16 ms·
Apple’s rotten appeal
- grabcocque 10y agoApple here is making threats, but they're threats the commission should listen to carefully. I mean, if the Commission wants to drive US tech companies out of the EU on the specious grounds that it might help the moribund EU startup scene, go ahead. But let's just say I have no doubt the UK government is quietly watching. I doubt it would be enormously difficult for Apple to relocate from Dublin to London.
- skrause 10y agoThe EU would be fine with Apple moving its money to the US and paying their fair share of taxes there. But you can't tell the US that profits are generated in Ireland while agreeing with Ireland that profits are generated in the US, just so you end up paying taxes nowhere.
- sangnoir 10y ago> The EU would be fine with Apple moving its money to the US and paying their fair share of taxes there. Why would it be fine with this? Taxes are paid where the revenue is generated. If money were to be repatriated without tax to HQ's resident country, then all companies would be registered in tax havens and pay no tax. Apple is trying to play off the EU against the US - they ought to pay the due taxes in both jurisdictions.
- pawadu 10y ago> Why would it be fine with this? Why not? Apple doesn't produce any tax income for them, Apple has zero R&D in EU, and Apple not selling to EU consumers would only benefit the local companies like BQ, Sony and Alcatel.
- quonn 10y agoThey don't create jobs, so they should not be taxed? What a surprising statement! It's possible to make a point that a company that creates jobs should not be taxed (although I think that's wrong, too).
- pawadu 10y agoI am talking about short term effects, and not claiming this is a very sane argument. But you should understand that Apple was given a competitive edge against other companies that did pay their EU taxes. If Apple decided to leave the EU market tomorrow, it would in short term result in economical gain for the EU members since people would by buy the same amount of phones/tablets/laptops but now from companies that (hopefully) pay their corporate taxes.
- lispm 10y ago> I mean, if the Commission wants to drive US tech companies out of the EU on the specious grounds that it might help the moribund EU startup scene I thought the EU commission just wanted them to properly pay taxes. > I doubt it would be enormously difficult for Apple to relocate from Dublin to London. Once the UK is outside the EU, Apple needs a representation in the UK. No doubt. The UK also has a lot of associated tax havens. Probably useful, too. Possibly Apple also needs to be represented in the EU, if it wants to keep addressing a then 450 million people market.
- roryisok 10y agoLondon would be outside the EU though. Apple is based on Ireland because it 1) is in the EU, and 2) offers low corporation tax, not the other way around. If Ireland left the EU today, Apple would up sticks and move tomorrow, even if the tax rate stayed the same
- ben_w 10y agoWhile it would probably be relatively easy for Apple to move to London, I think the British stance on privacy (Investigatory Powers Bill etc.) would make Apple less interested than one might expect from simple tax rules. Then there are all the Brexit related questions about export of services, and I have no idea at all how that might or might not change things.
- keithpeter 10y ago"Then there are all the Brexit related questions about export of services, and I have no idea at all how that might or might not change things." I suspect noone has a clear idea about that at this stage. Negotiations yet to start &c and the negotiation stance that HM Government appears to take is itself a highly political question within some quarters in the UK.
- Marazan 10y agoThe whole point of being in Dublin was to have an EU based office plus a 'favorable' tax regime to bilk European nations out of tax revenue. Moving to London is a non starter as it takes that office out of the EU.
- tanto 10y agoIf Apple moves to London they would need to move back to the EU in few years. London is soon not to be part of the EU. Also the EU startup scene is most certainly not moribund. I guess you are misinformed. And at last. The Commission doesn't want to drive out a US company. The European Union just has the expectation that companies doing business in Europe should pay taxes in Europe.
- diakritikal 10y agoEh? this is not specious, a one off 0.005% deal is anti-competition and illegal under EU law, Apple doesn't get to decide what EU competition laws it can and cannot ignore. Ask Microsoft, ask Google... both tried, both failed. Nobody is rushing to incorporate as a startup in the UK right now, quite the opposite - there's lots of talk of moving to Berlin/Paris/Stockholm. There are numerous reasons for this but I'll mention two strong disincentives: 1.) Impending `Brexit` and loss of access to the EU single market 2.) The 'Britain is Closed for business' nature of the new snoopers charter which compels online companies based in the UK to get government approval for any new technology that uses encryption, and also compels them to build backdoors for the government spooks if asked.
- pluma 10y agoThe UK is leaving the EU. Having the EU HQ in the UK would not only be silly, it'd also be a huge headache (as many EU organisations are finding out with Article 50 approaching). Also, what would Apple gain from withdrawing? They weren't paying taxes in Ireland, but they're also not paying taxes in the US. If they pulled out of Ireland they'd still have to pay taxes somewhere, which is exactly the situation they're facing now (just in the US instead of Ireland).
- gutnor 10y ago> I doubt it would be enormously difficult for Apple to relocate from Dublin to London. Obviously it is not. Tax sheltering does not require much physical presence at all. It probably requires no more than changing a few contract between subsidiaries to initiate the cash movement to their fiscal haven of choice. The real problem for Apple is for the money that is already there. More generally this generation of tax avoidance is probably coming to an end: both the EU and the US are looking at it those days, and Ireland is one regulation away to have to find another way to print money. Not quite sure what's the big deal. Tax avoidance scheme are rarely stable long term. Extracting tax money is a global competitive market between state and large companies/rich individual. You should sleep peacefully knowing that in all the possible resolution of this affair, Apple will always have to effectively pay less tax than possible to your little startup stuck in a single country tax system.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dandare 10y agoYou don't understand, they would gain nothing by moving to London. Either London stays in the EU market in which case it must not give Apple unfair advantage or London does not stay in the EU market in which case Apple must pay tax for EU sales in EU.
- gutnor 10y agoYes and no, maybe. You are right that this current flavour of tax avoidance is not going to work anymore and moving to London now or in the future will not change the outcome for the money mentioned here, only future money. However about London, once outside the EU they will have the opportunity to position themselves as a tax haven with clever new tax avoidance scheme for large companies. Now you probably automatically dismissed the idea because that's a crazy idea. Setting up yourself as a tax haven does not scale to the size of the UK economy, and the UK would need to do it at a time of intense scrutiny by the global community and the EU will certainly see that as a aggressive negotiation tactic which is not going to help the Brexit negotiation. But well, there were better arguments for not leaving the EU in the first place, and yet the UK seems to merely go for the hardest Brexit possible. So who knows ? McDonald (fiscal) move to London is worrying. Nissan and others are a bit too happy after their secret chat with the PM.
- lyschoening 10y agoOr Apple could simply pay taxes on their products in the countries that they sell them in. No reason to move away from Ireland.
- quonn 10y ago> if the Commission wants to drive US tech companies out of the EU Apple has very few research and development or production jobs in the EU. It's mostly sales. For those sales they should pay taxes. The EU has nothing to loose here.
- IBM 10y agoIt's pretty obvious why Apple's appeal is based on procedural grounds and that's because the EC decision is against Ireland and not Apple. http://www.finance.gov.ie/sites/default/files/161219%20Summary%20of%20Appeal%20Grounds%20Publised%20under%20Embargo.pdf http://www.finance.gov.ie/sites/default/files/161219%20Summa... Ireland's appeal gets into the meat of it. I've been reading about this case as well as others against Luxembourg and Netherlands and I suspect it's very likely these decisions by the EC will not survive appeal. The use of state aid laws in this way is novel and the precedent it would set if they somehow prevailed would be a massive shift in sovereignty from member states to the EU. Low tax member states like Ireland have been under political assault for decades and this is the latest attempt to redress something the EU has no power over. If the EU wanted a unified tax regime across all members it should have been designed that way from the outset, but then the EU project may not have ever taken off if it required ceding so much sovereignty. Politically it seems like these cases can backfire massively. I suspect that when the EC began these investigations they didn't expect Brexit could happen. The implicit gamble they're making is popular support for combatting tax avoiders will be greater than rising Euroscepticism. EDIT: Just to be clear because it seems my comment is being misunderstood by several people, my second paragraph is my comment specifically about this case. The third paragraph is my explanation of the political context in which these cases have been brought. It's obvious these cases aren't about tax rates (it is indirectly, which was my point) because the EU pretty clearly has no authority over that.
- devoply 10y agoThey have 231 billion cash on hand. So not really a big deal for them to pay a small fraction of that as taxes, as they should have done and therefore should not have this much cash on hand.
- zip1234 10y agoI can't tell if you are sarcastic. Just because they have money doesn't mean they need to give it away. I'll bet Apple will spend it in a more productive way than any EU government would.
- rem1313 10y agoThe tax haven system is deeply flawed and I hope this gets the ball rolling in making these types of deals less prevalent.
- geodel 10y agoI think it is about as flawed as negotiated salaries by well qualified software engineers. I do not see clamoring for standard salary rate for $73K or some such in silicon valley because it is much more accessible to everyone. Instead we will negotiate and settle for 2-5x of that amount. Companies or people negotiate to get much better deal for themselves.
- throwayawnotime 10y agoWhere do I sign to pay 0.005 percent tax on my income?
- taf2 10y agoFirst you have to promise you'll provide at least a 4% employment boost in my town. e.g. (total jobs 5,500 and total population 119,230 or 4.6% in the case of Cork Ireland) Then assuming you agree to keep those jobs in my town for the next 10 years and considering the average salary of the employee you hire is a bit more than most in the area. There income tax combined with the increase in aggregate sales on goods and services it might be a good deal for the area. At least this is the typical rational for tax incentives. The issue with tax incentives is IMO is they create the perception of corruption (and in many cases maybe real corruption) - favoring one business over another etc...
- akerro 10y agoSure I can promise that!
- jbob2000 10y agoYou need a bit of context around Ireland, too. Ireland has been suffering from a mass exodus of young workers over the last few years. At its height, 10,000 young adults a week were leaving the country. Nobody wants to live in cold, rainy mountains working as a miner or fisherman. The thought was that if they could attract some swanky tech companies, the next generation of workers would be more enthused about staying in the country.
- matt4077 10y agoI believe "the last few years" is the wrong context. These tax deals began in the late 70ies, at a time where Potato and Fish were the dominant industries of Ireland. It's easy to forget that they've experienced massive economic improvements since joining the European Union.
- mdekkers 10y ago
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoDamn, is Vestager in the running for Dane of the year?!?! I'm going to have to vote.
- madmoose 10y agoToo late, she won already: http://www.b.dk/aaretsdansker http://www.b.dk/aaretsdansker
- bryanrasmussen 10y agosee this is what happens when one just gets Hacker news and foregoes the politiken subscription!
- ebbv 10y agoI hope the EU wins. Tax havens need to be illegal. In the US they have created a race to the bottom between economically struggling states. States compete with each other to offer the most incentives and the only ones who win out of this are the corporations.
- ianai 10y agoHow else can the US compete with the nearly free labor in China?
- ams6110 10y agoWell, the citizens of those states, who find employment with those corporations, also win, do they not?
- ebbv 10y agoNope because the state is subsidizing the companies and who pays for the state to run? They do. So they end up with infrastructure and education budget shortfalls.
- wav-part 10y agoReplace Tax Heavens --> Compitition states --> corporations corporations --> customers Do you see any problem ?
- ebbv 10y agoYes there's a huge problem, your analogy is terrible. I get why you think it's a good one, but it doesn't hold up to any real scrutiny. The biggest problem is your equivalence of corporations to customers. Corporations aren't the customers of states, and states aren't corporations. States don't exist to make a profit, they exist to serve the needs of the citizens. Corporations don't pay taxes because they are purchasing services with them, they pay taxes because we all have to pay taxes to do the things we want to do (provide education for our kids, have a police force to deal with crime, build and maintain bridges and roads, etc.) Anyway, I digress. It's a bad analogy.
- bardworx 10y agoMy wife is a CPA and works for one of the "Big Four" AND her engagement currently involves auditing an investment firm in Ireland, and the EU. After speaking with her, and getting her opinion, it seems most comments about this situation are rooted in too many arbitrary feelings without an understanding of how the tax law actually works. The crux of this issue is that US has a global tax code while EU has a localized tax code. What EU is proposing is really interesting because, if they win, Apple would be taxed twice, once on the money that their holding company has in Ireland and again once that money is brought over to the US. EU doesn't seem to care what other tax codes there are as their tax code is upheld by each conuntry in the EU and then there are EU panels that test for anti-competitive practices, etc. This raises issues in soveirnty of Nations if EU can supersede their tax code. It also raises a bunch of ethical issues within the EU when a company (investment institution) is based in one country while investing in another. To minimize the words written, from what I gather is this: Apple's situation is difficult because their argument is that they did not create (IP) in Ireland so they do not owe full corp tax on holding their money there. However, they pay all sales, (current) corp, etc. tax for all of their products where the item is sold or employees are working. Hence, this tax isn't a sales but a different classification of corp tax. They are being asked to pay taxes as if they are an Irish company that creates or manufactures their product in Ireland. Not as a holding company that pays their standard tax rate. There a lot of semantics in that statement and it's difficult to reiterate the explanation without a full blown essay. For the rest of EU, their tax code is a clusterfuck (for lack of a better term). Companies have to pay taxes in the country they do business + country that's their "Home". So an investment firm will have separate tax rates/brackets as the money moves acoss borders. This gets really complicated when countries are doing business outside of the EU but have their base there. There is also an issue with which currency the taxes have to be paid in (seems trivial except the exchange rate isn't stable). By all accounts, this looks like a pissing contest between EU and US firms and their stance can have global ramifications that are not foreseeable. One interesting perspective my wife raised is that because taxes are paid in "home county" currency, manipulation of the market becomes a viable option for multi-national EU/US/Workd orgs to lower/raise their taxes paid. This seems far fetched but a tiny change becomes big money on something like 14B (I doubt Apple will resort to such tactics because of money involved). TL;DR Apple pays taxes they are suppose to pay per Irish tax code. The money held there would be taxed if they move to US or if they invest/purchase items in Ireland/EU. Currently proposal is using a loophole within a loophole to attempt to double tax Apple (or any other company they choose to go after).
- ianai 10y agoThat website crashed twice in a row on my iPad.
- jholman 10y agoHalf the comments here refer to Ireland offering Apple some special deal. To the best of my ability to determine (IANAL), there is NO special deal. Apple is simply using a bog-standard Double Irish arrangement. It's a very common income-structuring arrangement for transnational corporations. Every comment that says "this'd be fine if Ireland let every company do it"? Guess what, Ireland lets any company do it. No signup required. It's just how corporate income tax law works in Ireland. I agree that tax havens are bad for civilization, and it seems to me that the EU's ruling is in a generally pro-civilization direction (whether or not it is, in fact, legal, under current EU law). Also, when people say "why is the EU allowed to rule on this", the answer to such questions is always "because the member state (in this case Ireland) first agreed to a treaty, and then ratified that treaty by creating an Irish law saying that Ireland had to obey the rulings". That's how treaties work. I'm not saying that's a good thing (I have serious concerns about the interaction between international treaty processes and what's left of democracy, but repairing it isn't helped by misunderstanding the mechanism). Again, the EU high court has jurisdiction because Irish law says it does, backed up by the probability that if Ireland flouts it hard enough, long enough, other member states are likely to jointly retaliate.
- wavefunction 10y agoI believe Ireland is failing to even charge Apple its statutory tax rate, which is why the the whole kerfluffle over Europe claiming back taxes are owed to Ireland, Apple claiming they don't, and Ireland claiming they don't want the taxes because they fear it will trigger a move by Apple from its shores. I assume offering deals like that runs afoul of international trade agreements.
- jholman 10y agoTo the best of my knowledge, Apple, Ireland, and the EU all claim that Irish tax law is being obeyed. Do you have any reference to this claim of yours? Europe claims that Ireland's tax law is EU-illegal, and thus Ireland must retroactively enforce an EU-legal tax law, and thus the back taxes. I certainly agree with you about Ireland and Apple's motivations.
- runn1ng 10y ago> The key point rests on language in Article 107 of the 2007 Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which provides that “any aid granted by a member state or through state resources in any form whatsoever which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favoring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods shall … be incompatible with the internal market.” I don't get this, to be honest. Doesn't every financial aid distort the competition, by design? What am I missing. edit: OK there is the whole article. It makes slightly more sense, but I would argue it's still hard to guess which aid falls where. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:12008E107&from=EN http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELE... ---------------------- Article 107 (ex Article 87 TEC) 1. Save as otherwise provided in the Treaties, any aid granted by a Member State or through State resources in any form whatsoever which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favouring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods shall, in so far as it affects trade between Member States, be incompatible with the internal market. 2. The following shall be compatible with the internal market: (a) aid having a social character, granted to individual consumers, provided that such aid is granted without discrimination related to the origin of the products concerned; (b) aid to make good the damage caused by natural disasters or exceptional occurrences; (c) aid granted to the economy of certain areas of the Federal Republic of Germany affected by the division of Germany, in so far as such aid is required in order to compensate for the economic disadvantages caused by that division. Five years after the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon, the Council, acting on a proposal from the Commission, may adopt a decision repealing this point. 3. The following may be considered to be compatible with the internal market: (a) aid to promote the economic development of areas where the standard of living is abnormally low or where there is serious underemployment, and of the regions referred to in Article 349, in view of their structural, economic and social situation; (b) aid to promote the execution of an important project of common European interest or to remedy a serious disturbance in the economy of a Member State; (c) aid to facilitate the development of certain economic activities or of certain economic areas, where such aid does not adversely affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest; (d) aid to promote culture and heritage conservation where such aid does not affect trading conditions and competition in the Union to an extent that is contrary to the common interest; (e) such other categories of aid as may be specified by decision of the Council on a proposal from the Commission. ---------------
- epx 10y agoApple is being singled out. Politicians create this kind of loophole for their friends (giant industries like oil, defense, etc. - that are "invisible" to the public eye - and sometimes to benefit politicians themselves to put their dirty money in tax shelters) and then complain when a very visible business like Google or Apple uses it.
- robert_foss 10y agoThe Irish politicians clearly have different incentives than the EU ones.
- jondubois 10y agoI don't think there are very strong legal foundations for the case against Apple, but I think that in terms of public opinion, Apple is in a very weak position. People are sick of these corporate tax schemes; we need someone's head on a stick (at whatever cost). Brexit and Donald Trump have shown us that people care less and less about doing the right thing "by the book" anymore; people just want to do the right thing for the majority - Even if that is politically incorrect and will mess up the world order. I think that just like Brexit and Trump, this is just a continuation of the same rebellious movement against globalization and the elite establishment.
- binthere 10y agoMajority: Brexit yes, Trump no.
- rallycarre 10y agoWhy is the EU going after Apple now? They knew of this tax haven for years. It's the EU's fault for letting one of its members do this. The fact that they are trying to change the tax code in Ireland AND retroactively apply those laws is bananas. If I take advantage of a tax loophole and the government closes that loophole, can they throw me in jail? Obviously people aren't companies but it sets dangerous precedent.
- fsaneq2 10y agoHow is it Apple's problem to pay for Ireland's mistake?
- randyrand 10y ago>0.005 percent C'mon Politico writers. Do you really not know the difference between and 0.005 percent and 0.005? You are off by a factor of 100! Apple is allegedly taxed at half a percent! Not 0.005 percent! I guess there's a reason journalists are known for their writing and not basic math skills. Moreover, Bloomberg reports this alleged tax rate is entirely made up (funny given Politico is all about fact checking) and there's no primary source affirmation of it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-09-01/pinning-down-apple-s-alleged-0-005-tax-rate-mission-impossible https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-09-01/pinning-d...
- scott_karana 10y agoOh lord, it's this all over again: http://verizonmath.blogspot.ca/2006/12/verizon-doesnt-know-dollars-from-cents.html http://verizonmath.blogspot.ca/2006/12/verizon-doesnt-know-d...