15 ms·
Homeopathy 'treatments' must be labelled to say they do not work, US gov orders
- nsxwolf 10y ago"No scientific evidence this product works" will be ignored. "This product does not work" would be more effective.
- zerooneinfinity 10y agobut could* be factually inaccurate.
- 31reasons 10y agoSo they are 100% sure that even placebo effect doesn't help the patients ?
- hood_syntax 10y agoThere are cheaper means of achieving the placebo effect, if that's what people desire
- jabgrabdthrow 10y agoCheaper than water? =]
- s_kilk 10y agoCheaper than a $20 bottle of water masquerading as a real treatment.
- tarheeljason 10y agoExpensive placebos work better. http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2015/01/29/expensive_placebos_work_better http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2015/01/29/exp...
- mamon 10y agoPlacebo effect is not some magic, like faith healing. It's statistical quirk. So placebo effect works whether or not you believe in it :-D
- dekhn 10y agoit's not a "statistical quirk". The placebo effect is reproducible and appears to be something that biology "does". how this works is an open area of research but not one that is really studied in detail.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoAre you sure? I read into it a while ago and it seemed people were converging on statistical quirk as the accepted answer.
- derefr 10y agoAFAIK, the "real" placebo effect is a very small and specific thing that goes on when pain alleviation or inflammation are experimental variables, because of the body's μ-opioid system. The rest of the placebo effect, outside of that domain, is being increasingly found to be the result of under-powered experiments.
- dekhn 10y agoWe can choose the argue about the scope of the effect (I think it goes beyond just pain and inflammation, and don't think it's limited to mu-opioids), but generally, yes, pain and inflammation are the two areas where the placebo effect has been seen to occur in a well-powered, well-controlled study.
- mamon 10y agoOk, I'll be more specific: the reason why drug trials are placebo-controlled is that human body is already equipped with the most miraculous drug of all: our own immune system. So, to accurately measure effectiveness of the drug we have to benchmark it against effectiveness of immune system. Placebo effect is just our own body fighting disease, no mystical forces involved.
- seanwilson 10y agoA placebo effect always helps by definition. To show something only has a placebo effect is the equivalent of showing it does not work.
- SilasX 10y agoIn some contexts, you may be legitimately concerned only with the absolute level of "works" and not the level relative to a placebo baseline. The (understandable, traditional) reason for measuring relative to placebo is that, "well, you don't need the drug if it's only as good as what a placebo gives -- just use the cheaper placebo! You should only bother with some special drug if it's better than what mere belief-in-effectiveness yields." But that assumes that people are equally credulous of every placebo; if a person is more credulous of homeopathy, and credulity is hard to manufacture, then it's not quite wrong to say that it "works" under a relevant definition. (I know this is kind of an angels-on-the-head-of-a-pen technicality, but eventually we'll want to actually understand why belief-in-effectiveness can matter at all, so we can exploit it, and reasoning like yours tends to give the idea that such an effort, by definition, can't work.)
- leesalminen 10y agoThose damn scientists don't know what they're talking about anyway. /s
- derefr 10y agoYeah, the former is a weak phrasing of the claim. The latter is too strong, though, to be scientifically precise. Better would be "overwhelming scientific evidence that this product does not work" or "the claims of this product have been tested false across hundreds of trials." Which is to say, we're not 100% sure it's bullshit—we can't be, in science—but we're 99.999999% sure, or so.
- bduerst 10y agoMaking a positive claim (the latter) only sets yourself up to be discredited when, after some amount of time, one of the products inevitably is proven to work for something. It's better to make the negative claim (the former) rather than risk losing what little authority you have with people who are struggling to understand the evidence behind these products to begin with.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- erl 10y agoI have some issues with the statement "No scientific evidence this product works". To me it is toothless and not very convincing. What if the product never has been tested scientifically? In that case, it might work... However, if a label would say "10 peer reviewed and published scientific studies find no evidence that this product works". Now that is convincing.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThis is absolutely key! "No scientific evidence this product works" does not mean the same thing as "this product does not work!" People confusing the two is very harmful. It could mean, for example, "there is plausible mechanism of action but there hasn't been much research on the topic [for whatever reason]" or it could mean "there's absolutely no known mechanism of action, it doesn't make physiological sense, and a century of research has proved it doesn't work." These two statements are obviously not the same!
- JadeNB 10y ago> To me it is toothless and not very convincing. What if the product never has been tested scientifically? In that case, it might work... > However, if a label would say "10 peer reviewed and published scientific studies find no evidence that this product works". Now that is convincing. I don't think that this is how medical labelling should work. If you want to sell a product on the basis of its effect on your health, then the onus should be on you to prove that it works, not on others to prove that it doesn't. In this setting, I think that a presumption of guilt (ineffectiveness or harmfulness) until proven otherwise is appropriate.
- Grishnakh 10y agoI don't see how that's convincing at all. To you and me who actually know a little bit about how science is supposed to work, sure. But to some Jane Doe who never took any science classes in college and has no idea what "peer review" is, and is taken in by the fluffy New-Age BS marketing on the product's label, that phrase isn't going to mean squat. The fundamental problem I think is that much of society simply doesn't understand what science is, and why it's important, or why they should care about scientific studies in regard to allegedly medicinal products they may use.
- senectus1 10y agoI reckon it should be "for decorative purposes only, not for human consumption"
- empath75 10y agoThis is long past due. I'm on a facebook list for dads, and after it came out that a homeopathic teething gel killed 10 kids (http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19/health/teething-remedies-infant-deaths.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19/health/teething-remedies-i...) someone asked if it was worth the risk to keep giving to his kids, since it worked. I tried to explain to him that homeopathic medicine is either 1) Nothing, if they diluted it 'correctly', or never bothered to put the poison in there to begin with or 2) Poison, if they failed to dilute it properly 3) Maybe some kind of actual medicine, in which case it's not actually homeopathic. There are no other options. He responded: "Well, it seemed to work for my kid, so I'm going to keep using it."
- DanBC 10y agoThat teething gel really changed my opinion from "harmless, but dumb" to "potentially fatal or severely harmful, and also dumb, and also allowing children to suffer the teething pain". There were an additional 400 children caused serious harm. I'm baffled by the attitude of parents like the one you mention.
- Veen 10y agoI don't think the "it's harmless" argument holds water whether or not they screw up the dilution: http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html
- Alex3917 10y ago> Nothing, if they diluted it 'correctly', or never bothered to put the poison in there to begin with There are both high-dilutionists and low-dilutionists within homeopathy.[1][2] I'm not saying you should run out and buy a bunch of homeopathic remedies or whatever, but also realize that the mainstream 'skeptic' account of homeopathy is not especially accurate. Also realize that the latest scientific research on food allergies involves homeopathic-like mithridatism, so even though the idea of a like-cures-like high dilutionist treatment isn't anywhere near a universal panacea, it does at least appear to work in certain limited cases. [1] https://www.amazon.com/History-American-Homeopathy-Academic-1820-1935-ebook/dp/B01KI63DYU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1479752156&sr=8-1&keywords=academic+history+of+homeopathy https://www.amazon.com/History-American-Homeopathy-Academic-... [2] http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/202602 http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/202602
- pg314 10y agoThey sometimes do work, because of the placebo effect.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIf something works as well as plain water, then it doesn't work.
- vinay427 10y agoI think that's the point that the commenter you replied to was getting at. In other words, mocking people who claim it "works" because they believed it worked by the placebo effect.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SilasX 10y agoOr we should work on getting better at controlled use of the dynamic behind the placebo effect.
- ars 10y agoThe dynamic is the brain. For example look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hospitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hospitalism - infants will themself to death because they are not loved. Ask doctors and nurses and they'll tell you about people with and without the will to live, and how having a good outlook can mean the difference between life and death.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThat Wikipedia page said nothing about infants willing themselves to death.
- 10y ago
- halleym 10y agoho·me·op·a·thy ˌhōmēˈäpəTHē/noun the treatment of disease by minute doses of natural substances that in a healthy person would produce symptoms of disease
- M2Ys4U 10y agoThat's not correct. Homoeopathy doesn't contain _any_ of the purported substance.
- 83457 10y agothere is a chance
- DanBC 10y ago...if it's been correctly diluted. Since there's almost no regulation the buyer has no way of knowing if it was correctly diluted or not. http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/ucm523468.htm http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/uc... http://arstechnica.com/science/2016/10/fda-homeopathic-teething-gels-may-have-killed-10-babies-sickened-400/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2016/10/fda-homeopathic-teeth...
- cnlevy 10y agoIt used to contain it.
- M2Ys4U 10y agoMy bank account used to contain money, I guess I'm homeopathically rich.
- halleym 10y agoWell, in reality, probably not. I was pointing out that homeopathy was originally 'fighting fire with fire'. Or at least, that is what the word means.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoInteresting to compare this with the current political story of fake news (or climate change denial, holocaust denial, conspiracy theories etc.) It seems we're just generally very bad at this stuff as a species.
- VLM 10y agoWe're actually very good at it, but we insist on doing it wrong a lot. You're not going to rationally logically reason someone out of a position they got into via completely irrational illogical unreasoning belief. Now you might replace their irrational illogical unreasoning belief with another like faith healing or anything an actor in a tv commercial wearing a doctors white coat says is true. As an analogy, in the history of mankind I don't think any Christian Creationist has ever been converted to evolution by throwing scientific journal papers at him. You'd have better luck setting him on fire or being torn apart by lions in a Colosseum and even that mostly doesn't work. But Christian Creationists DO convert to other religions every day, all the time, plenty of currently Buddhists or Hindus or Pagans or Satanists or whatever.
- keeptrying 10y agoIn a post-truth world, this might make the treatments MORE popular. :-/
- astrodust 10y agoIs it just me or is misinformation some sort of virus that slowly spreads? I've noticed a sharp uptick in people utterly detached from reality lately where presumably the former checks to keep people grounded, like a critical news ecosystem, or a robust education system, has imploded.
- MandieD 10y agoYou're not the only one - I've had this sense of a slow, but inescapably-accelerating epidemic for awhile now. Tuesday before last was not a shock. It feels like we're slowly falling off the trajectory of the Renaissance and Enlightenment; avoiding fatalism about that is my main challenge right now.
- pjc50 10y agoTwo driving factors, I think: dominance of the advertising industry, and a rise of "wicked problems" with no good comfortable answers. Global warming leads this: would you rather believe we're on an inevitable path to doom, or that everyone is lying to you?
- bduerst 10y agoTake a step further: Human attention has become a currency more than ever before, and pandering to human biases is one way media companies have learned to earn that currency. You used to need substantial capital to earn the reputation as a serious news organization, but now the barrier to entry is a vaguely-authoritative domain name and social media accounts.
- VLM 10y agoClose. I'm not saying you're wrong but I am proposing a fork from your post in that the really important question isn't "would you rather believe we're on an inevitable path to doom, or that everyone is lying to you?"\ But for the people in charge its more like: "would you gain more authoritarian political power by promoting that we're on an inevitable path to doom, or that everyone is lying to you?" Now lets add another wrinkle... lets say by the magic of groupthink 99% of one population is already a devout member of one belief system. If 50% of climate scientists (small group though they are) were dyed in the wool Republicans then coming out against them would cost votes prestige and power. But if they already are indoctrinated to hate you and your race and your religion and your group, you don't lose very much in a practical sense by signalling against them. In fact as a member of the opposition you probably should oppose them on general principles and your own group expects you to live up to your ... devoutness. I've seen it, watching people nearby me convert to denialism. I have to admit I agree with them on a lot of smaller details. A fascination with symbolic level commitments that are a rounding error WRT altering the Earth's long term problems but ruin innumerably human lives in the short term. "This symbolic proposal will help absolutely nothing in the long term, but in the short term it'll sure destroy a lot of jobs, jobs for people that our political group are trained to bitterly hate..."
- larrik 10y agoHow does this deal with the products that are basically just vitamins, but marketed as "homeopathic" as an umbrella term?
- ars 10y agoIt's only if they want to claim it treats a particular thing. They'll simply put the name on the label without an claim about what it does, and leave that to books. The regulation will do nothing.
- wnevets 10y agoits thinking like this that gets you brexit and president-elect trump
- JBReefer 10y agoPlease don't try to start flame wars on HN, and please be more substantial in your comments.
- zo1 10y agoNo it's not. Come on. You want to blame drought and flooding on him, too? It seems that almost every article I read on HN these days has someone trying to somehow inject a Trump or Brexit reference.
- wnevets 10y ago>No it's not. Come on. You want to blame drought and flooding on him, too? Where exactly in my post did I blame anything on trump?
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13007424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13007424 and marked it off-topic.
- Nano2rad 10y agoHomeopathy does work. Its mechanism is not understood, but it works. It may not cure cancer, but it does work for less severe illnesses. Its working is not placebo effect. People say it works by placebo effect, but without proof, most probably just a guess. So the US gov order is wrong.
- pat2man 10y agoAny evidence to back this claim up? From what I can tell the answer is no... http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/6860/has-most-peer-reviewed-research-on-homeopathy-given-positive-results http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/6860/has-most-pe...
- collyw 10y agohttp://www.bmj.com/content/321/7259/471 http://www.bmj.com/content/321/7259/471 not conclusive evidence by a long way, but still.
- Nano2rad 10y agoIn modern medicine, the treatment is for disease; in homeopathy the treatment is for symptoms and conditions. That means one drug treats one disease cannot be basis of the trial. so they may not have been compared well in the previous studies. Double blinded study also will be difficult because the practitioner has to see the patient. So when considering studies, have to consider these. The mode of action explained by homeopaths may be wrong, so could say it is unscientific. This story is on the results and measuring it and results can be measured scientifically. If it is placebo effect, it will not be effective for multiple times at multiple times in same person, could say there is personal bias. There are many conditions like cold, migraine which have no definite treatment in modern mainstream medicine, so there is no harm in experimenting homeopathy when having these conditions. I believe it is better to get a diagnosis from regular doctor first and then use homeopathy.
- Oletros 10y agoSo, curiously, no scientific test is adequate for homeopathy. How convenient. But reality is that it doesn't work, it is just a big fraud When you have any actual proof and no the same "Belieeeve!!!" call us
- perseusprime11 10y agoHow does Europe and Asia feel about this news? From the wikipedia page: "In Germany, to become a homeopathic physician, one must attend a three-year training programme, while France, Austria and Denmark mandate licences to diagnose any illness or dispense of any product whose purpose is to treat any illness.[284]... The Indian government recognizes homeopathy as one of its national systems of medicine;"
- 1337biz 10y agoThey realize that medicine is not black and white and that there is a reality beyond peer reviewed studies.
- 13years 10y agoIt is interesting in that if you search pubmed, you will find studies published all over the world which claim positive benefits to homeopathy with one exception, the U.S. You could draw multiple conclusion from that. Nonetheless, it is interesting.
- ryuker16 10y agothe stuff was junk science in Asia too. It just masks itself in the cloak of tradition.
- coding123 10y ago-- Removed :)
- will_brown 10y ago>doctrine of like cures like, a claim that a substance that causes the symptoms of a disease in healthy people would cure similar symptoms in sick people. Homeopathy is a pseudoscience – a belief that is incorrectly presented as scientific. Homeopathic preparations are not effective for treating any condition... Isn't like cures like the principle behind many modern medical therapies, such as: flu vaccination; anti-venom; and immunotherapy for allergies. Not saying this is wrong decision, but its always interesting to watch the Government pick winners and losers. In this case their justification includes "many are diluted to the extent..." and "in general claims not based on science". So is that an acknowledgment products are based on science and not diluted to the extent rendering them useless? On the other hand its great watching members of congress explain why they refuse to pass laws require labeling of food containing GMO, because they generally acknowledge GMO could be harmful to consumers but the science is still out and so until then consumers shouldn't be making their purchasing decisions based on GMO labels.
- arrosenberg 10y agoThe examples you gave aren't 'Like Cures Like' in the way homeopathy works. The things you described work by triggering your immune system to create T-cells with a memory of the disease. Homeopathy works by taking a chemical and diluting it, generally to the point where it practically doesn't exist. Best case scenario, it's a sugar pill, worst case, they don't dilute enough with something dangerous and you are taking poison. This isn't picking winners and losers, it's consumer protection that's required for a free market to be fair to consumers. If homeopathic producers follow clinical standards and proven that their products produce statistically better outcomes, then they can call it medicine and sell it on the market.
- will_brown 10y ago>Homeopathy works by taking a chemical and diluting it, generally to the point where it practically doesn't exist. Certainly I could be wrong it's just that "process" sounds a lot like immunotherapy for allergies. I am not trying to lump homeopathy and immunotherapy in the same boat by any means, but looking beyond the differences in the two I think it is possible to be more open minded than labeling the like cures like doctrine pseudo science. >This isn't picking winners and losers, it's consumer protection that's required for a free market to be fair to consumers. Like I said I don't disagree with the labeling, but that doesn't mean there aren't winners and losers being picked. Sure its fair for consumers to know homeopathy treatments haven't been tested (not unlike supplements require FDA warnings), but they are still losers while others are winners and escape fair disclosures to consumers (e.g. my example of no GMO labeling).
- hellogoodbyeeee 10y agoPotentially off topic, but Im trying to navigate the alternative medicine world right now. My mother in law just gave me a bottle of pills containing a Chinese herb meant to treat hair prematurely graying. I don't mind trying it and finding out it doesn't work in order to keep her happy but I've ran into some reports that it can cause liver damage, but I can't gauge how reliable those reports are. Any tips on how to find scientific research on things like this? The product is called "Fu-Ti"
- jff 10y agoPour some pills in the trash and tell her it didn't work. TCM is possibly worse than homeopathy in that at least homeopathic medicine is just water, while TCM is god knows what garbage.
- willvarfar 10y agoMother in laws and their daughters always are a difficult canyon to navigate. White lie may be best? Pretend to take it, and ask her occasionally if it's working..?
- abakker 10y agoWho cares whether the plant works or not? The point here is that you have no idea what is actually in those pills. Odds are good that it doesn't include any of the plant that it indicates and no law is currently broken by that fact. Meanwhile, hair dye is tested on many people and has its ingredients listed.
- VLM 10y agoThe good news for your liver is that sounds exotic and expensive and lawn clippings are cheap so the odds are excellent its just some oregano or garlic or something from the landscape, not the real stuff that might rot out your liver. http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/03/sidebar-whats-in-those-supplements/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/03/sidebar-whats-in-th... In before the stereotypical MiL jokes along the lines of "of course the pills are pure cyanide" etc.
- problems 10y agoCheck Wikipedia as it usually links out to medical sites and offers a decent summary in most cases. In this case Wikipedia links to https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3240794/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3240794/ which appears to be an analysis of 25 cases. I'd say it's pretty damning and avoid it personally. Search PubMed there seem to be a few papers around indicating it's toxicity and discussing it like https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22210538 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22210538
- seanwilson 10y agoDoes anybody have any good links to impressively strong placebo effects of any treatment? Or is it always just a slight reduction in reported pain? These debates always devolve into how placebo is a proven effect and doctors should prescribe placebos. Placebos seem to have limited effects though (they're not going to cure cancer or a cold) so this feels like a red herring.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 10y agoThe ones who already believe will think it's a government-pharmaceutical industry conspiracy to discredit it. Like my mother.
- mb_72 10y agoThis is excellent news. I am slightly ashamed to admit that an ex-g/f once convinced me to go to a homeopath to try and treat my Crohns, and back then I was completely ignorant of what that meant. Some hundreds of dollars later and a couple of weeks of taking some alcohol with water, carefully measured out in a teaspoon daily, I began to finally realise I'd been had. I wince now, but that was the first time I looked up information on homeopathy. Now, I'm not hugely intelligent, but I'm no dummy either, and have a reasonable education and understand of science, the scientific method etc; through pure ignorance I ended up handing over some cash and having a little bit of hope my health would improve. If there is something staring people in the face, people who are in my position might save their money and time. FWIW, the only reliable 'treatment' I've found for my Crohns is pizza. And I guess even this is 99.5% psychological!
- SixSigma 10y agoMy Crohn's went into total remission as soon as I stopped consuming alcohol.
- mb_72 10y agoI never drank when I was first diagnosed, and didn't for some years afterwards. Now I sometimes do, but whether I do or don't there is no noticeable influence on my illness. Still, if you have found something that seems to work, you have nothing to lose by keeping at it (except if you love a beer!)
- SixSigma 10y agoI love beer. But I love not spending days in hospital more. :)
- coryrc 10y agoNot that this is the place for it, but look up hookworms and fecal transplants for actual treatments. Though pizza sounds far more enjoyable.
- 10y ago
- snarf21 10y agoIt is also about time we force this for vitamins too. The disclaimer of "not been validated by the FDA to cure or treat a disease..." is a bunch of crap. It goes beyond false advertising, it is straight up untrue claims. They should be forced to do true double blind studies with several universities and show tangible benefit or don't advertise.
- 13years 10y agoIn the case of vitamins, these studies do exist, but they are already prevented by law from referencing these studies to make claims.
- tajen 10y ago> is misinformation some sort of virus that slowly spreads We're paying the lack of accuracy in "scientific truth". Journalists and political groups (on the Liberal side, especially) aren't innocent here. I see that a lot with feminism. For example: Scientific studies such as "Women in average are able to execute a parallel task in 169s, while men are able to execute in 177s" transforms into "Women 'better at multitasking' than men, study finds"[1]. Wait, what? 169s vs 177s!? Which serves the political group of feminists (hence, my stance about Liberals). It is also widely accepted that women are paid less than men. When we dive into studies, we don't find a 30% difference; We find a heavy distortion and fact extraction, so that the worst possible interpretation of the scientific study becomes the headline of the article, and that helps liberal political groups to make us believe that women have a worse situation than men. Which, of course, conveniently forgets to mention that far more men are killed, homeless (2x in France), beaten up, harassed or commit suicide (3x in France) than women, and more are workaholics, which justifies a part of the pay difference. I've talked about feminism but the same un-demonstration can be made about other groups targeted by the new wave of politics (=Trump). Any normal person would be legitimate to disbelieve journalists, political groups and scientists who forget to mention some interesting fact that completely overturns the picture: 169s vs 177s means that a large part of men performs better than a large part of women on this test. Maybe a lesson is, Liberals may have gone so far in misreporting science that they've discredited science altogether? [1] "Women 'better at multitasking' than men, study finds" – http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-24645100 http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-24645100
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoIt didn't take long for someone to be a living example of what op is talking about.
- tajen 10y agoMaybe fix the BBC article instead of complaining about the messenger?
- NetStrikeForce 10y ago
- SixSigma 10y ago“You know what they call alternative medicine that's been proved to work? - Medicine.” ― Tim Minchin
- balabaster 10y agoSlightly off-topic, but I can't help but recall a rather hilarious 9 minute beat poem by Tim Minchin "By definition", I begin "Alternative Medicine", I continue "Has either not been proved to work, Or been proved not to work. Do you know what they call "alternative medicine" That's been proved to work? Medicine." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KtYkyB35zkk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KtYkyB35zkk
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>Again, this is irrational from my side as you might not be even close to that group This poster said he votes "extreme right" because he pretty much blames the feminist movement on him not having a girlfriend despite admitting he lacks confidence. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12908279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12908279 By the way, I'm not stalking him or anything, I just read that post and thought "oh man that's gotta be the same guy that posted in the Trump thread" and checked to see if I was right.
- tajen 10y agoAccurate reporting in action!
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoHey. The comment you're replying to doesn't say any lies. It doesn't show all your reasons to vote FN (nor that you want to vote for them), but it clearly states one of the things you shared with HN. It seemed clear from the start that you had some kind of grudge against women and I'm trying not to judge you, because I don't know you and I'd make a wrong judgement. However, please let me tell you that women do indeed have to go through great lengths to get the same recognition we do. If you could, would you rather be a woman? If the answer is "no", think about the reasons. Things are definitely not black or white, but whatever your feelings are towards discrimination in favour of women, please please please take some time to walk in their shoes an understand how what might seem unimportant or a joke to us could put them in discomfort or just plainly scare them. Think about the bullies at school (you've mentioned identifying as a nerd) and how you would smile at their jokes and try to be best buds just because you felt scared by their physical superiority. From guy to guy, it's about empathy really.
- tajen 10y agoAbove: > blames the feminist movement on him not having a girlfriend That was too short to be accurate, the relationships between those events are parallel, not consequences. Look, I'm the result of positive action: We've done lots of things in favour of women. I'm actually grateful that society did that, because it's just plain better when a bro group becomes a mixed group. And the result is much more in line with my ethics of equality of chances for everyone. Unfortunately there are 2 drawbacks: 1. The mixed environment we have in programming is not a mixed environment. It's a separate environment with brogrammers in the mixed team, and girlsgrammers (I'm coining the term right now with you). Those girls are members of Girlz In Web movements. They get support from the company to get training. They get support from the team lead to develop their skills. They didn't have to have been programmers for 10 years before applying, because managers look for their human skills. They are targetted by specific job ads which filter by genre (ex: Twitter ads, Google Ads, Facebook ads). They get help from networks that are filtered for women. They complain that brogrammers harass them. So you may have a team with up to half of women (only 30% in my experience), but as males we don't have mixity and new acquaintances: We have a bunch of people who only talk to us if they want to, who are specifically protected by the management and who will be promoted anyway. 2. It is a known risk of positive discrimination, that we don't promote people who deserve it because we promote people to fit criteria. I'm a kid of that generation, I'm the one who repeatedly couldn't be promoted because there's a woman in the group. Now that you look at me in the eyes, what do you tell me? "Sorry for you mate, you couldn't develop your skills as a Team Lead, because we had this girl to promote, who's 4 years younger than you, doesn't know what an HTTP header is, but she's a girl"? That's not even what you tell me. You/society tells me "Those women, who got promoted early, aren't paid as much as males of the same management level, and it's unfair. By the way, men aren't oppressed.". About empathy... I get that women sometimes feel impressed. That's why I really take care of being respectful with women and not talk to them when they don't show signs that they agree to, because I'm afraid they will complain of harassment. Guess what, that made me so respectful with women that I'm still single. Story of my life. Anyway, back to the point: There isn't a correct depiction of the supposed wage gap in news articles, because they misreport scientific studies with blanket statements like "Women are better at multitasking than men". According to newspapers and if we believe the scientific studies they report, women only have qualities and males only have defects, except strength, which is the reason why men are rapists. I'm not even caricaturing much, it's pretty much equivalent to what they say. So we can't be surprised that men (in my situation, or other groups when newspapers misreport another truth about other topic) look for "more accurate sources". Because conflating "177s vs 169s" with "Women are better at..." isn't genuinely accurate, and repeating misreporting all across newspapers when it serves specific minorities isn't accurate either.
- yaakov34 10y agoIn addition to everything said, please don't take homeopathic drugs on the theory that "at least it's harmless." This usually happens when people try to please someone (parents, friends) by "just trying" homeopathy. I made the mistake of doing that, and it was definitely not harmless - the "medicine" contained strong allergens which not only caused hives, but resulted in the acquisition, for a few years, of allergies I never had before - apparently this can happen with sensitization caused by strong allergens. The homeopathic "doctor" was delighted. You see, the other thing in homeopathy, apart from the belief in water memory, is the concept of most disease as a type of itch ("psora"), which can erupt through the skin ("psora miasm"). No, really, I didn't make that up, you can (with some difficulty) find this stuff with Google. Since like cures like, allergens such as poison ivy, which cause skin rashes, are thought to be curing internal disease, and some homeopathic medicines are full of them, and are used as a complement to the super-diluted ones. Stay away from that whole swamp.
- heliumcraft 10y agowoah, this is new to me.. so they a ctually think these skin eruptions are a good thing because the disease is being "cured internally"??
- mstodd 10y agoI feel alone in thinking I don't want the government regulating any of this. What's next? A prayer disclaimer as you walk into a church? The people who buy this are probably the ones who can't afford real medicine, and now regulation is going to make this even more expensive. If you think this is the government trying to protect us against ourselves: it's not, and that's not the role of government anyway. This is just an alternative medicine attack to remove competition and keep the price of real drugs high.
- aoeuasdf1 10y agoPutting on a label doesn't cost anything. I don't see why you think this would make (non-) medicine more expensive? Also, the FDA has the responsibility to make sure that fake medicine cannot be advertised as being medicine. It doesn't remove competition, it removes fraudulent competition from competing with real medicine.
- bradenb 10y agoI'm not always for regulation but in this instance I absolutely think it is necessary. "The people who buy this are probably the ones who can't afford real medicine" This is the reason. If they can't afford real medicine I am doubly-supportive of labeling that prevents them from wasting that money entirely. I'm also not sure how often real medicine is more expensive... I've seen some expensive homeopathic treatments.
- DanBC 10y ago> The people who buy this are probably the ones who can't afford real medicine Homeopathy is popular in the UK where medication is usually free and has a low cost if it's not free.
- scott_karana 10y agoPraying is free, and arguably a form of expression. However, goods sold with the expectation of efficacy should _be controlled_ based on that promise.
- duskwuff 10y ago
- zerognowl 10y agoI agree with others that homeopathy is woo-woo. One of the oft-cited claims by practitioners is that water has memory[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_memory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_memory This sounds cute and it's probably true that water has some subtle hard-to-reproduce property of retaining certain configurations, but even if this were true, what's so great about it? I'm not entirely convinced that a hard-to-reproduce configuration of water will affect my physiology, and if it does, then this would have to be put through scientific rigeur, which it is not, it's performed on blind faith that it works.
- trav4225 10y agoDon't you get it? It's all about the "ionic frequencies" which cleanse the body of "toxins"! ;-)
- tn13 10y agoHere are the must take next steps for US government: 1. All churches, mosques, temples etc. to have a board outside their "Prayer Does Not Work." 2. All astrologers, tarot card readers, psychic readers etc. to have a large bold faced notice "This does not work". 3. All laws passed by congress must begin with "This might have severe unintended consequences that are bigger than the problem this bill claims to solve".
- mstodd 10y agoIt's scary how much power simply give to the government, and how thankful they are that government officials who they've never met can make decisions for people neither of them have ever met.
- trav4225 10y agoYes. There's a fine line between protecting people and becoming a full-blown nanny state. Safety is a good thing, but so is liberty.
- heisenbit 10y agoFrom what I have observed in my life the mechanism of homeopathy has great appeal to people who show some propensity to twisted thinking. Particularly of the all/nothing kind and having trouble with keeping opposites sorted. The problem seekers, the ones that instinctively reach out the most obvious wrong solution.
- ryuker16 10y agoidiots?
- BJanecke 10y agoFor anyone wondering if this is real https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/996984/p114505_otc_homeopathic_drug_enforcement_policy_statement.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements...
- anilgulecha 10y agoIndia, on the opposite end, has a ministry specifically for such woo-woo called AYUSH. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_AYUSH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_AYUSH). Only Ayurveda could possibly be looked at a little charitably, since it involves use of potential active ingredients, but even there efficacy is largely anecdotal, with barely any scientific rigor applied.