12 ms·
Swiss say goodbye to banking secrecy
- denzell 10y agoOnly for certain countries: https://www.sif.admin.ch/sif/en/home/themen/internationale-steuerpolitik/automatischer-informationsaustausch.html https://www.sif.admin.ch/sif/en/home/themen/internationale-s... Tax evaders from USA are safe.
- thecopy 10y agoNote that EU is listed as a single country. The footnote reads: >The AEOI agreement with the EU applies for all 28 EU member states and is also applicable for the Åland Islands, the Azores, French Guiana, Gibraltar, Guadeloupe, the Canary Islands, Madeira, Martinique, Mayotte, Réunion and Saint Martin.
- misja111 10y ago> Tax evaders from USA are safe. No, the USA forced Swiss banks to open up their administrations to the DOJ already in 2013. https://www.justice.gov/tax/file/631356/download https://www.justice.gov/tax/file/631356/download
- pas 10y agoI very much doubt that. When you open a bank account there they'll go to very great lengths to make sure you're not from the US and you don't fall under FATCA (forein account tax complience act), and if you do, then .. well, you usually can't just open an account there, but there are branch offices of course that are ready and willing to do business with people and entities associated with the IRS, probably they are a bit more costly though.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoThis applies even to Swiss citizens with American green cards, unfortunately. Note private banking has always had different rules from consumer banks.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe AEOI is a mutual agreement the US doesn't want to share their banking details with some nations on that list. That said iirc the Swiss have a separate agreement with the US that agreement is based on the 1996 tax treaty and allows the IRS and SFTA to look through the banking records of each nation.
- Vernooper 10y agoGood post!!!!I'm a WordPress designer, essayist and teacher situated in Birmingham, UK. I'm likewise a parent and school senator Website : http://laustan.com/ http://laustan.com/
- briandear 10y agoI feel that governments ought not have a right to my private financial information without a warrant. If they think I have committed a crime, they ought to be forced to prove such a crime. This is no different than every home having 24/7 interior surveillance with the hope that a crime could be discovered. Governments, especially so-called "progressive" governments have the wrong belief that our money belongs to the government first and citizens are permitted to keep their 'share.' I know many people here think that a total loss of financial privacy is 'fair,' because of some sort of misguided class-warfare, however how would you feel if your entire computer and web history were transmitted to the government with the purpose of identifying crimes you might commit as opposed to being in response to a warrant that establishes probable cause that you actually committed a crime. Having money in an overseas account does not even come close to reaching a threshold of probable cause for tax evasion. However having overseas money (or in my case, a domestic French account,) doesn't mean you are a potential criminal any more than being black means you are a potential criminal. This is financial "stop and frisk." In the US this loss of financial privacy and these 'disclosures' amount to a warrantless search. I welcome any counter argument. Just to be clear, I'm not a 'fat cat' billionaire -- just an American living in France that has the 'privilege' of being taxed (heavily) by both the US and France. My French bank has to disclose information about my accounts to the US Treasury and I have to fill out an FBAR each year to 'prove' to the US that I am tax compliant, thanks to FATCA. If it weren't for the obvious class warfare aspect, liberty minded progressives would be losing their minds over this violation of the fourth amendment. They'll howl over warrantless wire-taps but many remain silent with the financial equivalent of wire-taps. I am not advocating tax evasion, nor do I support or defend those actually evading lawful taxation; I am opposed to a police state where everyone is a criminal until proven otherwise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 10y agoEloquently put. I could not agree more. The US has a guilty-until-proven-innocent tax code and parallel court system run by the IRS whose Constitution-defying existence is baffling to me.
- vikiomega9 10y agoWhy does confidentiality play a big factor here?
- ZenoArrow 10y agoIf you have undeclared earnings (undeclared to avoid paying taxes), you'll want somewhere to hide that money.
- 8172zw818 10y agoSource?
- tptacek 10y agoPlease don't randomize your HN username each time you comment.
- 1982912981 10y agoPlease don't use "argumentation by throwaway".
- tptacek 10y agoI'm not. I'm refusing to even have a debate with someone who abuses the site this way. I was happy to respond to a rebuttal by a throwaway upthread. But now that it's clear what you're doing, I'm done.
- thrwwy20001 10y agoI apologize if it bothers you that much, but you're completely wrong about the motives: I'm simply tired of watching an arbitrary number go up and down by voting. That's it, nothing more to see here. If HN offered no-karma-no-grey-text accounts, I'd take one. But it isn't my site, so I'll just stop commenting altogether.
- bsusuabwbw 10y agoHe's probably shadowbanned I suppose? From my experience it's simply better to create a new account almost every time I want to comment (once a day or so). Also new accounts have severe restrictions on number of comments per day. Maybe he's trying to bypass that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- known 10y agoBlack money is converted to Black wealth long time back via Quid pro quo http://qz.com/843902/1-of-indians-now-hold-nearly-60-of-the-countrys-wealth/ http://qz.com/843902/1-of-indians-now-hold-nearly-60-of-the-...
- return0 10y agoThis is so long overdue, it's almost useless. Where were these laws in the roaring 80s and 90s when rich people were actually making money (instead of today's stagnation)? Everyone who has cash to move has probably moved their money in obscure location outside the reach of the west (e.g. UAE). These new secrecy deals are just there to solidify the sovereignity of old money in europe.
- sschueller 10y agoThe only people really affected are the ones without any money. The Americans living abroad not being able to get bank accounts because the local banks are too afraid of US fines or the double taxation of income for those living abroad.
- urza 10y agoIf you want to have financial privacy, start learning about cryptocurrencies. Getting to know bitcoin is obvious, but there are also other kids on the block. Monero is the most successful cryptocurrency that has privacy built in: https://getmonero.org/home https://getmonero.org/home In the medium term no banks in any country will be able to provide you financial privacy. We're not there yet, bu it is coming. And as a bonus with cc you get money that cannot be "frozen" because some government says so or money that disappears because your bank/government screws up. In the future cryptocurrencies will be more real money then fiat currrencies. For some countries this is true alredy today.
- chakalakasp 10y ago"Here, put your money in this magic box. It may double in value in a week or it may be worth pennies on the dollar tomorrow. Nobody will know what you do with this money if you shake the box right. Put the box under your bed -- if you lose it, all your money is gone." Bitcoin and the Swiss banking industry are apples and oranges.
- EthanHeilman 10y ago>Bitcoin and the Swiss banking industry are apples and oranges. I'd say it is a babies to cemeteries comparison. Banking privacy is dead or dying. Cryptocurrencies offer enormous potential however with regard to privacy they are still in the experimental phase and require time to mature and develop.
- pjc50 10y agoCryptocurrencies log all transactions in a world-readable log. Their only privacy is pseudonymity, which is very easily breached. And it's quite a hassle to acquire without going through an exchange which logs all your personal information for AML anyway.
- smokeyj 10y ago> Cryptocurrencies log all transactions in a world-readable log. True for now but there's some interesting experiments in this space, such as zero knowledge proofs, currently in dash and porting to ethereum (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-interactive_zero-knowledge_proof https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-interactive_zero-knowledge...). > And it's quite a hassle to acquire without going through an exchange which logs all your personal information for AML anyway. Also true, but crypto to crypto exchanges are relatively lax on regulation. It'd be trivial to trade into an anonymous coin, mix, then back to a public coin for some degree of anonymity.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoThe joke in Switzerland is the U.S. Treasury took actions against Swiss banking secrecy to defend its own business [1]. Indeed, Delaware and Nevada are notoriously light on what paperwork they require to spin up an entity [2]. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-27/the-world-s-favorite-new-tax-haven-is-the-united-states https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-27/the-world... [2] http://www.financialsecrecyindex.com/PDF/USA.pdf http://www.financialsecrecyindex.com/PDF/USA.pdf
- ckastner 10y agoAnother joke is that the U.S. is the last remaining tax haven in the world, because despite the U.S. requiring everybody else to share information with them (eg FATCA), they refuse to share information with anyone else. The U.S. is not a participating country of AEOI.
- cylinder 10y agoForeign banks should have called the US' bluff.
- marcoperaza 10y agoI'm not familiar with the details of what you're talking about, but never forget this timeless wisdom uttered 2500 years ago: "Right, as the world goes, is only in question between equals in power, while the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must."
- blueprint 10y agoTime to use Monero.
- bogomipz 10y agoIt seems like real estate is increasingly filling the role of banking secrecy any way. Real estate LLCs offer the same secrecy as a former Swiss bank account with the benefit with added benefit of having your investment grow potentially 5% a year long term. I don't see governments in the US or UK doing anything about this however. This article provides a good look at this phenomenon in New York City but its happening in many cities throughout the world: http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-york-real-estate-2014-6/ http://nymag.com/news/features/foreigners-hiding-money-new-y... I think real estate as the new bank account has far worse implications. Hiding money in foreign real-estate deprives the local economy of tax coffers as these folks won't actually live there and won't contribute to the tax base in the form of federal, local and state taxes. As well it hurts the country where those seeing to hide money are domiciled. As cities become even more crowded and the housing stock tightens even further, developers "building safety deposit boxes in the sky" to lure hot money seems like it might have bigger societal implications than parking money in a passbook savings account in Switzerland.
- aianus 10y ago> Hiding money in foreign real-estate deprives the local economy of tax coffers as these folks won't actually live there and won't contribute to the tax base in the form of federal, local and state taxes. They have to pay property taxes at least. And since they're not living there they don't use any of the taxpayer funded services either. Sounds like a net gain for the local resident taxpayer.
- bogomipz 10y agoSomeone who actually lives in a place pumps money into the local economy in addition to paying property and local taxes. Someone using a real estate as a bank account only pays real estate taxes. Given the above and the fact that housing and land are extremely scarce commodities in a city, how exactly is someone using housing solely as a bank account a net gain for a resident tax payer? This is of course just quantifying the financial aspect. What about the social aspect? What happens to the fabric of a neighborhood when development caters to people who don't actually live there? How is that a net gain resident tax payer?
- mtgx 10y agoI can't find the article, but Switzerland started sharing banking information with the U.S. a few years ago. This only makes it official.
- caseysoftware 10y agoFTA: > However, poor countries will not be accorded this privilege because they lack the resources to fulfill the conditions for automatic information exchange So bankers will be offered as a sacrifice but the dictator pillaging his country will be protected. How cute.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]