13 ms·
The worrying implications of China's social-credit project
- caseysoftware 10y ago> By 2020, Chinese officials say, it will “allow the trustworthy to roam everywhere under heaven while making it hard for the discredited to take a single step.” I think that line says it all. And before you say, "this will only apply to bad people!" check out the next paragraph: > The project is a response to the party’s biggest problems: the collapse of confidence in public institutions, and the need to keep track of the changing views and interests of China’s population (without letting them vote). It seeks to collect information on the honesty of ordinary citizens, public officials and companies alike. In the US, ex-convicts have major problems starting over and getting on their feet but this is a whole other level. This is punishing/excluding people solely based on their opinion, not based on actions or crimes committed. No wait, disagreeing is the crime.
- digi_owl 10y agoThen again, the US war on drugs was possibly racist in origin...
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThat's irrelevant even if true.
- CamperBob2 10y agoIt's relevant when the discussion touches on the question of whether a massive, powerful central government can ever really have its citizenry's interests at heart.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoWhile the War on Drugs wasn't completely rooted in racism, it is a verifiable fact that it's inception was heavily rooted in it: http://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/ http://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/
- Fricken 10y agoThis is the relevant quote, from John Erlichmen, the Nixon administration's Domestic Affairs Advisor: "The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying? We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did.”
- tn13 10y agoMinimum wage too has racist origins.
- arkitaip 10y agoIt will be interesting to see the rise of entire industries aimed at fixing your score.
- woodandsteel 10y agoHahaha. Of course, if someone is politically-connected, they can just get it done with a phone call.
- auganov 10y agoWhich in turn, could mean people being incentivized to make all sorts of globally nonoptimal choices. Won't be surprised if that's the beginning of an "end" for China.
- LiweiZ 10y agoGaming with this system would be deadly dangerous for most players. Those in this business must be from the top. The sad thing is people are treated just like records in db and most of them have no anger toward this. Every once a while, there are topics tout China would be more powerful and innovative, you know, there is no foundation for it. What China really has is the buying power.
- candiodari 10y agoDon't worry. The state will make sure that this system provides no reasonable rewards either. You're cursed into squalor if you follow, and you get persecuted to some extent if you don't. That's the problem with these systems. Their aim is and must be to get the population to willingly accept poverty and impotence.
- philfrasty 10y agoBlack Mirror Season 3 Episode 1
- orbitingpluto 10y agoI know it is a weird takeaway from that episode, but I found the ubiquitous social media tweaking while at work to be incredibly unprofessional and I wondered how that society could get anything accomplished... ever. And the whitewashed physical world with almost no other real technical improvements emphasized that point for me.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoTheir scores would also be tied to their jobs, people would get things done because it's another way to advance your rating. I saw the lack of technological improvements as the episode taking place roughly now, the tech for the rating system basically exist already.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoRemember the truck driver with a ~1.4 rating? She said she was a ~4.6 when she was young. That made me think that the technology had been around for awhile and that technology had stagnated.
- chrischen 10y agoChina has a pretty big problem of corruption and in general people doing bad things (with the smallest being line cutting). Probably why they're resorting to such drastic measures, and obviously such measures will be abused or have side effects of being used to silence dissenters.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- woodandsteel 10y agoExperts who study corruption say it can exist on a large scale only if those at the top of the government give permission to those under them to take bribes and engage in other criminal practices like pocketing the funds their departments are supposed to be spending. What is going on is a system where the lower-downs (including the military and police) support the government, and in exchange the government allows them to use their official positions to enrich themselves. The higher-ups do this because they know the public is not behind them, so they need to have a paid-off security apparatus that will suppress the public if it revolts. Keep this in mind anytime a leader in a country with a high rate of corruption says he sincerely wants to clean things up, but those lower down are stopping him from doing so. He is just plain telling a lie. And anyone who says they believe him is either naive or also telling a lie. By the way, if you want to know how clean or corrupt a particular nation is, a good place to start is transparency.org
- kahrkunne 10y ago>Keep this in mind anytime a leader in a country with a high rate of corruption says he sincerely wants to clean things up, but those lower down are stopping him from doing so. He is just plain telling a lie. Doesn't this kind of contradict what you said before, though? The leader needs to allow corruption lest he is overthrown (usually by those lower down such as the military, not the public), so in essence those lower down are preventing him from cleaning up. There really is no winning here - being a leader means pandering to the people below you, because if you don't they can just get rid of you. In a democracy this problem is partly solved by switching leaders often and dividing the power of the underlings over the entire population, but the dynamic still very much exists. And of course, in a country with no democracy it's many times worse (and very difficult to establish a democracy). Don't automatically assume that dictators always have bad intentions - they are trapped in a system too. Of course that doesn't mean that China isn't doing a bad thing here, I was just speaking generally.
- Apocryphon 10y agoI suppose one solace free citizens have is that this scheme is much like the weakness of the proposal for a big hulking border wall at the Rio Grande- both ideas presume the existence of governments that are efficient and capable to carry out such widely ambitious schemes. Would the PRC really be capable of such an unprecedented creation, with a population so large and a country so vast?
- nyolfen 10y agoto be fair, china also has a storied and generally successful history with massive walls
- Apocryphon 10y agoOh, that reference was more of an example of an ambitious project trumped by going against a national character. The U.S. hasn't undertaken any huge public infrastructural projects in quite some time, so how could the gov't build such a massive wall? Similarly, how could China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism, be able to create a seamless universal panopticon? Then again, I suppose the Great Firewall has been quite a technical feat.
- dragonbonheur 10y ago>China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism Successive US governments have appointed Goldman Sachs operatives to important government positions and you find that China is Characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism The US started a war for bogus reasons for the benefit of corporations like Haliburton and you find China is Characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism Obama did absolutely nothing to punish the people responsible for the worst financial market crash since the great depression and you find that China is Characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism Debbie Wasserman-Shultz empowered pay-day lenders using her public office in Florida and you find that China is characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism Hillary and Bill Clinton have been PROVEN to have engaged in par-for-play politics with operatives from Arab countries by the Podesta email leaks and you find that China is characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism The Koch Brothers have year after year used their money and influence to buy politicians at all levels so that they could pollute, fire people and evade taxes at will and you find that China is characterized by corruption and opportunism? >China, a country's whose politics and economy is currently characterized by corruption and opportunism The Syrian war has been nothing but another one of the USA's oil wars, with the USA FUNDING, ARMING and TRAINING TERRORISTS (Tulsi Gabbard just proposed the Stop Funding Terrorism Act, check it out), all so that Qatar could have a pipeline built from Saudi Arabia to Turkey, with the blessing of the Obama administration, and you find that China is characterized by corruption and opportunism? Throwing stones around while you're living in a glass house aren't you? Have you even seen the CORRUPT people that Donnie-Tiny-Hands-the-Swamp-Monster has appointed to his cabinet?
- paradite 10y agoA well written piece of propaganda tailored for Western readers to momentarily escape from the bad things that happened in 2016. We are doing badly, but look, Chinese are going to be way worse than us, how comforting. Seriously though, there are good amount of facts in this article that can be very educational, but I don't think the author's intention is to inform the readers about these policies. Instead a wide range of topics and past events regardless of relevance were thrown into the article to remind the readers again and again how bad China's past records are (and how fortunate "we" are compared to the dissidents in China). Yes, these policies can be used in bad ways, but rest assured that CCP is smart enough to the know the will of the people and majority of the people will still be happy with the eventual outcome of these policies.
- whenwillitstop 10y agoThe amount of propaganda in the news right now is at an all time high. The general population is becoming acutely aware of this though. There is a narrative pushed by every major news station that is false. The Russian hacking allegation is a classic piece of red scare propaganda, right out of the book. Scarier than a Donald Trump presidency, is a constant barrage of fear mongering news.
- edblarney 10y ago"The Russian hacking allegation is a classic piece of red scare propaganda, right out of the book" The Russians definitely hacked the US, as surely as they invaded Ukraine on two fronts. The effects may be overblown, but it's not 'propaganda', it's just a simple truth. 'Propaganda' in the US works more like this: + US soldiers with Iraqi gov. is fighting ISIS (terrorists) in Mosul. + The Russians/Syrian regime are fighting 'rebel groups'. But those 'rebel groups' are mostly Al Nusra i.e. 'Al Queda in Iraq'. Basically as bad as ISIS. But they are called 'rebels'. So it's a softer kind of propaganda, generally.
- whenwillitstop 10y agoEver heard of how difficult attribution is in hacking? They got access to the emails through a fishing attack. Even if the attack IP address originated from Russia, you think they really know it was Russia? Come on. This is pure manipulation of the American public.
- xnull2guest 10y agoThe United States invented the digital totalitarian state. The Chinese are modernizing. Allow me to comment that the world, with nationalistic one-sided accusatory bullshit like this headline, is headed for war.
- snambi 10y agoThe correct word would be "enforcing" it.
- xnull2guest 10y agoThe United States already includes social media into police threat scoring algorithms, which are used to track and prioritize police surveillance and citizen 'nudging'. Algorithms across the US attempt to constrain the conversation to maintain confidence in public institutions. Facebook censored me from posting the Snowden documents. It stopped Mayday protestors from organizing. Amazon took down Wikileaks (for a short while). This article is just an instance of hate-them-not-us propaganda. The problem is that I don't hate the Chinese, they are a peaceful country (read: are in and have not been in wars, are leaders of the UN peacekeeping forces, and do not militarily interfere in other countries' affairs). Plus they have done nothing to me and I love all the Chinese people I have met.
- woodandsteel 10y agoSo you are saying the civil rights situations in China and the US are equally bad? That is certainly not what the various organizations that study rights in different countries around the world say.
- jimnotgym 10y agoDo you have a reference?
- burkaman 10y agoThis article also specifically addresses that comparison.
- xnull2guest 10y agoIt actually doesn't mention that police surveillance of your social media posts calculates a threat score for you, which is used to make law enforcement decisions. In fact, the article I think does a poor job overall doing compare-and-contrast. It has a paragraph (two?) on the United States, and dovetails into an opinion (without covering America much at all) about why China is worse. Americans need to understand that they can't fight the Chinese for their rights. They have to fight Washington for their rights.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- siliconc0w 10y agoWhat will be interesting is when it becomes clear to china banks that the 'social score' is a poor metric for credit worthiness. My bet is that they will quickly and quietly go back to weighting FICO-style metrics (i.e history of repayment).
- mattnewton 10y agoWill they? I think that social capital will be worth more than the money because it's what keeps the men-with-guns on your side. If they are serious about making it hard for the "discredited to take a single step" then how angry the government is at you is a good predictor of you ability to pay. If you are talking about the incentive for a bank to defect and lend to people who could repay but have a poor score, that would be very interesting, but I am not sure I see how likely that is to be a real arbitrage opportunity if everyone else is on the same page as the government re: the score.
- zhemao 10y agoWell all the banks are state-owned, so it's kind of a moot point. They'll go along with whatever the government decides.
- candiodari 10y agoUntil it requires a denial of reality so great that it simply can't work. That usually doesn't take more than a decade or so.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoBut it does kind of make sense in China. If a prospective client has a solid history of paying debts on a timely basis as well as well-documented statements of dissent or disapproval on Chinese social media, that person is more likely to be arrested and therefore less likely to be able to pay the debts back, which has the double effect of more accurately estimating credit worthiness as well as punishing dissidents in advance.
- swuecho 10y ago
- hkon 10y agoThe chinese want this. They have no problem understanding the logic of: There are so many people in China, how are we otherwise going to prevent crimes. It's the same explanation for everything bad that the government over there does. I have talked to dozens of chinese people about this, always same answers.
- smallnamespace 10y agoHave you ever considered the possibility that China's society and norms differ markedly from what you're used to, and that they might have a point? Sounds pretty presumptuous for a person who's (I assume) never lived in China to claim that they know what's good for the Chinese better than the Chinese themselves do. In particular, political elites and bureacratic, centralized government arise exactly because high populations densities and large populations lead to conflicts that require specialized decisionmakers to resolve. That's why scattered bands of hunter gatherers don't create formal governments, but cities and large countries do.
- hkon 10y agoAs westerners we honor free speech and we do not like censorship. We do not like torture or political imprisonment. I was offering my experience in discussing these issues with chinese people of whom I know a lot. Part of my point was to bring forth the fact that stuff we automatically think of as bad, is pretty much a non-issue for the chinese, because to them it makes sense. Human rights, democracy and free speech is better than oppression.
- smallnamespace 10y agoDo you think that the Chinese people you talk to are wrong then, and that the Chinese should wholeheartedly adopt Western values, or that people in each society should find solutions that make sense in terms of their own historical development and cultural norms? I'd like to remind you that the track record of simply imposing a formal Western model of governance (with a written Constitution, laws, elections, the whole shebang) on societies that are used to other ways of doing things hasn't tended worked out very well -- e.g. Iraq or Afghanistan.
- Manglano 10y agoThe institution of "Social Credit" could easily become an apparatus of social coercion indistinguishable from the Truck Token systems. An individual not behaving according to the interests of the group would face starvation and homelessness for not adhering to certain social norms. It would be trivial to enforce beliefs (no matter how odd or antihuman) through this apparatus. Under a currency system driven by public opinion, survival becomes a matter of "Obey or Die." In such a system, existence is analogous to slavery. This is not an advocation for lawlessness, but rather for the continued use of currency and the independence of the financial organ from the whims of human opinion. The human mind is subject to ongoing cognitive and social distortion. Currency independent of these factors is a mitigating measure against human cruelty. A strong social benefit system and the show of empathy in which one is anchored is a stronger mitigation against antisocial behaviour than the Social Credit concept.
- Barrin92 10y agoSlavery is the rule of one group, usually ethnic over another. China's digital legalism here has very little to do with it, as it genuinely applies to everybody equally. This is a thousands of years old doctrine that goes through Chinese history. It's not the individual that is the frame of reference,but the collective and the belief is that good behaviour should be rewarded by a strong state and bad behaviour punished. This is in many ways more impartial than moving morality into the cultural or social sphere, where it is subject to identity and economical interests and so on. You can criticise it of course, it is coercive but it is definitely not slavery, it's the stark opposite. Slavery was moving fundamentally ethical concerns into the private, people were turned into property. The Chinese system moves fundamentally ethical questions into the public legal system. Bureaucracy has one big advantage, it subjugates everybody, powerful or weak alike to the same rules. No bureaucratic system can be maintained if it exercises gross violations of this principle because that's the thing it has going for it. The CPC is acutely aware of this. There is of course practical corruption but never to the degree that it undermines the system.
- nercht12 10y agoHe said existence is analogous, not "is". It's a matter of feeling by the person. While their every move isn't dictated - because it's impossible to enforce at such a scale - the parallels to slavery are there. >> Bureaucracy has one big advantage, it subjugates everybody, powerful or weak alike to the same rules. I'm fairly confident some small party at the top runs the show and everyone else is a subject. Every non-democratic government boils down to being an oligarchy, and those at the very top usually have the most freedom.
- miguelrochefort 10y agoI've been predicting the death of privacy and the rise of the social score for a decade. It's the logical next step in society, and I can't wait for it to concretize. Mainly, it should focus on trust and reliability. In the future, the only crime will be to lie (which includes doing what you promise not to do). Naturally, privacy will become a thing of the past. Once we have reliable trust scores, the world will be a lot more efficient and the workforce will become liquid (no interview, the employer will trust that you're the right fit for the job). All other forms of currency will disappear, and only in scarcity will those with a higher score have priority over others. Naturally, this will also be the end of copyrights and patents, as these cause artificial scarcities that are no longer relevant. Thank you China.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoThe Agnelli and Rotschild (proprietors) have brass balls. Everybody knows the Chinese just copy Western inventions.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoSeems right. Since we already implemented 1984, the next logical step is to make Black Mirror a reality. I'm looking forward to retiring as a social media coach.
- owly 10y agoAnd who here thinks that LinkedIn, FaceBook, Google aren't gathering similar data points? Just a matter of time...
- Animats 10y agoThe US is headed for a similar system: - Class A : US citizen, registered voter, passed scrutiny level for Global Entry, gun license, or security clearance. Gets to use fast lane at airport security. Eligible for national security related jobs. - Class B: US citizen, registered voter, not approved for Global Entry or gun license. Gets to vote. - Class C: US citizen, non registered voter. Gets to live in US permanently, but can't currently vote. Can hold most jobs. - Class D: US citizen, felony conviction. Cannot vote, ineligible for many jobs, cannot serve on jury or hold public office. - Class F: US permanent resident. Cannot vote, ineligible for many jobs. - Class G: Non-US citizen with temporary visa. Cannot vote, jobs limited or work prohibited, behavior monitored by ICE and CBP. - Class H: Illegal alien. Deport on sight.
- arbuge 10y agoI was in classes G and subsequently F before moving to B (no interest in A). Would much prefer any of those to class D from what I know.
- trendia 10y agoAlthough you mention a hierarchy of benefits, the criteria to move up or down is not currently dependent on your political views or opinion. For instance, global entry is dependent on being a member of The Democratic or Republican Party, and you won't be removed from it if you switch voter representation. That's the main problem with China's system: they're changing your rights based on how compliant you are with the Communist Party's agenda.
- anotherarray 10y agoThis is terrible, but isn't it also a reality in the West? Privacy laws getting loose, private business making deals with the government, social acceptance based on a "state of emergency". Only difference is that the infrastructure of "Western digital totalitarian states" is run by private corporations.
- 4818 10y agoEveryone is rating their citizens. Internet has become a too dangerous place for ordinary people.
- westiseast 10y agoIn case HackerNews is wondering, this is what a 50 Cent Party member looks like. Seriously. The comments contain all the classic deflections of wumao posts: the endless whataboutisms, claims that China is peaceful, minimizing the situation in China, outright lies, a seemingly endless and authoritative knowledge of any situation in China you care to mention that always parrots the government line... Everyone grows up learning a version of the Boy Who Cried Wolf stories. The moral is: when someone willfully engages in deception, it destroys their creditworthiness, even when they might be telling the truth later. Maybe you aren't wumao. Fine - but the Chinese government has invested years and billions in utterly destroying the trustworthiness of your viewpoints by employing people who sound exactly, 100% like you. Sorry buddy, it undermines all of the possibly valid points you are making.
- xnull2guest 10y agoI'm an American. I grew up in the New England area and I now live on the West Coast. I'm in Computer Security. I do not know how to address a challenge like this? How can I - without providing something absurd like my driver's license - prove that I am an American and of American decent? Note that I was talking the other day about the situation in Cyprus, where I used the terminology 'aggressive' to describe Turkish behavior. I was accused of being a Greek. Anyway, I fully reject the accusation that I am 50 Cent Party member or paid by any government, including my home country the United States.
- westiseast 10y agoSure, but refer to my last point. Don't appeal to us. The problem is not whether we have or have not evidence of who you are. The problem is that the Chinese government has actively destroyed its long term credibility on these issues by (a) using wumao and schills to attempt to DDOS public debate on these issues, (b) locking up and disempowering any voices of dissent that might allow a nuanced, authentic discussion of China-related issues in or outside of China, c) taking zero tolerance, blinkered and extreme views on many national/territorial issues that are very difficult for anyone else not Chinese to accept. E.g. I would totally support the idea of One China eventually, but why does the mainland government insist on denying that Taiwan is, de facto, a separate country right now? It's insane. Few would begrudge a future, managed and gradual reunion of these historically linked countries. But why on earth won't China (and pro-China commenters like yourself) drop the charade that Taiwan doesn't have its own constitution, currency, diplomatic service, politics, borders etc.? That's why your opinions can't be trusted - because they 100% mirror the insane opinions of the CCP and the wumao they employ. You might be a totally cool guy who just happens to believe that China is peace loving and coincidentally has done loads of detailed research into UNCLOS and the state of civil society and dissent in China. But the issue has moved on.
- eceppda 10y agoAny time you see an article discrediting China from the Western press, like this one, try this: Replace the text "China", with "US". What's remarkable is that the story rarely changes. Every undemocratic, evil-doing charge leveled by Western media at China is happening in the West as well. I'm well aware that it pays to villainize China in the press today. I assume they've made too much of our stuff or something, and now they're trying to be free of Western dominance or some heresy like that. Ohh! You evil China! Trying to be free of Western dominion!
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoWhenever you read a biased article about the West in the Chinese press, simply replace the text "West" with "China". What's remarkable is that the story rarely changes. Every evil charge leveled by the Chinese media at the West is happening in china as well. The emperor literally has no clothes on. I'm well aware that it pays to villanize the USA in the Chinese press today. It definitely distracts from problems at home, and has been a standard play in the CPC handbook for a long time. Ohh! You evil west! Trying to impose western imperialistic ideals on the world like human rights and voting in elections.
- lacampbell 10y agoEdgy. Tell us your opinions on North Korea.
- intrasight 10y agoWhat I find most disturbing about this story is that the "corporate kleptocracy masquerading as a government" paradigm that exists in China and Russia is now headed to the USA with the Trump administration. This type of "political scoring" will follow next. The Trump team has already requested from government departments the names of employees who attended global warming conferences. Welcome to the new America.
- afriday11 10y agoI don't see this program going through. The government there (any everywhere) is constantly trying crazy schemes like this with little results to show. Instead of worrying about what China is doing, those of us in the US should be worried what our own government and private corporations are up to.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoUnless one is in china, then they should really worry about what the Chinese government is gong to do. But I digress: the real danger is that other countries will use china as a blue print for their own digital authoritarianism, perhaps even the USA.
- jimnotgym 10y agoThe Chinese government must see the UK's Investigatory Powers Act, the snoopers charter as a great inspiration...
- gbog 10y agoFrom the article: "Big-data systems in democracies are not designed for social control." First I don't think calling western countries "democracies" is correct. From Europe the USA is certainly not embodying the model of democracy, if democracy is power to the people (it's more akin to power to the rich people). Buy even then, big data is designed from the ground up as a way to serve better ads, which is the companies way to do social control. So you have the choice between Pepsi/Coke controlled society or Gov controlled society. I'll have neither, thanks.
- tn13 10y agoWet dream of American politicians. All this only leads to a low trust society which eventually collapses due to its exploitation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]