39 ms·
Robots and industrialization in developing countries [pdf]
- anigbrowl 10y agoI have yet to see a political party with a coherent response to the looming specter of automation. Don't get me wrong, I'm very much in favor of robotic technology, but it's not compatible with existing capitalistic structures.
- Gravityloss 10y agoFor the capitalist, maybe it is? We slide back to feudalism, slavery and over the back side to unknown territory beyond where the majority of people's existence are at the whims of those few who control the machinery.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt doesn't make any sense to let a few people control the machinery. In a feudal structure, the lord guides the violence that asserts the control. If you are just talking about machinery, it's going to be awful tough for a small group to continuously resist the forces of millions that move against them. They might build machines of violence, but it is not so likely that they will be able to stop others from building them too (in which case we need a political solution, force won't decide the issue)
- Gravityloss 10y ago"It doesn't make any sense to let a few people control the machinery." But that's where it's going, it's a positive feedback process. The L shaped wealth curve. Are you advocating a different system of laws, not based on private property and business?
- maxerickson 10y agoI'm not advocating for it, I'm saying that it is likely to come about, even in the face of extraordinarily violent resistance by the few that end up with the wealth.
- disordinary 10y agoIn many ways it's where we're at. The top 1% having the wealth of the bottom 50%, etc.
- dogma1138 10y agoWell there is considerably less threat to workers in regards to automation in the West than in the developing world, we've outsourced everything already to the developing world, now the developing world is about the experience the same thing. The west has sufficient capital and social infrastructure to get by even without a preemptive socioeconomic changes the developing world doesn't have the luxury. The girls that work in sweatshops in Bangladesh won't be able to retrain or become master crafters selling overpriced crap on Etsy because you'll going to be buying clothes from a dispensary that would 3D print or weave the clothes in minutes to fit your size and specifications perfectly, while people in the west can. Truck drivers will likely to find other things to do since there will be sufficient capital to pay for jobs, newer generations would have jobs that don't exist yet, heck as long as the west keeps generating wealth the "self employed neohipster economy" can continue growing, we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think, you can make a pretty good money from selling bamboo sticks on Etsy, and when everyone will have a 3D printer, weaver and CNC milling machine in their home or at the local 7/11 people would be able to sell their designs on the printer's template store. Just like smartphones enabled everyone with even basic programming skills to make a decent income from selling apps, like youtube and other sites enabled people to make money by generating content, automation including on-demand manufacturing will generate new opportunities. But these opportunities will likely to be limited to the already privileged just like every other opportunity beforehand, the developing world always gets the scraps of the table.
- collinmanderson 10y ago> we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think I'd be curious what percentage of YouTube channels are actually profitable. Sure, there are probably a lot of people making millions, but I bet there are even more failures out there. Self employment probably won't work for everyone.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf you actually put in the required effort and make it a full time job you can make money, if you dick around then you won't. https://socialblade.com/ https://socialblade.com/ and other similar sites have pretty good estimates, even if you lower the income of pretty much every full time production channel by 10 it's still more than enough to live on.
- olalonde 10y agoAutomation has done a lot of good for digital things, it's still crazy to me that services like Google Search, Gmail, YouTube or GitHub are free to use for the most part. Probably a long shot, but I wonder if the freemium or ad-supported models will eventually be adopted for physical things. Imagine fast food chains giving away free meals but with more delicious/healthy paid options on the menu (hmm, I admit that particular example sounds a bit dystopian but I couldn't come with something better). Not sure that's ever going to happen within a capitalistic system but it's fun to wonder about.
- chiefalchemist 10y agoNothing is free. Noth. Thing.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoFree* *Conditions apply, nothing is free.
- olalonde 10y agoThat is a very profound and original insight. That being said, I meant "free of charge", see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium for more context.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoEverything is free, we inherited the underlying wealth of the world for nothing, we just choose to charge for it.
- chiefalchemist 10y agoNot every cost is financial. It could be time. It could be personal privacy. But free - even free of charge - isn't free.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tbrownaw 10y agoSo, way less drastic than the number of agriculture jobs taken by machinery (reduced from "practically everyone" to "the U.S.A. is at under 2%"). Cool.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoPeople don't realize that the tractor was basically the number one job killer for humanity. We went from 70%+ of the population involved in farming to less than 3%. We created new industries and jobs from that and we will do so again.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWhat jobs? There is a limit to human needs. At some point the robots will feed, clothe, transport, heal and entertain us all. What remains? Hobbies? We will have to invent make-work things for folks to do I guess. And call it work.
- bbcbasic 10y agoLike Facebook?
- TheGrimner 10y agooff the top of my head, : art, music, literature, relationships, exploration. without the requirement to toil, humanity could be free to explore the stars and enjoy this ride.
- umanwizard 10y agoYou're assuming whoever owns the means of production is okay with giving you enough of a share to survive.
- AJ007 10y agoThe made up stuff already exists. The explanations a person gives for doing a particular thing perhaps has less to do with the logic of why and more to do with some fundamental instinct to keep busy.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoI had a dream where I had the last programming job in the world - writing cobol printer drivers. Then somebody came in and put a box on my desk. "What's that?" "Its a device that can write cobol printer drivers". I stood up, and went to the door, and opened it, and there was only a grey blankness. Then I woke up.
- swalsh 10y agoWhat a nightmare. The last programming job available is writing a cobol printer driver?
- dejv 10y agoEvan AI will not touch that nasty codebase
- astrodust 10y agoMaybe it will build a machine that goes back in time to hunt down people that made all the bugs, thereby "solving" the problem in the most efficient way it can envision.
- johnchristopher 10y agoWoah, calm down Skynet.
- contingencies 10y agoAI will, without baggage or attitude, consider immediately any Turing-complete system trivially equivalent.
- Cyph0n 10y agoDude, that sounds like a terrible nightmare.
- aswanson 10y agoWhy would computers need to communicate through printouts, tho?
- emblem21 10y agoRobots solve one problem very, very well: Labor shortages. Rural America is poor, not because it is not rich in natural capital and real estate, but because it suffers from a perpetual labor shortage. (14 percent of the U.S. rural are spread across 72 percent of the Nation's land area) Urbanization has a monopoly on talent at this point in time because of globalization and the wealth structure of internationalist neoliberal capitalism. (The Silicon Valley model) Robotic labor will change that, especially given the strictness of UAV laws in the US and the UK today. They are practically legislating that drones must find profitability in low-value, low-population areas. Fine. Challenge accepted. To give another example of such labor shortages, 75% of the United Arab Emirates population is Chinese, Indian, Pakistani, and Filipino immigrants doing construction jobs. The other 2.3 million native UAE nationals can't possibly engage in all of the ancillary labor opportunities that Dubai money commands. Wealthy nations are suffering from labor shortages all over the world and have been for decades. They've raced to solve these problems in the only way they know how: attracting the flow of post-colonials because of standards of living arbitrage. (Very often, people used to being so poor being treated like garbage in a wealthy nation is a significantly better prospect than staying home) In the EU, for example, they can no longer print their own currency, but each member state can still issue bonds. They are already engaging in socialist taxation regimes, so raising taxes to pay for the bonds is impossible. Therefore, you need to enrich your corporations by giving them access to cheap labor and pray you can tax them before they allocate their new found wealth in the Isle of Mann. Unfortunately, this impulse isn't such a clean transition, as most of these old world nations (with old world money) have the political, institutional, and cultural reflex to give new blood two options: Comply with your role in our social pecking order 100% or be exiled/imprisoned/exterminated. Race riots, cultural flare-ups, demographic conflict, and other Huntingtonian events can easily be exploited and exacerbated by political opportunists, ultimately destabilizing the very social configuration that made your nation attractive to begin with. No matter what the well-wishers say, when it all goes belly up, civilizations always divide themselves along ethnic (the American definition) lines. If we continue to refuse (as many have since the 1970s) addressing the labor shortage problem with our established institutions, people like me will be forced to address it technologically and your cherished institutions and the morality that they stand upon will be ground into the dirt upon its passing.
- dfabulich 10y agoMany of the folks here like CGP Grey's video on this topic, "Humans Need Not Apply" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU But you should watch that in contrast with one of his newest videos, "The Rules for Rulers" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs > The more the wealth of a nation comes from the productive citizens of the nation, the more the power gets spread out, and the more the ruler must maintain the quality of life for those citizens. The less, the less. > Now if a stable democracy becomes very poor, or if a resource that dwarfs the productivity of the citizens is found, the odds of this gamble change, and make it more possible for a small group to seize power.
- imaginenore 10y agoThat's why basic income is inevitable. We simply don't have enough jobs for everyone.
- daenz 10y ago...or the notion of what a job is changes. Unless machines can literally provide everything that humans can want (including art, interaction, companionship, etc), then there will always be something for humans to do to make money.
- tiglionabbit 10y agoLike in The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson. You can make anything in the matter compiler for free, so long as you've bought the intellectual property rights for the design.
- intended 10y agoWhich are all relatively poorly paying. Art is a log scale when it comes to compensation - and many of the best paid are dead. The issue is not job loss, its job replacement with worse paying service sector jobs which act as a barrier to upward social movement (because lower pay means less access to various positive network effects)
- treelovinhippie 10y agoI think what we need is a new economic paradigm whereby humans work in symbiosis with AI and ever encroaching automation. There's a model I'm working on where the base economic protocols are coded into a decentralized blockchain platform like Ethereum. Usually the knee-jerk easy response to automation is universal basic income. And while I wish/want us to all have a UBI; those in the developing world will definitely be the last groups on the planet to receive one. The future vision of the blockchain is the complete dismantling of all hierarchies and total autonomy at the individual level. So governments, organizations, VC, companies, jobs etc are replaced with DAOs and blockchain-based co-ops capable of the same or greater complexity and value-add without the hierarchy. The big issue I'm facing, and I think the whole ecosystem is facing, is how do you transition the global economy to that future? It needs to be incremental but rapid, familiar but new, to exploit existing human incentives and status quo's while hiding all the unfamiliar crypto jargon behind the scenes such that anyone can immediately and intuitively adopt the new economic protocol.
- disordinary 10y agoI wonder if it's going to be that big a deal where you live, the huge companies now know no borders. We live in a world of such scale that it's nearly impossible to compete with the companies that are established. As we loose jobs to multinationals and automation then something has to change in the way we structure our economies, because the income divide will grow as the rich (who earn wealth from owning) will not suffer as much as the middle class and poor (who earn money from working). At the very least companies like Google, Amazon, Facebook, etc. Are going to have to start paying fair taxes in any jurisdiction that they operate in. The fact that technology will be cheaper and more accessible (see the SpaceX internet satellite constellation) and no one will have jobs in the developed or developing world, coupled with the fact that in general poorer countries seem to have more natural resources (that can be automated but still generate wealth for the house country), means that things might actually level between the developed and developing. Of course the big companies will be based in the US and Europe, but unless you're giving every single person shares the money that they make will go to a few. In this admittedly doomsday scenario the money will actually drop because people won't be working to pay for services or buy products, but the scale will be such that they will still be highly profitable. Expect revolutions before that day.
- cconcepts 10y agoIn my line of work, the recent increases in health and safety legislation and resulting costs of compliance with having personnel on site in situations where they might get harmed in any way means that the return for automating processes is HUGE even compared to five years ago. My prediction is that we will be forced into a situation where we have millions unemployed and needing universal basic income because they were educated to be employed in a system that suddenly lost its ability to accept any risk to people....which coincided with the technological ability to automate their jobs away. The fact that people get hurt will eliminate their ability to be a viable means of production in many industries.
- abrkn 10y agoI like to think about the locomotive train. It must have been a very difficult time to be in the horse business. Yet here we are.
- siidooloo 10y agoWe got here by creating a social saftey net (even if a very minimal one).
- jfoutz 10y agoI like to think about the smart phone. It must have been a very difficult time to be in the feature phone business. Finland's economy looks to be about a decade behind. I wonder what it'll be like when things change quickly.
- disordinary 10y agoThe problem is every revolution has created jobs, this one looks like it's going to take millions away.
- lxmorj 10y agoAnd where are the horses?
- intended 10y ago
- chiefalchemist 10y agoYet another election issue that never was. Let's hope everyone promised manufacturing jobs doesn't get upset when they find out the truth
- randomdata 10y agoThere does seem to be a plan there. The President elect plans to abolish the federal minimum wage[1]. Not even robots can compete with free. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2016/05/09/donald-trumps-excellent-economic-idea-abolish-the-federal-minimum-wage/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2016/05/09/donald-tr...
- disordinary 10y agoIt's interesting and a little scary, we're going to have to drastically rethink the way our economies operate and what our lifestyles will be like in the future, and fast. The problem is we've seen that people struggle to let go of old ideals, for instance climate change deniers, because they're reluctant to let go of their lifestyle despite all evidence that it's not sustainable. Unfortunately, the more you fight it the harder the fall will be. This also makes Trumps promise to bring manufacturing back to the US quite interesting, because the labor cost is too expensive in places like China and they are loosing the manufacturing jobs themselves, just to automation. The only way to reverse the tide would be for large subsidies on US based manufacturing, and tariffs on imports, i.e. a protected economy, which has never worked in the past. In fact manufacturing IS returning to the US, Foxconn has been building US factories as have other large contract manufacturers, it makes sense from a supply chain perspective. But the return of manufacturing does not equate to a return in manufacturing jobs, those jobs are gone and will never return. And many, many more jobs will be lost within the coming years.
- grecy 10y ago> This also makes Trumps promise to bring manufacturing back to the US quite interesting.... The voting in of Trump shows how conservative and not forward-looking the US is. Vast swaths of the South are hell-bent on keeping things the way they are (for better or worse). The US has also been one of the "lower" OECD countries for a decade or two in a lot of measures [1]. I won't be surprised if it's one of the last OECD countries to have a strong manufacturing sector, requiring humans to do a lot of work that in other countries has been replaced. Other countries will figure out how to rethink economies, happiness, purpose, etc, and the US will just keep doing what it's always done. I think there will be tens of millions in OECD countries living with basic income (or something in a similar vein) with tens of millions in the US are still laboring at work. [1] The US is at or very near the worst among OECD countries in: infant mortality, child poverty, child health and safety, life expectancy at birth, healthy life expectancy, rate of obesity, disability-adjusted life years, doctors per 1000 people, deaths from treatable conditions, rate of mental health disorders, rate of drug abuse, rate of prescription drug use, incarceration rate, rate of assaults, rate of homicides, income inequality, wealth inequality, and economic mobility.
- known 10y agoFreedom from Robots http://marshallbrain.com/robotic-freedom.htm http://marshallbrain.com/robotic-freedom.htm
- Chathamization 10y agoI wouldn't be surprised if that happens in the developing world. As someone else pointed out, if your economy changes from a mostly agricultural one to one more similar to developed nations (where most people aren't involved in agriculture), you're naturally seeing most of your old jobs disappear to automation (and many new ones open up). In the developed world we don't seem to be going through much of a automation revolution at the moment - for example, U.S. productivity growth is actually fairly low right now[1]. [1] http://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm http://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm
- c-smile 10y agoDon't worry! Mr. Trump will build the wall between us and robots. And those robots will pay for it. Hasta la vista!
- nopinsight 10y agoThere are four major categories of jobs that can resist automation: 1) Entrepreneurs and organizers who initiate new products, services, movements, or new styles of arts and interactions. 2) People experts--designers, entertainers, artists, experience enhancers, high-level service personnels, value-enhancing salespeople--who understand deep human needs and use their creativity, empathy, interpersonal skills, and technology to realize them. Routine "people jobs" that customers wouldn't pay more to interact with humans could be replaced by AI agents, in some cases in humaniod robotic bodies. 3) Well-rounded analysts who can communicate with clients and stakeholders and translate their needs into fairly high-level specifications for automation technology to perform. Low-level programming jobs will increasingly become more of a niche as software & platforms can adapt better through machine learning and upcoming AI advances. More and more software will be programmable, implicitly and explicitly, by end users. 4) Locomotion specialists--physical therapists, specialist nurses, dentists--who integrate theoretical knowledge and experience with their flexibility and dexterity. Robotics technology will take a good many decades before it can cost effectively compete with these experts. I think we may achieve human-level ability to think and solve problems flexibly before these people are challenged. (Let me know if there are categories I miss.) -- It seems to me categories 1) and 2) above may have the most openings for workers in the future. Education systems in most of the world are badly inadequate for preparing people for those jobs, however. The worst-fit systems are in developing countries where they are still heavily rooted in models for training 20th century industrial workers. Open-ended educational models like Montessori need to spread much more widely to prevent inequitable jobless future for the masses. Note: Basic income is orthogonal to having respectable occupations and providing value to community. It is likely that human psychology has been shaped, culturally and even evolutionarily, in a way that people need a purpose and a valued occupation to live and feel well. (Perhaps the average number of working hours will be reduced to 3-4 hours per day and people will be free to pursue their hobbies and social activities.)
- intended 10y agoGreat point. I was looking at education tech, and I think education is not a "solvable problem". Retention and mastery Remain the two ends of the success spectrum. But where a student lies on that spectrum depends on a lot of variables, several of which directly link to economic outcomes in the nation such as 1) nutrition levels of parent and grand parent (in particular female education) 2) nutrition availability 3) average household wealth 4) child labor (more importantly - the necessity for children to work to keep the family unit going) 5) country stability (no war is an obvious one) 6) teacher quality and school funding These in turn impact very personal variables that determine how students codify information such as 1) student age (children vs an adult who needs to retrain while keeping a family afloat) 2) learning style 3) mastery of language of education, and mastery of the language of higher education (multi language societies have to Deal with this) 4) stress 5) health and health availability 6) freedom to study (if you are a girl child, or Of the wrong tribe/caste/color/religion) And this doesn't account for many other variables such as people actively trying to teach you falsehoods or bad syllabi (sort of part of the education quality) And this entire system does not exist in a vaccum - parents tend to push kids into education streams which improve job options, hence the demand for STEM.
- Lazare 10y agoI can't wait to live in that world. The sheer increase in wealth and quality of life that this will represent, at every stratum of society, is going to be immense.
- cmurf 10y agoLet's pretend food, clothing, and shelter (structure) can be made cost free due to automation/robots. Land itself right now is not free, it is either owned or rented. In either case people need an income to pay for that. Where does this income come from? Or, do you destroy land ownership? And if it's destroyed, how is it determined who lives where and how much they get if all land "costs" the same.
- rdtsc 10y agoHappened to father-in-law. Worked at a printing company. Before used older machinery which needed more manual operations, more fixing and supervising. Company bought a new German printer, it was automated and more advanced. Required only a fraction of people from before to run it. Owners tried not to be evil and kept a lot of employees. People who used to do more intense manual work, were now standing around watching the new marvelous German-engineered printer do its magic. Some of the positions were almost made up just give workers a chance to stay longer. At some point they offered people money to quit. Some took that option, including father-in-law. Not sure what happened to others. Basic income is a good idea. I am behind it. But people like my father-in-law would be against taking it. They'd need to do some work, to feel like they are useful and they are earning a paycheck. I think the idea has to be promoted carefully so it doesn't seem like a handout or redistribution of wealth. Not exactly sure what the solution would look like.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoWhy not just pay people to do what they were doing before? You still have to paint, but you do it for free for whoever wants it. Since you're doing it by hand, and can take as long as you need, you can do more personal work, for people you care about. Paint a church. Paint a local business. Have a skeleton organization that basically just works as a dispatcher and collector of time sheets. You still only get paid for work done.
- rdtsc 10y agoCould, be yeah. They tried some of that there and it worked for a bit. I think the company probably found it unsustainable and first they offered a lump sum for people to quit, then they might lay people off. At some point the idea is that companies who automate and don't keep the people because, well that's what makes them more money, will win or out-compete those who don't. Maybe basic income can be used to incentivize people to learn more -- learn to program, social help (learn to help others, provide care for elderly), learn to manage and maintain robots, maybe find a way to strengthen the community (we'll pay you, but if you help build or maintain the local school you get paid more...?)
- pilooch 10y agoBernard?
- Pica_soO 10y agoGood thing, that in our heads, we are just medieval community monkeys, yearning for a role, a place in our daily life. Well - the replaced already replaced a president, to replace those that replace them, in the short and long run. Now- if everybody loses his place in society's maze at this pace, then the unraveled community's will take up the mace and smash the enlightenment straight in the face. The Last AI to go may as well, be the UN-Report Writer in space. "Anything that gives a human being meaning - as long as it chooses it voluntarily, is off limits to the machines." Hammer that in stone, put it up on Palo Alto Plaza. The scape-goat hunt is in full progress, and once the Society runs out of scape-goats, they will start to bite into the financial protective shields of the transformation accelerators and propellers. He who runs out of propaganda money last, shall sit upon the crumbling hill - victorious? Makes for a interesting Fermi Paradox solution- society self-medievialized and religious entrenched against progress and machinery until the cosmic dice ends it.
- dmichulke 10y agoI cannot help it but see this as a socialist opinion piece. Clearly, without the introduction of a major tax on robots as capital equipment, robot-based manufacturing cannot boost the fiscal revenues needed to finance both social transfers, to support workers made redundant by robots, and minimum wages, to stem a decline in the living standards of low- skilled and medium-skilled workers. If robots do the work AND there is a functioning market, this will have two effects: - substitution of low-skilled labor - cheaper prices across the board People most often forget the second item and ask for transfers as if people were automatically entitled because socialism. But they will get their share via the second item. Also, work is infinite because human needs are infinite. Maybe servants in households become more popular again, who knows? If work weren't infinite we would all be unemployed already, according to the theories of 19th century economists. Yet here we are, working, and repeating the same mistake. Another argument is that in the worst case we can just destroy all robots (and factories and wheels while we're at it), let's find out if we're better off after that or worse. Finally, the current economic mainstream calls out "deflation" as the biggest threat to the economy, yet it is deflation that will increase real wages automagically. Of course, highly indebted entities (such as your government) will want you to believe otherwise so they claim that everything grinds to a halt if we just have negative inflation for a few months. Also, Central Banks would lose their justification if deflation is discovered to be not as bad as claimed.
- lg 10y agodeflation is tricky... if oil gets 10x cheaper because there's lots of new sources, it's great. if oil gets 10x cheaper because after the nuclear holocaust people are living in caves and don't have the refineries or machinery to make it useful, not so great.
- dmichulke 10y agoExactly. Deflation is not bad per se (though it can be)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago