7 ms·
The Thin Gene
- nealabq 10y agoHere's an idea: a site for people with unusual genes, good or bad. They can describe why they're unusual, and in some cases get asked for more details or even for a DNA sample. All voluntary of course. Forums for people with similar conditions, questions about long term affects or attempted remedies. Feed the data to an AI. Maybe monetize with subscriptions to medical researchers.
- ZeroFries 10y agoI feel it would be filled with hypochondriacs and special snowflakes
- anigbrowl 10y agoWho cares? It would still advance DNA research by identifying the prevalence of false positives. Incidentally I'm really sick of comments like yours dismissing other people on the sole basis that they're especially interesting to themselves. For all you know that might be indicative of some subtle mental illness. If you can't comment without denigrating other people then maybe you're the one with the problem.
- ZeroFries 10y agoYour comment seems more denigrating than mine, ironically. How would bad data advance DNA research? Im saying hypochondriacs are not what you'd want when trying to collect accurate medical data. How is this denigrating to those who are interested in themselves?
- aptwebapps 10y agoWouldn't the principle of charity assume that the creators of such a site put some effort in to filtering the data (at either input or output time or both) to make it manageable? If someone posts an idea here is it necessary for them to add a bunch of caveats so we know they've already thought of the obvious things and have answers?
- notheguyouthink 10y agoFwiw, i know what you mean about the typical "HN Comments", but i do think you're being a bit harsh on him/her. I think their comment/concern is valid, and a meaningful point of discussion. It's not overly critical, and there is no tone. Likewise, yours feels (to me) to have far more of a tone, seemingly directed at (but not soley caused by) ZeroFries. Anyway, i can tell you're frustrated at "HN Comments".. so, i just ask that you try to be constructive in these types of replies, or you only contribute to the problem.
- nitrogen 10y ago"Hypochondriac" and "special snowflake" are both heavily judgmental and dismissive terms, at least in my experience. Assuming the comment was expressing genuine concern with no malice, less judgmental language would have been useful.
- notheguyouthink 10y agoFair point
- andrewmcwatters 10y agoCould you not comment on HN like this, please?
- therein 10y agoI had this idea a few years ago.
- mixedCase 10y agoHave you implemented it?
- therein 10y agoI started looking into it but I was busy with something else at the time. I had talked to the mods of /r/nootropics and also the owners of a few domestic suppliers/storefronts and they were definitely very interested. I mean, it is clear that if we are as a community serious about self-experimentation, we have to find a way to consolidate the results of our individual n=1 studies.
- franciscop 10y agoIdeas are worth nothing; the value is in the implementation
- ndonnellan 10y agohttps://epatientfinder.com/ https://epatientfinder.com/ and others connect patients with trials. I don't work there, but I know someone who just left our (EHR) company to join. They're not on the genetic scale (that I know of), but I think it's a great idea to allow opt-in for patients that are curious about potential trials.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoYou just described 23andme.com.
- gwern 10y agoNo. 23andme.com only provides SNP information on the most common few hundred thousand variants (mine has ~600k called), typically those which are present in >=1% of the population. With these sorts of mutations with serious fatal effects, the mutations are, for obvious reasons, present in <<1% of the population. So 23andMe is very uninformative about rare mutations like in OP. (23andMe does provide an exome sequencing service, which might cover OP's mutation, but it would still miss many other problems, and due to its high price of ~$900, has never been popular - at that price point, you might as well get a whole-genome.)
- packrat386 10y agoA modern day Erysicthon
- goblin89 10y agoFBN1, the gene also behind Marfan syndrome[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marfan_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marfan_syndrome
- Neliquat 10y agoThe solution for obesity is self control. Any other band aid is just a crutch. I wish we could move past 'genetics' and take personal responsibility.
- blacksmith_tb 10y agoNot that they are entirely equivalent, but try and apply that argument to, say, heroin addiction. Or depression.
- nxc18 10y agoWhile having strong self control is of course important, there are differences between individuals that you're not considering. Many of the people who give this self-control argument have never had theirs tested - it is hard to not eat a lot when you are acutely hungry and eating doesn't stop that, for example. Also note that your statement doesn't really work in the general case. I have friends who are extremely skinny (to the point that it distresses them) who are trying to get bigger. It doesn't matter how many thousands of calories they eat, how excellent their nutrition is, they struggle to gain anything - and that is someone who naturally only wants to eat ~1500 calories per day. Is it lack of self-control that they don't spend every waking moment stuffing in high-calorie food despite not being hungry?
- avar 10y agoHave these friends of yours tried talking to e.g. a powerlifting or bodybuilding coach? It's pretty easy to get on a structured low-effort diet to gain weight, and muscle mass with some exercise thrown in. Getting above 1500 calories isn't some desperate effort of "spend[ing] every waking moment stuffing in high-calorie food". It's a couple of protein shakes a day that take you a couple of minutes to prepare & slurp down. Eating enough can be a very difficult logistical problem, but not at the 1500 calorie level, but at something like a >5000 calorie level where you're a professional strongman or powerlifter, or someone like Michael Phelps eating 8000 calories a day.
- nxc18 10y ago
- gwern 10y agoOn a related note, the first GWAS hit for anorexia nervosa has been announced just today: "Genome-Wide Association Study Reveals First Locus for Anorexia Nervosa and Metabolic Correlations", Duncan et al 2016 http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/11/25/088815 http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/11/25/088815 "Anorexia nervosa (AN) is a serious eating disorder characterized by restriction of energy intake relative to requirements, resulting in abnormally low body weight. It has a lifetime prevalence of approximately 1%, disproportionately affects females(1,2), and has no well replicated evidence of effective pharmacological or psychological treatments despite high morbidity and mortality(2). Twin studies support a genetic basis for the observed aggregation of AN in families(3), with heritability estimates of 48%-74%(4). Although initial genome-wide association studies (GWASs) were underpowered(5,6), evidence suggested that signals for AN would be detected with increased power(5). We present a GWAS of 3,495 AN cases and 10,982 controls with one genome-wide significant locus (index variant rs4622308, p=4.3x10-9) in a region (chr12:56,372,585-56,482,185) which includes six genes. The SNP-chip heritability (h_SNP^2) of AN from these data is 0.20 (SE=0.02), suggesting that a substantial fraction of the twin-based heritability stems from common genetic variation. Using these GWAS results, we also find significant positive genetic correlations with schizophrenia, neuroticism, educational attainment, and HDL cholesterol, and significant negative genetic correlations with body mass, insulin, glucose, and lipid phenotypes. Our results support the reconceptualization of AN as a disorder with both psychiatric and metabolic components." More specifically, with endocrine components (https://twitter.com/psychgenomics/status/802254444154892289 https://twitter.com/psychgenomics/status/802254444154892289). (Of course, you don't need any GWAS hits to do research on the genetics of anorexia nervosa or to look for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_correlation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_correlation with other traits, since that can be done with polygenic scores sans any hits or with twin/family studies, but it does help motivate research.)
- jrapdx3 10y agoThis is a very interesting and well-written article. The subject of particular importance to me for a couple reasons. One is professional. I ran an obesity treatment clinic for several years but it's a clinically important area of practice that fascinated me as far back as undergraduate years. The article correctly states that treatment for obesity is largely unsuccessful, the tools and methods have barely made a dent in terms of solutions. Surgical procedures for obesity are crude measures to be sure, very frequently associated with severe nutritional deficiencies that are hard to manage. IMO at best surgery is a desperate "last straw" means to stave off fatal outcome, worthy in that sense, but hardly a prescription for the 99% of the population who are not in that condition. Fact is there's no medical problem more complex than obesity. Hundreds of genetic factors are connected to the many metabolic, endocrine, and immune system alterations from normal found in the obese. There are profound correlations with behavioral disorders and metabolic abnormalities associated with obesity. An issue in the research that I'll need to learn more about is whether obese patients actually have excess aprosin. The woman who is the subject of the article is deficient, but that doesn't necessarily mean that blocking the hormone will have a favorable effect in obesity. Also, it's apparent the hormone has multiple effects, antagonizing the hormone effect could well cause undesirable outcomes. I can easily empathize with the woman's plight. While I'm not suffering anything like the devastating condition portrayed, I've always been on the underweight end of the scale. Even as I go forward into my "mature" years, this characteristic hasn't changed. Tall and very thin body build isn't optimal for health and social reasons, then again people say I look good for my age, so it's not the same set of problems as the article describes. The lesson I take from the article and real-world observations is the incredibly vast range of individual variability among humans, not that we'd have any doubt about it based on even casual observation. But it's a reality we have to constantly remind ourselves about. Our preference of putting things into categories blinds us to the limits of categorizing. Truth is on close examination humans will inevitably fall between the cracks wherever we put the categorical boundaries.
- tropo 10y agoDon't forget viruses. There are viruses that are unusually common in really huge people.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcoffland 10y ago> For instance, the contestants on the “Biggest Loser” TV show became paragons of self-control; some shed more than 100 pounds, something very few of us could ever achieve. And yet a recent study showed that even these incredibly disciplined dieters gained all the weight back. This study has now become quite famous but it should be noted that the participants where given no help after the show and not surprisingly went back to their old habits. > “Unfortunately, many contestants are unable to find or afford adequate ongoing support with exercise doctors, psychologists, sleep specialists, and trainers — and that’s something we all need to work hard to change,” -- from http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/05/02/health/biggest-loser-weight-loss.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/05/02/health/biggest-loser-we... One participant did manage to keep most of the weight off but only through persistence. I feel for those with real genetic disorders but for most of us we can lose weight and keep it off. New York Times articles which tell us that it's not our fault, that it's genetics, leptin, metabolism, aging, etc. are exceedingly popular but for most of the population these are just excuses. Here us how you do it. Drop your daily calories to a very low but still safe level (1500 or less) by counting and writing down the calories of everything you eat. Do this for at least two months. Then start an exercise cycle where you do an hour of highly strenuous cardio at least five days a week. Continue for at least two months. Then go back to dieting. Repeat until you hit your goal weight. Then you can relax until your weight creeps up 10-15 lbs at which point you start the cycle again. This is what it takes for an average person in our modern society to stay healthy. If this seems extreme consider that for thousands of years most of our ancestors endured much more physical exertion on a regular basis and on less calories. We live in a world of excess which is in itself a sufficient explanation for our obesity problem. Excluding of course those few people who actually suffer from weight related diseases.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> New York Times articles which tell us that it's not our fault, that it's genetics, leptin, metabolism, aging, etc. are exceedingly popular but for most of the population these are just excuses. The science explains why some people have to work so hard to be thin, while others like myself can eat whatever I want whenever I want and still remain rail-thin. If I can eat 3k calories a day and be skinny, while someone else needs to drop to 1500 calories to not be fat, it seems the height of unfairness to blame that person for being in that situation.
- lucidguppy 10y agoI feel like this is a submarine for gastric bypass surgery. I've noticed that in the UK there seems to be a lot more push for these through documentaries (US has them too). I was able to lose a lot of weight on a whole foods plant based diet. Its a permanent change. With the SAD diet being the dominant form of nutrition - very few people can maintain a healthy weight (25%).
- lucidguppy 10y agoI feel like this is a submarine for gastric bypass surgery. I've noticed that in the UK there seems to be a lot more push for these through documentaries (US has them too). I was able to lose a lot of weight on a whole foods plant based diet. Its a permanent change. With the SAD diet being the dominant form of nutrition - very few people can maintain a healthy weight (25%).