14 ms·
Google has reportedly stopped developing its own self-driving car
- alrs 10y agoThe only way this could have worked was to push cyclists and meat-drivers off the road and hand the bulk of the decision making to something centralized. I'm so thankful this vision appears to be dying.
- gchadwick 10y agoDying? The article says Google will be concentrating on selling their tech to existing car makers rather than producing their own car. Nothing more. Which makes perfect sense. Personally I never thought Google building the entire car was their planned end game.
- ars 10y agoThe article is marketing speak. It's dead. That's how they talk when they kill a product but don't want to say that. Which doesn't surprise me in the slightest. I suspect a self driving car, on city streets, without general AI, is impossible. It'll only work on prepared, limited access roads (like highways). Next step: Instrument highways for self driving cars. In-City self-driving cars is dead.
- Kiro 10y agoYou have no idea what you're talking about.
- MarHoff 10y agoI think he does. We must let go delusional thinking that with current AI we can safely throw autonomous car in a dense urban area. Using autonomous car to improve mobility in rural area (eg. for elders people) would prove much more applicable as a paid service and complemental to public transportation. But if mainstream geeks and investors keep dreaming about K2000 they will be deceived by current AI.
- pveierland 10y ago> We must let go delusional thinking that with current AI we can safely throw autonomous car in a dense urban area. Given the capability which Tesla currently demonstrates, it seems extreme to call the idea of full autonomy with current AI technologies delusional. With their current progress, full autonomy in production seems reasonable within a few years. https://vimeo.com/192179727 https://vimeo.com/192179727
- MarHoff 10y agoI only see some nice data-visualizations added in post-production and spice-up with a feelgood song after a successful ride. As for capability and reasonable aspect, I will be much more interested in reading post-mortem reports of the fatal crash under a truck by road safety organizations when (and if) they come out...
- MarHoff 10y agoAnd as it turned out Uber AI now cross red light: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CdJ4oae8f4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_CdJ4oae8f4 Distinguishing verifiable facts from marketing is actually important...
- Symmetry 10y agoGoogle's been safely driving cars around in a dense urban environment for a while now.
- ars 10y agoIf you check, you see that they have only been driving in limited parts of the journey (the easiest parts obviously). It's not an end to end trip. The cars are also unable to handle unexpected changes in traffic lights, or road signage. They are very very far from being able to drive entirely independently.
- pkolaczk 10y agoI also think he does. Currently all new cars come with some kind of automated assistants, some even semi-autonomous. Unfortunately they are much less reliable than humans. They are still struggling with "easy" problems like keeping in lanes and occasionally I have to "fight" with the lane-assistant because it tries to push me out of the lane I'm driving, particularly in turns, bad roads or in bad weather conditions. I'm not counting the number of times when it just shuts off because it can't "see" the lanes or the lanes are "too complex" for it. Or take the traffic-sign recognition systems. Seems easy, right? Not so fast. All the systems I tried made a lot of severe mistakes. For example sometimes they were thinking speed limit signs painted on the back of trucks or buses were real ones. Or they struggled when they saw too many signs or signs partially covered by something else. Recently I watched a test of a semi-autonomous Mercedes S500 in a typical big-city traffic. During a 10 minute test-drive it managed to "unconciously" change the lane and drive 2 lanes for some time. And also it would have passed a crossing on a red light, if the operator didn't intervene. Nice try, but the car industry is still very far from making fully autonomous driving a reality.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- netsharc 10y agoSelf-driving will happen. Bicyclists will probably profit because the people on the phones will no longer crash into them, since their cars are doing the driving. Meat drivers would be insured out of the "market". Someone (I think Jeremy Clarkson) has compared cars to horses. Horses used to be just utility animals, mistreated, etc. With the advent of cars they became sport and leisure animals, well-treated and owned only by rich people. Manual driving cars will probably still exist, but for sport and leisure, and just like horses, confined to racetracks.
- maxerickson 10y agoCars are a capital intensive, low margin business. Self driving isn't going to change either of those much. Compare revenue and net income: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/F/key-statistics https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/F/key-statistics https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GOOG/key-statistics https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GOOG/key-statistics Alphabet makes $19.07 billion of net income on $85.54 billion of revenues. Ford makes $7.25 billion of net income on $153.4 billion of revenues.
- Pyxl101 10y agoIs that surprising? I never assumed that Google was planning to build actual cars with this tech. I suppose I never really thought that deeply about how it would roll out, but if I had, I would have guessed partnerships with others in the industry. If they can nail "self-driving tech" as well as they've nailed search, they'll potentially earn licensing fees from all vehicles, rather than from the slice of vehicles they'd manufacture themselves (with a long, expensive learning curve ahead of producing quality vehicles).
- tyingq 10y ago>I never assumed that Google was planning to build actual cars with this tech They did seem to hint that they were going to. They did invest in their own, in-house built prototypes. If you start here: https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/faq/#q4 https://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar/faq/#q4 , you'll see the types of partners they were talking about working with. These aren't automakers.
- throwaway40483 10y agoI think the insane part of Google's original plan was the "no steering wheel" part, not the fact that they wanted to manufacture the cars themselves. There are so many corner cases. I can't imagine that they would get the tech working 100% out of the gate without needing some sort of manual override.
- Animats 10y agoFor a little 25MPH mini-car, full automation was and is quite practical. Google could have manufactured those things and put them on campuses, senior communities, and such. About five companies are already making slow-speed autonomous shuttle vehicles, most of which have no manual controls.
- prawn 10y agoSurely you can have some level of manual override without a steering wheel.
- schainks 10y ago
- ragebol 10y agoBut they are working with other car makers. Regardless, Google kick-started a lot of other car makers to start developing self-driving cars or made it OK for other car makers to be more public about their efforts. Similarly to Tesla in pushing EV's in other car makers.
- gil 10y agoWhich tells me there's something fundamentally wrong with the automotive (for these specific examples, but there are others) industry. Edit: typo.
- NeutronBoy 10y agoEh, other companies were heading towards the same goal in smaller increments (and more slowly). First it was cruise control, then emergency auto-braking, then assisted cruise control, then lane assist, then lane change assist, then object identification with cameras, etc... It's just that they didn't publicise their goal of 'the car will do all the driving'. It was the same logical endpoint though.
- johnward 10y agoThis is true but I think the development in the tech industry kind of kicked it into high gear. Of course I still don't see manufacturers effectively beta testing tech with real drivers like Tesla. Car companies don't like huge risk they like churning out features slowly and predictably.
- Ensorceled 10y agoThe profit incentive isn't there. Cars as a Service will drastically reduce overall car sales so why would you expect a car company be at the vanguard of a movement that will gut their industry?
- mavhc 10y agoBecause then they have a chance of winning
- russdill 10y agoThe headline is a bit misleading, it looks like Google is not going to manufacture self driving cars, but will develop self-driving technology. I'm not sure how this is a surprise.
- lambdasquirrel 10y agoWell, given how deep its pockets are and its past propensity to try on big projects, I'd say it was surprising. What's more surprising is that both Apple and Google seem to have ended up in this same place.
- Loic 10y agoIf Google develop the car, they need to do all the end user support. This is not in the DNA of Google. If they provide the technology to a car manufacturer, they can extract a fair amount of money from them and they do not have to deal with direct end user support. When my car has a problem, I want to talk directly with someone to get it fixed.
- Insanity 10y ago> This is not in the DNA of Google. Google has ventured in that area though, just take a look at Pixel, their smartphone. But the scale difference between developing a smartphone and a car is quite a big step. I am not that surprised though, getting into the car market is difficult and unsure. Just doing the technology part seems to make more sense imo.
- stunthamsterio 10y agoI'd say the big difference here is running costs. I've worked with automotive clients (Ford, GM, Renault etc) for a while, and that's a big factor for them, especially in the lease market. Also given that a car is not a 'throw it away and hand the customer a reconditioned unit' item, repairs become far more expensive and time critical. The sheer drag of maintaining a network of repairers, keeping them stocked with (Sometimes huge) spare parts, managing repair times etc is astonishing. I can see why Google and Apple would want to lean on established players instead of going it alone.
- throwaway40483 10y agoI'm wondering what this pivot will do the morale in the Chauffeur team. There has been so much turbulence in the team with several key members leaving to form their own company because they were so frustrated with the pace. I can't imagine partnering with a traditional automaker will increase the pace.
- kidmenot 10y ago> I can't imagine partnering with a traditional automaker will increase the pace. Right? I was thinking exactly the same. One would think that having a car built in-house enabled them to iterate that much quicker. Then again, Google is full of smart people, so there surely is a reason behind this decision.
- michaelt 10y agoOne would think that having a car built in-house enabled them to iterate that much quicker. There tends to be a pretty clear separation between the self-driving sensors and brains ('the new stuff') and the car platform ('the old stuff'). As long as you're willing to have some sensors and actuators visible (i.e. you're working on a prototype rather than a consumer-ready product) there's not much technical value added from building a custom car vs modifying an existing one. Indeed, it can easily slow you down as now you have a bunch of work to do developing a new car. The car that won the DARPA grand challenge was fairly close how it came off the production line - except for an off-the-shelf electrical actuator system developed for disabled drivers, an off-the-shelf secondary alternator to power all the sensors and computers, and a bunch of sensors bolted to the roof rack. The reasons to build your own are business/PR rather than technical/development speed. For example they can make it look cute and unaggressive which might be good PR; or insist on a public transport style vandal proof design for an on-demand business model. These might be good reasons, but they're business reasons not technical reasons.
- deskamess 10y agoI think this is the Android playbook. Partner with phone/car manufacturers and let them do what they do. You got to worry about customizations/fragmentation but I am not sure if that is going to be an issue for a 'behind the scenes' technology. You got to somehow tie this into Android Auto (license this?) for an integrated environment and integrations with phones or onboard maps (to get the search dollars).
- denzil_correa 10y ago> The Information reports that Google’s self-driving car unit — known internally as Chauffeur — is working with establish automotive names to develop cars which will include some self-driving features, but won’t ditch the steering wheel and pedal controls. Self-Driving cards to self-driving technology was the exact same news which was reported out of Apple "Project Titan" too. It seems to be a trend in this self-driving car space.
- vesinisa 10y ago> working with establish automotive names Is that a typo in the article or some esoteric grammar for avoiding the past participle of 'establish'?
- ralfd 10y agoManufacturing and legislation is difficult enough, but how did Apple/Google plan distribution? Servicing? It is not comparable to consumer tech, very few would buy a car where it is unsure if this is only a hobby and if it it will be supported 5 years down the road. The incumbent car companies have a massive advantage.
- johnward 10y agoGoogle has a huge disadvantages in support. You can't automate car service and simply ignore customers in that business. It would be a massive overtaking for Google to try to provide customer service.
- nodesocket 10y agoIt seems a bit strange to go the software only route when Tesla and Uber already have working hardware & software. Apple and Google missed the chance to spend their piles of cash and buy either Tesla or Uber. Now it is too late. All four are going to be battling head-to-head.
- emdowling 10y agoIt's fascinating to see Google and (purportedly) Apple move in a similar direction away from developing their own actual cars and instead building the software platform. It makes a lot of sense for Google, who have always struggled with selling products direct to consumers. It is more surprising for Apple, but makes sense if you look at how they can add the most value. I'm looking forward to seeing how this plays out. Are cars going to be (even more) commoditised at the low end and differentiated by the platform on top of it (Apple, Google, Tesla) in the same way phone carriers were commoditised by the iPhone? My gut is that they won't (industrial design is a huge part of choosing a car manufacturer), so the dynamics between platform and carrier (Toyota, Fiat Chrysler, etc) are going to be fascinating to see unfold. The traditional car industry moves at such a glacial pace, yet you have two tech titans ceding a lot of control to them. Of course, you then have the "apps" that will run on top of them, like Uber. How they interplay with it all is another dimension too. Tesla has fired the first shot here by restricting usage of non-Tesla car pooling services. It is a worrying thought to think that buying a BMW might mean I'm locked into only renting out my car through Apple-approved car riding services (and while I can't see Apple creating their own car pooling service, never say never). Tesla seems to be the only player doing the entire stack from top to bottom. Very reminiscent of early Apple.
- hanief 10y agoWhether Apple pursue the hardware route remains to be seen. They only changed their strategy, probably to develop the core self-driving technology first then worry about the design of the car later.
- petra 10y ago>> Are cars going to be (even more) commoditised Self driving cars as a service are much better deal for the consumer. And they'll be more commoditized[1], same as taxis are, from the consumer perspective. On the other hand, building the car with the highest reliability , and the lowest cost of operation , is a hard challenge. But: if electric cars are going to win, cars may become mostly batteries on wheels, so a lot of power will go to the battery companies, maybe even to the point they'll build the cars(like Samsung is working on). And about Tesla: a lot of it's value is about brand. cars as a service kill branding(if everybody transports with a Tesla,it's nothing special) . Maybe that's one reason why they don't want their vehicle as a service. [1]One thing i'm curious about : is taxi sharing realistic in a world of self-driven cars ? one guess: to make it viable, someone would have to build cars that are both shareable, but offer privacy for each of the passengers. And actually, this doesn't require self-driving to offer great value, so i wonder why aren't we seeing work on this?
- finstell 10y agoEverybody is rushing to develop their own self-driving car, then they change their minds in various ways, then team members change who they work for, some of them quit and start their own company, some fail, some got acquihired. They give deadlines and cannot meet them. Everyone is dying to be first in the market or something like it. Feels there is so much greed. I don't get it, what's the big fuss, why must everyone hurry? Can't they be just calm and progress in a sensible manner. I don't expect this thing to turn out to be winner takes it all. Automative industry is much like a close knit society where they depend on similar resources. It's not exactly the same as posh start up culture.
- emdowling 10y agoSimple: everyone is looking for the next big platform. The smartphone revolution came by surprise to most and it has taken years for companies to catch up. Everyone is racing because they don't want to be caught with their pants down again.
- dx034 10y agoExactly that. If one company (especially one with high production capacity) would now release a fully functional self driving car, they could dominate the car market for the next decade. Orders for trucks, delivery vehicles, uber etc would alone max out production for several years. If done by a major player (e.g. Toyota, GM, VW), they could probably get legislation in some states changed quickly if they can proof that their system is safe. Catching up isn't easy, you won't be able to just reverse engineer it.
- netsharc 10y agoSo if Google has this tech, isn't this move basically saying "Hey boys, I've got this sexy stuff. Who's going to be the highest bidder?". Is there still a no politics policy on HN? -- POLITICS BELOW-- Also it'd be interesting to see in the Age of Trump if Google would be red-taped if tries to sell the tech overseas, Trump would probably solicit bribes from the Detroit people to put up such a law.
- 10y ago
- helb 10y ago"Google’s self-driving car team preparing to spin out from Alphabet’s X" [http://www.recode.net/2016/12/7/13875208/google-x-self-driving-spinout-alphabet http://www.recode.net/2016/12/7/13875208/google-x-self-drivi...] on HN yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13155600 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13155600
- Tepix 10y agoThis decision will be beneficial for the relationship between Google and the car manufacturers. Google will no longer be a competitor. Whether or not there will be a first mover advantage remains to be seen. It certainly feels as if Tesla has such an advantage for the electric car market with the huge amount of pre-orders placed for the Model ≡.
- devoply 10y agoAll these side projects are just to keep certain developers busy until Goog figures out what to do with them. There was never any intention of making a viable car. Just R&D to figure out what can be done that would then be applied to Goog's ad business.
- RealityVoid 10y agoI just want to mention that I think Google's partnership with Fiat-Chrysler is badly picked. The engineering of FCA is unimpressive and their process pretty much kills innovation within their company. I may be wrong but I see FCA surfing the google hype train.
- tyingq 10y agoPerhaps that's on purpose. If they partnered with an automaker known for great engineering, they might butt heads with their counterparts.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoI was starting to get the feeling, looking at Google's lidar-on-the-roof design, that they were getting a bit obsolete before even making it to market, having suffered from the curse of being first and having to build on older tech.
- goatslacker 10y agoThis was known and expected.
- andrewclunn 10y agoSee, "Everything other than the highway is really hard, and Tesla already beat us all to market there."
- ceejay 10y agoMy guess is existing auto (and other) manufacturers have all but locked up world's supply chain of raw materials necessary to make it feasible to manufacture automobiles at large enough scale. If I were Google (if they seriously want to consider getting into manufacturing their own products) I would look into starting a chain of junk yards and refineries.
- azernik 10y agoIt's just a very capital-intensive business with long turnaround times on new hardware designs. It would take not only a lot of investment, but also a large delay on Google's part to get their own car out the door.
- kpil 10y agoIt's also requires a lot of know-how, that takes long time to build up. Building electrical cars removes some of the difference because the traditional drive train is a large chunk of engineering. (Hint, China can't design good engines yet, so they are buying companies with people that do.) If I remember correctly ABB patched together a electric drive train technology demo car 20+ years ago including a drive by wire system with electric steering and brakes. They probably mostly did it to show off their high voltage pmm controllers.
- baybal2 10y agoDeath by pivot
- lambdadmitry 10y agoSlightly off-topic, but: > While Google may be taking its pedal off the gas for self-driving vehicles Is it considered OK to include obvious puns like that in a seemingly serious publication?
- dagw 10y agoIt would have been preferable with a better pun, but adding a touch of levity to otherwise dry topics in serious publications is always welcome.
- Ensorceled 10y agoYes. Even The Gray Lady includes jokes and puns in their headlines all the time.
- greglindahl 10y agoThe Economist stuffs everything full of puns.
- pvsukale3 10y agoYou know what would be cool ? Deepmind working with Tesla , with their best engineers on this team.
- retox 10y agoThey realised they would actually have to provide customer support and that they couldn't quietly ditch a car after 18 months.
- mikebay 10y agoI would never buy Google's any products. Haha, never ever.
- lstroud 10y agoI hope this means that the didn't feel they had the legal expertise to get through the regulatory controls. Hopefully this is not related to legal issues around responsibility for accidents, insurance, etc.
- CM30 10y agoI don't think this is all that surprising to be honest. Google is (by and large) a software development and services company, not a car manufacturer. If they make their own autonomous vehicles, that means they then have to handle everything from safety testing to customer support and sales in addition to the self driving car technology itself. By working with existing car manufacturers, they can focus on their part of the deal (the technology) and let someone who knows about designing, building and selling cars do the rest of the job.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- baggachipz 10y agoYes, perhaps, but the counter to this is that they could "benefit from the closed system of vertical integration" that seems to be all the rage these days. I could envision a scenario where they partner with existing manufacturers for a couple years, then "courageously" break off and produce their own vehicle in order to "control the process".
- jerf 10y agoThat would be one hell of an ecosystem to bootstrap, even starting with a partnership with an existing company, even for Google. Building "a" car isn't that hard. Building a car that conforms with all regulations, has had all the testing done on it, can be manufactured at any useful scale, and, oh, also is something that people want to buy, is not a problem that should be underestimated. (Yes, props to Tesla. They did it. Well... mostly, at least, but it's at least a reasonable guess they're on a success trajectory. It's still a hard problem.) It would probably be easier for Google to manufacture their own computing hardware from scratch, and as far as I know, they don't do that. Yes, they get it customized because they are a big customer, and they've at least dabbled in phone hardware, but even that wasn't "from scratch". I've got a 2013 Nexus tablet, and it's got all sorts of things in it that aren't from Google. As big as Google may be, they are not infinitely big, and they have the paradoxical problem of being too successful to take on every little business. Large profitable businesses can't economically afford to take on new businesses that are significantly less profitable than their current businesses, because the rational business decision then is to reallocate the resources being given to the unprofitable sub-business and give them to the profitable sub-business to make more profits. [1] The car industry is very hit-driven due to the need to sell enough cars to overcome massive fixed costs, but even at in their most profitable years I'm not sure the car companies came even close to Google's profitability. I'm not taking the time to look that claim up, because I'm sure that even if they did, they never did it year after year after year the way Google has. [1] Obviously I'm simplifying a complex thing here. I understand that's a complicated topic, but details would be an unimportant-to-my-point waste of time for all.
- slackoverflower 10y agoSo many leeway for Tesla. Uber's only hope for beating Tesla's car sharing feature was working with Google. Uber is not even profitable yet, they can't invest in this category yet. Tesla going to steal the show, already Apple-like cult forming around it.
- dagw 10y agoUber's only hope for beating Tesla's car sharing feature was working with Google. How do you figure? Uber is currently working with Volvo on autonomous cars, and when it comes to producing safe, reliable cars that people want, in volume, I'd personally bet on Volvo over Google.
- emcq 10y agoUber bought Otto, an autonomous vehicle startup that was created by many of the Google X car folks. I think Uber is doing fine.
- cpncrunch 10y agoDuplicate. Earlier submission here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13165111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13165111 Also, the title is incorrect.
- dang 10y agoThanks, we've updated the title to what the article says.
- blizkreeg 10y agoI've been thinking of spending some time on an idea for a personal transport vehicle. I can imagine the safety and testing regulations being onerous and everything else that goes with making and selling any form of automobiles not for the faint of heart. Seeing as how giant cos like Apple and Google are exiting the "making" space of vehicles, is it crazy to even toy with an idea of building a vehicle that moves people?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoPresumably you'd want to take your idea to a company that values it, and has experience in the safety and testing part. Tesla is not that big, and other smaller car makers have entered the field. It's ludicrous to assume Google doesn't have the power to enter the car market if it wants to, it's influence over government is legendary. It could buy off the regulatory issues, at this point. If Google isn't entering the car market, it's because Google doesn't want to enter the car market. Likely because it's not a high margin industry.
- athenot 10y agoEven Elon Musk admitted it was crazy to take on cars. I suppose it's one of those industries that looks simple from the outside because we're so familiar with the user side, but the manufacturing of which is surprisingly complex.
- blahfuk 10y agoAs someone who's worked for one of the big 3, the supply chain and logistics is mind-boggling. Not to mention what it takes to create factories that can put out vehicles at the rate of the big guys. I don't think Google or any other software company could compete without completely retooling their entire company. It's not something you can do as a side project.
- vxNsr 10y agoTo add to this: when GM tried to copy the Toyota model it took them 20 years and they still went bankrupt.... And now Tesla is using the factory that was created for that original purpose.
- batmansmk 10y agoWhy do you think Google want this information to be out? A - Because they are lagging behind and don't want to look like they played and lost. B - To seek partnerships through Techcrunch. C - They don't want a non-working B2C product, but sell a B2B one instead, because they doubt their capacity of making it happen alone.
- frik 10y agoWow. But they probably try to achieve the same strategy as with Android. It could work out very well. Sadly it seems in contrary to Android it won't be open source.
- nickgrosvenor 10y agoSo Google's ad revenue business subsidized the education of thousands of people who took their newly acquired knowledge of autonomous vehicles to the big car companies. Aside from the Ad business Google is more like Stanford than any actual business.
- stuckagain 10y agoThe people who left from Google's self-driving car division walked in the door as the world's leading experts on the subject. I'm not sure you can say that they learned everything from Google.
- spdionis 10y agoConsider it funding general research then. Same result.
- yalogin 10y agoThis has to be considered a failure on some grounds at least. Why haven't they made an acquisition to bolster their shortcomings? They bought boston dynamics which failed. I am guessing they just did not see the ROI in getting into car manufacturing. Instead they see themselves as an "Android for self driving cars" company there by building their systems/software for cars, drones, etc.
- novigodd 10y agoDoes anyone seriously believe that seld-driving cars are only a few years away? So far I have only seen them working in nicely controlled environments (American suburbs or highways, nice weather, clear road markings, etc). And even then they drive slowly and awkwardly. How will they handle the narrow roads in British towns, the unwritten right-of-way rules on Swiss mountain roads, the scooter avalanches of Vietnamese cities, the pot hole riddled streets of Russian cities, etc? I think this is just an other case of Silicon Valley folks not realizing what's outside of their bubble.
- greglindahl 10y agoSilicon Valley has plenty of fog, narrow and winding mountain roads, darkness, bad road markings, etc.
- novigodd 10y agoTrust me they are nothing compared to the poor road conditions, lunatic drivers or dangerous weather you'll find in the rest of the world or even the USA.
- dispose13432 10y agoMakes sense. I don't think Google ever (OK, in the past couple of years) really intended for self-driving cars to happen, or expected self-driving cars to happen (within a few decades). What it was (and what Project X seems to be these days), was a great way to attract talent. "Wanna work in a company which makes self driving cars, internet balloons, 20% time, and robots" sounds way cooler than "Wanna work in Doubleclick v.2"
- jklinger410 10y ago>I don't think Google ever (OK, in the past couple of years) really intended for self-driving cars to happen, or expected self-driving cars to happen (within a few decades). Self-driving cars will roll-out to select markets within the next couple of years. Google just doesn't want to manufacture the vehicles.
- xpac 10y agoHow does this news fit with this piece? "Waymo: Google’s Self-Driving Car Company Is Finally Here" https://www.wired.com/2016/12/google-self-driving-car-waymo/?mbid=social_twitter https://www.wired.com/2016/12/google-self-driving-car-waymo/... Sounds to me like two fundamentally different ways?
- wrsh07 10y agoThe update to this article is more or less here: https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/13/googles-self-driving-car-unit-spins-out-as-waymo/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/13/googles-self-driving-car-u...
- seccess 10y agoMmmmmmm maybe not, this just went public: http://waymo.com/ http://waymo.com/
- dang 10y agoThread on the HN front page right now: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13168888 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13168888.
- notatoad 10y agotheir tagline is "we're building a safer driver" not "we're building a safer car". doesn't seem to contradict the techcrunch report.
- radiorental 10y agoThe impression I get from the limited information on waymo is that their prototype is still just that. A test bed for a platform that real car manufacturers can implement in their vehicle line-ups. I believe that's why you don't see controls in the prototype. It's unnecessary engineering R&D for what they are really focused on. The R&D is prohibitively expensive and outside of the capabilities for many car makers. I see Google and Apple selling to the Mazda's & Nissan's of the world. They focus on what they do well, Google works on the SDC backend. And they get to learn more about us, where we go, who we meet, what we say.
- dweekly 10y agohttp://waymo.com/ http://waymo.com/ - sure doesn't look shelved.