10 ms·
Obama bans new oil drilling in Arctic Ocean
- givinguflac 10y agoThis sounds like good news to me, hopefully not short lived when the new administration comes in.
- yoz-y 10y agoAlthough I would love to see governments taking environmental issues seriously, I just can't fathom this legislation not being discarded by the next administration in the months to come.
- finid 10y agoWell, you can be sure that it will be discarded, because the person most likely to be responsible for energy is either S. Palin or some other oil companies-friendly professional. Republican administrations tend to be "good for business", which translates to "bad for consumers", so get ready to be shafted.
- chronic6l 10y agoMaybe you should make a business? But I guess working for someone else is just too damn easy to feed your family...
- finid 10y agoYou should investigate what "good for business" means in US politics.
- DominikR 10y ago> "good for business", which translates to "bad for consumers" I know it's trendy to be left leaning so you easily get away with such generalising statements but ask yourself these questions before hating on all businesses: Would you buy an iPhone or a laptop designed and built by a government agency? A car? How about a pair of shoes or pants. Would you prefer sending your children to private or public schools. Same goes for universities. Would you rather participate in evil Capitalism to earn a living or live under government social security regimentation, possibly even with a job provided or forced on you by government. Is there even anything where you would prefer the government option over something offered by private businesses? If you don't want private businesses to offer products and services, and government products and services suck, then who is going to provide this?
- Frondo 10y agoI would prefer to send my kids to public schools and universities. I would far prefer single-payer health care or state-run health care to the current American system. Mind you, I don't want to shut down private universities or health care providers for anyone who wants to pay for them. I do want education and access to medical care to be universally available to all people (not just citizens, but people) in this country, and having a state-run system for those makes sense. Consumer goods, I don't think there needs to be a government producer of those in general, unless the markets have somehow failed to make some necessities of life available to people.
- finid 10y agoYou missed the point, and I'm not sure you understand what "good for business", as practiced by Republican administrations in the US, means. It simply means no regulations. So businesses are free to do anything they want, with consumers at the receiving end of the negative consequences of such practices. Most recently, we saw how that played out under the last Republican (Bush) administration. In an environment in which corporations were going gang-busters, I don't recall that administration ever bringing a single anti-trust case. That "good for business" environment eventually led to the 2008 financial crises. And the single most important curb that was put in place to prevent such a crisis from happening again is under threat, because the guys set to take office in January (2017) have already said they'll undo the Dodd-Frank Act.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt isn't legislation. And while this is sort of pedantic, it is an important factor in the next administration being able to easily discard it. If it were legislation, congress would have to be part of getting rid of it.
- hollander 10y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12993634 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12993634 If this is true, it would take several years, maybe until the next elections.
- djaychela 10y agoSo, how long will it be before this is overturned? Being from the UK, I don't fully understand the way the US legal system works... I know Trump has said that gay marriage is not under threat because "it's a law", so how is this different? (if, of course, it is different)
- awinder 10y agoGay marriage was determined to be a constitutional right by a conservative Supreme Court (judicial ruling), versus this being an executive order from Obama. Trump has previously said he plans on throwing away all of obamas executive orders, which he can do on his own. That said Obama is now working with trump to transition govt and taking a much more active role in it due to trumps team being under prepared, so who knows. Maybe pieces like this that trump doesn't really care about live on. Hard to say, it's a brave new world in US politics.
- _delirium 10y agoIt's fairly complex even for executive orders; depends on how they were implemented. Some are purely the president's prerogative, in which case the next president can do whatever they want as well. But quite a few are Congress having delegated to the executive branch implementation of some provision (Congress loves to craft fairly vague laws and delegate the details to administrative rulemaking by various agencies). In that case there are certain required rule-making processes that have to be followed, such as public comment periods, cost-benefit analyses, appeals, etc. The president can direct an agency to implement a particular preferred approach, but it has to make it through this process to become binding regulation, and a subsequent president would have to go through the same process to reverse it.
- ohyoutravel 10y ago>>Congress loves to craft fairly vague laws and delegate the details to administrative rulemaking by various agencies I can't quite tell from your tone if you're implying that this is a bad thing, or if you're of the opinion that Congress is shirking on their duties when they do this. I read it like, "'Congress just LOVES to pass vague laws so others have to step in' /sarcasm." My apologies if I'm misreading your tone. For posterity, just to be clear, this is definitely a good thing here. In the case of, for example, the environment, which this post is about: Members of Congress are not experts in every field, so it makes more sense to pass a law called the Clean Air Act requiring protection of the air with some parameters, and then letting the experts at EPA fill in the details. In this case at least, it's not Congress shirking their duties, but rather the way it should work. i.e. Congress issues laws requiring general things, and the experts at the various federal agencies fill in the details with regulations (though obviously it doesn't always work perfectly).
- ourmandave 10y agoObama banned certain new leases through 2022. From a related report: http://www.pressherald.com/2016/11/18/obama-administration-bans-arctic-oil-drilling-through-2022/ http://www.pressherald.com/2016/11/18/obama-administration-b... Even if the economics of Arctic drilling improve and a Trump administration wants to reopen the area to exploration, both oil company officials and environmental groups say, Trump would be unable to toss out the five-year plan immediately. To undo the Obama administration’s ban, a new administration would have to prepare a supplemental report, which could take as long as two years, depending on whether it needs to prepare a new environmental impact statement. After that, the federal government would have to organize a lease sale for companies interested in drilling there.
- notliketherest 10y agoI wouldn't put it past the Congress to blow that requirement out of the water.
- Frondo 10y agoUnlikely to make it past the Senate democrats, who still have filibuster power.
- anonymousab 10y agoIs that a power that could be removed by the Republicans? Not that this is the issue where they would bother to do so. But the Democrats may be looking to pick their battles rather than be fully obstinate and force the GOP's hand.
- maxerickson 10y agoI wonder if this even matters after the huge shale discovery in Texas.
- throwaway5752 10y agoWhen you hear about news like that, remember that 1) a billion barrels is about 50 days of US consumption and the Us is less than half of global consumption 2) that the announcements are usually about "oil in place" which an estimate of the total size of the deposit, of which 10-40% is usually recoverable. If you are talking about Alpine High, it's less than 1/2 a year of US consumption of oil and less than 3 years of US consumption of natural gas at current rates (and very likely less depending on the recovery ratio).
- maxerickson 10y agohttp://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2016/11/17/usgs-largest-oil-deposit-ever-found-us-discovered-texas/94013292/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2016/11/17/us...
- paulddraper 10y agoWolfcamp shale has 20 billion barrels of oil. According to your numbers, 3 years of US consumption (not counting recoverability). So...it's a pretty big deal.
- iampherocity 10y agoMaybe. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/science/fracking-earthquakes-alberta-canada.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/science/fracking-earthquak...
- astrodust 10y agoThree years of consumption is a drop in the bucket, I'm sorry. If you think that's a big deal you need to get your head checked. Three years is a blink in time. If it was fifty years or more you would at least have a case.
- dekhn 10y agoRealistically, right now the US has enough sources to produce huge exports without touching the Arctic (or the Pacific Coast, which has enormous untapped resources). Economically, it makes sense (I'm not addressing environmental concerns) to hold off on exploiting this oil. Currently there is so much global supply that adding more would just depress prices while encouraging unnecessary economic growth. While it would have an enormous environmental impact, there may come a time in the future of America where we are obliged to tap these resources for our economy.
- paulddraper 10y ago> encouraging unnecessary economic growth economic growth is always a "necessity"
- dekhn 10y agonah there are severe consequences to excessive growth especially when subsidized by low oil prices. Please see https://www.amazon.com/Quest-Energy-Security-Remaking-Modern/dp/0143121944 https://www.amazon.com/Quest-Energy-Security-Remaking-Modern... for the hard-won lessons.