13 ms·
Watt time is left
- staticelf 10y agoIs there a background for this? I don't understand the article.
- aneeshnl 10y agoApple removes the ‘time remaining’ battery estimate in new macOS update http://www.theverge.com/2016/12/13/13939278/apple-macos-sierra-new-macbook-pros-battery-life http://www.theverge.com/2016/12/13/13939278/apple-macos-sier...
- Etheryte 10y agoWell that's simply the silliest way to try and solve the battery-life issues of the new laptops.
- tptacek 10y agoThat's not what they're doing. They're recognizing that the estimate has always been misleading.
- taneq 10y agoThe estimate has always (at least, based on my 2010 Snow Leopard MBP) been pretty good at telling you how long your laptop will last if you keep doing exactly what you're doing now. Same as any other kind of estimate (yes, even the legendarily-terrible Windows file copy dialog). It's not misleading, you just have to understand what the numbers mean.
- mikeash 10y agoQuite an amazing coincidence that they recognized this right after they released a new line of computers whose battery life failed to live up to expectations. And quite annoying that they're "recognizing" this, when it's often quite useful and not at all misleading. I made good use of that display before, and now they've taken it away.
- coldtea 10y ago>Quite an amazing coincidence that they recognized this right after they released a new line of computers whose battery life failed to live up to expectations. Or was reported to have "failed to live up to expectations", by idiots who merely assumed the estimate and didn't bother to do an actual clock wall check.
- mikeash 10y agoSo I'm being punished for the actions of some idiots I never met? That's not better.
- neom 10y agoAnd in pretty much every consumer product that you use. Ethnography is a thing.
- coldtea 10y agoNo, I doubt they changed it to punish Mike Ash specifically. Rather they decided to cut the fake precision (X hours YY minutes) and stick to the segmented-battery icon display. It's like some statistics were saying there's a 45.32% chance of something, just because that's what their simplistic division of the samples gives them, despite the confidence margin being plus/minus 5 percentage points. Instead, they now tell you it's "between 40% and 50%". The target audience of the statistics is not "punished because some idiots took 45.32% literally". They are just shown a better value.
- mikeash 10y agoThey could have changed it to "about X hours" if precision was the problem.
- dpark 10y agoMore correct but less useful isn't actually better. An estimate of time remaining is more meaningful than a percentage of battery capacity remaining, even if the latter can be provided with more accuracy.
- moolcool 10y agoUh huh...
- mstade 10y agoDidn't they have a similar reaction to the antenna issues on iPhone 4 (5?) back in the dizzy? They'd show five bars when truly, it was more like one or two? I forget the details, but this seems similar to me.
- hellofunk 10y agoJust trying to think back that far makes me dizzy.
- joecool1029 10y agoYeah, it was the iPhone 4. Previously on their software the signal meter was tied to some specific RSSI dBm, but that phone had a poor antenna design and dropped calls at higher perceived signal. So they responded by adjusting the meter to better reflect call quality instead. You can enable raw RSSI numbers in the field test menu still. Also related around that time: Apple pushed an update for AT&T that changed their HSPA indicator from 3G to 4G without any upgrade haven taken place.
- terryf 10y agoI've quite often used it to check if I can finish the movie I'm watching for example or if I have enough battery to finish writing something during the flight and so on. I'd say especially for the movie case, it's surprisingly accurate.
- lobster_johnson 10y agoAccording to Apple, the new laptops don't have a battery issue, but that the battery estimate is misleading. For example, people were reporting that macOS would show 3 hours remaining, but then the laptop would actually last 6 hours. No idea why this came up at the same time as the hardware launch. macOS has had various background sync tasks for a while — iCloud sync, Photos, Time Machine, etc. Sierra adds some background services (specifically, "Optimized Storage") that might have a bigger effect.
- abritinthebay 10y agoThe point is that those estimates aren't actually accurate. That they mislead the end user so they don't belong in primary UI. This article is nice to show that you can get the data from the command line (you can still get it elsewhere in macOS too) but the snark at Apple for saying they can't do it when it's in fact a deliberate design choice just makes the author look uninformed & petty.
- wyager 10y agoIt doesn't matter if they aren't perfectly accurate. Neither is the battery "percentage"; it's a constructed number that usually has an unintuitive relationship with the actual physical state of the battery. The point is that it's a useful number, as it answers the question "approximately how much longer can I keep doing what I'm doing right now?".
- abritinthebay 10y agoPercentage is pretty darn accurate actually. Mostly because it's based on remaining charge not fluctuations in load like time. You can measure this yourself with any lipoly batteries you have at home. It's quite reliable
- coldtea 10y ago>Mostly because it's based on remaining charge not fluctuations in load like time. It should display "remaining charge" then, not absolute hours and minutes.
- lightedman 10y agoMost people aren't educated enough to know what math operations to do in order to convert and get a time estimate.
- coldtea 10y agoMost people don't understand that "1 hour remaining" will actually be "20 minutes remaining" if they start some heavy gaming either...
- onion2k 10y agoI don't think it's fair to suggest Apple removed the battery life indicator because they don't know how to make one.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's a joke. Of course they know how to make one. They had one in 10.12.1.
- johansch 10y agoSo is there any good (hopefully free/open) third-party solution to bring it back to the menu bar on the mac?
- akvadrako 10y agoSure, iStat Menus is great.
- mwfj 10y agoIt's also $18 and closed-source. You might have wanted to disclose that since I mentioned free/open. Just saying.
- jdcarter 10y agoSeconded on iStat Menus. Despite its cost, it shows a ton of useful statistics, including moving graphs of CPU activity, network IO, storage IO, etc.. It's easy to customize the display so you see just what you care about.
- msrpotus 10y agoI've been using Battery Time Remaining for a while and it has some useful features that even the old indicator didn't have (for instance, which apps are draining the battery the most). https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/battery-time-remaining/id551420833?mt=12 https://itunes.apple.com/au/app/battery-time-remaining/id551...
- johansch 10y agoLooks nice. It does feel painful to give Apple 30% of $0.99 (US) in this instance.
- DavideNL 10y agoYou can also get it for free (and the source) on Github.. https://github.com/codler/Battery-Time-Remaining https://github.com/codler/Battery-Time-Remaining PS. i especially like the notifications you can set at 100%, 15%, 5% etc battery life. very handy!
- dexwiz 10y agoApple should have added a Amp or Watt usage number, not removed the estimate. Similarly, most new cars have fuel estimates on their dashboards. But its not just miles to empty, its also miles per gallon. So drivers can get feedback on usage rates versus total capacity. I imagine the argument about this, is that most people don't have any handle on what a Watt or mAh is. But people don't have a good handle on how far 25 miles is, or how much a gallon is in comparison to their tank. Think about it, you rarely see the fuel you put into your car beyond a few drips at the pump. And while you may know that its 25 miles between your house in work, if I took a random point on a map and said find something 25 miles away, with no scale, most people couldn't do it. Gallons and MPG are just arbitrary numbers that consumers have learned how to compare. If you exposed those numbers, they would get a better handling on what their device consumes, and how their activities affect it.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoThey still have the percentage indicator, which is presumably directly proportional to mAh remaining, and people generally have a good understanding of what percentage is. Using your analogy, your gas gauge doesn't show the number of gallons, it shows a relative level.
- bendykstra 10y agoHis point is that Apple should show the energy consumption rate in addition to the percentage indicator, just as cars show fuel consumption as mpg and fuel remaining as a percentage.
- dexwiz 10y agoOlder gauges just showed percentages, but many new cars will tell you gallons, current MPG, and an estimated distance to empty.
- pyromine 10y agoHow far back do we have to go to get to cars that just showed percentages, cause I have literally never experienced one in my life. Even my model year 2000 clunker has instant MPG, average MPG, miles to empty and a gas gauge with actual gallons.
- jsnell 10y agoIf the core problem is supposed to be that power usage is now more erratic, how about this small refinement: - Compute discharge rates for one minute segments, like Ted did in this post - Store the last 10 discharge rates - Report a time estimate based on the minimum/median/maximum of those 10 rates. That gives fairly quick feedback after you start doing something expensive, but isolates the effect of short-lived and infrequent bursts.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's not as if erratic power usage is a new thing, anyway. My 2013 MPB's battery life can easily vary by an order of magnitude. It'll last 10+ hours if it's sitting there not doing much, or maybe an hour with an intense 3D game. The estimate they provided up to 10.12.1 was still quite good if I was doing the same thing for a while, which I usually am.
- imwally 10y agoI started working on a little CLI battery status indicator even before I knew Apple was going to pull the time remaining feature. On macOS I like to hide the dock and menu bar but usually keep terminal open with tmux running so I decided to write something I could place in my tmux status line where I could keep an eye on my battery life. https://github.com/imwally/battstat https://github.com/imwally/battstat
- lloeki 10y agoI've had a python{2,3} script for, like, years, collecting advanced details using ioreg. Sample output: ~> ~/Workspace/toolbelt/battery Temperature = 2967 CycleCount = 384 DesignCapacity = 6600 MaxCapacity = 6362 WearRatio = 96% CurrentCapacity = 5886 ChargeRatio = 92% Voltage = 12162 Amperage = -1061 InstantAmperage = 64286 InstantTimeToEmpty = 8:34 TimeRemaining = 5:33 AvgTimeToEmpty = 5:33 FullToEmptyTime = 5:59 https://github.com/lloeki/toolbelt/blob/master/battery https://github.com/lloeki/toolbelt/blob/master/battery
- serkanyersen 10y agoThis is awesome. Thanks
- stevefeinstein 10y agoThis might work well with bitbar. https://getbitbar.com https://getbitbar.com
- tedmiston 10y agoI haven't upgraded to 10.12 yet, but this seems like a good time to remind people about coconutBattery [1]. You can't see a prediction in minutes yet (maybe they'll add one with Apple removing it), but the battery metrics have always been more useful than for me than what's built-in. You can see the discharge rate, current charge, full capacity, and original capacity though. [1]: http://www.coconut-flavour.com/coconutbattery/ http://www.coconut-flavour.com/coconutbattery/
- dchest 10y agoThank you! It has "time until empty" indicator (%r) http://imgur.com/a/74qLJ http://imgur.com/a/74qLJ
- tedmiston 10y agoOh, cool. I hadn't seen the menu bar option before.
- djsumdog 10y agoI haven't used a Mac in years, but back when I had one, I did use Coconut Battery to track the degradation of my battery over time. It's a great little application.
- tedmiston 10y agoCan anyone on the latest update of macOS confirm whether the time prediction is also gone from Activity Monitor > Energy at the bottom?
- yoz-y 10y agoThe estimate is still there, you can also get if by running `pmset -g batt`.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- trymas 10y ago> sysctl -A | ag watt Gives nothing. Why it's not shown? rMBP late 2013, macOS 10.12.2.
- ggreer 10y agoThe author is using a Thinkpad running OpenBSD. I don't think macos or linux kernels expose battery info as kernel state. Also, thanks for using ag. :)
- trymas 10y ago> I don't think macos or linux kernels expose battery info as kernel state. Bummer. > Also, thanks for using ag. :) Thank you for making it ;)
- Osiris 10y agoI wrote a battery meter (BatteryBar) 8 years ago that uses a more complex algorithm to calculate an "average time remaining" rather than instantaneous. Basically, my software keeps track of how long the battery has lasted in the past and uses that to inform the current time remaining (with adjustments based on current discharge rates, etc). I'm not sure why Microsoft/Apple haven't done something similar. I've even sold licenses to Surface Pro sales reps that they use to show off the battery life of the Surface to potential enterprise clients.
- waynecochran 10y ago197.45836985100788781720 is grossly superfluous precision is it not?
- andrewgleave 10y agoYears ago (probably 2009) I wrote a small utility which polls the SMC to get current and voltage readings and from hardware. Wrapped it up in a simple app which shows realtime power consumption in my menu bar. Didn't do much with it since the SMC keys differ for pretty much every piece of hardware Apple create and there is practically no information so it requires some investigation for each.
- Skunkleton 10y agoThey removed it to cut down on complaints. Most people wont get the advertised 10 hours, and now most people wont notice.
- comex 10y agoOr: Most people will get the advertised 10 hours, and now people won't think they're not because of an inaccurate estimate.
- Skunkleton 10y agoI guess it depends. Seems like people are getting more that 10 hours out of it when used for light tasks.