11 ms·
The Brilliance of a Stradivari Violin Might Rest Within Its Wood
- chillingeffect 10y agoStradivarius was ahead of his time, but all of his violins have been updated and modified since they were built, such as adding Bass Bars [1]. Since then, his results have been duplicated and/or improved. The name Stradivarius still carries an amazing amount of weight. Researchers have shown musicians can't actually differentiate between newly built violins and Stradivarius: "The duo asked professional violinists to play new violins, and old ones by Stradivari and Guarneri. They couldn’t tell the difference between the two groups. One of the new violins even emerged as the most commonly preferred instrument." [ 2 ] Therefore when TFA from NYT makes this vague, unsubstantiated claim "For hundreds of years, the best violin players have almost unanimously said they prefer a Stradivari or a Guarneri instrument," take it with a grain of salt or preferably evidence that mainstream media benefits by perpetuating mysterious illusions for the emotional allure. [ 1 ] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bass_bar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bass_bar [ 2 ] http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2012/01/02/violinists-cant-tell-the-difference-between-stradivarius-violins-and-new-ones/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2012/01/0...
- leephillips 10y agoBut isn't it true that "the best violin players have almost unanimously said they prefer a Stradivari or a Guarneri"? It seems that's what they say, even if they may not actually be able to tell the difference.
- thieving_magpie 10y agoI think you're misinterpreting the statement "For hundreds of years, the best violin players have almost unanimously said they prefer a Stradivari or a Guarneri instrument". While maybe they don't unanimously state it, that does seem to be the prevailing opinion over "hundreds of years". Just because there are violins that match a Stradivarius doesn't change that. Please audiophiles don't kill me but it seems loosely similar to the debate over lossless FLAC files and a record. Though I will note that unlike the audio debate you're saying there's no perceptible difference between the two.
- 21 10y agoAudiophiles have moved beyond that stage. Today they are debating the difference between FLAC files and WAV files, and "audiophile-grade" audio players fully decode the FLAC file in memory before playing it, into a single continuous memory region (obviously, continuous in user-space, in kernel space it can still be "fragmented", but this is too subtle for current day)
- copperx 10y agoI hope you are joking.
- AimHere 10y agoI suspect he isn't. Have yourself a giggle at these guys discussing the finer points of FLAC vs Wav sound quality (to be fair, some of them do make sensible points about the ability to tag files and whathaveyou, but still...) http://forums.naimaudio.com/topic/flac-vs-wav-audio-quality http://forums.naimaudio.com/topic/flac-vs-wav-audio-quality
- nitrogen 10y agoThe only possible way there's a difference is if the CPU used to decode a FLAC file changes the noise emitted by the computer or puts noise on the DAC's power supply that affects its clock stability or raises the noise floor.
- onion2k 10y agoI can't even imagine the amount of fear I'd feel if someone asked me to make some modifications to an antique violin worth millions of dollars. It'd be like deploying an update on a Friday afternoon.
- analog31 10y agoThe fear would be palpable, but on most of those instruments, the modifications were done in the 19th century, as the modern violin was developed. They changed the size and shape of the bass bar, and the geometry of the neck. Also, the materials and construction techniques all lend themselves to repairability. Just holding one of those instruments would make me nervous, but in terms of both maintenance and use, they were made to be played. This is just something that people accept. I obviously don't play a Strad (he didn't make double basses, that's my excuse), but when I got a nice new bass, people asked me if I'd ever take it out of the house, or if I'd use my old bass for performances. I tell people the same thing, it was made to be played.
- dyim 10y agoIt'd be like deploying an update before leaving for your honeymoon!
- manarth 10y agoNow imagine leaving it on a train: http://www.thelocal.de/20160108/violinist-forgets-24-million-stradivarius-on-train http://www.thelocal.de/20160108/violinist-forgets-24-million...
- dahart 10y agoAt least a deploy you can fix or roll back. Break a Strad or Guarneri, and you're done.
- mikestew 10y agoMmm, not necessarily. Someone took a fireplace poker to Bill Monroe's mandolin. Someone managed to put it back together: http://www.mandolinarchive.com/perl/show_mando.pl?55 http://www.mandolinarchive.com/perl/show_mando.pl?55 (The last picture shows the damage, first one shows its restored state.)
- WildUtah 10y agoNYT makes this vague, unsubstantiated claim "For hundreds of years, the best violin players have almost unanimously said they prefer a Stradivari or a Guarneri instrument," take it with a grain of salt or preferably evidence that mainstream media benefits by perpetuating mysterious illusions for the emotional allure. This story is the epitome of fake news. This is the kind of content it is so hard to filter when anybody on the web can make a serious looking website and publish pure fiction as if it were news. AI is nowhere near being able to classify these stories. Lots of election stories were similarly challenging. Even humans have to be pretty smart to pick them out sometimes.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>This story is the epitome of fake news Is "fake news" going to be the new meme here? If you think this epitomizes "fake news", your detector needs recalibration.
- elihu 10y agoAccording to the link you provided, the bass bars were replaced with bigger bass bars to handle the tension of modern strings. So, it wasn't as if they didn't have bass bars to begin with (which is sort of implied by your wording). For what it's worth, replacing the bass bar or braces periodically could be considered part of the expected maintenance of some arch-top instruments. When or how often it's needed is debatable, but instrument tops will sag over time due to pressure.
- bsder 10y ago> Stradivarius was ahead of his time Is this really true? I was under the impression that the primary issue with the wood was that it came from a stand of trees that had been through an unusual number of drought years and made the wood unusually dense. So, while the craftsmanship was excellent, it was a happy accident in the material that made it world-renowned. This is similar to how Damascus Steel was an accident of having vanadium in the raw inputs. And was not to be replicated once that raw material went away. And, you can say what you will about Strads, but wood has a peak in stringed instruments that seems to be about 30-50 years in. After that, it's slow degradation. Strads are long past their peak.
- jwatte 10y agoBlind tests suggest that most of the brilliance today comes from the brain knowing it's a Strad, because great modern violins sound just as good or better. (The other brilliance was being 200 years or more ahead of everyone else at the time!)
- astrodust 10y agoThese blind tests, again and again, conclusively prove that those listening to the music cannot tell a Yamaha from a Strad. They'll describe the Yamaha in glowing terms until they realize it's a violin made last year, then immediately shit all over it. It's like wine people who are easily duped by a fancy looking bottle. A true sommelier can identify different wines by taste alone, but for every one of those there's a dozen frauds who pretend they know what they're doing, just parroting stuff they've memorized. The other troubling thing is the gender of performers is very hard to discern from a blind performance, but when the performer is visible the judges skew very heavily towards men. It's absurd. https://www.theguardian.com/women-in-leadership/2013/oct/14/blind-auditions-orchestras-gender-bias https://www.theguardian.com/women-in-leadership/2013/oct/14/...
- ENTP 10y ago"A true sommelier can identify different wines by taste alone, but for every one of those there's a dozen frauds who pretend they know what they're doing, just parroting stuff they've memorized." Funnily enough, these are my exact thoughts on the state of the software industry and trying to hire good people.
- beat 10y agoListening is different from playing. Or perhaps more precisely, the experience of passively listening is different from the experience of actively listening to the instrument you're creating music on. As a guitarist, I do a lot of experimentation with picks. I can easily tell the difference between different kinds of picks by sound when I'm playing. But I can listen to old recordings of myself where I couldn't even tell you which guitar I played! Interestingly, a drummer I play with regularly can usually tell when I've switched picks, and has opinions about what picks I should be using. Such is the closeness of musicians working together. Any of these A/B blind test experiments strongly need to be live. A recording isn't a measure of a violin... it's a measure of the violin, the microphone, the mixing board, the mastering process, the amplifier, and the speaker.
- edblarney 10y agoMy grandfather made violins as a hobby. He would wear 20 year old pants, never ever eat out, grew most of his veggies in a garden. He would think nothing of spending $100's on a tiny piece of wood from god knows where.
- dahart 10y agoHahaha! My father makes violins as a profession. He also thinks nothing of spending hundreds on small pieces of wood from strange places. He recently flew to Lithuania and gave some strangers several tens of thousands of dollars for a few piles of wood. My dad does eat out and buy new pants every now and then, though. :P
- geebee 10y agoDoes anyone know if the researchers have made an effort to quantify the acoustics they are trying to recreate or explain? The NYTimes article summarizes it this way: "For hundreds of years, the best violin players have almost unanimously said they prefer a Stradivari or a Guarneri instrument... Why nobody has been able to replicate that sound remains one of the most enduring mysteries of instrument building. Here's the thing, is there actually a notably different sound? I have read the study that shows professional musicians don't necessarily prefer the sound of a stradivarius over a high quality new instrument, that doesn't necessarily mean they don't sound different. How good are they at telling the difference between these instruments, is it something a non-musician could notice or be trained to notice relatively easily. Ideally, a researcher would be able to quantify the tone that is elusive. Alternatively, a team of listeners who can clearly distinguish between the two, reliable, would be useful. Because it sounds like the goal here isn't so much to get a really nice sound, it's to figure out why these instruments sound different (if indeed they do!) I read the abstract, and it sounds like they've analyzed the composition of the violins and have found some notable chemical differences in the wood. It's not an uninteresting result, but I still have to wonder if we're a few steps ahead of ourselves here. First things first, do Stradivarius instruments, as a group, have an identifiably different tone or acoustic quality that makes it possible, either through acoustic measurements or trained human evaluation, to reliably classify them apart from other instruments.
- davesque 10y agoI've wondered this myself. I majored in music and I know that musicians love their legends. They love to agree that this or that historical figure was a genius or a jerk (but usually nowhere in between) and the same sentiment carries over to instruments. It's basically a perfect setup for bias to come into play.
- icantdrive55 10y agoYea, I used to worship old Martin guitars. I then happened to see this guy on YouTube sample three guitars. A Martin, a Yamaha, and the Ibanex. I figured my Ibanex would come in dead last. It came in first? That said, I have an old Dobro guitar, and it does sound better than any guitar I have owned? The more I think about it, I think my Dobro's nut is just set high--making my terrible fret work sound better? (There's even debate about old vs. new Dobros. New Dobros supposedly sound better. This thinking also popped up when old Dobros were getting hard to find.)
- delecti 10y agoI thought at least part of this was already known. The story as I've heard it is that there was a rather dry period preceding Stadivari's violin making, which led to particularly dry and hard wood, both good things for a violin.
- iammyIP 10y agoThe brilliance of the stradivary is aging over centuries on a base of very good craftmanship. Why does the old stuff taste better than the new? Because it has aged well on a good base. That means today we can build much more excellent violins with machines, but music is traditional, thus prefers the hand made things first. New machine made violin can never sing as beautiful as old mystery thing of ancient music rituals.
- iammyIP 10y agoYes, and in the actual a/b tests nobody could single out the stradivari with any significance. The human performer turned out to be the most deciding factor by several magnitudes.
- aczerepinski 10y agoMost people can't discern between a violin and a viola, or an alto and tenor saxophone. The percentage of people who have the refined ears to detect differences between a Strad and other great violins must be unbelievably small.
- kasey_junk 10y agoSure, but the population of people who are involved in the industry where this matters is a much more interesting population. The population of people that can recognize good sql vs great sql is tiny as well...
- Fezzik 10y agoFWIW, it seems like even professionals cannot distinguish between a Stradivari and a new violin... and may even prefer the latter. "When the researchers totaled up the results, there was no evidence the players could reliably pick old from new. And when players were asked to pick their favorite instrument, the winner was a modern, freshly made violin." http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/16/313099219/is-a-stradivarius-just-a-violin http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/16/313099219/is-a-...
- laurentdc 10y agoReminds me of those audiophile A/B/X tests that always end up in a tie between whatever equipment.
- davidgerard 10y agoWe already know where the brilliance of a Stradivarius rests: in the listener's imagination. http://www.thestrad.com/blind-tested-soloists-unable-to-tell-stradivarius-violins-from-modern-instruments/ http://www.thestrad.com/blind-tested-soloists-unable-to-tell...
- WhitneyLand 10y agoAs many have pointed out the entire premise is flawed, with double blind testing showing no objective advantage in the first place (inspirational value withstanding). Then another study found competitions are biased as well, with judges rating people differently based on physical appearance and the amount of body english they use while playing.
- WhitneyLand 10y agoAs many have pointed out the entire premise is flawed, with double blind testing showing no objective advantage in the first place (inspirational value withstanding). Then another study found competitions are biased with judges rating people differently based on physical appearance and the amount of body english they use while playing.
- tsm 10y agoSince everyone's talking about the double-blind study again and as one of the (probably) few people on HN who's seriously played a Strad, I feel obligated to link to my previous comment on the matter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12095164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12095164 TL;DR—fine antique violins seems to have a wider range of good tone colors available than modern instruments, but these tone colors take significant practice with the instrument (months, not minutes) to discover.
- TwoBit 10y agoThe primary reason professionals prefer Stradivaris is that it increases their profile and not because they sound better. Time and time again blind studies show that professionals can't tell the difference or even prefer the modern instruments. But when your resume states that you own a Stradivarius, you will be more highly regarded.