9 ms·
Andrew Wiles: what does it feel like to do maths?
- daxfohl 10y agoAny other big proofs / theorems that came seemingly out of nowhere? Yitang Zhang's bounded prime gaps comes to mind. And of course that physics thing from that Swiss patent clerk guy, can't remember his name offhand.
- hiddencost 10y agoGrigori Perlman dropped a proof of the Poincaré conjecture with little warning.
- typon 10y agoHottest mixtape of all time
- jseliger 10y agoYes. And Masha Gessen wrote an excellent book called Perfect Rigor about the proof and the man: https://jakeseliger.com/2016/11/29/perfect-rigor-a-genius-and-the-mathematical-breakthrough-of-the-century-masha-gessen https://jakeseliger.com/2016/11/29/perfect-rigor-a-genius-an.... Highly recommended.
- daxfohl 10y agoGranted he was one of the world's best two or three mathematicians at the time.
- willis77 10y ago> that physics thing from that Swiss patent clerk guy I think you're thinking of Carl deGrasse Feynman.
- daxfohl 10y agoSphere packing in dim 8 and 24 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryna_Viazovska https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryna_Viazovska) and the "Set" game limit (https://www.quantamagazine.org/20160531-set-proof-stuns-mathematicians/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/20160531-set-proof-stuns-math...) are two more recent examples.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoThe post schows a good example of someone who achieved mastery in his field of interest and solved a really hard problem. The traits/habits he describes remember me of the lessons I learned from the book Mastery by Robert Green. Just one line from a short summary [1]: >> Desire, patience, persistence, and confidence end up playing a much larger role in success than sheer reasoning powers. [1] https://sivers.org/book/Mastery2 https://sivers.org/book/Mastery2
- Numberwang 10y agoDo you recommend reading the full book or the summary?
- NumberCruncher 10y agoI like the works of Robert Green so my biased opition is that the book is worth reading. He uses a lot of different examples for describing a principle and generally one or two of them get stuck in my mind making easier to remember the principles. It is kind of "learning by example". His books are also easy to read for me despite of having English as my third language.
- acidbaseextract 10y agoI highly recommend the full book. Robert Greene is killer at providing examples, proving his points then boiling down those examples into action you can take. The persuasive force of hearing the patterns of mastery in the lives of people we all admire, and seeing the variations on the theme that can apply to our own lives, is lost in a summary. Also the audiobook is excellently read, if you're into that sort of thing.
- jaseemabid 10y agoFor those who don't know, Andrew Wiles proved Fermat's last theorem.
- duncanawoods 10y agoIts well worth watching one of the best documentaries ever made: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x223gx8_bbc-horizon-1996-fermat-s-last-theorem_shortfilms http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x223gx8_bbc-horizon-1996-fe... He explains the experience of a genuine Eureka moment after herculean effort and false dawns and its incredibly moving. I also enjoy when the other mathematicians are asked to explain modular forms... and struggle a little :)
- michael_nielsen 10y agoThe first two minutes are absolutely extraordinary, both for the insight, and for the emotion revealed.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- stuxnet79 10y agoOh wow it's Michael Nielsen. Your neural network book helped me get through the last year of undergrad. Thanks!
- raitom 10y agoDonut. Bridge. Modular Form.
- narutouzumaki 10y agoI just watched, first the first two minutes and then the whole thing. Just... beautiful. Makes you want to get up and actually put effort into something, whatever that might be!
- razakel 10y ago>I just watched, first the first two minutes and then the whole thing. Just... beautiful. Makes you want to get up and actually put effort into something, whatever that might be! The look in his eyes when he says "nothing I'll ever do will be as important" is simply inspiring.
- cyberfunk 10y agoThis was so so encouraging and reminded me of why I started this math thing in the first place. This post made me better today, because it reminded me it's okay to be stuck. You just have to keep going.
- Jun8 10y ago"What I fight against most in some sense, [when talking to the public,] is the kind of message, for example as put out by the film Good Will Hunting, that there is something you're born with and either you have it or you don't. That's really not the experience of mathematicians. We all find it difficult, it's not that we're any different from someone who struggles with maths problems in third grade. It's really the same process. We're just prepared to handle that struggle on a much larger scale and we've built up resistance to those setbacks." I disagree. I understand the purpose of this statement, i.e. not to discourage people, etc. but clearly there are differences between Terry Tao, Wiles, Feynman, and many others and your typical PhD in these fields. This is like saying anyone can become Phelps with practice (although pinpointing his unique advantages can be complicated: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-makes-michael-phelps-so-good1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-makes-michae...). Not everybody can be above average! And of course, there are the rare cases such as Ramanujan. I think a better explanation is the one that Stephen gives in On Writing: "I don’t believe writers can be made, either by circumstances or by selfwill (although I did believe those things once). The equipment comes with the original package. Yet it is by no means unusual equipment; I believe large numbers of people have at least some talent as writers and storytellers, and that those talents can be strengthened and sharpened."
- Isamu 10y agoI disagree with your disagreement. When people say that there is not so much something special about themselves but that the work they put in enabled their success, they are not claiming the reverse is true: that hard work results in success. They are saying that success is the result of hard work. Not that hard work results in success.
- metaphorm 10y agoI'm not clear what distinction you're making. It's a bit of a truism (to the point of it being a cliche) for a successful person to say "I'm successful because I worked hard." Of course that isn't an identical statement with "hard work results in success." Nor should anyone with a fluent grasp of language conflate the two statements. So what are you disagreeing with, really? That's what I'm not clear about. Successful people, for diplomatic reasons, emphasize their work ethic instead of their talent. Certainly they have both. Did anyone claim differently?
- digler999 10y agoWhat I'd like to know is what his routine is like. I think I recall watching the FLT documentary and he talks about retreating to his home office for hours at a time where he was not to be interrupted. I wonder how he or other mathematicians organize their time and track their progress. For most of my life I've struggled with procrastination, time management issues, and concentration problems. I feel like the only time I can concentrate is after 10pm, for a narrow window of an hour or 2 before I go to sleep. I'd guess mathematicians must not suffer from that problem or have learned to overcome it to be able to wrangle their minds around abstract mathematical constructs.
- treehau5 10y agoIf you are like me -- It's something you have to chip away at slowly, because your brain is probably so used to having sudden, increased rushes of pleasurable activities -- whether that's habitually checking HN, facebook, reddit or whatever quickly, or reading an interesting topic or checking out an interesting book -- yes all these things are great, but if they aren't directly, tangibly helping you towards achieving your goals, however insightful or educational they might be, you have to be able to restrain. You can actually learn to concentrate again. It will take time and work, just like anything else in life. If you want to get in shape and start running, you don't start running 3 miles right out of the gate, no you start with maybe one mile, where you split between jogging and walking. Then you jog a full mile, then run a mile, then 1.5, etc. Same with being able to intently concentrate for long periods of time -- you have to learn how to do it. How? By trying to concentrate intently on smaller, tangible things. The better you get at it, the more you will be able to do it. That's why I like things like the pomodoro timers. On my good days, I am able to just sit down and blaze through a couple of pomodoros and not even notice the timer went off long ago. Most important thing I have found is setting tangible, short, achievable goals that all point to a larger goal, and then setting aside a reward. We are so used to having our reward now, now, now, but we need to retrain our minds that the reward comes after. There are more aspects to procrastination I have found -- fear of failure, fear of success, fixed mindset, all these concepts are great, but at the end of the day, in my opinion, I treat my brain like it is a muscle, and you can train it to do things just like anything else in life.
- klt0825 10y ago"Do you think maths is discovered or invented? To tell you the truth, I don't think I know a mathematician who doesn't think that it's discovered." Anyone else struck by this? It has really never occurred to before that I've always assumed that we were simply discovering math versus creating it.
- kxyvr 10y agoWell, I suppose it's a philosophical thing, but I don't subscribe to the discover point of view. However, to be clear, I don't think there's anything wrong with this viewpoint. For me, math is a set of rules that we know to be consistent. Based on these rules, we put together new constructions that obey this framework. When I prove a theorem, I don't really internalize it as discovering something that was already there, but as putting together a new creation based on a set of tools that I already have. As the author of the result, I have the flexibility to be as creative as I want in how I prove the result and that creativity has an affect on how people view and internalize the theorem. I mean, if someone writes a narrative story we could say that the story was always there and that they just discovered it in a sea of words. Again, there's nothing wrong with that point of view, but I prefer to say that the person created the story.
- arctangent 10y agoOpinion isn't as clear cut as Wiles makes out. There are definitely opposing viewpoints. This would be a good place to start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_of_mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_of_mathematics
- psychometry 10y agoGödel would have probably answered the opposite way, as would I think many logicians.
- boomzilla 10y agoSo are logic frameworks discovered or invented? Are true/false values discovered or invented? I think the question whether math is discovered or invented is silly. It is both.
- ktRolster 10y agoInterestingly, I never thought of math as an art, but reading this quote in the article makes sense: Well, mathematicians are not that philosophical. (Laughter) We're artists, we just enjoy it and we leave it.
- reefwalkcuts 10y agoI never expected this interview to be motivational.
- socmag 10y agoI loved the section on "What do you do when you get stuck?" Then you have to stop, let your mind relax a bit and then come back to it. Somehow your subconscious is making connections and you start again, maybe the next afternoon, the next day, the next week even and sometimes it just comes back. Sometimes I put something down for a few months, I come back and it's obvious. I can't explain why. But you have to have the faith that that will come back. I'm not a mathematician, but yup, I think that's true in so many ways. The number of times I just take a break, come back..."Oh I know!".
- ibejoeb 10y agoThat's the part that stood out to me, too. It's the interval between hyperproductivity and just scraping by... It took me a long time to understand my own process: that there is a pattern, and how to take advantage of the high and cope with the low.
- spynxic 10y ago..Now what you have to handle when you start doing mathematics as an older child or as an adult is accepting this state of being stuck. People don't get used to that. Some people find this very stressful. Even people who are very good at mathematics sometimes find this hard to get used to and they feel that's where they're failing. But it isn't: it's part of the process and you have to accept [and] learn to enjoy that process. Yes, you don't understand [something at the moment] but you have faith that over time you will understand — you have to go through this. Well then.. found my confidence booster for 2017. Thanks!
- spynxic 10y agoRegarding the last question, "Do you think maths is discovered or invented?" Couldn't math be considered both? A process of invention as far as deciding which axioms to assume and a process of discovery when finding the repercussions of those assumed axioms
- j1vms 10y ago> A process of invention as far as deciding which axioms to assume (...) Possibly, but I think what mathematicians find is that they end up having little choice about what sets of axioms (when taken together) are useful, fertile, and/or interesting and which aren't - when studying various mathematical systems. Which leads us to consider that trip down to what those essential various groupings of axioms to once again feel more like discovery than invention. Further, abstract math tries to shave concepts down to only what is logically essential. Arriving at what's left at that point is more akin to discovering a rare diamond or gold nugget buried deep beneath the surface, and inherent to the basic "construction" of the universe (philosophically, that which might exist beyond/before/after/without us).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- LeicesterCity 10y agoThis makes me wish I became a mathematician. Anyone know of modern day self-taught mathematicians that contributed to research? I'd like to learn maths on my own, but if there is no possibility of research contribution, then I guess my time would be better spent with something else.
- tpudlik 10y agoVery few self-taught people contributed to research in the 20th century. I can't speak with authority about mathematics, but in my own field (physics) the only self-taught researchers I can think of were people trained in allied fields (math, chemistry) who ran into physics problems in the course of work in their own discipline. The root cause, I suppose, is that it takes much less time and effort to just get a PhD than to make an original research contribution, so most people get credentialed along the way. Academic programs also immerse you in current research work, making it possible to figure out where you could make contributions in the first place.
- kriro 10y agoFascinating short interview. I wish they would have asked him what he thinks of theorem provers and if he maybe uses them in his workflow in some way.