6 ms·
Unfortunately, with firearms registration and no-fly lists, Muslim registries are part of the slope we've set precedent for. A citizen should _never_ have to
by exabrial 10y ago
Unfortunately, with firearms registration and no-fly lists, Muslim registries are part of the slope we've set precedent for. A citizen should _never_ have to register with the government to exercise a freedom explicitly granted in the constitution.
- this-dang-guy 10y agoI'd argue "A citizen should _never_ have to register with the government" should really be the entire statement. Things like aid and whatnot should really be isolated and broken off to prevent mass collection dbs.
- xupybd 10y agoDoesn't every birth have to be registered with the government?
- this-dang-guy 10y agoFor "social security" benefits. Yes. And look how that's turned out. It's deemed proof of citizenship (and a vital document) despite being just a poor quality piece of paper. The data is misused in just about every way. From colleges using it as a student id number to people committing crimes with it.
- jdmichal 10y agoIf someone is using a SSN as proof of citizenship, they are blatantly wrong. SSNs can and are issued to aliens. https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10096.pdf https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10096.pdf USCIS lists as common proofs of citizenship: US birth certificate, US passport, certificate of citizenship, or naturalization certificate. https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Resources/A4en.pdf https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Resources/A4...
- maxerickson 10y agoI imagine they are thinking of it being a list C document: https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/acceptable-documents https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/acceptable-documents (an unrestricted SSN is proof of eligibility to work in the US)
- this-dang-guy 10y agoYes, and no less than 3 of my former jobs required a photocopy of the card itself. You can argue legal requirements, or you can shut up and be paid. Sometimes it's better to be paid than right. (Especially on your first few jobs)
- zo1 10y ago"select * from individual where religion = 'muslim'" You would think it's that easy as the "government knows all". But from working on government databases and systems, it's hardly the case. Disparate systems, competing departments, endless workshops that hold up progress, political spats, etc. And this isn't even in a country like the US that has separate states!
- xupybd 10y agoDoesn't every birth have to be registered with the government?
- woofyman 10y agoNot even for voting?
- dagw 10y agoYou don't have to vote.
- marchenko 10y agoEugene Volokh wrote an excellent and highly-cited paper on this point, summarized here: http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/slipperymag.pdf http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/slipperymag.pdf
- dmritard96 10y agoequating the purchase of a shotgun to having an ethnic or religious identity is a sad statement.
- exabrial 10y agoWhy? Both are guaranteed in the Constitution. Picking parts and playing favorites is what has lead us to the current state of affairs.
- tjohns 10y agoOne is a potentially deadly weapon, bearing a serial number that might be especially useful if found at a crime scene. The other is a largely inconsequential part of your personal identity, which has routinely been used as justification for persecution throughout human history. (Personally: I support responsible gun ownership, but I don't think there's anything wrong with asking owners to register their serial numbers.)
- exabrial 10y agoThere's plenty wrong with asking people to register their serial numbers, especially when you combine these two statements: > asking owners to register their serial numbers > deadly weapon, bearing a serial number that might be especially useful if found at a crime scene
- tjohns 10y agoI'm legitimately curious here... what's the actual problem? I don't see any issue combining those two statements. The second amendment gives you a right to own a firearm. Nowhere does it say you should be allowed to use it to commit criminal acts with impunity. I view it like the requirement to have a license plate visible on my car, which seems reasonable given the risks involved in driving.
- exabrial 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lucaspiller 10y agoIt's an interesting argument. How could that work for things like driving, where you need to prove competency before you are legally allowed to do something?
- jasonlotito 10y agoDriving a car isn't a protected right unlike the other things mentioned in the parent comment.
- BeetleB 10y agoBecause driving on public roads has never been a right in the US. It has always been a privilege that you are granted.
- bpodgursky 10y agoThat's not really accurate. Freedom of assembly is interpreted pretty generously. It's fine to disqualify on not knowing how to drive safely, but any other unrelated qualifier would be struck down as unconstitutional.
- adrr 10y agoThats a good point. If the US did a "no drive" list, there's no way it would standup in the courts. Counter point would be a "no firearm" list which runs counter to the 2nd amendment and may standup in the courts.
- sn0v 10y agoDriving isn't listed as a Constitutional Right though.
- Jtsummers 10y agoDriving isn't considered a right, but also registration is with the States, not the Fed.
- hashhar 10y agoI think the important point is that competency doesn't come from religion. It comes from past actions and current environment one is exposed to.
- woofyman 10y agoFlying isn't a constitutionally protected right. Voting is though. Should you be able to vote without registering?
- jmcdiesel 10y agoFlying actually falls in a gray area... Considering you are "taxed" in essence for the TSA, to move between states... freedom of movement between states and all...
- dagw 10y agoThe TSA is, in principle, something voters have 'chosen' to put into place and could remove if they wished. Also there is no difference in the TSA 'tax' if you fly between states or within a state, so as such in has nothing to do with interstate travel.
- exabrial 10y agoFlying is an interesting case, per the 5th amendment we have the freedom to travel (liberty). There are too many points to consider for an HN thread, but in general, I would propose flying as a reasonably protected right, but no-fly lists as a violation of that right because of the absolute lack of due process. There is plenty of room for reasonable and effective security measures, as long as they don't intimidate, discriminate, inconvenience, or harass citizens.
- exabrial 10y agoVoter registration is an interesting scenario too, but there's more than what meets the surface: There are multiple rights to protect. We all have the right to vote. We also have the right that your vote is of equal weight to everyone else's vote. We must also be able to ensure that votes are anonymous, to protect people from being persecuted. Finally, we also have the right to a secure election that only allows citizens to vote. In my opinion, voter registration is a reasonable regulation to protect everything I mentioned above, as long as it does not intimidate, discriminate, inconvenience, or harass citizens.