a ratcheting effect at each recession.
- edblarney 10y agoWith jobs, there are big demographic issues, as well as the underlying shift of jobs overseas. So it may have nothing to do with 'ups or downs' - just a long term secular trend in those areas. Recessions just exacerbate the problems a little, possibly.
- nerdponx 10y agoThanks for the paper. My understanding has been that it was due to stickiness in both wages and labor demand. That is, a recession is an excuse to cut wages/benefits/hours/headcount that managers either didn't care to cut or were afraid to cut in good times. That, or it spurs managers to actually innovate and figure out how to do more with less. If that understanding is even partially correct, it's ironic that labor laws designed to protect employees might actually be contributing to over-corrections in the labor market that directly hurt employees.
- samfisher83 10y agoWelding is not a routine job. Good welders make pretty good money.
- jimmywanger 10y agoI don't think they were talking about welders, but welding machine operators. https://job-descriptions.careerplanner.com/Welding-Machine-Operators-and-Tenders.cfm https://job-descriptions.careerplanner.com/Welding-Machine-O... From this job description it seems like a job that is very easily automated, as you're not doing anything interesting, just feeding the machine and making small adjustments.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoRoutine doesn't necessarily mean low skill or low pay, it just means that you do pretty much the same thing from day to day. There are probably surgeons out there who have fairly routine jobs, make half a million dollars a year doing it, and earn every penny.
- ghaff 10y agoI'd add that there are a fair number of jobs that are pretty routine--until they're not. (At least today, pilots are a good example.)
- badlucklottery 10y agoI agree that what remains of welding work isn't a routine job for sure. I think the article is discussing the repetitive, low to medium skill welding and machine babysitting that has been automated or is just plain unnecessary with new manufacturing processes. What's left is the higher skill and un-automatable welding work.
- tptacek 10y agoBe a little careful with the terminology here. If you drill down into the research, they're referring to the cognitive/manual routine/non-routine quadrants. Typical illustrative examples would be: Routine/Manual: Factory line work Routine/Cognitive: Retail clerk Non-Routine/Manual: Truck driver Non-Routine/Cognitive: Software developer In this scheme, every job falls into one of those four quadrants. I agree, welding (probably most of the "trades") are "non-routine/manual".
- lordCarbonFiber 10y agoThis is, for society at the very least, a "good thing". Who's dream is it to perform a "relatively narrow set of repeated tasks" for 8 hours a day? As mentioned, take these "prime aged workers" teach them skills, and suddenly we have a spike in actually valuable labour instead of a middle class of unfulfilled office drones stuck in a stupor. IMO, the framing should be look at this amazing business opportunity to onboard high value workers, not cautionary doom.
- st3v3r 10y ago"Who's dream is it to perform a "relatively narrow set of repeated tasks" for 8 hours a day?" Someone who wants to provide for their families, not worry too much about work, and be able to enjoy their weekend? " IMO, the framing should be look at this amazing business opportunity to onboard high value workers, not cautionary doom." How?
- zepto 10y agoWho is going to 'take' people and teach them skills?
- lordCarbonFiber 10y agoWe can start with the ones crying about a shortage of programmers and engineers (read, ones that think the cost of employees is too high). If you can impart a skill for $X at a discounted salary of delta(Y) so long as X ~ Y you're breaking even or making money over the the 1-2 year time frame the average person spends at a job. Note this is how finance has been hiring line engineers for years.
- zepto 10y agoIf it is so simple, why aren't they already doing it? And if they are not already doing it, how do you 'start with' them?
- knieveltech 10y agoWithout exception the people crying about programmers and engineers want the market flooded so they can pay lower salaries. If there really was an epic shortage of programmers we'd all be getting executive level compensation.
- retbull 10y agoIt is interesting that the people who are losing jobs aren't retraining. What exactly is Trump/Republican party going to do to help with that? Bring back Coal when renewable is cheaper?
- te_chris 10y agoProbably dead nothing and then blame liberals and Mexicans again in 4 years when everything has got worse.
- knieveltech 10y agoYou assume that blame would be misplaced? Liberals tossed workers and organized labor overboard ~30 years ago: http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/11/23/yes-democratic-party-did-abandon-working-class http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/11/23/yes-democratic-...
- ben_w 10y agoI would assume that the Democrats (as a non-American, what's up with calling them 'liberals'?) being out of power for four years will make them literally incapable of being why Trump fails to solve these problems.
- knieveltech 10y agoMeh. The Democratic party coopted the term liberal and use it in all of their marketing. So much so that their opponents now use the term as a naked slur. shrug Politics in the US is stupid and getting dumber and scarier by the day.
- diyorgasms 10y agoThe Democrats are absolutely liberals in the European sense of the word. They are pro-capitalism and have abandoned any pretense of pro-worker or leftist thought. HRC was George W. Bush reincarnate, Bill Clinton was as far right as any pre-Reagan Republican. Obama is a bit to the left of the Clintons, but he's still staunchly center-right and you'll notice that Obamacare is not single-payer nor does it allow for the government to compete in the marketplace.
- tarunm 10y agoSo the normal 'human' link is paywalled but access through Google news is complete. Why is this unfair practice not penalized by Google?
- metaphorm 10y agobecause Google benefits from it
- danso 10y agoWhy would it be penalized by Google? One of the factors in the SERP algorithm is how accessible a page is when someone clicks-through from Google, including load times, page-covering ads, and so forth. Google also punishes pages that show one thing to the crawler and another thing to human visitors who click through on the search results, i.e. "cloaking" [0]. That is not the case here. edit: Maybe your question is actually: why does HN -- and all other non-Google sites who link to WSJ articles -- continue to link to WSJ articles when it provides a bad experience for the user? HN admins have made their position clear that the content of WSJ articles are worth going through the workaround. [0] https://www.searchenginejournal.com/17-ways-to-get-de-indexed/53537/ https://www.searchenginejournal.com/17-ways-to-get-de-indexe...
- tarunm 10y agoWell I did some clicking around and came to know that this falls under their First Click Free [0] option. The details sounds more unfair to me. Example - 'A user coming from a host matching [www.google.] or [news.google.] must be able to see a minimum of 3 articles per day.' Isn't this a net neutrality violation? Because of their monopoly, they are able to force a work around to get access to content and a better UX for their visitors at the cost of other referrers. A more fair/neutral program could be a 'limited subscription' type access where the content site allows a limited number of articles to users (from any referrer), Google gets access to content for indexing and tags the content appropriately as 'limited access'. [0] https://support.google.com/news/publisher/answer/40543 https://support.google.com/news/publisher/answer/40543
- 10y ago
- breadtk 10y agoMirror: https://archive.is/Tltad https://archive.is/Tltad
- CodeSheikh 10y ago"To counter these trends, the U.S. must invest in raising the skills of the workers most likely to be affected by the disappearance of routine jobs..." Not sure how's that going to play out for example a welding machine operator can't become a mechanical engineer in a short span of time because those routine jobs are eventually going to be consumed by automated robots, per this study. Why not motivate people to look into alternative booming industries? Healthcare and therapists for example. With aging population, people would require more health therapists and similar service oriented jobs.
- aylons 10y agoAnd for a welding operator to become a physical therapist is an even larger leap. Also, there's also a lot of resistance (and prejudice) in going from blue-collar to pink-collar, partly because care and health services are seem as feminine jobs(except doctors, of course).
- knieveltech 10y agoHard to have much sympathy for someone who's strangling themselves with their own gender stereotypes.
- kamau 10y agoOften times it's not the worker that strangle themselves. I remember reading some years ago (can't remember where) about the struggles that male nurses have. Male patients often refuse male nurses as they don't want another male to see their bodies, and female patients will refuse male nurses out of modesty. And, according to the same source the problem only intensifies as the male nurse gets older.
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoUniversalize that statement and apply it to X demographic not choosing a STEM degree and you'll find yourself in a struggle session.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JohnTHaller 10y agoWelding machine operators are a drop in the bucket compared with the biggest looming job shift on the horizon: truck drivers. It's the most commonly listed job in 29 states and there are millions of them across the US. And most will be replaced by automated driving systems within the next couple decades. Yes, there will be service jobs within trucking, but that will be a small fraction of the 'routine' jobs that automation will replace.
- passthefist 10y agoDon't forget the jobs providing services to the people that drive the trucks. Many of those are going to be lost like those old rail and highway towns that built up and then bust when the popular routes changed.
- the8472 10y ago> truck drivers. It's the most commonly listed job in 29 states This has been brought up previously in HN discussions. It's an artifact of arbitrary binning choices.
- JohnTHaller 10y agoRegardless, there are still around 3 million of them. That's not a small number.
- Ensorceled 10y agoThere are a fair number of comments dismissing this issue with a "retrain or get left behind" and expressing not a lot of sympathy for those who don't. Remember, the average IQ in the US is just below 100[1]. Exactly what kind of jobs do you expect to retrain these people for? And how are they equipped to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps? Most of these jobs provided on the job training or apprenticeships so it's not even a matter of "they did it once they can do it again". Also, many are battling obesity and related illnesses such as diabetes or struggling with mental illness and/or addiction. We need a systemic overhaul of the economic system and soon. Self driving vehicles will put 3-5 million out of work in the next decade. [1] https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country# https://iq-research.info/en/page/average-iq-by-country#
- uiri 10y agothe average IQ in the US is just below 100 This represents a fundamental misunderstanding of IQ as a measurement. IQ is defined as a normal distribution with a median of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. The average IQ in the US is 100 for any IQ test calibrated to measure the US population. No absolute statements regarding intelligence can be made on the basis of IQs; only relative statements about how an individual fits into the normal distribution measured by the test. This ignores the flaws in Flynn and Vanhanen's study when it came to calculating IQ scores for different countries. They used incomplete data sets collected at different times using different tests. For 104 out of 185 countries, they had no data available at all. Instead, they averaged neighboring or comparable countries - for instance El Salvador is an average of Guatemala and Colombia while Kyrgyzstan is an average of Iran and Turkey. I think it is fair to say that the average IQ for $COUNTRY is 100. This is a meaningless statement when it comes to discussing macroeconomics or comparing countries on the basis of IQ.
- DashRattlesnake 10y agoThat's true, but it also seems kinda irrelevant to the OP (the link happens to be the 1st result for a google search of "us average iq"[1], so I think it was just a quickie cite to back up a statistic). Average IQ people (e.g. the welders and bank tellers) don't seem like they're in demand for high-demand knowledge-work jobs, so retraining is probably not the answer to any economic woes they're experiencing. [1] https://www.google.com/#q=%22us+average+iq%22 https://www.google.com/#q=%22us+average+iq%22
- jcbeard 10y agoSame basic trend we saw with industrial revolution. People lost their somewhat skilled (for the time) jobs to steam powered machines. As the recent election also put front and center, we're also competing with the entire planet for jobs. How do we compete with the Terminator and the foreigner bogeyman? You don't directly. Nations build a social safety net that cushions the churn of jobs, universal healthcare so that the stress of loosing your job and healthcare doesn't kill productivity, cheaper (or free) access to entry level college education (community college), and lastly nations need to provide geographic mobility (getting from the place without jobs to one with jobs isn't easy when your bank account balance is -$40 USD). The net effect of all these suggestions would likely be a good bump in long term national GDP and growth...we could likely implement most of them using less than 1/4 of our $600 billion yearly defense budget.
- WhoBeI 10y agoBeen thinking the same thing of late. There are many similarities. Lets hope it doesn't last as long though.
- synicalx 10y agoCutting a defence budget is never going to be helpful especially by such a large amount - you're going to lose jobs, lives, security, and given how widely US troops are deployed you're going to lose even more stability in many parts of the world.
- lgleason 10y ago"The paper, called “Disappearing Routine Jobs,” provides more evidence that the transformation of work in the U.S.—from an industrial economy to a digital one where routine work is automated or outsourced and the remaining jobs are concentrated in low-paid service work or high-skilled knowledge work" Note the "or outsourced" piece. If the prevailing wage in the US is $20+ an hour vs a 3rd or quarter of that in the developing world there is no way the average US worker can compete. While I get the automation argument, that still doesn't explain the large (seemingly majority) of retail goods in the United States are that manufactured in lower labor cost countries. Not everyone is cut out to be a knowledge worker. As much as I personally like tech, this is not going to be the great job creator for Middle America. There are still a lot of jobs that can't be automated and/or won't be for a long time. If it was possible to automate as much as some would have you believe in the short term straight up there are some robotics companies that would have not closed down (Willow Garage), and you would be seeing a lot more traction with others doing more interesting things instead of telepresence robots and clunky household devices such as the Roomba.
- gregdsouzaa 10y agoToday I tweeted about a video of Raghuram Rajan (ex-RBI governor, ex-IMF Economist)who explains this phenomenon succinctly. https://twitter.com/gregdsouza/status/816239880032305152 https://twitter.com/gregdsouza/status/816239880032305152
- kwhitefoot 10y agoLots of talk about retraining in these comments. All the retraining in the world isn't going to help in a society where the work is not actually needed to produce the goods we consume. We need to stop valuing people by what they do and start providing for people regardless of what they do. And you can do this secure in the knowledge that you do it out of pure self interest because if you don't an underclass will come into being on a scale not seen since feudal time and the people in it will have little to lose by being disruptive and violently rebellious.