5 ms·
I think it's already been fairly well understood by a subset of physicists that F&P probably had demonstrated a legitimate, previously unexplained phenomenon an
by dekhn 10y ago
I think it's already been fairly well understood by a subset of physicists that F&P probably had demonstrated a legitimate, previously unexplained phenomenon and that the primary mistake was in overinterpreting the results and allowing the U's PR department run too far with it.
What I find interesting is that when confronted with that idea, many physcists just get stuck at the original claims and don't understand that there is likely a novel phenomenon of some sort, deserving of study.
- bdrool 10y agoWell said. As far as I could see the whole thing was a huge scandal and black eye on the scientific community. The way Robert Park of the American Physical Society acted was particularly bad (he outright accused scientists of fraud without any evidence to back it up). Much of it probably came from competition for funding, as quite a few people got their feathers ruffled once the Dept. of Energy announced it would put funding into Cold Fusion research, thus diverting it from their own projects. Without absolving them of any responsibility for overstating their claims (which they absolutely should shoulder), it is truly a shame Pons & Fleischmann's findings could not be processed more rationally than they were at the time.
- mysterypie 10y agoI was struck by the viciousness of attacks against Fleischmann and Pons in the months after their cold fusion announcement. A few physicists even went out of their way to call them frauds and charlatans -- it wasn't enough to say that Fleischmann and Pons were mistaken. As if two quiet, humble, respected PhD's in electrochemistry were crackpots orchestrating some kind of scam. I feel sorry for the decades of shaming they had to endure (Fleischmann died 4 years ago; Pons is still alive). The attitude was that if their claims weren't 100% right and 100% reproducible, they're scum. When some of the results were turning out to be negative, it seemed that almost no physicist was willing to say, hey wait a minute, it's not cold fusion but maybe there's a new interesting unknown phenomenon there.
- myowncrapulence 10y agoThe attitude was that if their claims weren't 100% right and 100% reproducible, they're scum. You're describing every internet forum I've ever encountered.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoNo, that's only true when claiming something that is not compatible with the currently prevailing social/political narrative. If you're backing up the current narrative you're free to spew falsehoods. If you're studying something nobody else cares about then it's probably wise to at least try and stick to the facts.
- wallace_f 10y agoTo respectfully offer a different point of view, I have never found an internet forum that requires the veracity of claims be held to that level of scrutiny. In fact, I've been downvoted and ridiculed for things like requesting a source be given, or quoting a mainstream textbook (which disagreed with a user. HN is better than most imho, but most internet forums seem to be characterized by groupthink rather than vehement adherence to an ability to verify the truth of what one is claiming. I'd rather be in the company of the latter, even if they do ridicule you if your claims are not verifiable.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoI can think of one such forum, which deals with issues around audio and compression. From observing that I'd suggest it's very hard to maintain both friendliness and an adherence to the scientific method, simply because there is an endless number of people who have no understanding of or respect for what you're trying to do. They'll interpret friendly corrections as rudeness, and won't actually stop making wild unsubstantiated claims until you escalate to genuine abrupt rudeness and/or banning. Also, they'd probably be accused of "groupthink" for trying to maintain that objectivity by those who disagree with the conclusions. Humans are hard to deal with.
- amelius 10y ago
- tzs 10y agoIn 1993, physicist David Goodstein of Caltech wrote a look back at the whole cold fusion thing, and how it had become socially/politically unacceptable to do work in that area, right when some well respected experimenters were finally starting to get some serious signs that something interesting and new was going. Here are the last two paragraphs of the article: > Recently, I told this story in a Philosophy course we teach at Caltech called "Ethics of Research." The first question, when I finished my tale, was, do I believe in Cold Fusion? The answer is, no. Certainly, I believe quite firmly the theoretical arguments that say Cold Fusion is impossible. On the other hand, however, I believe equally firmly in the integrity and competence of Franco Scaramuzzi and his group of co-workers at Frascati. I was disturbed when I saw that Franco had gotten caught in the web of science-by-news conference in April 1989 (although I was truly pleased that he finally got the long overdue recognition his agency ENEA owed him), and I was even more distressed when I learned that Franco and his group had observed excess heat (the "bad kind" of Cold Fusion). However, I have looked at their cells, and looked at their data, and it's all pretty impressive. The Japanese experiment showing that heat nearly always results when x is greater than 0.85 looks even more impressive on paper. It seems a particularly elegant, well designed experiment, at least to the untutored eye of a physicist (what do I know about electrochemistry?) What all these experiments really need is critical examination by accomplished rivals intent on proving them wrong. That is part of the normal functioning of science. Unfortunately, in this area, science is not functioning normally. There is nobody out there listening. > I suppose that, if nuclear fusion really does take place whenever x is greater than 0.85 in palladium, the world of conventional science will eventually be forced to take notice. If not, then the whole story I have told you is nothing but a curious footnote to a bizarre and ugly episode in the history of science. Either way, I think the story illuminates the inner dynamics of the scientific enterprise in a way that few other stories have done. For that reason alone, it may be worth telling. The whole article is here: http://www.its.caltech.edu/~dg/fusion_art.html http://www.its.caltech.edu/~dg/fusion_art.html
- grzm 10y agoThanks for linking the article, and in particular for quoting the relevant paragraph. Taking that step back and giving people the the benefit of the doubt that they're working in good faith while at the same time recognizing the proper functioning of science is so important.
- phkahler 10y ago>> What I find interesting is that when confronted with that idea, many physcists just get stuck at the original claims and don't understand that there is likely a novel phenomenon of some sort, deserving of study. I found the physicist reaction "it can't be nuclear, it has to be chemistry" a bit disturbing. The cell was said to contain all of 4 elements, and none of the physicists were offering an explanation for what chemical reaction the two chemists were missing.