13 ms·
I seriously think that to get a CS or EE degree (or similar) B.Sci degree, you should be required to take at least one full term length ethics course. Same idea
by walrus01 10y ago
I seriously think that to get a CS or EE degree (or similar) B.Sci degree, you should be required to take at least one full term length ethics course. Same idea as the ethics courses taught to junior law students.
The internet is already fucked up enough with governments and rogue corporations messing with its AS-adjacency topology in non-free ways at OSI layers 1-3 , before you even get into stuff like writing backdoors at layer 4+ to pass all email to the NSA.
- marcfawzi 10y agoAnd yet you will find many lawyers are raketeers and extortionists.
- wildmusings 10y agoWhen you get a legally-binding order from the government of the United States of America, and exhaust your legal appeals, you either comply or go to prison. An ethics course won't do you any good.
- walrus01 10y agoPeople have the option to quit. The company is legally bound to obey, but individual employees can chose for themselves whether they want to be a party to it. Yahoo may still be court ordered to implement it, just hopefully not with their best and brightest developers. I also have a theory that a lot of the recent terrible news coming out of Yahoo is due to staff complying with the letter of the legal order but not the entire thorough spirit of it, intentionally doing a quick, shoddy bug ridden job.
- bluesmoon 10y agoUnfortunately it's not that simple. More often than not, someone high up will find someone low whose continued stay in the country is highly dependent on them keeping this job. While I've never had to make such a choice, I can tell you that my personal attitude towards what I would and wouldn't do changed the day this restriction was removed.
- jrowley 10y agoThe other point to be made is that you probably want your best developers implementing back doors (if you are compelled to do so), so at least the back door is as secure as possible (and not trivially bipassed)
- couchand 10y agoAll the more reason that you should take pause when your best developers refuse to do so.
- kashkhan 10y agoit only works if resignations are numerous enough to matter to the company.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIt only "works" in the sense of preventing it if resignations are that numerous. It "works" in the sense of "I, the individual employee, can still live with myself", even if only one quits.
- kabdib 10y agoOptions: - Refuse to take action. They want engineering done, they can bloody well do it themselves. Don't type a single keystroke in the direction of helping them. - Announce what is going on anonymously. Plenty of avenues for this. - Announce what is going on, publicly. See if they do indeed want to take you to court. - Quit. - Take down the service. Much easier if the service is only a part of your company. Helps a lot if you don't retain the information they're looking for. - Lie. - Destroy records (this is by far the riskiest action here, above a simple public announcement). - Delay. And delay more. - Keep information outside the jurisdiction, possibly controlled by a third party who will not comply with orders. - Misunderstand ("Is that a one, or an ell?") Most of these will get you into trouble, a few won't. Most of these are really difficult roads. I've given this some thought before. If I found a backdoor in a product, I would remove it with a tracking bug and a checkin, and send internal email about a really bad bug that I'd just fixed; the more internal people that know, the better. And if a VP showed up and berated me, I'd just tell them to fuck off, and quit if it came to that.
- marcoperaza 10y agoIf you want to quit to refuse to help, fine, but I take serious issue with what you're suggesting beyond that. These are the legal actions of the United States government, executing the authority given to them to the people's elected representatives, and overseen by a judiciary duly selected according the constitutional procedures. Their legal and democratic authority is unassailable. Further, you don't know what motivated these actions. Is it intelligence about a specific threat? Has the government identified how a specific adversary operates? You could be impeding the investigation into a deadly plot. You have no way of knowing this. This isn't a game. We have real enemies who would gladly kill all of us. We have processes as a society for deciding how we defend ourselves. If you don't like our current policies, then exercise your vote, exercise your right to speak and publish and assemble. But don't usurp the sovereignty of the people of this country.
- walrus01 10y ago> You could be impeding the investigation into a deadly plot. problem is, that's the excuse that's always going to be given by the intelligence community for even the most obviously unconstitutional intrusive privacy invading stuff, like the NSA's "opticnerve" program.
- hbt 10y agoThis is why we (as a community/industry) need to have the equivalent of a prison/death threat. The government wins by making it personal, by threatening prison and death for your obedience. It's not an abstract threat. It is directed to a specific person not a company or security team. The people who comply can quit those companies but they don't. I'm not referring to the ones down the chain (e.g the security team who was unaware) but the ones who obeyed and pushed something they believed was wrong. Whether it is public shaming or having a permanent stain on their reputation next time they go job hunting, we need a way to retaliate. Right now, they can fuck us and get away with it and what's their excuse? "the government told me to do it. Just doing my job. I had no choice." There are no societal consequences to cooperating with the government even when we believe it's wrong. Create a climate of "snitches get stitches" and maybe they will think twice before selling out the lives of a billion people. The same way these government officials hide behind patriotism when they mean blind obedience to my authority.
- bbarn 10y agoWow. This is probably the worst comment I've ever seen on HN. You're suggesting that people who follow the law, which you disagree with, get blacklisted, following the model of criminals killing other criminals who follow the law. If you want to change the government, there are far better ways than retaliating against citizens unwilling to risk life and limb for your ideology. I think you need to learn to direct your anger. Not everyone is in so privileged of a position to be taking your specific moral high ground over their own well being.
- throwaway21013 10y agoTroll. Period.
- hbt 10y agoSo now, quitting your job (because you're asked to do something unethical) is the equivalent of losing your life and limbs? Let me guess, you believe all government actions are lawful. All lawful actions are righteous and justified. The only permissible way to change the system is through the system. Did I get the gist of your morality? In which case, keep voting and I'm sure you will see the changes you want reflected in legislation just so they can be ignored in by secret courts and intelligence services. In the real world, people respond to threats (e.g prison). That's what the government uses. Why are we expected to behave differently?
- mtgx 10y agoNot true. Lavabit founder still roams free. But that's how they get you, through fear. You self-censor and agree to comply yourself, before you even dare to speak out against them. That's how they win without even lifting a finger.
- logfromblammo 10y agoThe ethics course will make you feel better about going to prison.
- hobarrera 10y agoYou can also "do it poorly", in such a mediocre way that what's going on leaks out. There's no way for them to prove that you did a bad job on purpose. While on topic, if they threaten you with prison if you don't do their bidding (with no due process, etc), doesn't that make them the terrorists (eg: they're using terror/fear to get people to do what they want).
- rmcpherson 10y agoI don't know how common this is in general, but an ethics course was a required part of the engineering core curricula at my school (Case Western Reserve). Ultimately, though, an ethics course isn't going to make people stand up for their ethics. A professional organization along the lines of the American Medical Association (at least in terms of political strength) that stands up for its members and censures those who behave unethically would do far more for strengthening engineering ethics collectively. When there are few professional consequences for unethical behavior at the behest of your employer, taking an ethical stand is ineffective and quixotic. You will be fired and another engineer will likely complete the job.
- rexf 10y agoI agree, I'm not sure that an ethics course will make people behave ethically. As part of my former life, I had to take an Ethics course for my accounting license. It focused on topics like conflicts of interest. Even though many professional (licensed) accountants have taken the ethics course and passed an ethics exam, it doesn't mean that much. Ultimately, behaving ethically will come down the individual's morals.
- imjustsaying 10y ago> When there are few professional consequences for unethical behavior at the behest of your employer, taking an ethical stand is ineffective and quixotic. You will be fired and another engineer will likely complete the job. Well quitting a job as a concentration camp gas chamber constructor may merely slow down the operation a bit, but that could mean more lives saved until VE day arrives. And yes I did just make that metaphor.
- derefr 10y agoThat assumes your job has a very low bus factor. Presuming a company of the scale required for a state to need its assistance, your absence (and that of however many people there are who agree with you) likely won't slow down the operation at all.
- 10y ago
- bluesmoon 10y agoThe people who do this aren't wilful engineers. Source: I'm a former member of Yahoo's Paranoid team.
- matheweis 10y agoAt my school (Northern Arizona University), CS students are required to do exactly this.
- ahelwer 10y agoUndergraduate ethics courses usually just go over the big historically-important ethical analysis systems (utilitarianism, Kantian deontology, veil of ignorance, social contract, etc.) Unlikely to touch on trickier issues such as why you ought to act ethically at all, or even what it means to act ethically - why, for instance, are you so certain writing backdoors for the NSA is unethical? This is certainly something which can be argued.
- nitemice 10y agoEven worse though, is that these sorts of courses are almost always derided by the majority of the student base as a waste of time, and "common sense stuff". I actually really enjoyed the one I did, although it had just gone through a major rewrite to improve it a lot. And yet, I don't think I ever heard any of my peers mention the course with anything but contempt.
- judahmeek 10y agoThat's because a course on ethics doesn't provide students with greater ethical reasoning or values. Such courses simply provide information and test whether students were listening to the lectures or not.
- user837387 10y ago>> take at least one full term length ethics course I did take one for my Masters in Computer Science. I think it was required. Unfortunately, for some reason I didn't understand most of it. Don't know why. My suspicion is that they didn't know what they were talking about or it was just a class full of BS.
- mburst 10y agoUniversity of Central Florida required this when I went there, but I think the issue is applying the learnings from the course vs getting the pay check from your employer. I think it's one of those things that is easier to say than do unfortunately.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chrismcb 10y agoHow would an ethics course solve this? There are people who think that this is the ethical thing to do. That it is OK for the government to see what the "criminals" are doing. The "I don't have anything to hide crowd."
- meddlepal 10y agoI suspect the people arguing for this want to push their brand of ethics and ideology. But you're right, there isn't a single set of ethics.
- jnpatel 10y agoFor its EECS undergrads, Berkeley requires CS 195: "Social Implications of Computing". http://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs195/fa16/about.html http://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs195/fa16/about.html
- matheusmoreira 10y ago>messing with its AS-adjacency topology in non-free ways at OSI layers 1-3 Can you please explain how this works? I would like to understand.
- walrus01 10y agoexample: all ISPs in Iran are required by law to be downstream of the single government run ASN, which controls all paths for data in and out of the country: https://www.google.com/search?q=DCI+iran+ASN&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b https://www.google.com/search?q=DCI+iran+ASN&ie=utf-8&oe=utf... example: the turkish government orders ISPs to null route IP blocks of things they disagree with (occasionally all of youtube).
- notyourwork 10y agoWhat engineering program doesn't require ethics as a standard freshmen engineering introduction?
- cbhl 10y agoI had to take a full term length ethics course to get my Software Engineering degree -- at what post-secondary institutions does this not hold true? How do we make all the unregulated ways of learning how to code (e.g. coding bootcamps) include ethics in their curriculum?
- c3534l 10y agoI think tech people are actually far more likely to be against this stuff than the general population. Also, a significant portion of people in tech don't have many formal qualifications compared to (as a bit of an extreme example) something like medicine or accounting. Also, as an accounting major myself, there was a big push to impress upon students ethics after the series of financial frauds in the 2000s. It involves a lot of telling us that Sarbanes-Oxley exists often, quizzing us on some detail of the act rarely, but never actually giving us ethically questionable situations and having us debate what should be done or covering cases of unethical behavior. Having taken an actually course in ethics, I'm not impressed by it's ability to get people to behave ethically, it was very theoretical and, actually, not very prescriptivist which is actually probably what you want. And the struggle you're up against, too, is that the NSA is a government agency giving you legally binding orders because, they argue, they need it for law-enforcement purposes. It's not even a black-and-white issue where you can expect everyone, even most, to agree on if the article described ethical behavior or not.
- X-Istence 10y agoMy alma mater had just that. It was a course named "Ethics in Technology". The description for the course: " TCH301 is designed to introduce students to essential concepts necessary to evaluate the ethical implications and potential impacts of the use of new technology within human society and culture. Students will explore modern ethical dilemmas in technology, looking at multiple aspects of how the introduction of technology redefines law and values. " From: http://majors.uat.edu/Tech-Studies/Pages/Core_Curriculum.aspx http://majors.uat.edu/Tech-Studies/Pages/Core_Curriculum.asp... It was and still is a required course to graduate with a degree from UAT.
- pjscott 10y agoEverybody at my school took one of those. It was all platitudes all the time. No substance at all. Every once in a while I hear someone call for more people to have to sit in Platitude Class, and I can't figure out why.
- kogepathic 10y agoIn Canada all engineering students are required to take an ethics course. Granted since it is taught to all engineering disciplines the material is quite broad, mostly focusing on topics like bribery and negligence, but it does also cover whistle blowing.
- EnderMB 10y agoI think that this is largely already the case. I studied at a post-polytechnic university in the UK (think community college), and we had a legal and ethics course, and IIRC this very subject was touched on.
- Snowdax 10y agoHere in Ireland anyway for a university to be accredited at all ethics has to be part of the engineering curriculum. First Semester of our first year we got a dedicated ethics class.
- davidgerard 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13169587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13169587
- partiallogic 10y agoThey do in Spain, it covered data protection laws & professional ethics and was in the third year of the four year degree
- muyuu 10y agoIt wasn't required but I did take a course on ethics and law. I'm pretty sure many programmes include such courses.
- Jach 10y agoSave it for the MBAs instead, or even as an onboarding requirement along with other training for new management hires. It's not generally the engineers making these decisions. Sometimes it's an active issue and at the end of the day someone must implement something terrible (knowingly or not -- direct a junior engineer to do some complex task with the expectation they'll leave behind security vulnerabilities, just as good as getting someone to intentionally leave an issue). Ethical engineers can and probably should quit -- who knows how much a required, dull ethics course would influence that though? Other times at the end of the day it's just lack of engineers doing something -- typically due to management not signing off/budgeting. Ethical management won't even necessarily help here, the incentives don't change. Some sort of stronger corporate liability for negligence is needed, probably, but the problem is not generally the engineers -- engineers, with an ethics course or not, are typically the only people who care about these sorts of things in the first place! What's the largest dip in stock price due to a password leak? How about shady government collusion? Have any groups of shareholders demanded more care to avoid such issues at any company? I'll wrap up with a joke: "It should be noted that no ethically-trained software engineer would ever consent to write a "DestroyBaghdad" procedure. Basic professional ethics would instead require him to write a "DestroyCity" procedure, to which "Baghdad" could be given as a parameter." --Nathaniel Borenstein
- jonahrd 10y agoI disagree strongly. If you from an engineering perspective are the only one who truly recognizes the implications of a management decision, you need to speak up about it.
- Jach 10y agoEngineers do speak up, frequently. For a famous example, see the Challenger disaster. Again, engineers aren't generally the problem. Still disagree?
- djsoosbnw 10y agoThe NSA don't seem to lack the technical talent to wantonly shit all over the Constitution. Plenty of HN posts laud people for working for the government, the entity which engages in war crimes, torture, and mass surveillance.
- mhurron 10y agoYou think a course will teach someone ethics who does not have any? Or they do have ethics, but theirs are simply different than yours. Plenty of people believe assisting with government surveillance is the ethical thing to do to 'keep people safe.'
- angusp 10y agocan't speak for all CS students but we certainly have an ethics course. Unfortunately a lot of people see it as an insult to their intelligence yet need reminding of many of their professional obligations and that their 'cool hackathon idea' might be illegal
- macspoofing 10y ago>I seriously think that to get a CS or EE degree (or similar) B.Sci degree, you should be required to take at least one full term length ethics coursev Why limit to CS or EE? Why not ... everybody?
- jandrese 10y agoAnd if there is any class of people known for their impeccable ethics it is lawyers. I'm not sure that class is having the intended effect.
- Clubber 10y agoFor what it's worth, Ethics was a required course for an undergrad business degree in my college in the 90s. I'm not sure if it still is. Ethics is easily thrown out the window once some executives falsely proclaim that they are required by law to do what's best for shareholders. Since shareholders have a minimal voice outside large holders, it's easy for those executives to claim, "the shareholders want profits, period." Of course, they don't mention that executives want bonuses too. An interesting thing about ethics when you study History. When asked how they could indiscriminately kill Jews during the Holocaust, Nazis usually claimed the first few times were difficult, but the acts became a matter of course; normal as anything else in their day. In that same war, the Soviets committed brutal atrocities of the German cities they conquered, as did the Japanese in China. Every country has committed heinous acts in their history. Once it starts, inhumanity can spread like wildfire. We as developed world citizens believe we are civilized, and for the most part we are; but we are only a stones throw away from being capable of casually committing what we would think of as atrocities as the norm.
- Lawtonfogle 10y agoDuring my time in college I took multiple ethics and related classes and in my opinion they aren't worth the paper I printed class assignments on. None of these answer practical issues like what happens when the law is bad or when one's livelihood is on the line. None of these give practical advice on how to fix a society where ethical behavior is not inherently incentivized.
- pksadiq 10y ago> I seriously think that to get a CS or EE degree (or similar) B.Sci degree, you should be required to take at least one full term length ethics course. That would be a nice idea, but short living. Say for an example, we had "free software." Now many say "open source." As long as we are having greed for money or power, nothing is going to change.
- metaphorm 10y agotaking an ethics class is not a guarantee of ethical behavior. in fact, I have my doubts that it even improves the odds. and even if it did improve the odds, there's always _someone_ that won't care, or can be bought. it only takes a handful of unethical actors to make problems like this one happen on a regular basis.
- eutropia 10y agoAt the ABET accredited engineering school I attended, we were all required to take both an engineering ethics class, and more specifically a computer ethics + law class (for those of us in the CECS track). Computer Engineer here.
- deepakhj 10y agoSan Francisco State University's CS program requires an ethics course.
- binaryblitz 10y agoI am a developer and I had to take a course similar to what you're talking about. So it's out there, but making it more common would definitely be a good thing.
- barry-cotter 10y agoGiven that actual professors of ethics, professional ethicists, are no more moral than other professors this would be nothing but a waste of time. http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/PowerReason-130204.pdf http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/PowerReas... The Moral Behavior of Ethicists and the Power of Reason, Joshua Rust, Eric Schwitzgebel Professional ethicists behave no morally better, on average, than do other professors. At least that’s what we have found in a series of empirical studies that we will summarize below.
- barry-cotter 10y agoGiven that actual professors of ethics, professional ethicists, are no more moral than other professors this would be nothing but a waste of time. http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/PowerReason-130204.pdf http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/PowerReas... The Moral Behavior of Ethicists and the Power of Reason, Joshua Rust, Eric Schwitzgebel Professional ethicists behave no morally better, on average, than do other professors. At least that’s what we have found in a series of empirical studies that we will summarize below.