33 ms·
To Slow Global Warming, We Need Nuclear Power (Op-Ed)
- amai 10y agoAnd to even reverse global warming I suggest a full blown nuclear war. All the CO2 producing industry will be destroyed and the nuclear winter afterwards should be cold enough even for hardcore global warming alarmists.
- spodek 10y agoWhen will the mainstream consider it acceptable to talk about reducing consumption (without confusing it with lowering the standard of living) and reducing the population (without confusing it with eugenics)? We waste incredible amounts and a lower population means more goods for everyone. I'm not saying they solve everything. I'm just asking when we can talk about these issues that are a lot easier to implement than splitting atoms.
- DennisP 10y agoWe've been splitting atoms for 70 years. France has run its electric grid on 80% nuclear power. What's our track record on reducing consumption and population? Not saying we shouldn't do them all, but I don't think nuclear is the most difficult of these three.
- jat850 10y agoMy thoughts too. I would go further and say that at our current point in time, splitting atoms is easier than reducing population, and maybe easier than reducing consumption.
- omegaworks 10y ago>What's our track record on reducing consumption and population? As for the latter, it's great actually. Lifting people out of poverty and keeping their kids alive lowers their birth rate.
- DennisP 10y agoGlobally we haven't reduced population, we've just reduced its rate of increase. Our success rate on actually reducing global population is zero. And generally, lifting people out of poverty has meant increasing their carbon emissions.
- smaddox 10y agoFrance was able to run at 80% fission because they were selling excess production at low domestic demand times to adjacent territories. If you want to use nuclear for more than base load, you run into similar storage/transmission issues to solar/wind. Either way, we need a larger and more capable grid, so that production and demand can be balanced over larger areas.
- KVFinn 10y ago>Either way, we need a larger and more capable grid, so that production and demand can be balanced over larger areas. Yup. Larger power markets benefits every kind of power: wind, solar, and nuclear. There is a lot of resistance to this though. Every state would prefer wind sites build in their own state, rather than buying power from the windier state farther away. If you had a truly national sized grid then the power distribution between even just wind and solar is remarkably stable.
- p0nce 10y agoYes we have to support nuclear over-production during summer and store it with dams. Yet this winter we'll be under-capacity, lots of reactors are currently shutdown because of maintenance.
- DennisP 10y agoModern nuclear plants are able to load follow [1]. The main reason we use them for base load is that nuclear's cost is mainly fixed, so it makes economic sense to run them at full capacity and follow demand with fossil, which has lower fixed costs and higher variable costs. Molten salt reactors would be quite good at load following, because the reaction rate slows down so much as the fuel temperature increases. If you draw less power, you apply less cooling, so the fuel heats and the power output goes down. For example, the IMSR, likely the first MSR to be commercialized, is naturally a load-following reactor [2]. This doesn't mean it wouldn't make economic sense to, say, run nuclear for baseload, add solar for extra daytime demand, and use storage to smooth out the remaining demand mismatch. But that's a matter of economic optimization, not a technical limitation of nuclear. [1] http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2013/02/14/responding-to-system-demand/#sthash.VRgqQpEI.dpbs http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2013/02/14/responding-to-system-de... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSR#Control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMSR#Control
- thinkcontext 10y ago"What's our track record on reducing consumption and population?" EU28 and Japanese electric consumption is falling. Population is falling in Japan and is in some EU countries (Germany) and likely will on average in the EU in the not too distant future.
- ams6110 10y agoProposals that are contrary to basic human nature rarely gain much traction.
- triplesec 10y ago'Basic human nature'is a phrase that assumes a lot of things. How would you characterise this phrase in more detail, as it pertains to this topic? And how would you justify such claims?
- trevyn 10y agoThe human drive to reproduce.
- omginternets 10y agoFirst-world countries with ready access to contraception are facing a birth deficit, which is being eased by immigration. Sex-drive is hard to stamp out. Actual reproduction, not so much.
- flukus 10y agoThe desire to breed is pretty hard wired, species die without it. Sex is only fun because it rewards our desire to breed.
- Retra 10y agoSex is fun irrespective of it causing breeding. They are evolutionarily linked, but the have no moral relationship within the human brain. The desire to have sex and the desire to have children are for most people, completely independent desires. And for what it's worth, humans have no obligations to our evolutionary past. "How we evolved" has no direct bearing on what we want (or 'are meant') to do with our lives. It only determines what we are circumstantially capable of. EDIT: Here's a nerdy analogy for you. There is a relationship between the "programmer's intent" and the "binary program". But that relation has no bearing whatsoever on the relationship between the "binary program" and the "runtime behavior" of that program. These are independent relationships analgous to the relationship between "evolution" to "individual" and "individual" to "individual desires." (The feed-back which would link these -- from "runtime behavior" to "programmer's intent" -- only happens when the programmer is working, long before you end up with the binary you have when you run the program. In fact, this feedback is only ever employed to generate a completely new binary, never to modify the prior one. Thus ensuring that they cannot be co-dependent relationships, and thus evolution has no ability to determine individual behavior past the point of your DNA being fixed at conception.)
- niels_olson 10y agoI don't understand what you mean. What consumption shall we reduce? Less oil? Working on it (see: solar). Less food? Working on it (see: /r/progresspics, and all the science and journalism on this, soda bans, etc). Less cars? Working on it (see: Waze, Uber, Lyft, public transit, et al). Do you suggest that China didn't try population control at scale for generations? (1) What, exactly, do you mean? (1) https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-lifts-one-child-policy-amid-worries-of-graying-population/2015/10/29/207fc0e6-7e2b-11e5-beba-927fd8634498_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-lift...
- Taek 10y agoLess transportation, less devices (instead of upgrading every year, how about using the same phone 5 years in a row?), don't eat meat, generally just reduce consumption. It does not count as less consumption if you replace oil with solar. Replace it with a void. Whatever activities you were doing that required energy, just don't do those things. We could do a lot better if we just lived like the 1600s.
- welly 10y ago"We could do a lot better if we just lived like the 1600s" Sure, nothing like a bit of plague and disease to thin out the population a bit.
- kalleboo 10y ago> Less oil? Working on it (see: solar). And failing at it, oil use is still going up > Less food? Working on it (see: /r/progresspics, and all the science and journalism on this, soda bans, etc). And failing at it, see worldwide obesity statistics > Less cars? Working on it (see: Waze, Uber, Lyft, public transit, et al). And failing at it, see the meteoric rise of motorization in developing countries > Do you suggest that China didn't try population control at scale for generations? Are you suggesting it was a success, and didn't cause a huge gender imbalance which is threatening to cause social strife?
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marcoperaza 10y agoPeople = economic power. Consumption = economic power. It's very likely that China and/or India will eventually be the most powerful countries in the world. Why? The simple fact that they have the most people and will have the biggest markets. And anyhow, if we can sustainably support double or triple the current population, then why not?
- adventured 10y agoVery large populations will increasingly be a liability in the age of robotics + AI. China and India will suffer immensely because they're simultaneously extremely poor, extremely under-educated and overpopulated at exactly the wrong time. Their over-population will be a persistent drag on raising the standard of living for all of their people, leading to stagnation once their easy fill-in growth is done (China's ended years ago). There is no scenario under which either nation can substantially boost the economic output of their bottom ~800 million, the global economy will never grow fast enough to allow for it. For example, India's path forward on easy GDP growth is already blocked by the end of the manufacturing boom that China was riding for decades (and that regional competitors in east Asia are already deep into taking from China). India coming from extraordinary poverty, will find it very easy to maintain 5% & 6% type growth for years to come, the economic wall will show up as they try to leap toward the middle of nations economically. It's very likely that neither China nor India will ever become the most powerful countries.
- DrScump 10y agoreducing consumption (and) population Those goals don't conflict with a shift to nuclear.
- freehunter 10y agoThey don't, but if we met those goals we may be able to get away with not using nuclear. Nuclear produces a lot of power with relatively low side effects, but solar and wind produce a smaller amount of power with no side effects. If we can globally bring our power consumption down to that smaller amount that can be met by solar and wind, we could get rid of the economic and political arguments that keep nuclear from taking off. Nuclear has such a bad name in so many countries that it'd be nice if we could consider it a dead technology. To do that, it would really help if we could cut consumption to not need the massive glob of power than nuclear is designed to provide.
- DrScump 10y agosolar and wind produce a smaller amount of power with no side effects Actually, manufacture, transportation, and installation consume mostly fossil fuels, and manufacture has environmental impacts (including waste products). I'd consider that a "side effect".
- freehunter 10y agoBut that's true of nuclear as well. Building a power plant and disposing of waste (not to mention disposing of waste water, which is often an environmental challenge) have huge costs that are fed by fossil fuels as well. What's implied by "produce power with no side effects" is it does not take fossil fuels to keep them running, nor do they put out any harmful by-products. Even hot water discharged into a lake and steam discharged into the air is more of a harmful by-product than the literally nothing that solar and wind generators produce.
- krzyk 10y ago> solar and wind produce a smaller amount of power with no side effects Without side effects? wind? Have you by any chance seen what wind plants do to birds? Or have you had the opportunity to live in a house near a wind plant? The noise is very annoying. Water plants looks much better than wind plants.
- waynecochran 10y agoPopulation would be declining in us w/o migrants entering the country. So the US is doing its part on population reduction. https://www.census.gov/popclock/ https://www.census.gov/popclock/
- oconnore 10y agoI don't think you read that right. The growth rate is still (net) 1 person every 24 seconds without migrants.
- waynecochran 10y agoOops your right. My bad.
- maxerickson 10y agoImmigrants and their children do account for most of the population growth in the US though.
- panic 10y agoWhat makes you say they'd be easier to implement?
- appleiigs 10y agoWe can't even agree if there is global warming or not.
- stellar678 10y agoWe're actually all over that, and it will only continue to get better. The US energy productivity (GDP per unit of energy) has gone up 58% in the last 25 years, and most other regions of the world have seen large gains as well: http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=27032 http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=27032 Our energy use per capita also continues to decline.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- torpfactory 10y agoThis. Do we really need more stuff? I think the HN crowd is certainly beyond this sort of simplistic understanding. But what about non-physical things? Do we need more entertainment? We are without a doubt the most entertained people in the history of the world. Do we need better connectedness? (I think we do, but it's not the kind on offer by Facebook). I think writing letters and using snail mail is about the bandwidth limit for humans having deep conversations. Do we need more and better sensual experiences? I love amazing food, but I'm not sure I could build a fulfilling life through my belly. Maybe the best thing that global warming could do is force us to confront our choices. What is truly important? We probably don't need the consumption we currently maintain to have the really important things.
- visarga 10y agoWhile I like the sentiment, I think global warming won't make us consumption minimalists. New materials and automation will make production cheaper. Automation will also make earth cleaner and self-cleaning. We're not just on the cusp of AI, but also of nanotechnology (where we manufacture with DNA and proteins), nuclear fusion (see the amazing new REBCO tape superconductors), 3d-printing and probably a dozen other emerging tech trends. We don't, as a society, go the way of minimalism. Technology progress happens as if it has a will of its own, not dependent on individuals, governments and even wars going on. We're witnessing the birth of a new bootstrapped entity - we had the virus, the cell, the organism and now the machine. The moment we make a self replicating factory that only uses cheap local materials, we've seen the birth of this new life form. It will be the new cell, the bootstrapped, self-replicating, self-repairing, adaptive source of everything we need and capable of improving itself by continuous optimization. We can't stop the birth of technological life.
- white-flame 10y agoPopulation is a self-correcting system. As people (especially women) get broader education, success, and opportunity, reproductive rates decline. When life is tough, people pop out more children. Reducing consumption is a strange one. We keep making our devices more power efficient, but we pile on more of them. We have more efficient cars, but we seem to be driving them longer and more often. Busy-ness fills whatever space it's given, and that's a huge driver of consumption. Of course, the very notion of "start ups" as promoted by sites like this are all about increasing consumption, often with new and frankly superfluous service-based conveniences. Money flows when consumption increases, so it'd have to be a truly cultural shift of simplicity, not a legislative or business shift. While I do think energy consumption per capita in first world countries is probably decreasing, we haven't yet hit "peak population", and lots of people are moving up in poorer nations to be able to consume more.
- 6t6t6t6 10y agoFor me, reduced consumption is about promoting different habits. In most of western countries, the society is set in a way that happiness is directly tied to consumption. Marketing and the society in general, makes people feel that the only way to fill their lives is by buying things. In some other countries, people may be able to achieve similar levels of happiness with lower consumption levels; for instance, by doing things instead of buying things.
- adventured 10y agoIf you want to plug every car into the grid - and get rid of the combustion engines - in the next 20 years, then yes, we need a substantial increase in energy production and grid capacity. Want everyone to use autonomous Uber-type services instead of owning? They might; that's not happening in the next 20 years however.
- jerkstate 10y agoSure. You first.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoA. Who exactly are you suggesting do something? B. What exactly are you suggesting they do?
- unclebucknasty 10y agoI think you're right that what the terminology conjures in the mind is important. And, it can be tricky to communicate some of these ideas positively. For instance, the phrase "reducing the population" is probably as unpalatable as "eugenics" for some. It does sound a bit callous; as if we are saying that we want/need people (i.e. members of the existing population) to die. Even phrases like "population control" and "population management" carry this negative connotation. There probably needs to be a new, friendlier term. Something positive-sounding like "right-sizing" or "harmonizing". In short, these ideas need better PR.
- pdkl95 10y agohttp://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_and_the_magic_washing_machine http://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_and_the_magic_washing_... Hans Rosling has a very good argument that we need a certain minimum amount of energy usage if we want both social and population stability. Wasted energy in the developed world is an interesting discussion, but if we want to address climate change the focus has to be on the much larger population of the world that is trying to rapidly increase their energy needs. > without confusing it with lowering the standard of living That's precisely the problem. Any proposal that significantly reduces energy usage almost certainly involves telling a large portion of the world "no, you don't get a washing machine" or similar restrictions on the basic benefits of industrialization.
- fulafel 10y agoIt's easy to imagine many proposals that don't restrict access to washing machines. For example a per capita progressive CO2 tax would be one. We generally have the mechanisms to implement binding international agreements about these things, it's just a question of political will.
- CountSessine 10y agoWe generally have the mechanisms to implement binding international agreements about these things Binding? Name one that doesn't involve nuclear weapon proliferation.
- dispose13432 10y ago>For example a per capita progressive CO2 tax would be one You can't Carbon tax people by income (because people don't pollute directly). You'll target polluters. So you go to Apple and tell them that they emitted so many kg of CO2, pay ... tax, Which will undoubtedly find its way to rising phone prices, which means (poor) people don't get nice things.
- fulafel 10y agoThere are several alternative ways to address this, for example products bought by consumers might account toward their CO2 emissions. Or just apply the CO2 tax to companies directly. Anyway, let's not get lost in the details, I was just offering a trivial counterexample against the claim that > Any proposal that significantly reduces energy usage almost certainly involves telling a large portion of the world "no, you don't get a washing machine"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sfifs 10y agoWithout large scale energy usage (eg. heating/cooling), large parts of the world (anything outside say +/-10 to 30 degrees of latitude) are practically unliveable for most parts of the year in modern standards of comfortable living. So you practically cannot reduce energy consumption without depopulating. In terms of population reduction, history suggests any culture that does not propogate will be pushed aside by one that does. It will be interesting to see if there will still be a Japan in 3 generations.
- wahern 10y agoWaste is a value judgment. A more constructive rephrasing is to ask when are we going to factor in the cost of externalities (emissions, toxins, etc) into the price of energy. The best way to reduce consumption, especially for a fungible product like electricity, is by increasing the price. The higher the price someone pays, the less they're going to "waste". The dilemma is gauging and factoring into the price of a product the cost of externalities, especially externalities that are remote from the consumption. Guaging the cost is difficult (we normally use free markets to do that for us), but factoring the cost into the price is easy. You can remove subsidies, e.g. for things like coal. You can tax generation, like a carbon tax. You can tax consumption, and even get fancy, like using progressive taxation (i.e. low base rate so people can operate their refrigerator, with an increasing rate as consumption grows). Another alternative is energy saving measures. California has very aggressive energy efficiency requirements for all kinds of products, not just cars. They lead by far every other U.S. state, the U.S. federal government, and even Europe. Most people are unaware of it. Conservative economists argue that it just shifts consumption to other uses. But in _reality_ it's been highly effective; it's a significant reason why California has the lowest per capita energy consumption in the country. The fact of that matter is that changes in consumption patterns are relatively inelastic (as are, notably, responses to energy pricing). So as long as California continues to impose and amend efficiency regulations, it can continue hastening more optimal, more economically efficient energy consumption compared to the "free market" laggards. The trick is that the energy efficiency standards very closely track the state of industrial manufacturing techniques, maximize efficiency gains while minimize manufacturing costs. It's a small example of "central planning" by technocrats gone right. It works because it's practical to quantify the costs (changes in technology and manufacturing methods) and benefits (fewer watts) with a high degree of accuracy; and because if there's a miscalculation and the burden imposed is too high, people simply won't buy new products and will continue using the older, more inefficient ones, so there's a strong signaling loop back to the technocrats. BTW, it's worth pointing out that we do _all_ of these things. At least, California does. So to answer the question of when we'll begin doing it, we already are, and have been for decades. The real question is, can we do better....
- niels_olson 10y agoMy undergrad is in Physics and I took engineering classes in Rickover Hall. I was stationed on a nuclear ship. Even after deploying for the Fukushima disaster, I am a fan of nuclear power. But I have a hard time justifying new investment in an era where solar is competitively priced. The downside of solar is approximately 0 compared to the downside of a reactor accident. I'll even allow for the high, high likelihood that more people will die installing roof-top solar than will ever die in the lifetime of all nuclear reactors combined. The political capital lost in a reactor accident isn't worth it. The lost of faith in technology, the loss of trust in science. The mass hysteria just isn't worth it.
- DennisP 10y agoSolar plus all the infrastructure required to run a wind/solar grid without fossil backup is not yet competitively priced. It looks great at low market penetration but we need to eliminate emissions, not just lower them a little. We're going to end up with plenty of mass hysteria if we don't put the brakes on climate change as fast as we possibly can, by every means available.
- ianai 10y agoOnly mass hysteria will force societal change.
- labster 10y agoThis is the kind of comment that sounds sarcastic on first read, but is entirely genuine. Human societies, en masse, are terrible rational decision makers. Or maybe it's that they're very good rational decision makers on the individual level, leading to the tragedy of the commons? So we'd need mass hysteria to cause group rationality? Ooop, that's the bell, Pretzel Logic class dismissed!
- ekianjo 10y ago> Human societies, en masse, are terrible rational decision makers. Never seen "societies" making any decision. Most of the time, there are very few people in positions of power who make such decisions. If you want to see "societies" making decisions every single day, look at the market. Not so irrational at all, though.
- flukus 10y agoAssuming nuclear can slow it, we needed it 20 years ago, not now.
- leodeid 10y agoYes, yes, the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, the second best is today. Is nuclear any different? I am unaware of anything about nuclear energy that would have worked 20 years ago but is a bad idea to do today.
- sova 10y agoTrue or false: a nuclear reactor can create a nuclear explosion? (the answer may surprise you!)
- jat850 10y agoI would expect a significant percentage of people know that nuclear explosion is not a risk of nuclear power.
- leodeid 10y agoI would be surprised, to be honest, if more than half the american population knew that a nuclear power plant literally cannot blow up like an atomic bomb. However, I can't find any information to support either of our gut feelings. All of the polling information is of the form "how much do you like nuclear" or "what is the best non-fossil fuel power source". I'd love to see answers to "why do you think nuclear energy is a bad idea" or something.
- pdkl95 10y agoWhile it isn't proper poll, Veritasium's interviews[1] with the general public support the supposition that most people lack basic information about anything nuclear. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQmnztyXwVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQmnztyXwVA
- niels_olson 10y agoTrue or false: a reactor accident costs more in political capital than all the capital of building it to begin with...
- freehunter 10y ago>(the answer may surprise you!) Is the answer "yes"? "Yes" is the only answer that would surprise me. Because the answer is no. It can't.
- melling 10y agoHere's a Ted Talk that says the same thing: https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_how_fear_of_nuclear_power_is_hurting_the_environment https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_how_fear_of_...
- optforfon 10y agoOne thing that needs to be stressed is that realistically there is a rather limited amount of Uranium than can be extracted from the earth for nuclear power. That if we could magically convert to 100% nuclear power - it wouldn't last that long. from wikipedia "Still, the world's present measured resources of uranium, economically recoverable at the arbitrary price ceiling of 130 USD/kg, are enough to last for between 70 and 100 years" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power#Conventional_fuel_resources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power#Conventional_fue... reactors have a life of around 60 years I think. So maybe you could double the amount of nuclear power? But it's not like the world can magically go to 100% nuclear indefinitely.
- wbl 10y agoReprocessing can massively increase utilization. All that U 238 can also be burned once it is Pu 239.
- unethical_ban 10y agoPlutonium and Thorium are other options.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoThat "arbitrary price ceiling" is exceedingly arbitrary. You get a lot more than $130 worth of electricity from fissioning a kilogram of uranium even with present technology. In current U.S. power reactor designs (no breeding) you can get about a million kwH of heat from one kg of uranium. If you figure 30% efficiency and 12 cents per kWH, that's about $40,000 worth of electricity. It should be clear that even with present technology uranium is economic to recover at prices dramatically higher than $130/kg. If breeder reactors are used the recoverable energy from a kg of uranium goes up by a factor of 100 or so, making that kg of uranium worth about $4 million in terms of electricity. With that technology it would be economically feasible to recover uranium from sea water, and there's enough of it in the ocean to last for billions of years.
- kevinburke 10y agoWhat (if any) progress is being made on producing nuclear power via groups of much smaller reactors, instead of larger reactors that are more failure prone? What are the latest trends in the nuclear power industry?
- maroonblazer 10y agoOne of the best retorts to the anti-nuclear position comes from Richard Rhodes, author of "The Making of the Atomic Bomb" on an episode of "Book TV" on C-Span in response to a caller asking/warning about nuclear waste.[0] In this 3 minute clip he lays out a very compelling argument for nuclear power. Here's the article in Foreign Affairs he references in the clip (registration (free) required).[1] [0]https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4639510/richard-rhodes-nuclear-power https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4639510/richard-rhodes-nuclea... [1] https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2000-01-01/need-nuclear-power https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2000-01-01/need-nucl...
- humbleMouse 10y agoNot all nuclear energy is the same. I encourage people to check out Thorium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium http://energyfromthorium.com/ http://energyfromthorium.com/
- NolF 10y agoThorium still has some major technical issues such as corrosion from molten salts though.
- EGreg 10y agoI used to think that global warming was a slam dunk. But then I looked at the data... the carbon makeup of the atmosphere hasn't changed much at all, and we have already reached peak oil. If the carbon sinks (oceans etc.) can hold 2x the current amount they absorbed without much trouble then we are in the clear. Perhaps CFCs and Ozone Depleting Substances present a danger but we have largely reduced their use since the 90s. So I am not sure anymore than people will mess up the ATMOSPHERE globally. Locally - yes. And that doesn't let people off the hook when it comes to overfishing, logging forests, destroying ecosystems such as rainforests, wild bees and monarch butterflies, introducing new predators into oceans, non-biodegradable plastic, turning the world into farms etc etc. Having said that, where is the data showing humans having a huge effect on the atmosphere composition??
- SapphireSun 10y agoWere these the graphs you were looking at? global temperature anomaly since 1880 -- http://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/graphs_v3/ http://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/graphs_v3/ carbon dioxide for last 400k years -- http://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/carbon-dioxide/ http://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/carbon-dioxide/ One person I met seemed to think that CO2 would be balanced by algae blooms in the oceans, but he wasn't a climate scientist. Nonetheless, if the ice caps melt enough before CO2 is compensated for, they'll release tons of methane which is an order of magnitude more potent than CO2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_methane_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_methane_emissions Here's NASA's site on the evidence for global warming: http://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ http://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ Here's a site that discusses the evidence that humans are at fault: http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/science_and_impacts/science/human-contribution-to-gw-faq.html http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/science_and_impacts/sci...
- EGreg 10y agoSee my reply to a sister comment for the data I am speaking of. I agree that currently we have some correlation of global warming and CO2 increase, but this doesn't prove causation esp considering the 70s experienced global cooling. https://skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-co2-enhanced-greenhouse-effect.htm https://skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-co2-enha... AND the main point is that there is a limit on how much more Co2 can be released: roughly the same amount that already has, if we reached peak fossil fuels. To put things in perspective, that's going from 0.03% to max 0.06% concentration. CO2's effect as a greenhouse gas should be measured as a function of its concentration relative to the TOTAL atmosphere. Maybe it rises exponentially, but maybe not. Like putting layers of paint on a window. We'd need hard numbers. Meanwhile... no matter what you do, carbon credits or not, eventually ALL the fossil fuels WILL be burned up so it's only a matter of time. Better to learn to build artificial carbon sinks and methane sinks to capture the CO2 back underground. It's called forests and algae. Want to save the world? Plant forests! http://www.americanforests.org/magazine/article/north-american-forests-in-the-age-of-man/ http://www.americanforests.org/magazine/article/north-americ... On the other hand we CAN reduce the amount of methane by reducing the amount of cows we raise for hamburgers etc.
- tibarun 10y ago"Nuclear power lobbyists and their marketing firms want us to believe that humankind’s current CO2 atmospheric releases would have been much worse were it not for those 438 nukes now operating. How much worse? The World Nuclear Association industry trade group estimates that an additional 1.1 GT of CO2 would have been created in 2015 if natural gas plants supplied the electricity instead of those 438 nukes[17]. Do the math! 1.1 additional GT out of 36 GT emitted is only a 3% difference. This 3% value is not a typographical error. Worldwide, all those nukes made only a 3% dent in yearly CO2 production. Put another way, each of the 438 individual nuclear plants contribute less than seven thousandths of one percent to CO2 reduction[18]. That’s hardly enough to justify claims that keeping your old local nuke running is necessary to prevent the sea from rising." Read more: https://fairewinds.squarespace.com/demystify//demystifying-nuclear-power-nuclear-powers-carbon-dioxide-co2-smoke-screen https://fairewinds.squarespace.com/demystify//demystifying-n...
- shadykiller 10y agoAlways been curious about this - wont nuclear plants increase thermal input of earth ? True for fossil fuels too which were never burnt in such vast quantity These energy sources are outside of solar energy so how much more can they warm up the earth ?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kijin 10y agoAll energy produced in any type of power plant eventually becomes heat. Fossil fuels have the additional property of making Earth retain more of it. Solar could also increase the temperature if it traps energy that would otherwise be immediately reflected back to space. I'm not sure if the difference is significant, though, compared to the effect of greenhouse gases.
- jlj 10y agoIs it technically possible to have a global power grid, where solar generated on the sunny side of the earth can be used on the dark side, eliminating the need for energy storage?
- tehabe 10y agoPossible maybe, there was a project called Desertec, but it is pointless. The advantage of renewable energy is the possibility of a decentralised energy supply.
- niftich 10y agoMassive infrastructure costs, the need for political coordination, and transmission losses [1] make this scenario unlikely. [1] http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-much-electricity-disappears-between-a-power-plant-and-your-plug/ http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-...
- mikeyouse 10y agoTransmission losses aren't the restriction that many people imply. Modern HVDC lines have less than half the losses as compared to a similar-length AC line. There's a cable under construction from Scotland to England that will have a 2,200MW capacity, will run over 400km, and will have losses under 3%.[1] Brazil finished a 7,700MW line that runs 2,400km from a series of hydroelectric dams to major population centers with something like 8% losses. Sure, 8% of 7,700MW is a ton of energy lost, but 8% for moving power from the equivalent distance of Denver to NYC is pretty damn good. It's not out of the realm of possibilities to build a HVDC line from England to the US within the next decade or two. If you figure 6,000km and 1.5% losses per 1,000km, you might be able to keep the total loss below 10%. Run an 800KV line (or a pair of 800KV lines) and you could probably install a 15+ GW of transmission capacity. [1] - http://www.eaem.co.uk/news/world-beating-%E2%82%AC11bn-under-sea-cable-connect-england-and-scotland http://www.eaem.co.uk/news/world-beating-%E2%82%AC11bn-under...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fgpwd 10y agoThe initial estimates for the cost to repair the damage caused by Fukushima were as far as I remember, around 50 billion dollars. According to a recent news article [1], the costs are now estimated at 250 billion dollars. They just keep on increasing. And then there is also the human/environmental damage to consider. I have been excited about nuclear since my school days, but at this point the downside if something goes wrong is imo just not financially worth it. I would much rather pay 2x for a safer solar plant with similar output than invest something this high-risk. It's like selling uncovered options, with no way to set a stop-loss or to recover if anything goes wrong. I think it is likely that at some point the global community will also realize that the cost considering the risks is just not worth it and begin to move away from nuclear fission. Especially if any another incident like Fukushima happens in the next decade or so; that could have big implications on nuclear policy. [1]:http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2016-12-17/fukushima-nuclear-clean-up,-compensation-costs-nearly-double/8127268?pfmredir=sm http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2016-12-17/fukushima-nuclear-c...
- underrun 10y agoThe advantages of advancing technology and building smaller safer reactors would go a long way to avoiding such disasters. Because things can go wrong is not a reason to stop research into making them better and safer. The real way to keep ahead of this is not to extend the life span of existing reactors but to build aggressively in order to take older ones offline as newer smaller safer reactors are ready. And keep doing that.
- MichaelApproved 10y agoIterating aggressively is great when the consequences aren't as dire as nuclear mistakes. The last thing I'd want is more plants built aggressively when stupid mistakes happen at the non-aggressive rate, such as installing the reactor backwards. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Onofre_Nuclear_Generating_Station#Safety_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Onofre_Nuclear_Generating_...
- shawn-furyan 10y ago
- dkarapetyan 10y agoWhat happened to pebble bed reactors?
- mwlyons 10y agoHead over to www.x-energy.com to see plans for our Xe-100 high temperature gas cooled pebble bed reactor! @xenergynuclear on twitter
- swehner 10y agoGarbage from the New York Times, as usual.
- sanjeetsuhag 10y agoQuality contribution to the discussion right here. Do you mind elaborating what do you think is the problem with the article ?
- swehner 10y agoSorry if your sense of entitlement to quality contributions was offended. The article has no substance, makes arbitrary suggestions. What's the "slow" in the title about? The word occurs once on the page, and that is in the title. Let's go through some paragraphs. 1st paragraph: garbage 2nd paragraph: garbage (Not the qualifier to "emissions from the electricity sector") 3rd paragraph: garbage 4th paragraph: garbage Note, no alternative energy sources are looked at or mentioned, except for "fossil fuels". It's just gossip. BTW, author is claimed to be "Senator Lamar Alexander, Republican of Tennessee"
- dang 10y agoThis comment is uncivil and your previous one was unsubstantive. Posting this way is an abuse of HN, so please don't do that. We're looking for civil and substantive comments, and would appreciate it if you'd read and follow the site rules: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- blondie9x 10y agoYou need a combination of solar, wind, geothermal, hydroelectric, and yes nuclear. What some forget is base load power. One of the main reasons natural gas is used as an alternative for coal despite still producing carbon emissions is because it also can be used as a base load electric grid fuel. Nuclear can provide clean base load power. I understand many are concerned, especially after the terrible tragedy at Fukushima; however there are ways we can prevent that tragedy from ever reoccurring. By transitioning to nuclear technologies utilizing fuel cycles that consume nuclear waste or use fuels capable of reducing risk of meltdown accidents, we can get closer to both clean energy and safety. We don't primarily need nuclear but it should be considered in the mix at least for baseload considerations.
- kumarski 10y agoI haven't met anyone intelligent who suggests we should go Solar. Silicon tetrachloride pollution is the worst.
- aswanson 10y agoWhat do the folks here think of investing in uranium mining stock cameco?
- petre 10y agoWith environmentalists pushing for nuclear station closures, power stations going out of service due to exceeding their lifetime and MOX fuel available, cheap solar, offshore wind, I'd rather not.
- probablybanned 10y agoI'm not a nuclear engineer so I hesitate to shit up the thread with my armchair opinion, but I'm a big fan of small, low maintenance reactor designs like the Toshiba 4S. I feel like that's the way it ought to go: Away from large stationary reactor installations that require a huge amount of skilled labor on site for construction and maintenance, and toward modular banks of reactors that can be taken offline and refurbished off-site. With a smaller, one size fits all design, one might expect to find economies of scale that don't currently exist. In much the same way, SpaceX seeks to make Falcon launches routine and push down costs of their incredibly complex machine through rapid iteration and refinement -- although reactor failures in the field must not be of the "energetic" variety of course. Are there limitations of physics that will keep nuclear power stuck in the mainframe era, or might we see a commodity revolution?
- scurvy 10y agoIsn't nuclear still really expensive? I read that Entergy was shutting down some nuclear plants they recently acquired because they had not-good track records and it cost more to produce energy than what they could sell it for [0]. In networking terms, nuclear energy always felt like Infinband or ATM to me. In theory, superior in many ways but in reality a pain in the ass that never really quite worked well. What the world needs is Ethernet and nothing more. I'm not sure what the energy equivalent of Ethernet is, but I know it aint nuclear. [0] http://www.nbcchicago.com/investigations/Nuclear-Plant-on-Lake-Michigan-Plans-to-Permanently-Shut-Down-405526615.html http://www.nbcchicago.com/investigations/Nuclear-Plant-on-La...
- kashkhan 10y agoThe expense comes from unwise regulation and lack of development i.e. pork. It works perfectly fine in france which is 80% powered by nuclear. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_France#/media/File:Electricity_in_France.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_France#/media...
- scurvy 10y ago"We? No, we are not French. We're American, because you're in America, okay? Greatest country on the planet." (movie quote before anyone gets too upset)
- beders 10y agoJust to remind the nuclear fans here: cost of Chernobyl: estimated around 201b euros, cost of lives: between 4000 and several hundred thousands indirectly, the area is a radioactive wasteland for centuries to come, the reactor still needs additional protection. The effects are still measurable all over Europe, resettlement of thousands of people. That is ONE reactor gone wrong. Why anyone would build another one when solar is down to .21 per watts is beyond me.
- goatlover 10y agoBy wasteland, you mean humans no longer live there, but I've seen video, and it looks like plants and animals are doing okay. You wouldn't be able to tell there had been a meltdown. Maybe some of the animals have a higher cancer rate than normal, or other health issues? Would be curious to know. Looked to me like nature had taken over after humans left.
- kashkhan 10y agoFrance is mostly powered by nuclear. How many french have died from it? Yes it's possible to make a nuclear wasteland. But it's also possible to not make it.
- petre 10y agoThe RMBK reactors at Chernobyl are of an irresponsible design, with no containment, graphite moderator and a highly positive void coefficient. Combined that with human error and zealotry and you have a recipe for disaster. Russian VVER PWRs on the other hand have excellent track record with no accidents whatsoever. Your country has at least two gen IV reactor designs with pasive cooling and negative void coefficient. Solar is not base load. To make solar base load you need solar thermal with molten salts or a gas pipe nearby to run the turbines on gas during the night. Solar PV is good for distributed power generation, as they do it in Germany where almost every building has solar PV on their roof. Your other bet for base load power of a comparable scale to nuclear is geothermal power, but it's highly location dependent.
- dispose13432 10y ago
- JacksonGariety 10y agoPlease, HN: read more about fukushima. This could be the end of it all. All of human history could go out in the blink of an eye.
- kashkhan 10y agoFukushima was badly built, badly protected, and badly operated. First few decades airplanes were deadly. Now not so much. All tech can be tamed if you put in the effort.
- JacksonGariety 10y agoBut what if someone doesn't. A chain is as strong as its weakest link.
- kashkhan 10y agoyes. Modern large airplanes are more complex than reactors and have more uncertainty, and have more places on the chain they can go wrong. But they don't, at least not in the US in last 15 years. Why?
- Ygg2 10y agoFukushima was also befell by a strongest tsunami in decades. And even then, the greatest damage was by the tidal wave.
- pvaldes 10y agoAll tech can be tamed, the problem is "tamed by who and for doing what against who?". As any sirian children could teach us, airplanes are deadlier than ever.
- kashkhan 10y agotechnology enables. it doesn't care about life or death. It's not supposed to. Humans are supposed to are about life or death. Take your beef up with humans using tech to kill.
- wamatt 10y agoIt's kind of unfortunate that the label "nuclear power" seems to inevitably bundle both nuclear fission and nuclear fusion into the same public policy debate. Their respective safety profiles couldn't be further apart. While the economic risks for a failed nuclear fusion strategy can be argued, given even a modest chance for eventually producing large amounts of clean and safe energy output 24/7, should we not be pursuing fusion more aggressively?
- Twisell 10y agoLast year I met a doctor that work at the experimental ITER fusion plant. He was pretty optimistic about the technology but totally desperate about budget. It's an international initiative and US are actually one of the country that pay the least compared to its Income per capita... By today funding it's clear that real solutions won't be ready until 2050, hence fission is still required in the mix until then. I don't get how people can blinding defend that renewable alone is the answer, because once you do the math it just don't work.
- wamatt 10y agoAlthough considered somewhat non-traditional, aneutronic fusion[1] approaches may have interesting possibilities on significantly smaller budgets than ITER [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion#Current_research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion#Current_rese...
- clarkmoody 10y agoFrom a few weeks ago on HN, I watched this video[1] that made me much more optimistic about fusion. The bottom line is that the ITAR direction is misguided since superconducting technology has come so far in recent years. The video is worth the watch. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4
- coolman90 10y agoWhy would you say such thing anyways..
- mkandes 10y agoWe will probably have no better production-ready, scalable, (minimally) carbon-free option for energy production to combat climate change in our lifetimes. If you don't believe me and you haven't seen a real scientist explain the scale of the energy problem in a cogent way, you should watch Nathan Lewis: 2005: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUKqx2uk-Gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUKqx2uk-Gs 2014: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16IQhTiN6OI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16IQhTiN6OI If he cannot sell you, no one will ... and he's a solar guy.
- adrianN 10y agoI'm not that old. I believe that I'll see a fusion reactor connected to the grid.
- mkandes 10y agoMaybe one day. My bet is that, at best, a commercially built one won't be switched on before 2065. ITER [1] is and will continue to be behind schedule and over budget, pushing back any follow on plans for DEMO [2], let alone the subsequent commercialization of that technology. Of course, there's always hope for a breakthrough. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO
- aamederen 10y agoThe thing I worry about nuclear power is that, with the latest events in 2015 and 2016, once again we saw that, we are still pretty bad at preventing terrorist attacks and I cannot think about how a terrorist attack to a nuclear plant end up? I am even surprised that no big attack has been made to such a dangerous facility.
- sintaxi 10y agoAgreed. The security budget for a modern day nuclear power plant would be astronomical and forever growing.
- aninhumer 10y agoI think you might be overestimating the risk here. A nuclear power plant is essentially a massive concrete bunker. It's designed to contain a nuclear reaction, so I suspect you'd need a phenomenal amount of explosives to cause any damage, and if you have those, there are likely much more effective ways to use them for terrorism. If instead you attack the facility to attempt to gain control and cause a meltdown, you'd need to gain access to all the various safety overrides, and then hold that position for as long as it takes the reactor to meltdown. And that's assuming there are no absolute fail-safes that can't be disabled. And all this is assuming that the failure mode of the reactor is even bad enough to cause significant damage, which is less the case with newer reactors.
- Wissmania 10y agoOne advantage of nuclear power relative to other renewable sources is that it that unlike wind/solar, it can provide consistent energy 24/7. Our energy storage solutions are simply not good enough to provide sufficient power in downtimes. If your concern is safety, then nuclear power seems to be the best choice: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents
- philipkglass 10y agoThird generation reactor designs like the AP1000 and EPR were, prior to actual construction, promoted as increasing safety and reducing construction costs/time via standardization and simpler passive safety features, compared to older Generation II/II+ reactors that currently make up most of the world's operating reactors. Now that they're actually under construction these reactor designs too are terribly over-budget and over-schedule, just like the 1980s reactor projects that burned US utilities bad enough to scare them away for a generation. AFAICT "late and over budget" usually happens with megaprojects of all kinds, and unfortunately commercial power reactors are only available in "mega" sizes. The AP1000 and EPR especially were designed larger than median Gen II units, for economies of scale, but seem to be reaping anti-economies of scale. Small modular reactors with a faster learning curve and more units to learn across might finally tame schedule and cost problems... but it's hard to find investors optimistic and deep-pocketed enough to spend a decade iterating on the concept with real hardware. Most "nuclear startups" are stuck at nothing but simulations and PowerPoint. Shouldn't government be making these sorts of high-risk, high-reward, long term investments? They should, but unfortunately political opposition to nuclear power is much more concentrated, if not more broad, than support.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoThe UK government just made a big commitment to a new nuclear power station at Hinkley Point C, largely funded by a high guaranteed cost per unit of electricity. I'm doubtful it will ever go live though.
- ReganKoopmans 10y agoIf managed correctly, it's far far cleaner than coal and oil.
- Marazan 10y agoNuclear was the correct answer 15 years ago. It is no longer 15 years ago.
- jcoffland 10y ago> It is no longer 15 years ago. It never is.
- jolux 10y agoThe math just doesn't add up, unfortunately. It seems like a harsh reality that liberals are unwilling to confront for hippy-dippy tree hugger reasons but even economically speaking nuclear is just a bad idea: http://crookedtimber.org/2016/07/20/nuclear-math-doesnt-add-up/ http://crookedtimber.org/2016/07/20/nuclear-math-doesnt-add-...
- olouv 10y agoI'd recommend anyone interested in this question to watch "Into Eternity" (available on YouTube), a documentary about the facility Finland is building to house all of their country's nuclear waste.
- f_allwein 10y agoNuclear power also leaves behind waste that is hazardous for between 10.000 and 1.000.000 years ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste ), i.e. has t be stored safely for that amount of time. Most countries using nuclear power haven't even found a site to store waste permanently (e. g. Germany), let alone figured out how to tell future generations to stay away.
- lkbm 10y agoThis sounds crass(?) to ask, but if we already have some, does more make it much worse? At this point we HAVE some nuclear waste already. Safely storing nuclear waste is an extremely difficult problem, and one we have yet to fully solve. But if I have X tons to store for 10k+ years, what's the marginal cost of increasing X by a factor of two, or ten, or a hundred? (And what sort of increase in X would we be looking at?) If someone told me to figure out how to affordably and safely store five megatons of nuclear waste (rough number from a quick Google search), I'd spend a lot of time with lots of experts figuring something out. If partway through you came back and said "oops, make that ten megatons", I might say "oh snap, our current site/plan doesn't scale", but I feel like it's more likely that I'd say "well, the bulk of the solution scales just fine". (Maybe the site wouldn't scale and the political NIMBY part would have to be redone, though, which is not a small problem.) But I don't know! The fact that we haven't figured out the problem means maybe we should put some effort into that, but we if we're going to scale up nuclear, we should probably do it soon. Probably twenty years ago or so.
- lispm 10y agoAgain, these articles lack a specific plan. I would have thought that there would have been enough time to come up with numbers: how many reactors, over which period of time, costs, hiw to finance it, how to build-up the industry, what is the actual contribution in CO2 reduction, who would build them, ...
- a_imho 10y agoWhy aren't these designs more widespread? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor
- Animats 10y agoThere's interest in small and medium nuclear reactors, including interest from Trump's transition team. The IAEA has a brochure on the 40 or so competing designs.[1] A few are under construction. None seem to be operating yet. Russia is building more nuclear powered icebreakers. Those are close to completion. One with a new reactor design was launched in 2016 but is not yet operating. 2017 may be a good year for nuclear power. A few plants are scheduled to come on line. [1] https://www.iaea.org/NuclearPower/Downloadable/SMR/files/IAEA_SMR_Booklet_2014.pdf https://www.iaea.org/NuclearPower/Downloadable/SMR/files/IAE...
- _ph_ 10y agoThe article is one big fallacy. It is absolutely correct that today nuclear is the main source of carbon-free power generation. But that does not say much about what the best technology for new installations is. If built to good safety standards, nuclear is not cheap. Solar and wind should be much cheaper, and of course completely safe alternatives. Unfortunately, the article does not discuss any of these alternatives.
- Altay- 10y agoPer-capita energy usage is already falling across the developed world. And that's just with current trends. We could easily tax electricity far higher in most countries, mandate higher efficiency (the US still uses giant furnaces and hot water heaters) and tax carbon. Why do people on Hacker News seem so drawn to Nuclear? Its insanely expensive, it takes forever for a plant to come online, and worst of all for an industry that likes to remain 'boring' -- it draws too much public attention. Why fight all that? WHY?
- jagger27 10y agoBecause when a super volcano eruption blocks out the sun for 6 months we could still have a stable baseline.
- abledon 10y ago"Why do people on Hacker News seem so drawn to Nuclear? Its insanely expensive, it takes forever for a plant to come online, and worst of all for an industry that likes to remain 'boring' -- it draws too much public attention." Because we are numbed from too many waterfall style management projects and can't imagine any other way ;)
- rhino369 10y agoIf we taxed carbon that highly we'd end up just building nuclear plants anyway. Solar and wind just can't provide baseline power or on demand power, at least not yet. Reducation is use needs to be a key part of global warming mitigation, but it isn't going to be the only part. Per capita is falling, but the world is still growing. And per capita usage is skyrocketing in the third world. And per capita electrical grid usage might increase as electric cars start replacing ICE cars.
- damptowel 10y agoFor the uninitiated, I found this a good introduction http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/ http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/ (It seems to have a pro nuclear bias, the author claims neutrality)
- peg_leg 10y agoThe article was written by politicians
- pl-94 10y agoUnfortunately, we still need nuclear power: 1) Wind and solar are intermittent. Even if you produce more than what you consume, you still have to deal with the huge consumption peak of the evening. This is huge. No solution for now about it. 2) Energy storage is not scalable. It is available for smart homes, but there is just not enough lithium-ion on Earth to deal with the evening peak. Flywheels have too small performances. 3) Germany consumes more coals now that it has stopped its nuclear plants. 4) With respect to coal and gas, nuclear power is better: less dependance to Middle East, no CO2, very good EROEI, and actually, it is responsable for much less deaths than other energy sources. The real issues about nuclear powers are: 1) It provides less jobs than renewable energies (mainly when people will produce their own energy). 2) It will cost more than solar panels. But not yet.' So. The solution is to continue the current nuclear plants for 20 years, not to invest in new ones; and expecting in the meantime that storage is becoming scalable.
- CurtMonash 10y agoFor nuclear power to be feasible, we need different kinds of designs than the historically common ones. 1. Passive safety features are a must, period -- especially in a world full of hackers and terrorists (or at least terrorist wannabes). Obviously, they don't protect against all human error, accidental or deliberate as the case may be. But they sure could lower the risks. 2. We also need truly standardized manufacturing. It seems that the buzzword there is "SMR" -- Small Modular Reactor. This is for multiple reasons. Cost and general safety are the most obvious. Further, site-specific safety analyses would actually have a chance of being correct.
- jcoffland 10y agoFor those of you suggesting solar as a better solution read this article [1] about the toxic waste (silicon tetrachloride) produced in solar panel manufacturing. Add to that the storage problems [2] [3] and impact of land use of massive solar installations [4] and it's no longer a home run even if the price is coming down. [1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03/08/AR2008030802595.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03... [2] http://www.npr.org/2015/08/04/427734398/when-relying-on-the-sun-energy-storage-remains-out-of-reach http://www.npr.org/2015/08/04/427734398/when-relying-on-the-... [3] http://www.businessinsider.com/renewable-energy-storage-problem-2013-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/renewable-energy-storage-prob... [4] https://carnegiescience.edu/news/solar-energy%E2%80%99s-land-use-impact https://carnegiescience.edu/news/solar-energy%E2%80%99s-land...
- Klasiaster 10y agoModesty and determination to tackle change seems more needed than economic expansion.
- knorker 10y agoDuh. This is one of the reasons I think Greenpeace is doing counterproductive work over the last few decades, at least in the energy space.
- bryanrasmussen 10y agomy natural cynicism prompts me to note that nuclear war would also slow Global Warming.
- techplex 10y agoDr. Leslie Dewan has developed a Nuclear Reactor that can run on the Nuclear Waste we currently have all around the world. Learn More: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UXXwWOImm8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UXXwWOImm8
- sschueller 10y agoIsn't the problem with these the extremely corrosive salt liquid that needs to be contained and there isn't any reasonable solutions to do that at this time?
- sureshn 10y agoThe article appears to be written in a biased manner and lacks Rational and logic , till now no body has ever been able to come up with a solution on how to deal with nuclear waste in a safe way or how to deal with a accident in a nuclear plant
- ikeyany 10y agoYour comment inadvertently shows why we should be supporting fusion energy research (the problems you speak of are problems with fission).
- thraway2016 10y agohow to deal with nuclear waste in a safe way Yucca Mountain was a damn good proposal, but NIMBY killed it.
- murukesh_s 10y agoDo I need nuclear power if it's cheaper? Yes! Would I like to stay near a nuclear plant? Hell no.
- sandGorgon 10y agothe future is Molten salt reactors - not because of this article, because it is the only abundant fuel for the two of the largest energy consumers for the next two decades: India and China. India+China have the world's largest thorium resources. China is also investing more than a billion dollars in molten salt reactor research (led by the son of Jiang Zemin) [1] Peter Thiel, who is pretty much the think tank for the new government, has a personal investment in Transatomic Power that is doing very interesting work here. I see no reason that this project will not receive a shot in the arm after January. TLDR : India + China + Peter Thiel = Molten Salt Reactors [1] http://fortune.com/2015/02/02/doe-china-molten-salt-nuclear-reactor/ http://fortune.com/2015/02/02/doe-china-molten-salt-nuclear-...
- daflip 10y agoThere's many ways to slow global warming. Is replacing power production with nuclear really humanity's best first to-go in slowing global warming? I would have thought not.
- iamgopal 10y agoIts quite fun to imagine, how ultimately the urge to share your life with other ( all trillion $ semiconductor industry for what, sharing your cat pic ? ), has propagated whole era of advance semi conductor technology, which in turn have been primary cause of reduction in solar power price.
- ommunist 10y agoYou only need nuclear power to get grasp upon unlimited solar energy from the orbital plants. Russia is building nuclear powered large spaceship engine right now.
- runj__ 10y agoSpace is one of the big ones for me, we need nuclear for space exploration, I'm fine with solar for earth as long as we keep nuclear science up.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoI believe that nuclear power is the best power. It's probably the best kind of power for America to invest in. Solar power is probably my least favorite kind of power because nuclear power is better.
- douche 10y agoTo slow global warming, we needed more nuclear power in the 70s, and continuing investments in it along the way, rather than slowly decommissioning the plants we did have. I'm not really a utilitarian, but people freaking out over three relatively minor incidents with nuclear plants is a terrible justification for avoiding nuke power and accepting coal, with all of the side effects that mining, transporting, and burning that stuff entails.
- Tepix 10y agoBefore new nuclar reactors are built, the long term storage problem needs to be solved. It's just unacceptable for future generations and makes cost estimates impossible. For all we know, it will never be a solved problem and the world will grow more unstable making highly radioactive nuclear waste something that has to be heavily guarded, making it even more expensive.
- tomrod 10y agoNuclear is only part of the solution. It doesn't scale up or down very quickly. Solar, wind, and energy capture mechanisms are still very much part of the solution. If we're efficient enough in the last three, we don't need the first.
- kogepathic 10y agoHad to look up the writers of this op-ed: they're Lamar Alexander (R-TN)[0] and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)[1]. Not sure if they're in the pocket of the nuclear industry or not, but given the (correct) points by others that nuclear is more expensive than other renewables, it wouldn't surprise me if there is an ulterior motive to this op-ed than stopping climate change. Specifically, I'd have to disagree with this statement: > For one thing, we should extend existing reactor licenses from 60 to 80 years, in cases where the Nuclear Regulatory Commission says it is safe to do so. In almost no cases should reactors that are 60 years old have their operating licenses extended. These are almost all Generation II reactor designs [2] which have the same safety faults as Fukushima. For example, the Generation III design includes facilities designed to contain a melted core [3]. While these obviously haven't been tested with a real core melt-down, these kind of improvements could have made Fukushima arguably less of an environmental disaster. I really wish the US would look into LFTR again, as they did in the 70's and China is doing now [4]. LFTR have some distinct safety advantages to the PWR/BWR designs favoured by the industry. Unfortunately, all the big money is behind PWR/BWR and no one wants to take the risk and invest in developing LFTR reactors for civilian use in the USA. Costs less to modify the flawed but time tested PWR/BWR designs than to risk investing in designing an LFTR reactor that no utility would every pay money for due to the lack of a proven track record. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamar_Alexander https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamar_Alexander [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheldon_Whitehouse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheldon_Whitehouse [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_II_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_II_reactor [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_III_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_III_reactor [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_fluoride_thorium_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_fluoride_thorium_reacto...
- natch 10y agoI favor solar instead because it's not so subject to control by a centralized power (corporations and governments). Given the right conditions, any property owner can just add solar to their property, generally at an affordable cost and with incremental rollout if needed, and they have full control over at least that slice of their energy use.
- JanezStupar 10y agoUntil radical left ideologues stop cockblocking any discussion about nuclear and fearmongering we aren't going to be seeing any reasonable discussion on the topic.
- dang 10y agoPolitical ranting and name-calling aren't allowed here. Please don't post like this, regardless of your politics or anyone else's. Edit: actually, since I see you've done this quite frequently and ignored previous requests to stop, we've banned your account. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13238756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13238756 We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236566 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236566 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- squozzer 10y agohttp://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/equality.pdf http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/equality.pdf - Beware of the person who gives advice, telling you that a certain action on your part is “good for you” while it is also good for him, while the harm to you doesn’t directly affect him.
- JanezStupar 10y agoYou have no idea what you are talking about.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines by posting uncivil and unsubstantive comments and ignoring our requests to stop. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13236820 and marked it off-topic.
- zwieback 10y agoThere are alternatives to massive expensive reactors from companies like Nuscale, might be a good option to round out energy production in areas where other clean energy sources aren't available.
- Radle 10y ago"Carbon emissions from the electricity sector increased 24 percent after the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station in California closed." Because existing coal generating stations can be scaled up quickly. With planing one could have also build a solar generator before.
- fcanesin 10y agoSolar don't have the power density needed by US. Do a simple calculation of current energy levels plus 1% YOY, turns out that you would need to cover the world with panels in just a few decades. There are proved new technology on nuclear (like molten salt and front advancing reactors) that is orders of magnitude safer. The light water reactor design from the 50-60th used in this aging plants was funded by Navy and was appropriate for its use but is not the best solution for grid power generation. Applying this already tested and safe solutions (search for ORNL molten salt) will buy the time until fusion is here, new high temperature superconductors (REBCO in special) have completely changed the game here, and a small high field tokamaks should generate net gain in less than 20 years.
- tim333 10y agoNah. Less area than that http://landartgenerator.org/blagi/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/AreaRequired1000.jpg http://landartgenerator.org/blagi/wp-content/uploads/2009/08...
- fcanesin 10y agoThis is a gigantic amount of area just for 2030! The compound grow don't stop there. Compare this view of the US from a satellite at a much closer zoom, if you can't see all the concrete even in Boston-NYC-Washington area. But from a world view you would need that square of solar energy. https://goo.gl/maps/wWpFW7nRZSq https://goo.gl/maps/wWpFW7nRZSq
- kgarten 10y agoSad to see again another propaganda nuclear article at HN. I remember the top article after the Fukushima disaster at HN was an astroturfing blog post on why Fukushima is no big deal (with a lot of misinformation). Here we are again ... Even if we take out the major catastrophy scenarios there's still the waste problem to deal with (and no it's not solved with the newest tech). And of course, I will get downvotes for that ;)
- tim333 10y agoIf you just extrapolate the exponential improvements we've seen with solar and batteries for another decade or two they'll be way cheaper than fission plants. And it'll take a good decade for them to come on line. The outlook for fusion is surprisingly positive. I never thought I'd see it in my lifetime but there have been a bunch of breakthroughs recently. See the "Breakthrough in Nuclear Fusion?" talk from Dennis Whyte, head of Nuclear at MIT. The main bit 00:26-00:30 - they just have to build a reactor the size of the JET reactor (existing near Oxford) but with the new REBCO tape (also existing and available) and you could have a funtioning power generator https://youtu.be/KkpqA8yG9T4?t=26m6s https://youtu.be/KkpqA8yG9T4?t=26m6s They should crack ahead and build one of those.
- mmmBacon 10y agoI was in kindergarten about 13 miles away when the Three Mile Island (TMI) accidentally occurred. I recall people being panicked about it and my neighbors jamming up the roads trying to get away. There was great controversy when they wanted to restart the undamaged reactor. Most of the controversy surrounding whether the operator could be trusted to run the plant safely as the accident was largely the result of poor management and inadequately qualified operators at the controls. Despite having lived through all that I still support nuclear power. I think a standardized design approach like they have in France is the right way to go as it can lower costs and improve safety. I think standardization can also improve trust by reducing the likelihood that human factors could cause an accident.
- s0me0ne 10y agoIf each state is willing to deal w their own waste, go for it, but stop shipping it to other states!
- Nomentatus 10y ago"I support nuclear power as a proven means of created large wildlife preserves." So needed these days. I think that's gonna be my next T-Shirt.
- mikevp 10y ago"I am not so much pro-nuclear as I am pro-arithmetic." -- Stuart Brand. The dogma that we can power industrial civilization on "sunny days when the wind is blowing" energy is arithmetic denialism. I will believe that you care about CO2/climate change if, and only if, you do not oppose replacing carbon-based energy with the source that passes the arithmetic test.
- Pica_soO 10y agoIm pretty sure, reading the comments below, i will find lots of engineering solutions to make nuclear power saver. And those solutions will be good. But how to make nuclear power saver, when the economy takes a downturn and middle management at the plant closes both eyes to cheap, not on spec repairs and not-so-excellent replacement solutions for the problems. How do you ensure a constant high-maintenance machine against the corroding forces of the market? State maintenance funds? But this would be unfair to any energetic non-carbon replacement energy source. On the other hand, the rise of solar could lead to a series of Chernobyl by economic neglect. And that is why i am against nuclear- they are able to hold there economic surroundings hostage.
- kgarten 10y agohmmm ... seems more a last try of some lobbyists to push nuclear. Solar power is now the cheapest form of energy in almost 60 countries :) http://www.sciencealert.com/solar-power-is-now-the-cheapest-energy-in-the-world http://www.sciencealert.com/solar-power-is-now-the-cheapest-...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]