21 ms·
Post Virtual Reality Sadness
- wincy 10y agoThis is very interesting to read. I personally had an experience that increased my anxiety by using the video app Whirligig. It has a cinema mode that puts you in a room, but off to the left there's just a dark, open space. After reading House of Leaves I found myself really creeped out by the dark, open void that existed to my left, and found that feeling followed me for several hours after leaving virtual reality. It seems like in VR it's very important to have control of your surroundings, because a game/app developer could easily cause trauma or scare people who aren't expecting it. The immersion and its effect on your subconscious is really shocking to people who haven't tried it.
- pault 10y agoHah, I just finished House of Leaves based on a recommendation from a friend, and I totally understand. I didn't really enjoy the book, but it was so pervasively creepy I had a hard time reading it, and often felt extremely uncomfortable at home alone after a reading session.
- hprotagonist 10y agoI don't know that this is VR-specific. I remember feeling like this after: - Playing with MS Paint on Windows 3.1 for hours on end until my eyes burned when i was 8. - Inhaling Lord of the Rings in about a week when i was 10. - Playing Ocarina of Time for 12 hours a day as a young teen. - Playing WoW in 100-hour weeks as an undergrad on summer break.
- Kurimo 10y agoAgreed. This whole phenomenon was reported on widely after "Avatar" came out. News anchors gleefully reporting that people left the theater feeling depressed their world wasn't as fantastic as Avatar. More of "the kids aren't alright!" reporting they love to do to scare parents and elderly folks. My solution: Move out of the big cities. I live in a small town in the countryside and my world is that fantastic.
- m1sta_ 10y agoMoving to the country is as difficult as moving to the city.
- rjbwork 10y agoSeriously. Get me some fiber and a trainline into the city and it becomes feasible. Alternatively, hopefully I can live to become either rich, or retire comfortably to that countryside home.
- harryf 10y ago> More of "the kids aren't alright!" reporting they love to do to scare parents and elderly folks. Sadly this is one of those topics, like violence in video games, where we don't get beyond this cycle of "accuse and deny". Which is a shame because IMO there are really important topics here we need to address collectively such as how this connects to addiction http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html The "data point" I've been able to confirm with other parents of small kids (under 10) is there is a connection between extended periods of computer-aided escapism and aggression. The experiment you can try with most kids is give them a smartphone or iPad for 1-2 hours then take it away again with minimal warning but without using force. Once you've recovered the device, the next 15-30 minutes will typically involve aggressive behaviour; shouting, physical aggression towards siblings, demands to have the device back and something not unlike Gollum desiring his Precious. Based on my own experiences, adults can exhibit similar behaviour but extremes are dampened by conditioning, so harder to detect e.g it manifests itself in different ways e.g. sadness or depression instead of aggression. My hypothesis for this is something like 'For every 15 minutes given to a medium capable of 'fully absorbing' human attention (books, computer games VR), 5 minutes of "unconscious recovery time" will be required to re-align the attention to the current "real" reality, during which subjects may display behaviour such as aggression, sadness or general distractedness / fidgeting' This ratio of 15 to 5 might be different depending on the medium e.g. VR might have a more accentuated ratio than reading a book. Why this is so I can't say for sure, but it's something like a tax on time spent existing in a disconnected reality vs. the "real reality" our bodies live in.
- MalcolmPF 10y agoExactly. These are the symptoms of a withdrawal from escapism. You could replace "VR" in the article by many other kinds of absorbing experiences. Not to discredit the author's own personal findings, it's probably a healthy thing to be self-aware of these feelings. And there might be something to VR that makes the contrast of detachment more intense.
- ethanbond 10y agoWell in the author's opinion it's actually not the same. That's why he specifically points out counter examples of non-VR experiences which have similar but notably less intense effects. It's still an opinion, sure, but the author did address this comparison.
- sdoering 10y agoReading this I felt reminded of my experiences playing for Liverpool Action Role Playing. Being in character for several days and totally escaping get the outside world - then shedding the costume and sitting in a car on the motorway back home. Well talk about post adventure depression. Then walking up to the door of your longtime girlfriend and knowing get what was awaiting me - talk about remedy. Escapism in the former of a holiday from reality might be great - but reality has it's own perks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- psyc 10y agoI used to get that feeling to an extreme when exiting a movie theater. It had much more to do with being deeply unhappy than it had to do with movie theaters.
- canada_dry 10y agoIt's the intensity of the experience that will make VR the new hyper-addictive drug of choice for escaping reality in the near future. I fully expect my children to be lamenting how their children won't want to come back to the physical (real) world - much like how we wanted our kids to get off the computer, and our parents didn't like us being on the telephone and watching TV.
- danenania 10y agoSword Art Online is a great exploration of this if you like anime.
- davesque 10y agoHere's a fun thought that is really more of a science-fiction writing prompt: The author talks about his instinct to interact with the real world in the same way he interacted with the VR world. What if, as humans develop more and more realistic and immersive VR systems, it gives their bodies a real evolutionary incentive to develop telekinetic abilities?
- api 10y agoThere's a Stephen King novel called The Lawnmower Man that's basically this premise exactly. The film version is decent too and kind of fun in a 90s cyberpunk throwback sense too. Stay away from the sequels since as usual they are terrible.
- munificent 10y ago> There's a Stephen King novel called The Lawnmower Man that's basically this premise exactly. The Lawnmower Man I remember is just a short story and has nothing to do with VR or cyberspace at all. The movie doesn't have anything to do with the story. Like "I, Robot", it's a case where an existing unrelated screenplay had the name of a famous written work slapped on it to try to increase viewership.
- somedumbguy22 10y agoOr, after they leave the VR experience, the people find they can still do the same things/have the same powers, leaving them questioning if they ever left. Kind of like what happens to Neo in the Matrix.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- GuiA 10y agoOrganisms don't have evolutionary incentives to develop abilities. Environments exert evolutionary pressures, which select for/against existing traits (inherited or mutated) in organisms.
- 10y ago
- api 10y agoI've always been a bit concerned about VR being highly addictive, especially for people who want something to 'escape'. This seems to bolster this concern. Of course people can and will get addicted to almost anything. VR may be healthier than heavy drinking, heroin, meth, etc.
- crooked-v 10y agoMost of the more interesting VR control interfaces require enough movement to at least be healthier than, say, sitting at a desk and playing WoW all day.
- AndrewUnmuted 10y ago> VR may be healthier than heavy drinking, heroin, meth, etc. Honestly, I don't see why these activities are mutually exclusive. I am much more concerned about the kinds of destructive power that people who are heavily-drunk, on heroin, or tweaking on meth, can now have inside of these head-mounted displays.
- 6d6b73 10y agoVR will probably be THE solution to overpopulation. Slow, but painless.
- mtgx 10y agoProbably coupled with some pills to "make you feel more immersed", like those drugs in the Inception movie. Netflix' CEO seems to already be thinking about this: http://www.ibtimes.com/simulation-hypothesis-matrix-possible-hallucinogenic-pills-entertainment-could-define-2438750 http://www.ibtimes.com/simulation-hypothesis-matrix-possible...
- bertiewhykovich 10y agoThis is obviously a repugnant tactic that should be rejected with no hesitation and fought at every turn -- but it does kind of seem like the goal. Infinite VR pornography, sifted by neural nets to match every possible desire, a lifetime supply of Soylent, legal weed -- bam presto, you've solved the problem of all those people unemployed by the automation of the means of production.
- jonahrd 10y agoCan't the same be said about other forms of media? You go to the movies to escape, but on the drive home you feel sad that your life isn't as fantastical as the movies. Similar things can be said about the way we use our smartphones. I'm sure after you have the time to become "normalized" to VR, the real world will seem less depressing. perhaps even refreshing.
- ethanbond 10y agoAccording to the author, yes there are similar effects but no they aren't as intense.
- amelius 10y agoPerhaps this is related to Post-coital tristesse? [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-coital_tristesse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-coital_tristesse
- bertiewhykovich 10y agolol yeah dude, playing with an HTC Vive is exactly the same as fucking. exactly. there's no difference.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoDay 1 Vive owner here. This sounds pretty uncharacteristic of the experience and I guess this person has some psychological issues or is overplaying the VR experience for ad impressions. I read /r/vive religiously and no one seems to have this issue. Yes there's sometimes a "I wish I was playing now" but I've had that all my life and frankly it was 100x worse when I was playing MMOs or competitive shooters. This feeling isn't any different than the classic "I wish I was fishing" sentiment. We simply crave relaxing and rewarding experiences. The only legitimate symptom I've heard of is some people, myself included, get VR dreams in the beginning, but they quickly go away. This has led me to the idea of making a VR lucid dreamer trainer considering dreams and VR environments have so much in common, but thus far not a lot of traction on my part especially in regards what game mechanics would help you achieve lucid dreams. That said, I find most of the experiences fairly milquetoast with rare "Wow" moments which cannot be relived again. Unlike a typical skinner-box game, you really can't get wow'd over and over, but man, those initial wow's are incredible. I just flew in Freedom 7 in Alan Shepard's shoes last night in the beta for 'Go For Launch.' This had the real controls and the real audio in the mission. I didn't exactly weep, but it did affect me strongly on am emotional level, especially when I thought someone should ask Shepard to try this and tell us how realistic it is only to remember he passed away a while ago. I've been at work all day and haven't wished to be back in the capsule and I know if I do it again, it'll lose 90% of the magic. I may not ever play that mission again to be honest. Savor the moments, guys. Don't pine to be constantly re-living the same stuff over and over in VR. It'll disappoint you in the end. VR is special in a way, but its not magical. It follows the same rules all other entertainment does. If you're finding yourself addicted then you've got a personal addiction issue. Its not the medium, its you. You probably need help at this point. Ask any ex-WoW addict how bad it can be and how it ruins lives. Seek out that help.
- guitarbill 10y ago> This sounds pretty uncharacteristic of the experience and I guess this person has some psychological issues or is overplaying the VR experience for ad impressions. > If you're finding yourself addicted then you've got a personal addiction issue. Its not the medium, its you. The author gets many things right, such as the change in perception of distances. I get this from VR, but I also get it from changing from glasses to contact lenses (and vice versa). Doesn't sound like complete click-bait to me. I do think it's an interesting point that the escapism VR offers is possibly equivalent to some dissociatives, and that it hasn't really being considered. Some people struggle with addiction to (plain) video games. Blaming the person isn't fair or helpful at all.
- manachar 10y agoSometimes I wonder if VR is building Plato's Cave or revealing more of the way out of it. The more we learn about humans the more its clear our narratives and "real world" are at least partial figments of our imagination. We remember narratives that we choose to and ignore evidence to the contrary. VR could help reveal this for people (somewhat the same as is claimed for hallucinogens). It could also allow us to increasingly choose to build fully artificial realities. Who wouldn't choose to be a god? Interestingly, I find this somewhat similar to looking at landscape photography that people enjoy - especially from vacation destinations. Almost every picture now has more dynamic range, edge contrast, contrast, and saturation than the human eye experiences. This means people get to amazing places but are disappointed when reality doesn't match the photo. Then they use various apps on their smartphone to try to take a picture that matches the fantasy (often by erasing any of the local context or culture).
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago> It could also allow us to increasingly choose to build fully artificial realities. Many works of science fiction as well as some forecasts by serious technologists and futurologists predict that enormous amounts of computing power will be available in the future. Let us suppose for a moment that these predictions are correct. One thing that later generations might do with their super-powerful computers is run detailed simulations of their forebears or of people like their forebears. Because their computers would be so powerful, they could run a great many such simulations. Suppose that these simulated people are conscious (as they would be if the simulations were sufficiently fine-grained and if a certain quite widely accepted position in the philosophy of mind is correct). Then it could be the case that the vast majority of minds like ours do not belong to the original race but rather to people simulated by the advanced descendants of an original race. It is then possible to argue that, if this were the case, we would be rational to think that we are likely among the simulated minds rather than among the original biological ones. Therefore, if we don’t think that we are currently living in a computer simulation, we are not entitled to believe that we will have descendants who will run lots of such simulations of their forebears. — Nick Bostrom, Are you living in a computer simulation?, 2003
- 10y ago
- nugget 10y agoPeople talk a lot about futuristic sex robots but what about VR experiences that are not only physical but deeply emotional - wherein you experience seduction and actually fall in love? Think about riding in a weeks long 18 hour a day RPG crusade with a Milla Jovovich lookalike Joan of Arc who, in between battles, is irreparably infatuated with you. The tech needed to achieve this level of total immersion may yet be decades away but once it arrives it's scary to imagine - love, not sex, being the real emotional Achilles tendon of the human experience.
- tetraodonpuffer 10y agoisn't this the same kind of territory currently being explored by Westworld? In Westworld instead of being VR it is actual reality (with robots) but the dilemmas are quite similar
- greggman 10y agoPutting 3d models of people in VR is easy. Getting them to do anything interesting and not just be a few scripted things is much harder and very far from a solved problem. Maybe that doesn't matter. Maybe all you need is the character to look you in the eyes. But I suspect most people would need more. Someone you can actually talk to. Not just pick multiple choice responses
- 794CD01 10y agoSo part of the product can involve hiring a random human to play the part of the love interest, with the VR putting an attractive face and voice on their actions. Heck, that person can even be another customer getting the exact same thing out of you, chosen because your google/facebook profile suggests your personalities are sufficiently compatible.
- Afforess 10y agoI wonder if the author has ever experienced the joy of reading a good book, or the first showing an amazing movie. Finishing an amazing story, you feel a let down afterwords; the characters were not real and you can never interact with them. The realm of fictional worlds are often more engaging, and seem superior to the world you live your day-to-day life in. The actions and experiences in those stories were more fulfilling, the characters had more agency; their lives or stories were more "real" than ours. After experiencing the greatness of our imaginations, how can our bleak reality measure up? I often find that I start reading my next book immediately after finishing the previous one in attempt to recapture this high, to re-experience the betterness one more time. I don't think this effect is specific to a medium. That it can happen with VR is a sign that the technology has matured.
- frankhorrigan 10y agoYeah, I tend to agree. I think you can probably toss this on the list of lessons that human beings seem completely incapable of learning (myself included). That escapism doesn't really work.
- dv_dt 10y agoI am more optimistic. Some people may react to those feelings by going and constructing some of that world in reality. Isn't that sort of the link between a whole range of SciFi/Comic books in the 50's and landing on the moon? And we can not only hope that the Star Trek economics of abundance comes about, but that it is made true through a combination of technology and new economic thought.
- careersuicide 10y agoA few years ago I started reading "The Wheel of Time" by Robert Jordan. I had somehow timed it so that the week I finished the thirteenth book "Towers of Midnight" the fourteenth book "A Memory of Light" came out. I blew through the first chunk of the book and then got to a chapter that was over a hundred pages long, maybe even longer, Google says it was over fifty thousand words. It was the last battle, the moment the previous four million words had been leading up to. I read a few pages and then set it down. For six months. It was obvious the series was going to end in a way that was bittersweet (as all good stories end) but I just couldn't bear the thought of there being nothing left. By putting it down I was freezing the moment I had left it in time. When I returned to finish the book I felt that familiar sense of sadness. A period of my life (fourteen months!) was over. I'll probably re-read the books someday, but I know it won't be the same. I often get that feeling when I finish a work of fiction I enjoyed greatly. But there was something about "The Wheel of Time' that made it much more profound. Any medium that can tell a story that people find intense and immersive will produce that same feeling. Why would VR be any different?
- eof 10y agoI have been using and developing inside my Vive for about a month. It's only part time, so I am spending ~10 hours a week in VR. I certainly get some of what the author is talking about in terms of that coming-out-of-the-matrix feeling: the tetris affect of my chaperone cage is strong, and objects feel weird to interact with, using the phone UI is kinda ridiculous.. however, I certainly don't think I am experiencing any type of postpartum sadness. Roomscale VR is /ridiculously/ immersive. Every.single.person. I have put in omg and wtfs; even if they don't particularly care for video games.
- jonstokes 10y agoThe few times I've tried VR I've had post-VR sadness, but mine was sadness because it totally failed to live up to the hype. I could see the pixels, for one, so I never forgot I was in VR. And the other thing is, as "magical" as those experiences are, they just don't measure up to real life. I've played virtual instruments and games and visited a VR villa and so on, but none of it was as magical as watching my kids do pretty much anything on a regular basis. I dunno, though, maybe I haven't tried the right thing in VR.
- mattmanser 10y agoIt's not that kids playing are engrossing or amazing or anything. Go watch someone else's kid play for six hours. You're obviously not going to get the same high, it's pretty boring, pretty quickly. A small amount of people will enjoy it. Some chemical's going off in your brain, saying "WOW, my kids are AMAZING". It's a delusion that helps the human race carry on. How can you compete with a nature built in drug? What you going to do for kicks in 10 years time when your kids are teenagers? The allure will have rubbed off by then.
- jamesrcole 10y agoAlso remember that it's very early days for VR. What we'll be capable of doing in VR 20 years from now will likely be very different.
- hosh 10y agoNot too much different from people coming down from intense psychedelics or mystical experiences. Among the spiritual seekers for these kinds of mindblowing experiences, there is a seeking for greater and more intense experiences. What follows is a sort of emptiness or depression. It's touching on dukkha, that is, existential anguish. The key, as it has always been, to be present in the present moment, whether that means being present during the VR experience, or being present in meatspace. Being present to that emptiness will allow it to bleed out and dissolve. I'm personally glad to hear about these reports. There is a good possibility that VR and AR is the gateway towards mainstream exploration of consciousness. Up until then, honest discussion about existential anguish has been buried and suppressed, and I don't think that has served our civilization well. Here's a shoutout to all the explorers to come.
- Lich 10y agoHm, never had a feeling like this at all. Been using VR since DK1, DK2, and CV1. At its current state, I think VR is really cool, and at times immersive, but it's just not immersive enough for me yet. I don't know about others, but the fact that I can see the peripheral edges of the lens breaks immersion for me most of the time. There are moments of immersion, but those are very rare. I tend to experience it in moments where I'm moving from an enclosed space to a very large open space (i.e. a tunnel in Half-Life 2 out to a city view). I think I will find VR very immersive when the lens are somehow able to wrap around your vision completely so that I can't see that I'm looking through goggles. Don't misunderstand me though, I think what we have now is incredibly cool and immersive. I did try the Vive controllers, and that really kicks up the immersion a whole lot. I'm waiting to buy the Oculus touch controllers.
- tzakrajs 10y agoPeople can find ways to be sad about anything. Our brains are most ideally suited for this.
- rikkus 10y agoBetter watch out for that Despair Squid and check if you have an unexpected ponytail [1] [1] http://reddwarf.wikia.com/wiki/RD:_Back_to_Reality http://reddwarf.wikia.com/wiki/RD:_Back_to_Reality
- dahdum 10y agoHaving spent many hours in VR (Vive Room Scale) at a stretch, the article rings true to me. The biggest surprise being that it might not feel perfectly real at the time, but the memory is much closer. The next generation of pixel density will make a huge difference IMO. I can comfortably work in VR with multiple desktops, but the resolution is tad too low.
- pYQAJ6Zm 10y ago>I can comfortably work in VR with multiple desktops, but the resolution is tad too low. I am interested in this. Can you, say, write code or read text for long hours, without having to upsize the text too much?
- dahdum 10y agoYou've got to up the text size or shorten the distance in VR to be comfortable, which is the annoying part I think will be solved in the next gen. I get around this by adding multiple emulated displays (using Headless Ghost / Compulab Emulator) that are visible only in VR. Gives more room for window placement. I'm used to working with 2-6 monitors on the desktop so it's natural for me to extend that into VR, but some people don't like the head movement needed.
- badloginagain 10y agoA lot of comments here mention this isn't unique to the VR medium. I would suggest that VR is fundamentally different than reading a good book or watching a great movie. I would expect this is closer to when movies were first invented. There's a story (which may be untrue) of a movie which had a train heading towards the camera, and people running out of the theater thinking it was real. I expect the feelings the author is exploring is in part experiencing a brand new medium. What I really like about this article is how the author isn't drawing conclusions, but rather saying this is an interesting phenom to investigate further. VR does provide extensions to fundamental human ability (I can only thing of the depression a disabled person would feel if they could move around virtually), and I would be interested to see if there's a fundamentally addictive quality to extending your interactions with reality.
- atemerev 10y agoBack in 1993, I used to hang out in an advanced VR lab of the time, with many options to try. Once I played Descent for 3 hours, with a shitty VFX-1 headgear. Even then, returning back to reality was painful.
- 6d6b73 10y agoIt was hard to return back to reality after playing that game on a regular monitor, I can't imagine what it must been to play it with any type of vr headgear.
- Animats 10y agoThere's an answer to this in China. VR is becoming big in China, but not for games. For sales pitches. Right now, foreign real estate selling in VR is a real thing. Coming soon, "Alibaba is committed to making VR the premium shopping experience of the future".
- ngokevin 10y agoI work at Mozilla VR on A-Frame (https://aframe.io https://aframe.io). I talked to the Alibaba VR team in Hangzhou, and the top VR real estate project (iStaging). They are obviously interested in eCommerce given TaoBao. I don't think Buy Plus went super well given it was targeting Cardboard. But they have stuff cooking with Vive and Magic Leap. Unfortunately, VR eCommerce is a hard problem. It's shiny-sounding, but it's difficult to provide actual value to consumers that isn't just hype. And also VR hasn't entered mainstream China at all, not even for developers, so adoption is an issue. No one has space, and the VR cafes only attract super gamers. iStaging created their WebVR viewer with A-Frame: https://aframe.io/blog/istaging/...this https://aframe.io/blog/istaging/...this seems to be doing well given Cardboard is enough for this use case. 360 photos aren't really a compelling experience, but sufficient allowing clients to at least get a tiny feel for the place. But the articles about VR becoming "big" in China, I am not sure about given visits there over the last couple years.
- gerbilly 10y agoI have two feelings about this: 1) It reminds me of the quote: “Finishing a good book is like leaving a good friend.” ― William Feather 2) What is the author doing in actual reality that makes it so pale compared to VR? It's interesting that the first example brought up is about interacting with a phone. For god's sake man! Play a sport, have sex, go for a walk and smell the leaves, go for a swim in the ocean. Sweat, strain, climb and explore. Be an _animal_ because that's what we are! Go and get barrelled on a wave in the ocean and then come back and tell me that VR is better. :-)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- radiorental 10y ago> 2) What is the author doing in actual reality that makes it so pale compared to VR? I don't think it's that straight forward. I have a pretty fine damn time irl http://www.pauric.net/blog/?p=22 http://www.pauric.net/blog/?p=22 I've played a few of the leading titles on PSVR but then hit upon this simple puzzle game that has burrowed into my mind. I can't wait to get back to it, I lose hours to this game https://youtu.be/YoxJFkFzu98?t=1h56m49s https://youtu.be/YoxJFkFzu98?t=1h56m49s It scratches an itch that is hard to find in the real world (I do enjoy packing our cases up for vacation though). I think it's something about the immersion, pulling on your focus so hard that you loose yourself, like a good book. VR is all the things you compare it to (wrt pulling focus) except it's on tap.
- randyrand 10y agoI have this and have been dealing with a very similar effect to this for 4 months now. Depersonalization. It's a very odd type of depression and detachment from reality. It's very uncomfortable and can last indefinitely. Mine was triggered roughly a year after I had been into VR and also a year after I moved away from home. It's hard to say which played a bigger role. It was triggered by my best friend coming to visit me. It's fucking terrible. And I don't know what to do about it.
- the_nozzle 10y agoIf VR experiences are surpassing your real life experiences you are leading a pretty shitty and boring life.
- VLM 10y agoSomething I've noticed in many comments is its a mix of the game or story with perceptual warping. My own perceptual warping story doesn't come with a game, but I assure you its super disorienting to spend a couple hours looking thru a low power binoc microscope to work on electronics and then just get up and walk around, your hand eye coordination is all messed up for awhile because what you see your hands do has been times 2 magnified and bent 90 degrees upward for some hours. Putting a key in a keyhole is a challenge for a couple minutes till reality snaps back. Its a form of sea sickness, after all. Your position sense doesn't match your optic sense and that makes some people puke although in low doses you just feel really weird. Much like there is a difference between the taste of a beer in a relaxed setting vs after a long afternoon of yard work, your blood sugar or hormones or something distort your perception of the taste of the beer. Or DnD / pathfinder / rpg in general seems more fun when candle-lit. And a zillion observations in a hundred comments here about drugs or whatever. I would think there are more technological opportunities to mix perception alteration with a story or game than just AI or what we've mentioned. Perhaps someone could scientifically calculate a formula to determine the correct music for a game. Maybe there is a type of food that naturally goes with social media use (probably something sugary). Maybe a certain hue of general room lighting is good for certain TV genres. Aside from VR technology, however cool it may be, I have this feeling narrative/game plus perception warping is a large mostly unexplored solution space. I like to sail. I wonder if, along the lines of the theory above, liking sailing comes from ultra low dose perceptual warping due to subclinical sea sickness combined with the purely mechanical labor of sailing. Could you give me a small dose of anti-anti-sea sickness pills and I'd love basketweaving or something.
- swalsh 10y agoI'm not sure "sadness" is the way I'd describe it, but returning back to the real world is a bit weird if you've been in for a few hours. I've always attributed it to the wind-down. The crazy part of onward is it literally invokes a prolonged adrenaline reaction. At least it used to, it's not nearly as much anymore. Leaving can be exhausting. It's definitely part of the addicting aspects. The first few times when I dove to the ground because I heard gunshots near me was exhilarating. I find myself wanting increasingly more intense moments.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agowhere is this guy getting these immersive experiences? I have an oculus and haven't experienced anything that great yet.
- 3chelon 10y agoThe Phase 1 effects remind me of the first time I got behind the wheel of a car immediately after playing GTA. I was barely able to drive because I was afraid of doing something stupid.
- StanislavPetrov 10y agoAll I could think while reading this is its exactly how you feel after coming down from LSD.
- technological 10y agoQuestion if anyone could answer (thank you) Is VR experience is expected to be something very new , I mean for example when u do something new like play a video game or sport you experience something new , is VR experience is something similar ? OR is it trying to mimic the natural behavior (like feeling of hitting the ball when playing a sport )
- jfoutz 10y agoI haven't experienced that effect myself, but i don't have a rig. I can't help but think of waking up from really intense dreams. Perhaps like those fever dreams when a little bit sick. My mind accepts the reality it's making up, and it's very intense. Perhaps fun, perhaps frightening as the generation drifts over to nightmare territory. I understand what others are saying about books, but really vivid dreams seem like a closer match. You can't control a book, in a dream there's still some agency, some action that can change everything.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI'm concerned that AR will make this worse rather than better. The amount of dopamine that we will get from constant AR we glasses or contact lenses is going to be devastating. Just look at this artist rendition: https://vimeo.com/166807261 https://vimeo.com/166807261
- sandworm101 10y agoI wonder how much this has to do with vision correction. VR goggles, like TV screens, flatten everything into a single plane. If your eyes can focus on that plane they see everything. The real world is different. None of us have perfect vision at all distances simultaneously. We have to refocus when switching between near and far. The result is that nothing in the real world is every as 'in focus' as the VR world. So like wearing flippers while swimming, the real world is fuzzy and requires you to work harder than you did while wearing the device. This is akin to why BBC documentaries always look better than the real thing. (I watched Planet Earth II last night). Those giant lenses in the fancy cameras can keep more objects in focus, allowing us to see both the parrot and the mountain background in ways we couldn't in the real world.
- rubicon33 10y agoI struggle to believe that this is a serious post, from someone who has seriously used VR. At the very least, I imagine their experience is very subjective. I have the Oculus Rift, but have experienced nothing like what he's describing. Maybe its the lack of room scale, the lack of hand/arm interaction (Oculus Touch isn't out yet), or maybe I'm just playing different games? Oculus never felt magical to me. In fact, if I'm being honest, it was kind of a let down. Yea it's cool, but the resolution is garbage (even in the production version I have). This article reads like someone who's never used VR, but worries about what it COULD do to you... if it really were great.
- eof 10y agoHave you used a vive? The resolution I don't think is any better, but the vive does feel magical to me. Everyone I put in it seems to feel similarly; but the tracked controllers are probably a big part of that immediately immersive experience
- rubicon33 10y agoI haven't used a vive no. My guess is that the "magical" feel does indeed rely on your hands showing up in the game ("tracked controllers" as you put it). Without that hand tracking, it's difficult to feel truly immersed in the world.
- HiroP55 10y agoI have experienced this post VR depression with PSVR. Although I have to say that it has been happening less and less the more I play. Perhaps it's possible to become desensitized to VR. I've found myself becoming more aware of the fact that I'm in a game. I'm not saying the magic has completely wore off. I still experience moments of aw. Anyone else experiencing this?
- davidgerard 10y agoJaron Lanier: Why people should pay more attention to me and not Web 2.0 When I noticed myself getting mean online I thought, “Something has gone terribly wrong.” It was obvious the rest of the ARPAnet had a social problem, not just me being some sort of asshole. My book You Are Not A Gadget: A Manifesto is ruffling virtual feathers across the ARPAnet. And so it should, because I invented virtual reality. Wikipedia, which is a tissue of lies, says so. Prospect magazine’s Top 100 Public Intellectuals Poll lists me. Also, my hair is much better than yours. And I’m fifty. According to Wikipedia, so I’d better change my birthday. Today, the web is a bland place. It’s all user-generated content — silly clips on YouTube, spiteful anonymous comments on blogs about my books, endless photographs of people at a bar with their friends or up a mountain with an ironing board. It was much better back in the early days of the ARPAnet, before we let the commercial users on. These words will mostly be read by numb mobs composed of people who are no longer acting as individuals. You know, the peasants. Virtual reality is far more ennobling, but you never hear people talking about that any more. The ARPAnet only creates banal mashups of old culture. Salvagers picking over a garbage dump. Only the old-world economy of books, films and newspapers creates original content like Lawnmower Man or Battlefield Earth. Everyone knows that real artists have no influences. This stuff the kids are into these days is just noise! The ARPAnet is also killing music, according to my good friends at the RIAA. Did you know there’s no music in Spain any more? It’s true! Will we — meaning I — be able to live off our brains in the future, or will we just have to give our creative works away for free? If we can’t live off our brains then we’ll need a form of SOCIALISM just to survive. WIKIPEDIA IS COMMUNISM! Until the Wikipedia Corporation finally builds a good interface, for goggles and power-gloves. Open source and open content are a cancer. The dogma I object to is composed of a set of interlocking beliefs and doesn’t have a generally accepted overarching name as yet, so I’m going to call it Digital MAOISM, which is COMMUNISM. Update, five years later: Here is a detailed retcon explanation of why I was not just trolling for headlines by calling Wikipedia COMMUNISM, but was speaking precisely and you just weren’t thinking hard enough: [snip 10,000 words] Also, you should get into virtual reality more. You Are Not A Gadget: A Manifesto is published on papyrus scroll and hand-illustrated by monks. You cannot have a copy until you have fought your way up the mountain and proven yourself worthy.
- nilved 10y agoSome parts of this article make me think the author should seek therapy. I don't see why virtual reality couldn't trigger derealization disorder in susceptible individuals.
- kin 10y agoThis isn't VR specific. I can get lost and immersed in any story regardless of the medium and be saddened afterwards. But, I will say that VR is one of the most immersive experiences out there. With the right game/universe, I can totally see people having withdrawal issues.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoIf you've ever had a dream where you can fly, VR can come close to that feeling of wonder and freedom. And like when you wake up in your bed, fully in the grip of gravity, coming out of VR can be a letdown.
- fisherjeff 10y agoSeems like a good time to re-read Ray Bradbury's "The Happiness Machine" http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/wp-content/uploads/satevepost/ray-bradbury-the-happiness-machine-SEP.pdf http://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/wp-content/uploads/sateve...
- farright 10y agoAfter playing Holopoint for 30 minutes, I felt a sense of elation and heightened perception. I felt like I could type faster, and my reaction times were faster. It reminded me of Lawnmower Man. I didn't get this effect with less intense games like Space Pirate Trainer.
- Kiro 10y agoI know this is supposed to describe a problem but for me it has the opposite effect. I _want_ VR to be so immersive that the real world feels dull so I'm very stoked to give VR a go after reading this.