7 ms·
Companies have been discussing "checkout-less" stores since forever, but nobody has been brave enough to do it due to the perceived threat of shoplifting. And
by Someone1234 10y ago
Companies have been discussing "checkout-less" stores since forever, but nobody has been brave enough to do it due to the perceived threat of shoplifting.
And while shoplifting is a legitimate threat, are non-shoplifters going to be turned into shoplifters without a checkout? Are normal shoplifters stopped by checkouts? These are the core questions, and until it is tested nobody will know for sure.
Target is getting awfully close to this. With their Cartwheel app you're meant to scan all your items as you shop (so it auto-applies coupons and discounts); but they haven't taken it to the next logical step and allowed you to provide your Cartwheel output at the checkout for checking out.
I will say that the way Target has implemented smartphone barcode scanning makes me think that there might be a future in all this. It is extremely painless, they just need to stop kicking you out of the scan screen when it finds a discount (i.e. it doesn't kick you out if no discount is found, but does when a discount IS found, that's problematic for efficiency reasons).
- bbrks 10y agoIn the UK, Tesco have been running a 'Scan as you Shop'[0] thing for a couple of years now. Customers pick up a scanner as they enter, scan their items as they go into their cart, and they have special checkouts which read your scanner. There's a random chance that your scanner will be audited by a human against the contents of your shopping cart. Usually the first time you use it, then it backs off. [0] http://www.tesco.com/scan-as-you-shop/ http://www.tesco.com/scan-as-you-shop/
- xd1936 10y agoSam's Club has been doing similar for the last year[0], as well. They already have a built-in "check your receipt at the door" flow that customers are used to, so it wasn't that hard to offer an electronic tweak to the existing system. [0] http://www.samsclub.com/sams/pagedetails/content.jsp?pageName=scan-and-go http://www.samsclub.com/sams/pagedetails/content.jsp?pageNam...
- geekamongus 10y agoI used this for the first time two days ago. I was pleasantly surprised, and it felt really awesome --almost to a point of guilt-- skipping the checkout lines. However, once I reached the exit where the man was inspecting receipts, things screeched to a halt. I showed him the bar code on my phone, and he looked at it, exclaiming, "Oh no, Scan and Go. You used Scan and Go." He then turned to find a powered-off scanning device that he couldn't get to start up, as he muttered, "I wish they'd never started that." I replied, "As a customer, I love it." He had to call over a manager, who used her scanner to scan my barcode, blindly scroll through my purchased items list to get to the green button, and declared me good to go. Meanwhile, I had held up all the people trying to exit behind me. It was still faster than checking out, but hopefully they get proper training for their employees implemented.
- draw_down 10y agoSounds great if it's not as unbelievably user-hostile as the self checkout machines. Those things are just total crap, every one I've ever tried.
- raverbashing 10y agoOnce I got the hang of it, I've had almost zero problems with self-checkout machines It's usually one of two things: a purchase that must be approved (either alcohol or some medicine) or scanning the single item barcode of a multi-item
- ambicapter 10y agoI always either get erroneously told to put item in the bag, or have to take an item out of the bag because for some reason it shouldn't be there according to the register.
- CmdrSprinkles 10y agoThe secret is to hate the environment and just use the plastic/paper that is already there. For me: When I am doing my weekly food shopping, I just use plastic. When I am grabbing something I forgot or picking up beer or something during the week, I just leave everything in the area, pay, and then bag with my reusables after the fact. These days I only need human interaction when I buy booze, and that consists of a cashier eyeballing me and approving it.
- sqeaky 10y agoI think there are bigger problems, like how they implicitly assume everyone is a thief and are will to damage usability for everyone because that assumption. That stupid scale isn't going to stop any shoplifter, but it does inconvenience me every time. EDIt - Grammar.
- draw_down 10y agoRight. They're user-hostile.
- jblok 10y agoWaitrose have had the exact same thing for many years now.
- leesalminen 10y agoStop & Shop in the NE US released this in ~2006
- sqeaky 10y agoWhere is that at? I am Omaha and google maps did not show a "Stop & Shop".
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's a grocer in the Northeast.
- leesalminen 10y agoGood one :). NE = North East, not Nebraska in this instance though I can see the confusion.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coleca 10y agoI worked on that project (Shopping Buddy) and a few later iterations of it. This was before the iPad, we had these huge IBM super rugged tablets on the carriages. We used something like Zigbee to triangulate the precise location of the carriage in the aisle, so we could tell whether the cart was at the beginning, middle or end of aisle 5 or aisle 6 and target ads appropriate for where you were. There was a small scanner for you to scan your groceries as you went. It was ridiculously expensive to outfit one store w/the tech so we ended up with a simpler version using Motorola MC70 handheld scanner guns and ditched the exact triangulation and instead went to more generic stuff where we would just check which AP you were connected to so we would know which third of the store you were on (produce, frozen foods, or middle of the store). That system then got ported to iOS and Android so you could use your phone instead of the scanner. The original version despite its issues was pretty advanced for the time (mid 2000s). They still have the mobile / MC70 version rolled out to the entire chain now, it's very successful from what I hear.
- BjoernKW 10y agoTesco also has pushed self scanning tills for years now. However, the number of employees working at the cash register is still the same because those scanners sometimes do not work and most importantly their user experience is deplorable. So, you frequently have to ask someone for help (and I'm in my mid-thirties and very tech-savvy. I can only imagine how someone twice my age would feel when using these scanners).
- dingaling 10y ago> However, the number of employees working at the cash register is still the same Actually the ratio of staff:active-self-checkout machines is planned to reduce in each new deployment as customers become accustomed to the machines. Starts around 1:2 and usually sits around 1:4 with a target of 1:8 or even 1:12 at quiet times. That's definitely a reduction in cashiers since the machines displace existing check-out lines & registers. Source: an acquaintance is a manager in a Tesco Superstore.
- robryan 10y agoSimilar at supermarkets in Australia, one staff member could be watching over about 12 self checkouts. They still offer regular registers for people with a lot of stuff and people that don't like self checkout. The machines are good enough now that I almost never get stuck, although some people are a lot more prone to needing staff assistance to complete checkout.
- crottypeter 10y agoTerrible UX is spot-on. I was using one of these just this morning: got all my shopping onto the scale/shelf and was getting ready to pay. The machine asks how many 5p bags I used. So I start packing the stuff into my backpack to find out whether I need a bag. The machine pipes up: "Did you remove something from the scale?" The screen has a full screen modal warning that I have to put the shopping back. I put the things back on the scale and guess that I won't need a bag and I pay using contactless but what if my shopping won't fit in my bag? I understand why we have to "pack" things onto a scale (it makes it much harder to take things without scanning them) but it has to trust you at some point.
- tdeck 10y agoThis exists in the US, too. I saw one at Giant in Pennsylvania when I was home for the holidays.
- Magnets 10y agoTesco started that back in the late 90s and Sainsburys also did it 5+ years ago, then Tesco seems to have had another go at it recently. edit: Safeway was first, in 1997 The Camden store illustrates the progress Safeway has made in other directions too. As part of its customer friendliness, Safeway was the first of the major food multiples to introduce self-scanning, the system it calls Shop & Go. http://www.managementtoday.co.uk/uk-safeway-follows-leader/article/410947 http://www.managementtoday.co.uk/uk-safeway-follows-leader/a...
- camtarn 10y agoOur local store installed them to great fanfare back in the 90s, kept them for about a year, then quietly removed them. I was always very curious as to why: perhaps they didn't get used very much, or perhaps customer satisfaction with them was low.
- djsumdog 10y agoHuh...I had travelled around the UK/Ireland last year and I don't think I saw any of these. Maybe I was hitting the wrong stores, or people were using them and I didn't recognize them.
- SilkRoadie 10y agoIt is typically found in very large stores. I only have only seen this in two Tesco stores.
- 10y ago
- dasboth 10y ago> There's a random chance that your scanner will be audited by a human against the contents of your shopping cart. Usually the first time you use it, then it backs off. I must be really suspicious-looking because I've been subjected to a "random audit" all 5 times I used it. Gave up because with a weekly shop it's quicker to go to an actual checkout than having someone scan all of my items again. The idea's good, but my experience of the execution has been bad.
- erelde 10y agoI'll admit, my first thoughts were "How can I exploit this system? How would I place sensors? What kind of sensors? Pressure plates? Cameras? IR trackers?" etc etc. And I'm no shoplifter, never done that, I just tinker with stuff all the time. It's a kind of occupational psychosis. Same with lockpicks.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoYeah, but ultimately it's pretty easy to steal from a lot of regular stores too, and most people just...don't. Because they're not thieves.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joezydeco 10y agoMy take is that a foil-lined bag will bypass the whole system.
- chris11 10y agoI think that could easily be detected if they wanted to. It sounds like they may be tracking your store movements and what items you pick up, so it would be odd if a shopper carrying items walked out of the store without registering any of the bought items.
- cobookman 10y agoIf the cost of sensors + additional theft is less than the cost of the removed salespersons. Then the system makes business sense.
- csears 10y agoI thought it might be vulnerable to a human DOS-attack, where a flash mob of shoppers wearing similar cloths and/or masks all walk in at the same time, grab items, pass them around, and then all try to leave at once.
- golergka 10y ago> perceived threat of shoplifting If that's the problem, couldn't these companies just test it? I mean, even if all the items in the single pilot store were stolen, would it really be such a big cost for Wallmart R&D department to have exact empiric knowledge as opposed to "perceived threat"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jdmichal 10y agoI actually read this completely differently with regards to shoplifting. How can you shoplift when you have multitudes of cameras watching your every movement and automatically assigning to you any products you take off the shelf? This is the dream anti-shoplifting system; it's automated loss prevention personnel.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoSo, you're saying your non-member friends have to wait outside if you decide to pop into Go for a few items.
- seren 10y agoIt will flag clients for "suspicious" behavior, compare your face with known shoplifters in the last 10 years, and check if you are on the FBI most wanted list. You'll be arrested before having picked up a single item.
- sqeaky 10y agoWhen it is installed and working it could be part a "The Culture" like utopia. But even if it has an error rate as low as 0.01% and ruins the lives and careers of people because of technical mishaps it can make their lives a dystopic nightmare.
- speps 10y ago> Target is getting awfully close to this. With their Cartwheel app you're meant to scan all your items as you shop (so it auto-applies coupons and discounts); but they haven't taken it to the next logical step and allowed you to provide your Cartwheel output at the checkout for checking out. Tesco in the UK is already doing that. You just finish your shopping by scanning an "end of shopping" barcode, you pay and then you go with your trolley. You sometimes need someone to remove the security tags or check that you're 18+ for alcohol but that's it. However, home delivery is even better in my opinion, it's very common in the UK nowadays. You see those vans everywhere, from nearly all big supermarkets.
- s_q_b 10y agoAmazon has the money to run the studies to prove whether it increases revenue. I suspect it wouldn't be too hard to both detect shoplifting and differentiate it from legitimate purposes using a modern high-end multisensor fusion machine learning system. Better make sure to carefully balance the samples in your training set to avoid confounding variables though, or else your AI is going to get quite racist and sexist very quickly.
- RUG3Y 10y agoEven if they gain more shrink/ loss by having customers scan their own items, the reduction in employee labor is almost certainly worth it.
- mankyd 10y ago> are non-shoplifters going to be turned into shoplifters without a checkout? One could respond that you can never truly shop lift if you follow the rules. First, you have to check in when you enter. Second, they tell you to grab and go. As long as you don't try to be malicious about it, then it's on Amazon to figure out what to charge you for. If they fail to see something, that's on them.
- Spare_account 10y agoPresumably there will be some terms and conditions that require you to examine the receipt for the visit and make good any omissions. I don't suppose it would be impossible for Amazon to protect themselves from this kind of loss.
- amscanne 10y agoIt seems to be that as long as you're malicious (I.e. deliberately hiding items), then that's on them. At least that's what the implied contract is to me. Otherwise it's just a "self checkout" app.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chrischen 10y agoApple does it. You can use the Apple Store app to scan and pay and walk out.
- _pmf_ 10y agoreal (part of the Metro group of retailers) and IKEA do it in Germany (and have been out of the evaluation phase for some years).
- winteriscoming 10y agoThis reminds me of the story about unmanned stores in Sweden https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/kidspost/sweden-opens-first-unmanned-convenience-store/2016/02/29/fa8c87ee-db35-11e5-891a-4ed04f4213e8_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/kidspost/sweden-ope... where you just walk in with a smartphone with a app, buy and checkout all by yourself
- joezydeco 10y agoHere in Chicago the Jewel/Osco chain of grocery stores tried handheld scanners mated with the self-checkout systems about 10 years ago. I lived near one of the test stores. It worked pretty well, but from what I heard the shoplifting rate was a lot higher than the comfort level of the store's executives. There really is no way to check that you've scanned every single thing in a large cart full of goods. They experimented with things like random checks from cashiers, but that just added to the labor and confusion. The project was scrapped a year or two later. RFID could fix that if we're really close to being able to scan a whole cart full of goods in one sweep (which the Amazon project seems to imply). But then you have an issue where every single vendor to your store needs to be inserting compatible tags into the packaging. That adds cost and logistics.
- pimeys 10y ago> RFID could fix that if we're really close to being able to scan a whole cart full of goods in one sweep (which the Amazon project seems to imply). But then you have an issue where every single vendor to your store needs to be inserting compatible tags into the packaging. That adds cost and logistics. I remember seeing this working when I was in university [0]. They just couldn't focus on supermarkets because the tags were too expensive (10-15 cents per tag). [0] http://www.vilant.com/ http://www.vilant.com/
- JPKab 10y agoI own a house in Bentonville, Arkanasas. I now live in Denver, but owning a property in Walmart's company town means I always pay careful attention to retail developments that threaten Walmart. I know a lot about the various retail companies and how effective they are with technology. Anyone that thinks Target is going to do anything effective in this space doesn't understand how god-awful their entire logistics/supply chain is. It's legendarily bad. Amazon is another story. And this particular technology is something that can destroy Walmart, eventually. I'll be watching this very closely, because if I see enough headway being made I'll be selling my house before the disaster hits the market there. Honestly though, groceries and CPG are HARD. I suspect that Amazon has simply thought about cost-savings from having minimal staffing in a store and used it to justify the insane capital costs of an RFID tag on every item and the scanners/camera/compute needed to operate the Go store. What's always so funny to me is how the millennial generation in general has a hugely negative view of Walmart for paying poorly and destroying small businesses, while having a positive view of Amazon. In this case, Amazon will continue to do what it's been doing (destroying businesses) while paying nothing, because it's automating away a huge segment of work. I'm not saying this is a bad thing, but it's definitely going to happen, and like self-driving vehicles, this is going to disrupt society big time.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> What's always so funny to me is how the millennial generation in general has a hugely negative view of Walmart for paying poorly and destroying small businesses, while having a positive view of Amazon. The difference is that while both may offer low prices while destroying small businesses, the customer experience on Amazon is great while the customer experience at Walmart sucks.
- petra 10y ago>>Amazon is another story. And this particular technology is something that can destroy Walmart, eventually. It's a nice innovation, but it does almost nothing with regards to competing on price with Walmart. And with the self checkouts, checking out isn't even that big of a deal. So i don't see how it's going to affect Walmart.
- crooked-v 10y agoIn Apple stores, you can buy anything off a shelf using an app on your smartphone and walk out with it without even needing to talk to an employee. Of course, all the really pricey stuff like watches, phones, and computers is kept in a back room.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI'm surprised people read Amazon Go as shoplifting friendly. My first thought was: wow, and they made it much harder to shoplift. In a regular store you can just tuck an item in your jacket. With this tech, they know when the item left the shelf, that you were standing there, and that it left the store with you. Sure, it's hackable. Everything is hackable. But this actually seems like an anti-shoplifting measure to me. Heck, I could imagine them installing this system in a normally staffed store just to detect shoplifting!