5 ms·
I'm not sure why everyone thinks Obama killed coal. Cratering natural gas prices are what killed coal. So short of artificially raising the price of nat gas, co
by matwood 10y ago
I'm not sure why everyone thinks Obama killed coal. Cratering natural gas prices are what killed coal. So short of artificially raising the price of nat gas, coal is not coming back regardless of who is in charge.
http://reason.com/blog/2016/10/11/natural-gas-ambush-killed-off-coal-minin http://reason.com/blog/2016/10/11/natural-gas-ambush-killed-...
http://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/Cheap-Natural-Gas-To-Spark-Another-Wave-Of-Coal-Plant-Retirements.html http://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/Cheap-Natural-Gas-...
- marcoperaza 10y agoThe amount of political heat that the Obama administration took for, the amount of effort that they poured into, their new coal regulations makes me skeptical of your claim.
- alexc05 10y agoIn fairness, quite often we see examples of "political heat" being driven by wilful ignorance and disingenuous outrage. In order to "score points" with the people who are watching them yell at their opponent. A politician might pretend their opponent has a position on something (A) and get very angry about that publicly, while knowing the whole while that actually the truth is (B) or sometimes they might even know that (A) was actually the only viable choice the whole time.
- pavlov 10y agoIf "amount of political heat" were a function of actual facts, Hillary Clinton would have been leading the assault at Benghazi herself. Blaming Obama for the decline of coal's commercial viability was a convenient fiction.
- jrcii 10y agoKilling Coal: The Obama Administration’s Intentional Assault on an Industry http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/01/19/killing-coal-the-obama-administrations-intentional-assault-on-an-industry/ http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/01/19/killing-c...
- pmorici 10y agoIt's not like Obama did nothing that effected coal. The industry lost over 83k coal mining jobs during the last 8 years. Hillary lost Pennsylvania, a big coal mining state, by 68,236 votes. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/01/coal-obama-federal-land/424422/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/01/coal-o... http://dailycaller.com/2016/09/05/obama-kept-his-promise-83000-coal-jobs-lost-and-400-mines-shuttered/ http://dailycaller.com/2016/09/05/obama-kept-his-promise-830...
- greendesk 10y agoI am of the opinion that the reasons the industry lost jobs, are primarily: 1. Price of natural gas is very competitive. 2. Automation. Mechanisation inside coal mines becomes more effective. 3. As old coal plants are retired, their replacements require exceptionally high capital expenditures. While running an already built coal plant can be feasible, competition for building new plants is not economically competitive. In the end, it is the free market that took those jobs. In the end, the market always wins.
- pmorici 10y agoDoesn't really matter 83k unemployed people aren't going to care about the nuances of which factors contributed how much. If the industry was already on it's way down the smart thing to do would have been to let it run it course instead of pushing regulations that wouldn't matter any ways and swung the state against you. Similarly if the factors killing coal really are not driven by government regulation than installing a pro-coal guy at the EPA shouldn't have any effect.
- jljljl 10y agoCoal was regulated before concerns of climate change became mainstream because it kills people. The pollutants it releases poison people not just in the state where the plant is located, but in neighboring states. None of the costs of medical treatment or loss of life were borne by the coal industry itself prior to regulation.
- 10y ago
- greendesk 10y agoIt is a perception issue; apparently coal miners are swayed to believe a people decided to close coal mines. For some people, it is easier to perceive that a bureaucrat is against your industry, as opposed to find out that the economic value created is exceptionally low. When a person loses a job, it will be heartbreaking for the person to realise the job performed earlier has low economical value. Telling someone "We do not need your services anymore" is harder than telling "Well, all those bureaucrats that live elsewhere decided it...". I do think that economic value of coal is low and it is economically swapped out for other sources.
- crdoconnor 10y agoThis presumes a simplistic model of the market that completely ignores the combination of regulations, tariffs and subsidies. And, FWIW, Obama did favor natural gas. Corporate oligarchs have always tried to make the results of their deliberate decisions and the candidates they throw money at sound like the inevitable march of progress. But it isn't. And this election was a repudiation of that.
- jdavis703 10y agoWasn't natural gas a byproduct of the shale oil/hydro fracking boom? It seems that perhaps (while oil prices were high) these coal miners should've moved to North Dakota and Texas. Is this not the equivalent of a jQuery developer complaining about lack of jobs when they could maybe learn React or Angular?
- Turing_Machine 10y agoEquating a 45 year old man with minimal education, a mortgage, and generations of family history in an industry with a 20-something software developer with none of those things is... not reasonable.
- BEEdwards 10y agoOh so after all that time accusing my generation of being lazy and unmotivated, they would rather stay unemployed and vote for a racists than change it. got it.
- KirinDave 10y ago> I'm not sure why everyone thinks Obama killed coal. Cratering natural gas prices are what killed coal. So short of artificially raising the price of nat gas, coal is not coming back regardless of who is in charge. What the Coal industry wants is even more federal handouts. We already give them a ton of money to keep going on the grouds that it's a transition economy and a bridge for the US economy. But the Coal Industry is really damn greedy as a whole. Even with high profile failures like Solyndra, in general green energy runs at a fraction of the cost. This of course hurts workers, because the labor involved is less well compensated as part of that cost reduction. However, as far as I can tell we're already turning the corner to where (for _generation_, ignoring environmental costs), solar and wind already outperform coal on a cost basis. People who want to preserve bulk coal generation do so for ideological reasons. From a more "green" perspective, there are more important things we should be doing with our coal and natural gas then burning them to heat water.
- maxerickson 10y agoSo that's an actionable step that can be taken. Fund the build out of solar production without worrying too much about profits. Not at a loss, just choose to fund factories that will build solar panels as an investment in the future rather than from a portfolio of competitive investments as an attempt to maximize profit.
- giardini 10y agojrcii posted this an hour ago and (s)he was, for some reason, downvoted until it was [dead]. But I think it's a relevant and newsworthy article: "Killing Coal: The Obama Administration’s Intentional Assault on an Industry" http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/01/19/killing-coal-the-obama-administrations-intentional-assault-on-an-industry/ http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/01/19/killing-c... Please don't kill information simply b/c you disagree with it; otherwise there can no dialogue and ycombinator becomes little more than a billboard for the current dominant political whim.
- khuey 10y agoIt got killed because breitbart.com is not a real news source.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe EPA's Clean Power Plan rule--a major priority of the Obama administration--has the implicit goal of closing hundreds of coal power plants. Although the EPA has not said so out loud, plenty of other people have. It is currently stayed by court order; a Trump administration could decline to defend it, and thereby permit it to die in court. Low natural gas prices are in part because the Obama administration has strongly resisted any significant restriction or regulation of fracking. They have resisted it because they want gas prices to fall and displace coal. When it comes to energy development, it's hard to think separately about technology and policy; they are both factors in every change.
- greendesk 10y agoPlenty of coal plants are/were too old to maintain and upgrade. If memory serves me right, 2/3 of coal plants were constructed before 70s. I find it odd to require that they continue to operate, while more effective options for energy generation emerged in the last 50 years. Yes, let me iterate it - so many coal plants were older than 50 years, that it is a miracle they operated for so long. Obama's administration did not change their age; they were on their way out. It is hard to separate technology and policy, but I find it hard to stipulate a policy to deter an upgrade of a 50-ish year old to be good policy.
- paulyg 10y agoLower gas prices certainly did not help, but if not for regulations introduced during the Obama administration, many coal plants would still be running. I worked, as an engineer, for a company that made equipment pretty much just for coal fired power plants from 2002-2014. Starting with the ammendments to the Clean Air Act in 2009, then the CSAPR, then MATS, we watched utility after utility make the decision to close plants rather than install the required emissions control equipment. So maybe if natural gas was more expensive they would have chosen to install the equipment, but if not for those regulations they would have just kept running.