8 ms·
Self-driving cars will exacerbate organ shortages
- spraak 10y agoIt seems likely that the artificial creation of organs could produce enough by the time self driving cars are actually ubiquitous enough to cause a shortage > 1 in 5 organ donations comes from the victim of a vehicular accident. And I'm quite surprised that's true!
- cm2187 10y agoI would have thought it would be more than 1 in 5. Keep in mind the organ must be healthy for it to be suitable. That rules out a lot of diseases, people dying of old age, etc.
- manmal 10y agoI think most donations come from relatives. AFAIK some donations are also recoverable, e.g. when only a part of the liver is transplanted and it will regrow to its full size?
- paulcole 10y agoSurprised it's so high or so low? For non-kidneys (and increasingly livers), I'm not sure where else to find viable hearts, lungs, and corneas.
- cm2187 10y agoAs long as we don't have self driving motorbikes, there will be an ample supply of young, healthy donors. I have been told Motorbikes is what a surgeon, specialist in transplantation, has in mind when he rubs his hands when it is raining outside. "It's going to be a busy day". Probably more relevant in Europe than in the US.
- cobbzilla 10y agoindeed, I have heard paramedics refer to the vehicles as "donor-cycles"
- paulcole 10y agoGovernment will mandate software be written that maintains a rate of 30,000 car accident deaths per year. Gameify it and have the option to pay a microtransaction to reduce your risk for some number of miles. Or the option to increase your computed risk but double your driving speed. Lots of opportunity for disruption here.
- BWStearns 10y agoIt's dark and possibly off color but it could be a decent satirical short story.
- paulcole 10y agoI was thinking of something like Libertarian Police Force from the New Yorker. http://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/l-p-d-libertarian-police-department http://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/l-p-d-libertaria...
- JaRail 10y agoIt would also be a great way to offset the declining tax income from declining gasoline sales.
- mcgrath_sh 10y agoThat is a great way to kill all transport by car in the US. I understand there is a risk when driving in a car. However, when I am driving I am in control of, at least, a portion of that risk. I can control how I drive and how I react to scenarios on the road. I also have my best inteserests in mind. If I get into a self-driving car that will randomly kill me if I am unlucky enough to get into the wrong car at the wrong time, I cannot control that risk. It is no different than Russian roulette. No thank you. I would take public transot and/or move somewhere I could walk everywhere. Part of the reason that people accept the risk of driving in cars is because they have some control (or someone they trust has that control). Without that, I wonder how many would bother with driving?
- paulcole 10y ago
- failrate 10y agoWe are on the verge of being able to replicate organs at scale. I think that that harvesting them from donors who have destroyed their brains in vehicular accidents is just an unfortunate but necessary stepping stone.
- agumonkey 10y agoTrue, I had to check the article wasn't from theonion..
- mikeash 10y agoWhy? It's not as if they're saying that self-driving cars are terrible and should be banned because of this. They're merely identifying a non-obvious problem that will result from self-driving cars, and discussing potential fixes. It seems obvious that the tradeoff will be a huge net positive, but that doesn't mean we should ignore the negative parts.
- agumonkey 10y agoIt's just it's so obvious I don't see the need for reporting. What about vaccines or hygiene notes ? They avoided millions of new "organ donors" too.
- mikeash 10y agoIt never occurred to me, and the solutions are far from obvious. I doubt that vaccines or hygiene had much of an impact. Being an organ donor is not really compatible with death by disease, which tends to wreck the whole body. Organ donation requires being killed while leaving most of your body largely intact. Violent deaths involving the brain are good candidate, thus why motorcycles are so "popular" among transplant surgeons.
- gozur88 10y agoWe've been on that "verge" for three decades if you bought into the hype, and it's going to be a couple more decades before synthetic kidneys, livers, and hearts hit the clinic.
- woofyman 10y agoThere's still Chinese prisoner organ harvesting. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-carrying-out-millions-of-illegal-organ-transplants-annually-report-finds-a7107091.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-carrying-...
- chriscappuccio 10y agoGreat opportunities ahead for America's private prison investors.
- pacaro 10y agoA recurring theme in Larry Niven's writing
- Clubber 10y agoYes, but it will also lower the demand for organs due to less crashes with injuries. I'm not sure what the net would be.
- foota 10y agoI don't have statistic handy, but I imagine most organ donation need comes from illness.
- Clubber 10y agoI found some information. The largest organ by far that is transplanted is the kidney. I also suspect most of them are from disease rather than an impact injury. https://www.organdonor.gov/statistics-stories/statistics.html https://www.organdonor.gov/statistics-stories/statistics.htm...
- sigmar 10y ago>1 in 5 organ donations comes from the victim of a vehicular accident So preventing 35,000 deaths a year, may lead to 6,000 less organ donations? I'd take that deal. The article goes on to talk about changing from opt-in donations, to opt-out donations. Which seems completely orthogonal to self-driving cars, as (regardless of projected stats on future donor numbers) we should do whatever we can to decrease the number of people waiting on organ transplants.
- foota 10y agoIt's true that some people already support increasing organ donation (I do), but this might be a convenient political argument to do so. i.e., we'll lose significant number of organ donors and so need this to become opt-out.
- mamon 10y agoYou got that wrong: 6000 is the number of people are currenly dying from organ shortage, not the number of organs extracted from road accidents victims. Since one donor can provide more than one vital organ for transplant the balance is more like: 32 000 less deaths on the road, 100 000 less organs donated.
- sigmar 10y agoIf 1 in 5 donations come from a car accident victim, and there are 30,970 organ donations a year in the US[1]. That means 6,194 of those donations are from car accidents. [1] https://www.organdonor.gov/statistics-stories/statistics.html https://www.organdonor.gov/statistics-stories/statistics.htm...
- MereInterest 10y agoNot entirely orthogonal, as they both have an effect on the number of donations. The fact that the shortage will be caused by self-driving cars is unrelated to the solutions to a shortage. As you mention, we can't ethically prevent this shortage by increasing car accidents, so we should look for other sources.
- thescribe 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 10y agoTo alleviate concerns associated with commercialization, compensation could be limited to fixed payments or to benefit packages that include insurance, tax deductions for travel, lodging and lost wages, or paid donor leave. Is there a coherent argument for creating a "market" where sellers are banned from realizing the full market value of the thing they are selling? I guess people will say gouging, but that doesn't really work for an organ market (2 kidneys are actually better than 1, there's nothing short term or unusual about the shortage).
- woofyman 10y agoPersonally I wouldn't want to live in a society where poor people are exploited for their organs so wealthier people may live.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat's what they are proposing. They want to limit the prices paid for organs to avoid people feeling squeamish. Case A: Organs can be sold for $10,000 only. Lots of people do it. Case B: Organs can be sold for whatever. Lots of people do it for more than $10,000. I find Case B far less exploitative.
- tomjen3 10y agoSo you would rather limit the oppertunities of the poor, rather than allowing them to make a choice about their own bodies that you personally disagree with?
- woofyman 10y agoYes...it's exploitation. Should people be allowed to sell their heart or their eyes?
- tomjen3 10y agoHave you thought it through? People will sell organs if they think that is the best possible opportunity for them. You want to come in and deny them that resource, which means you want to force poor people to make a choice that they believe is worse of. Either you hate the poor and want them to be worse of (I don't believe this) or you think you know that persons situation better than they do. We tried a system of tell people what to buy and sell and what to make. It was called the Soviet Union and it was demonstrately worse.
- rahrahrah 10y agoRidiculous article. The parable of the broken window: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- throwaway287391 10y agoRe: increasing donations -- I've always wondered why it doesn't work roughly as follows: if you're an adult who finds yourself in need of a donated organ and are not yourself a donor, you're at the bottom of the list (below any donors) as a potential recipient from strangers who are donors. Puts the incentive in the right place and seems fair to me. What are the issues with that idea? Maybe the donor system would need to be made an opt-out rather than opt-in system first (as the article suggests), otherwise ignorance could be an issue.
- mulmen 10y agoWouldn't people just wait until they need an organ to join the list? How does punishing a subset of needy organ recipients increase the actual number of available organs?
- throwaway287391 10y agoRight, obviously you'd need to record the date they opted in and not give someone "credit" for registering once they were in need of a donation. It would help to increase the number of available organs because some people who don't care to register now might do so knowing that it means if they ever get into an accident they have a higher likelihood of receiving an organ.
- theonemind 10y agoThis sounds more like punishing the person who changed their mind. If they receive an organ, they can still die and give their organs. Logically, shouldn't they get moved up in the list to receive organs, but possibly not have the option to withdrawal their donation once they've received organs?
- throwaway287391 10y agoThe problem with that is it removes the incentive to sign up until you need an organ yourself. The vast majority of people don't need organs (at any given time), so if you allow them to opt in only once they need an organ, very few additional people would register, basically defeating the purpose of the idea. I agree that it would be better than the current system though -- there would still be a small increase in the supply of organs, but not a big one.
- antiquark 10y agomaybe Big Organ can pay google to randomly crash their AI cars. The free market at work!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Daviey 10y agoPreviously posted.. not sure why the dupe detector didn't pick it up, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13284588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13284588
- frik 10y ago> Much has been said about the ways we expect our oncoming fleet of driverless cars to change the way we live—remaking us all into passengers, rewiring our economy, retooling our views of ownership, and reshaping our cities and roads. "retooling our views of ownership" ? What have self-driving cars to do with car ownership? If the global economy works there will be always ownership, there will always be companies from somewhere that will sell cars. It's like the WWW, you can put up paywalls, but there will always be another site powered by another business model (eg ads) that cater the users. Or you can still buy traditional light bulbs, and ironically the two companies that lobbied to ban light bulbs closed down their respective business units and focus on something else. Recently John Deer and Tesla vehicles have some kind dongle/software-as-a-service thing, where you have to register your vehicle with an account - that can limit the after-sale value/business. For every company that follows that plan, there will be x other vehicle manufacturers elsewhere that stay with the normal business model.