8 ms·
There probably isn't an incentive to reduce methane emissions for farmers right now though, right? We'd have to pass regulations mandating a reduction, or an em
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
There probably isn't an incentive to reduce methane emissions for farmers right now though, right? We'd have to pass regulations mandating a reduction, or an emissions tax or something.
- jdavis703 10y agoNo, and that's not going to happen soon. But companies can start marketing their products as carbon neutral and selling them at a premium at retailers like Whole Foods.
- chillydawg 10y agoThe biggest producers are and will always be the mass market stuff, though. Who cares if 1% of beef is produced carbon neutral? It's nice, but it makes no tangible difference. Sadly this method of encouraging better behaviour won't work unless a costco or a mcdonalds, for some insane reason, wants to cut their profit margin and buy more expensive beef.
- jdavis703 10y agoI agree with you. I'd rather see faster, broader action. But it's not happening soon. But instead of waiting around ask your butcher if they can purchase a "zero carbon" cow (or better yet go vegan/vegetarian :)), don't buy mass market stuff with huge carbon footprints (this Christmas I'm mostly giving food or other things). I used to think the "your wallet can change corporate behavior" line of reasoning at the end of Big Corp exposé-style documentaries (e.g. Fast Food Nation) was a little naïve. But look at how many smaller ethical businesses are out there. Yeah people might make fun of the "small batch artisanal" shops out there, but we're making progress because it is popular enough to be a common punch line.
- ElKoji 10y agoAsking your butcher for "zero carbon" cow is pointless, I agree, it is also the equivalent of attempting to avoid buying things with "huge" carbon footprints (like everything that has plastic on it which is pretty much everything useful), much like buying in artisanal shops, or asking for "grass fed beef" or "free range eggs", it is all highly inefficient which is a problem with our growing population. They are all labels often as meaningless as "organic". The vegan and vegetarian options are rather more efficient and simple ways to achieve the same thing with the added benefit of not torturing animals for no good reason other than a particular taste. Once meat is gone from your diet that's it, no debating whether this you're buying has a huge carbon footprint or not, or simply lying to yourself with the zero carbon, dolphin friendly, free range, organic or grass fed labels. I know the usual argument, you're never going to get people to stop eating meat, but then again how are you going to get everyone to care for these labels (which usually carry a higher price in them)? and more over, policing that these labels are actually true?. Think about it, even in the futuristic scenario of populating Mars, are we really going to carry cattle with us, I think it is time to leave it behind.
- tankenmate 10y agoExcept that meat has been part of the human diet before we were even human, and evolution has adapted us to be omnivores. The human body can't produce a number of amino acids any more, a number of which are most easily sourced from the bodies of animals that can produce them (most of which are herbivores). For example Lysine and Methionine are easier to acquire from meat than vegetables; especially if you aren't burning lots of energy (exercise etc) or intake of lots of calories is a health issue. You can live on a vegan diet, but it is easier to live on an omnivore diet. And since for most people easier is preferable, and when talking about the population of the world as a whole, you'll still find that a large percentage of the world's population will eat meat if it is easily available.
- ElKoji 10y agoIt is easier for moat people to live with fossil fuel so it is preferable right? I'm going to pass on the tired discussion of meat is what we're meant to eat because we've been going it forever. Bottom line is you CAN live without meat, it is perfectly healthy so it comes down to a choice. Now my original point was that having this half measures that require constant policing from both the consumer and industries is harder than cutting down something you don't need for good. Both routes require an equal amount of convincing of people, from eating less meat to using your car less or buying particular types of products over others are changes that most people are not ready or willing to accept and most likely won't come to full fruition until a couple generations down the line (regardless of the route) but you can start one yourself that requires no action from increasingly hostile politicians or corporation whose sole purpose of existence is in direct contradiction with the objective. As it is said, you vote with your money. Also if a tax was to be put on hugely polluting industries it'd be self-defeating to not tax meat and dairy.
- tankenmate 10y agoMy point is this, short of banning eating meat people will continue to do so; even if you made vegetables 1/100 of the cost of meat and fixed the calories / Lysine / Methionine issue (which would probably mean post processing the vegetables which increases costs). Banning means legislation, that means politics. So seguing into climate change issues, this took politics too. It started with grassroots taking hold in the 60's counter culture, then the start of political pressure in the 70's. The first big political move was Reagan coming on board during the 80's; and also some lucky technology hook ups like solar powered calculators (never underestimate the power of logistical growth from a low end but widely used product). The 90's brought us government sponsored research and industry backed development and product roll outs; this led to massive improvements in cost mainly though scale. The last 15 years have led to product refinements, financing options, and a greater society wide understanding of just how bad climate change could be. And now we are at a situation of solar becoming cheaper than coal for producing electricity. 50 years! So if you want to achieve the same with meat vs vegetables there is an enormous amount to achieve, above all you'll need to convince people at least as well as climate change issues, get government backing, make it as enjoyable as eating meat, and drive down the cost of Lysine and Methionine extraction. In fact Canola (low erucic acid rapeseed) meal (what's left over after oil extraction) is currently used as livestock feed, this could be used for human consumption but would require further post-processing and possibly protein profile adjustment.
- kristopolous 10y agoThe worst move the environmental movement did is let the environmentally sensitive product be associated with consumption by a rich liberal urban elite. Until someone can fix this and disassociate ecological efficiency from the limousine liberal, these programs are unfortunately going to only be marginal. Minimizing environmental externalities can't be seen as optional. Lots of reasonable things increase cost - such as refrigerated storage and inspection. We don't tier the product market like this though, "oh you want your meat to be free of disease? Well then mr fancy pants... Here's the luxury product."
- 7952 10y agoYes agree, just look at canned tuna. How is it acceptable to sell products that kill dolphines? Yet "dophin friendly" is treated as a marketing thing. It is like having a note saying "no kittens strangled" on a bottle of milk. It would be better to require objective ethical discolsure upfront on products. So you have "child labour may have been used" alongside the fat content and ingredients.
- r00fus 10y agoThese regulatory outcomes are what we get when corporations have regulatory capture.
- fisherjeff 10y agoConsumer product prices will always race to the bottom. Environmental protections with non-zero costs will therefore always take a back seat to a more competitive price. I agree in principle with your sentiment; however, I have yet to come up with an alternative which does not involve strong environmental legislation. Which, in the US at least, is only likely to happen after it's too late, if ever.
- woah 10y agoWho cares about environmental friendliness? Liberals. Who has the money to pay extra for environmentally friendly products? Well-to-do liberals. I don't really understand how you think things could have gone differently.
- iampherocity 10y agoOn 1.5 billion cows with an average release of 70-120kg per year (I went with 90kg) you'll get a reduction by 1,350,000,000kg of methane. Thats a difference. A single percent drop from one of the main contributors of green house gasses is huge.
- jessriedel 10y agoLike how it would be insane of McDonald's to unilaterally agree to use cage-free eggs?
- gambiting 10y agoAll eggs used by McDonalds in the UK have to be from free range chickens already? http://www.mcdonalds.co.uk/ukhome/food-quality/eggs.html#close http://www.mcdonalds.co.uk/ukhome/food-quality/eggs.html#clo...
- cbr 10y ago(referencing http://news.mcdonalds.com/corporate/news-stories/2013/mcdonalds-to-fully-transition-to-cage-free-eggs http://news.mcdonalds.com/corporate/news-stories/2013/mcdona... )
- marcosdumay 10y agoIt has to start somewhere. You can't expect the entire meat industry to convert at once.
- DonHopkins 10y agoIf "low carb" and "gluton free" diets can be fads, then "fart free meat" can be a fad. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQBrhfN4uYc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQBrhfN4uYc
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> The biggest producers are and will always be the mass market stuff, though. Who cares if 1% of beef is produced carbon neutral? It's nice, but it makes no tangible difference. Couldn't you look at it as a vanguard thing? Like, once the public is more used to the idea because it's been on the market in some form, it's easier to mandate it?
- mrfusion 10y agoWe're talking about methane not carbon.
- encoderer 10y agoMethane is a carbon compound.
- gmac 10y agoCarbon neutral is essentially shorthand for doesn't contribute to climate change. Methane (a) contains carbon and (b) is a much more potent greenhouse gas than CO2.
- Retric 10y ago> More potent Only in the short term.
- huxley 10y agoNot that short-term. Methane has a GWP (Global Warming Potential or equivalent impact compared to same amount of carbon dioxide) of 86 over 20 years; 34 over 100 years; and 7.6 over 500 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential
- Retric 10y agoThat's very misleading. 34 / 5 is 6.8 so most of that 500 year potential is front loaded to the first 100 years. The difference from 7.6 vs 6.8 is because it breaks down into some CO2. And in fact is less potent than C02 from year 100-400.
- tim333 10y agoIt's an interesting puzzle as to how you'd monitor something like that for a global warming tax. Random cow inspections? Some kind of satellite thing?
- vidarh 10y agoAdd a default per-cow tax, and deduct from it for purchase of a seaweed feed, and make it bite sufficiently that it becomes substantially cheaper to include seaweed in the feed. This is how Norway encourages bottle recycling: There's no law mandating recycling of bottles, but there's a substantial tax on beverage containers that you get a reduction of in proportion to your return rate. This has resulted in a return rate of 99%+ of recyclable bottles by making it economically beneficial for retailers and distributors to participate in fairly elaborate and expensive collection and recycling schemes. It takes some work to get mechanisms like this in place in a way that isn't easy to exploit, but get the incentives right and you can let economic interests do most of the work.
- tim333 10y agoI guess that could work.
- tootie 10y agoUS does the same actually. $.05 tax on all bottles, $0.05 payment for recycling. It used to get people to recycle but now the penalty is too small to be worth it. On the flip side, rooting through garbage cans for recycling deposits is now a viable source of income for urban poor.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoOn the other other hand, we're essentially paying urban poor to empty cans and strew garbage over the sidewalk.
- tootie 10y agoThey never make a mess where I live. They know to never become a nuisance of the cops will start to harass them.
- discreteevent 10y agoIn Europe a country is fined if it doesn't meet it's targets. The measurement of emissions includes agriculture and is a big problem for some countries. So if they can monitor and prove that this method will reduce emissions then I think they will consider it.
- moby_click 10y agoA year ago there was a sad moment when the European Parliament laughingly decided to not limit methane emissions from ruminants: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/ep-live/en/plenary/video?debate=1446030648618 http://www.europarl.europa.eu/ep-live/en/plenary/video?debat... The relevant part is from 13:58 (Andrieu, Eric) to (including) !4:00 (Eck, Stefan). I'm not sure if there ever existed software that worked on that site, so you probably have to skip to 1:48 in the stream mms://vod.europarl.europa.eu/wmv/nas/nasvod02/vod0910/2015/wm/VODChapter_20151028_12104300_14320200_509dc321150aee25e47-337f.wmv?wmcache=0 It's not like that voting is directly relevant in the legislative process but that's another discussion.
- amelius 10y ago> There probably isn't an incentive to reduce methane emissions for farmers right now though I think we will be able to detect methane emissions on a large scale from space sometime soon, e.g. [1]. At that point, farmers can't escape the law in any way, and they will have an incentive to reduce emissions. [1] http://www.csmonitor.com/Science/2016/0615/NASA-detects-methane-leaks-from-a-satellite-in-space http://www.csmonitor.com/Science/2016/0615/NASA-detects-meth...
- kctess5 10y agoAssuming there is a law. I think we can already detect methane well enough to know that cows make a lot of it. You don't want to make the law something they must "escape" from, but rather something they can profit from by not polluting. Like tax credits.
- oska 10y agoI disagree. I think we need to increasingly shift to pollution taxes because 1) physical pollution is hard to hide and 2) minimising pollution both improves the environment and maximises industrial efficiency.
- veli_joza 10y agoThis new result could push things along, because it provides the solution without lowering production. There would be less lobbying and backlash against such measures if the industry has clear way of dealing with them.
- dharma1 10y agoI emailed an atmospheric methane professor about the NASA paper a couple of months ago, asking if it could be used for tracking permafrost thawing related methane leaks (in Siberia etc), and got this back: "Yes, there is a lot of work on finding methane emissions by satellite. This is good as a broad guide to spotting big emissions like the huge US leak: the real problem we have is in quantifying emissions at ground level from a wide range of much smaller sources, and in placing good accurate numbers on the fluxes. Unfortunately, the emission is from the ground into the boundary layer, at the bottom of the atmosphere, while satellite observation sees through the total column. We use wind back-trajectory analysis to identify the source of the methane (running the weather backwards), but there have been bad examples in the past where the media latched onto claims of major methane anomalies seen from space (e.g. in the Arctic or in S America) and didn’t realise that the methane was in the mid-troposphere in air that had last been in contact with the ground many thousands of miles away. What is needed is an integrated approach at all levels, using satellite observation, wind-tracking using chemical transport models, and careful ground measurement to identify sources."
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWell if it is 20% of the total green house gas effect then we should be willing to sell them carbon tax credits. Looking at how creatively Tesla used them I'm guessing you could entirely offset the cost of feeding the cattle with credits.
- disordinary 10y agoWe check run off, waste disposal, animal welfare, and a lot of other things on farms. It's all done with spot checks, I'd imagine this will be the same.